16 ms·
This is heartbreaking, and by no means anomalous[1]. I know a number of people that have committed suicide during the lock downs. It is becoming a political t
by freedomben 6y ago
This is heartbreaking, and by no means anomalous[1]. I know a number of people that have committed suicide during the lock downs.
It is becoming a political topic, which is always risky to weigh in on publicly, but I do implore people to keep in mind when deciding on policy the law of unintended consequences. Everything in life is a series of trade offs, including the decision to lock down. Even if you believe the lock downs have been effective, they cause real damage and disruption to people's lives and mental health. It is serious and needs to be considered and weighed.
What we have is a variation on the trolley problem, not a simple "save people with lock downs or not." I have no idea where the right balance is, but I've been shocked and saddened at the unwillingness of pro-lock-down people to consider the unintended consequences here. I have plenty of criticism for the anti mask crowd too, but this comment is already long enough.
[1]: I have no scientific data to back this claim up. This is my opinion extrapolated from anecdata. Take with a grain of salt
- tonyedgecombe 6y ago>I know a number of people that have committed suicide during the lock downs. Really? Because the increase in suicides is quite small (8% is the last statistic I saw) and suicides in general are quite rare (~13 per 100,000 people).
- statquontrarian 6y agoRare in the sense that death is rare, but it's in the top 10 causes of death; about 50K per year: https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/leading-causes-of-death.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/leading-causes-of-death.htm
- tomjakubowski 6y agoJust to complete the loop for anyone curious, suicide accounted for 1.7% of all US resident deaths (2.8e6) in 2018.
- freedomben 6y agoYes I won't mention any details out of respect for privacy, but two former friends/co-workers, one person I was in the military with 15 years ago, as well as one family member. It's obviously not only lock downs that have caused this, but they certainly added to it. My close friend had his marriage explode and turn horribly nasty. She took the kids and he ended up alone in a studio apartment for months, and then killed himself. His marriage was obviously not great before but they were making it work. Being stuck in the house together all the time was too much. I'm guessing data on suicides due to lockdowns is as problematic as deaths due to covid because these are typically complex equations, but it would be interesting to see a study. In my small non-representative case study, suicides are up >200% from average. It's normally 1 every other year or so, except 2018 when there were 2 :'(
- watwut 6y agoShe can't legaly take kids away from him, he has right to demand 50% custody. In cases where she allege violence, it can be pretty difficult to make courts believe that and approve zero contact.
- poulsbohemian 6y ago>She can't legaly take kids away from him, he has right to demand 50% custody Depends on the state, and not every state is as progressive as one might expect.
- jtbayly 6y agoProgressive ideology is literally the opposite of what you suggest here.
- watwut 6y agoIn which states exactly can't both parents demand custody rights?
- poulsbohemian 6y ago
- enqk 6y agoIt's a mistake to think the cases are evenly distributed in the population, and do not have clusters. Sorry for your losses, freedomben
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- User23 6y agoOne should look at disability adjusted life years. A 30 year old committing suicide objectively costs far more human life than a 95 year old dying of Covid-19. Also, suicide and other deaths of despair are far more socially costly than Covid-19 deaths of people that were going to die soon of something else anyhow.
- watwut 6y agoWhy do you assume that suicides are biased toward young healthy people? Young healthy people were in best position to not be isolated even in lockdown, unlike unhealthy people and old people who wont just play computer games for company.
- LorenPechtel 6y agoMost of the Covid deaths are not people that were going to die soon anyway. The last data I saw said an average of more than 10 years of expected life lost. It has been a right-wing deception that they were going to die anyway because they had pre-existing conditions, but most of those pre-existing conditions are things that are only slow killers if at all.
- User23 6y ago> The last data I saw said an average of more than 10 years of expected life lost. That isn't just data, it's data plus a set of assumptions. Won't you please further this discussion and share it instead of making vague allegations about right-wing conspiracies? It's well known that Covid-19 is by wildly disproportionately more lethal as age increases[1] and it's also well known that older people on average have less life left than younger people. Also please note that deaths of despair is a broader category than suicide[2]. Someone who drinks himself to death isn't counted as a suicide, even though it's a person taking action that ends his own life earlier than it otherwise would. Alcohol consumption has increased markedly during the pandemic[3]. Caring about 2nd and higher order effects isn't a right-wing conspiracy theory, it's just a sensible, intelligent, and compassionate thing to do. We should expect better than kindergarten tier reasoning from our leadership. [1] https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/covid-data/investigations-discovery/hospitalization-death-by-age.html https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/covid-data/investi... [2] https://www.marketwatch.com/story/the-same-number-of-people-could-die-from-deaths-of-despair-as-have-already-died-in-the-us-from-coronavirus-new-study-finds-2020-05-08 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/the-same-number-of-people-... [3] https://abcnews.go.com/US/alcohol-consumption-rising-sharply-pandemic-women/story?id=73302479 https://abcnews.go.com/US/alcohol-consumption-rising-sharply...
- _trampeltier 6y agoNot so rare, in switzerland for each death on the street / car accident, almost 3 people do a suicide.
- rualca 6y ago> This is heartbreaking, and by no means anomalous. I know a number of people that have committed suicide during the lock downs. Do you have any basis for that assertion? I've seen that argument being made since lockdowns started to be declared but there is never a single shred of data or source or evidence substantiating any of those claims.
- freedomben 6y agoI do not, just anecdata, so take my declaration as opinion extrapolated from lived experience. I've seen a few interesting links but haven't studied them yet. I'll add a note to the post.
- rualca 6y agoI've spent a few minutes googling for the topic, and I've stumbled in this link: https://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/statistics/suicide.shtml https://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/statistics/suicide.shtml Taken from the page: > During that 20-year period, the total suicide rate in the United States increased 35% from 10.5 per 100,000 in 1999 to 14.2 per 100,000 in 2018. It seems that suicide rates in the us have been constantly increasing for the past two decades, and there is no break in the trend during the past year.
- jessaustin 6y agoThe past two decades coincide with the increase in violent military action overseas. It's too bad that those who have made these horrible decisions don't face the consequences of their greed. They leave that to the enlisted.
- mcguire 6y agoI note that 0.1%, or about 350,000 people) of the US population has died of COVID19. (https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/) Suicides have been increasing in the US over recent decades and suicides are under-reported, but the annual suicide rate has been about an order of magnitude less than COVID19 deaths. Large quotes follow: "As many countries face new stay-at-home restrictions to curb the spread of covid-19, there are concerns that rates of suicide may increase—or have already increased.12 Several factors underpin these concerns, including a deterioration in population mental health,3 a higher prevalence of reported thoughts and behaviours of self-harmamong people with covid-19,4 problems accessing mental health services,4 and evidence suggesting that previous epidemics such as SARS (2003) were associated with a rise in deaths by suicide.5 "Widely reported studies modelling the effect of the covid-19 pandemic on suicide rates predicted increases ranging from 1% to 145%,6 largely reflecting variation in underlying assumptions. Particular emphasis has been given to the effect of the pandemic on children and young people. Numerous surveys have highlighted that their mental health has been disproportionately affected, relative to older adults,37 and some suggest an increase in suicidal thoughts and self-harm.8 "Supposition, however, is no replacement for evidence. Timely data on rates of suicide are vital, and for some months we have been tracking and reviewing relevant studies for a living systematic review.6 The first version in June found no robust epidemiological studies with suicide as an outcome, but several studies reporting suicide trends have emerged more recently. Overall, the literature on the effect of covid-19 on suicide should be interpreted with caution. Most of the available publications are preprints, letters (neither is peer reviewed),91011 or commentaries using news reports of deaths by suicide as the data source.12 "Nevertheless, a reasonably consistent picture is beginning to emerge from high income countries. Reports suggest either no rise in suicide rates (Massachusetts, USA11; Victoria, Australia13; England14) or a fall (Japan,9 Norway15) in the early months of the pandemic. The picture is much less clear in low income countries, where the safety nets available in better resourced settings may be lacking. News reports of police data from Nepal suggest a rise in suicides,12 whereas an analysis of data from Peru suggests the opposite.10 "Any change in the risk of suicide associated with covid-19 is likely to be dynamic. The 20% decrease in Japan early in the pandemic seemed to reverse in August, when a 7.7% rise was reported.9 Evidence from previous epidemics suggests a short term decrease in suicide can occur initially—possibly linked to a “honeymoon period” or “pulling together” phenomenon.5 Trends in certain groups may be hidden when looking at overall rates, and the National Child Mortality Database has identified a concerning signal that deaths by suicide among under 18s may have increased during the first phase of lockdown in the UK.16" -- "Trends in suicide during the covid-19 pandemic" (https://www.bmj.com/content/371/bmj.m4352 https://www.bmj.com/content/371/bmj.m4352) "“Based on preliminary data, Oregon has not seen an increase in the number of suicides for the first nine months of 2020 when compared to the same time period in 2019,” Oregon Health Authority communications officer wrote Aria Seligmann in an email. "The monthly suicide surveillance updates published by the Oregon agency (https://www.oregon.gov/oha/PH/PREVENTIONWELLNESS/SAFELIVING/SUICIDEPREVENTION/Documents/Monthly_Suicide-Related_data_report.pdf https://www.oregon.gov/oha/PH/PREVENTIONWELLNESS/SAFELIVING/...) show the frequency of suicide-related visits to hospital emergency rooms and urgent care centers decreased in the first and second quarters of 2020. For the third quarter of this year, suicide-related visits were similar to 2019. Suicide-related calls in 2020 to the Oregon Poison Center are coming in at a similar pace to last year, too. "Likewise, the Washington State Department of Health and the biggest local health department in the state reported no discernible upward trend, maybe even a slight decrease in suicide deaths, in the first three quarters of 2020. "As of a November tally, there were 861 suicides statewide in the first three quarters of 2020, compared to 940 suicides in the same period of 2019. A Washington DOH spokesperson cautioned that there are delays in the state’s death data collection, so the preliminary tally of suicide deaths will probably be higher when finalized — and therefore track closely with the pre-pandemic trend." -- (https://www.opb.org/article/2020/12/16/pandemic-2020-suicide-data-oregon-washington/ https://www.opb.org/article/2020/12/16/pandemic-2020-suicide...) The data is, largely, not available, and suicide prevention is a very important aspect of the current healthcare situation, but as it appears now, COVID19 is a much greater health threat than pandemic-response-related suicides.
- hristov 6y agoIf you were honest and serious with the response, the lockdowns did not need to be longer than two weeks. This would have had minimal psychic toll. You can see right now that the countries that were successful with the virus response like Hong Kong, Singapore, Taiwan, Vietnam have much less restricted societies right now and also did throughout the summer. They are all mostly open with mask wearing requirements. They might have some restrictions on stadiums and large indoor gatherings but everything else is going on as normal. You can end the lock downs quickly if you do the lockdowns right. This of course also includes proper government response, such as testing, contact tracing enforcing isolation, having covid clinics, etc. Not the idiotic "see no evil, hear no evil, the virus will go away by itself" policy of the us federal government. Here I should mention that you are also off topic. The cruise ship workers were subjected to much higher psychic stress than usual people. This is mostly due to the cruise companies irresponsible behavior during the pandemic.
- nwienert 6y agoWe absolutely don’t know enough to make generalizations about those countries. I know many Vietnamese living in Vietnam. Beyond the much larger spread of previous coronaviruses, different genetics, climate and more, they tell me that their culture keeps these things quiet. The government plays a large role in this suppression. There are whole years of investigation that need to take place before anyone can even potentially make positive statements about what happened. I’m shocked on all sides about how everyone seems to “know” the truth. We have some ok leads, we’re far from answers.
- djsumdog 6y agoI agree. I think genetics and the other factors you mentioned might have a major role. Also in the US and EU, PCR tests are done with over 40 amplification cycles, leading to massive amounts of false positives. There is no global standard for PCR and the WHO has even weighed in on these discrepancies. A traveler to Afghanistan shows a city that has few mandates outside of the airport: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nculZ8xu1wc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nculZ8xu1wc Life is pretty much normal there, because in low-income countries it has to. And when these people actually see and talk to each other about the situation, they can express contradicting ideas and not be locked into a spiral of fear. Int he US, EU, Canada and Victoria, Australia, separating people from one another is having a strong group think effect where no one is seeing things outside of a a very limited on-line or very local bubble. We are looking at the world through a straw, and it's greatly distorting our view of what's actually happening.
- tylerjwilk00 6y agoAgreed. People think policy takes place in a vacuum or that those that write policy are so wise and fair that they have thought everything out. Never the case.
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago> but I do implore people to keep in mind when deciding on policy the law of unintended consequences This is one of those things that feels easy with the benefit of hindsight, but it's extraordinarily difficult to do up front. Specifically: There are no modern studies that could quantify the negative externalities of mass quarantine on the mental health of a population. Obviously isolation will be detrimental to many, but where would you even begin to put a number on it? Even more difficult, there are counterbalancing factors to mass quarantine such as a reduction in traffic fatalities. This one could maybe be estimated up front because we do have some statistics and models around traffic deaths. Coronavirus is a unique situation because the negative effects are very non-linear. The fatality rate will skyrocket if/when hospital capacity is overwhelmed. Many policy decisions have been made in order to avoid those non-linear scenarios, which can look like overkill if you only consider them in the context of having avoided those scenarios. But the real problems come from the political maneuvering that this opens up. Once you open the door to unmeasurable or unpredictable possible downsides of a policy, you will be flooded with "think of the children" type appeals that use fear of "what if" scenarios to grind progress to a halt. At scale, there is no such thing as a possible that doesn't have downsides to someone, somewhere. Trying to mitigate any and every downside is impossible. > I've been shocked and saddened at the unwillingness of pro-lock-down people to consider the unintended consequences Frankly, I think the average person doesn't fall into all out "anti-mask" or "pro-lockdown" categories, despite what you see on the news. We only hear about these extremist positions because the extremist voices tend to be the loudest. When considering one's own position, it's tempting to only look at the most extreme examples from the "other side" because they're the easiest to dismiss. In reality, the vast majority of the population is firmly in the middle. The average person doesn't like the idea of extreme lockdowns any more than they like the idea of a total laissez faire approach. We just don't hear about the middle ground on the news or social media because it's boring.
- watwut 6y agoOne aspect is that there were models trying to calculate those other things like downsides. Both guesses on suicides and domestic violence going up, people not going to doctor. But that does not matter, because people will do the rhetorical point anyway. In most context, people who bring up suicide did not even tried to find whether those guesses exists. It is almost end of year, we have actual suicides statistics available. Suicides went slightly up, but not by much and they went slightly up in preceding years too. More people died from covid. Our best estimates say that if hospitals would get overfulled, in those places mortality would be even higher. But that does not matter for "what about" political point. Because that one is not motivated by attempt to find best policy, it is motivated by wanting the other side to be wrong.
- colechristensen 6y agoThe more important question is how do you match response with effects. 2% of covid deaths are people under 40, there is an at least linear correlation between risk and age. I value a day in my life much higher at my current age than I would serval decades in the future, and in general I think this is true. The issue is that the people with the most risk have the least to lose, and those with the least risk have the most to lose. Eventually you have to get to the calculus of how many months of bored teenagers is worth how many months of saved life for the elderly? When it comes to me personally, the pandemic and response has taken away a not insignificant chunk of the prime of my life. How many days of life did I save for my part and was it worth it? People tend to have this notion to cling to every second of extended life, that’s not necessarily right. Life is risk, and everything you do changes the risk. People tend to want to take one extreme without matching their choices with values.
- fapjacks 6y ago"Life is worth losing." -- George Carlin
- iso1631 6y agoWould you agree to withhold all medical care for over 60s for a year or two to let covid run free?
- colechristensen 6y agoNo?
- iso1631 6y agoSo what would the solution be when 10 million people need hospital beds and there are only 1 million, most of which are taken up by people without covid
- djsumdog 6y agoNo one is accurately talking about the risks. The vast majority of people who have died have been over 60. There have been young people who died, yes. But young people die all the time of things that often kill very few: fungal infections, respiratory disease, bicycle wrecks. Now the narrative is "Long Covid" which comes from very limited case studies and papers that depend on web surveys and lots of other questionable research that falls flat once you start diving into the papers. Meanwhile, all the things people are doing are about as effective as TSA Security Theater. The lockdowns simply do not work. We can see that in the numbers between California, South Dakota, Sweden and others. Every nation or municipality that takes a hard approach is no better off, and often much worse, than places that did substantially less. The masks are a placebo at this point and the numbers show they probably do next to nothing (except contribute to massive pollution, waste, shame and make us fearful of each other). In 50 years, the only way I think historians will look back upon this ear is pure mass hysteria; global mass hysteria on a scale never seen before. This is not a time of honor and should never be returned to.
- iso1631 6y agoSome useful data In the UK in 2019 there were 5,691 suicides, a massive increase and a general increasing trend Provisional data for UK in 2020 showed 845 deaths from April-June, or a rate of 3,380, however the data can takes months to come out due to inquests, especially this year as they've been delayed. https://www.itv.com/news/2020-09-01/male-suicide-rate-highest-in-twenty-years-new-data-shows https://www.itv.com/news/2020-09-01/male-suicide-rate-highes... However even if suicide rates had doubled. In the UK in 2020 there have been 75,000 plus excess deaths. Based on the observed IFR, if Covid had run wild this would be more like 600,000 -- assuming no health care system collapse (which would have happened, and still might) While suicide is a tragedy, and in the UK a worryingly high one, the effects of covid (which aren't all due to lockdowns) would likely have increased it (economic downturns cause suicide). In any case, it's a very small number compared with the excess deaths that covid causes.
- abduhl 6y agoMost people don't lose their jobs/businesses/careers and kill themselves the next day or even the next month, but that doesn't mean that their eventual decline into depression and suicide wasn't triggered by that loss. And not to get into such a charged discussion, but it's also important to look at the ages of those dying of COVID versus those dying because of how we reacted to COVID.
- iso1631 6y agoYes the effects may last a long time, much of the effects should be mittigated by government though (suicide is often because of financial issues - something that governments can fix by issuing a new-deal style work program post vaccination to reboot the economy) However if Covid ran wild and infected 70% of the UK, and assuming no healthcare collapse, based on medium IFR figures from https://www.mrc-bsu.cam.ac.uk/now-casting/ https://www.mrc-bsu.cam.ac.uk/now-casting/ There would be 38,413 deaths for those age 45-64 and 3,037 deaths for those age 25-44 In addition to the 100k 65-74 year olds, and the 350k 75+ Even if you felt those were acceptable figures, how would you deal with healthcare collapse? Decide to withhold hospital treatment from over 65s?
- birdyrooster 6y agoYou are making an appeal to your personal incredulity. Let me assure you, we’ve definitely considered the unintended consequences and it’s a bit of a misnomer because we already knew this would happen. Human psychology is not new. It’s sad and shitty. There is no alternative that isn’t shittier or we would be advocating for it. Do you have an alternative?
- onethought 6y agoI think more sadly, this strange "mental health" defence has been used to justify the needless deaths of 100,000s of people from COVID. There are orders of magnitude differences in the fatality rates of full lockdown mental health issues and zero lock down COVID deaths, it's not a hard decision at all. Compare Wuhan and New York WAY less death in Wuhan, with a much harsher authoritarian style lockdown (maximum mental duress you'd think). Or Melbourne Australia with a very strict lockdown compared with pick any major American city you like. Major difference in death rates. Edit: The trolley problem is really easy if one option kills 10,000 people and the other one kills 5... that's kind of difference we are talking about.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>which is always risky to weigh in on publicly, It wasn't always that way. Back in the day unless you said something totally out there and tone deaf (like something beyond the bounds of any commonly known ideology and on a highly sensitive topic) you didn't have much to worry about.
- tehwebguy 6y agoBack in what day?
- josephcsible 6y agoBefore Twitter existed.
- tehwebguy 6y agoGood thing there was no Twitter when MLK Jr shared his opinion, could have turned out badly for him.
- josephcsible 6y agoThere will always be nut jobs willing to go as far as to assassinate people they disagree with. The point is that "just" cancelling people you disagree with used to not be mainstream or common.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoImagine it's 2005 and Lebron says something unflammatory like "McVeigh had the right idea" or something. It would be in the sports news for one evening. Everyone would be like "ok weirdo". Some sports commentator would dredge it up in 2008 as a punchline to a joke and that would be it. The same thing in 2020 and someone would write a manifesto about how he's Literally Hitler(TM). There would be 50-50 odds a major outlet would publish that manifesto. The league would bench him for a substantial time. ESPN would distance themselves. He'd lose promotion deals. It would seriously negatively impact his career despite having exactly zero bearing on his ability to play basketball, the thing he's paid to do. Edit: Better, non-hypothetical examples: Mel Gibson had to drunkenly spout hateful things about people who are important in his industry to get kicked out of it. These days you don't even have to offend people relevant to you to get that kind of treatment. Look at the flak that 2000s rappers caught for song lyrics that objectified women and glorified street violence. Now imagine what that kind of backlash would look like today. Probably much bigger.
- glangdale 6y agoI'm always a bit baffled that any increase "suicide during COVID" is supposedly something that can be neatly blamed on lockdown measures. Isn't it at least possible that people could be committing suicide due to reasons that are directly causally connected to COVID - whether that is fear of illness/death, a sense of the world ending, death/serious illness of a close relative or friend and/or having been sick with COVID themselves? The last possibility seems particularly unnerving given how many people have had COVID and the fact that there do seem to be a good number of 'long-haulers' (some of whom report psychological effects). I don't know if there's a good way of quantifying this, but the idea that every suicide during COVID is 100% casually connected to lockdown measures (or the knock-on consequences of lockdown, such as job losses) seems like an article of faith.
- nicoburns 6y agoDo you really need evidence for this? 99% of the people I know are really struggling with the lockdown measures (although most of them accept they are neccesary). And the vast majority of those are due to lonliness. Only a few are actually scared of covid.
- mech422 6y agoDo you not need evidence? Anecdata that results in wrong conclusions could cost people's lives... For instance, what if lack of grief counseling after losing a loved one is a leading cause? We'd want to make sure people that need it can get the counseling, rather then just blame it on lock down.
- criddell 6y ago99%? We move in very different circles. A significant number of people that I know are doing pretty well. Working from home, having to travel less, fewer social commitments, and more time to spend on movies, reading, etc... are all things that appeal to some people. I've had more than one conversation that eventually has somebody saying they feel like an asshole for saying so (because they know people are hurting), but they like the new normal.
- mundo 6y agoThe underlying assumption here, that there are some areas that decided to lockdown and others that didn't, and each had different pros and cons, seems wildly inaccurate. The reality is that almost everywhere in the world did a lockdown of some kind, but in some areas it was effective and in other areas it was not; and, while everyone has suffered consequences of some kind, the consequences suffered by the latter group exceed those of the former by a wide and obvious margin.
- ineedasername 6y agoThe problem with tradeoffs related to COVID restrictions is that we can much more easily quantify one side of the trade off than the other. The Trolley problem at least usually stipulates the consequences of each choice. The second and third order consequences of COVID restrictions are extremely difficult to quantify especially during the crisis. So we are forced to make decisions about trade offs without knowing nearly the full nature of the trade.
- tachyonbeam 6y agoWell, the insane thing to me here, is exactly that. Every country immediately jumped onto the lockdown bandwagon, presumably because of peer-pressure, to avoid being shamed. We jumped into this and sacrificed fundamental freedoms without being able to quantify what the short, medium and long-term consequences of a lockdown would be, or how long we'd need to stay into lockdown. I think it's quite possible that the medicine could be worse than the disease, but that discussion hasn't even been had.
- jodrellblank 6y ago> "Every country immediately jumped onto the lockdown bandwagon" Sweden had no lockdown; The Lancet editor, a member of SAGE and the UK's former Health Secretary all said the UK lockdown was late and cost many lives for being late. Italy locked down on 9th March, Singapore on 7th April, Kuwait on 10th May, Bhutan on 11th August. It's not every country, it wasn't all at the same time, and it definitely wasn't immediate - e.g. within a few days of Wuhan's first lockdown on 23rd January. > "presumably because of peer-pressure, to avoid being shamed." Presumably because of a global disease pandemic. > "I think it's quite possible that the medicine could be worse than the disease, but that discussion hasn't even been had." It's been had a lot, months and months of it. Committees of medics, researchers, policy advisors, economists, politicians, civil servants, have debated it, Twitter threads have argued it, newspapers have written about it, it's being discussed right here in this thread on HN.
- gfxgirl 6y agoI have the opposite pov. The anti-lockdown people always seem to argue that without lockdown there would be zero economic consequences. They argue in some fantasy alternate timeline where everyone under 60 just goes about their business as usual. That's not what would happen. People would still avoid going out. Companies would still enforce work from home, etc. Hospitals would likely be full so when you went to get route medical treatment you'd run into a wall and quickly learn to take COVID seriously. It's not clear at all that the results wouldn't have all the same economic consequences on top of way more death
- sgtnoodle 6y agoIf you expect society to act responsibly whether or not the government mandates a lockdown, then isn't a government mandated lockdown unnecessary? And if so, isn't unnecessary government regulation strictly worse for the economy?
- stolenmerch 6y agoNo need to pretend there is some fantasy alternate timeline. There are several states that never had a lockdown[1] and even more that had less strict stay-at-home orders. Compare the COVID-19 numbers (ICU headroom in particular) from this year[2] for states with lockdowns vs. states with no lockdown. Also check out the current unemployment rates for each state.[3] Thee west coast faired no better than the midwest on several metrics. This is a back-of-the-napkin analysis to be sure, but it certainly suggests the anti-lockdown folks at least have a valid point that should be listened to in good faith. [1] https://ballotpedia.org/States_that_did_not_issue_stay-at-home_orders_in_response_to_the_coronavirus_(COVID-19)_pandemic,_2020 https://ballotpedia.org/States_that_did_not_issue_stay-at-ho... [2] https://covidactnow.org https://covidactnow.org [3] https://www.usnews.com/news/best-states/articles/unemployment-rate-by-state https://www.usnews.com/news/best-states/articles/unemploymen...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- freeflight 6y ago> It is becoming a political topic Good because this is not a new problem [0], it's merely exacerbated by the pandemic. Hopefully this finally gets the recognition it deserves and needs instead of being framed solely as a side-effect of the lock-downs. Sadly mental health is still a topic that's mostly stigmatized in many places along the lines of "only weak minded people struggle with depression", while resources and institutions to deal with it have had their budgets cut, and been closed down, for decades. [0] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2212657019300911 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S221265701...
- cylinder 6y agoWe had a 5% decline in suicide this year in Sydney. Although it wasn’t a very hard or long lockdown. The hypothesis is that increased welfare payments may be the reason but personally I believe the slow down/pause to what was a hectic pace of life, and being at home with family more contributed.
- tw34542 6y agoAnecdotally, i always thought i was a resilient person but unemployment is really getting to me. i finished my phd last December, have done excellent work published really good journals in my field (and publicly well known) but i couldn't stand the insane hours in academia. my advisor took out patents on my first author work but i did't argue for the sake of my degree. I have no network because i just sat in my office and worked daily...didn't make many friends in grad school...just worked. i'm never going back to academia; rent seeking vampires. the worst part is my advisor discouraged me from looking for internships over the summer. kicked me to the curb after all of that work. now, I send out applications daily, work on 'projects', and grind leetcode. It's so hard to get an interview without any network. I'm a very disciplined person, gym in the morning, eat breakfast in the office and work until my goals for the day are met. moving back home, unemployment, and no gym removed those structures from my life. I run a lot now days but the gym was my social life. my phd involved a lot of coding, hpc work, and 'data science', i don't understand why i can't get past recruiters. it sucks being 30, doing a difficult thing, and now being broke and unemployable. my undergrad students i taught have found jobs...i don't understand. in the interviews i've gotten, it seems like if i make one little mistake, i'm out or ghosted. i wrote and app for a well-known start-up in my area and then they ghosted me. i don't get this market. i'm starting to get really scared; these past two weeks i've sat in my room silently screaming and crying...I've never done that in my life. i run by some cliffs on a hillside and have really started to wonder...because i'm not afraid. i just don't want my family to have to go through it....creeping thoughts of uselessness, wasted life, and being a burden. sorry it's fragmented and don't worry i'm not going to do anything drastic...i still want to learn to paraglide and get to the top of denali...i can't go through life without doing those. ..i think my going to find some open source projects to contribute to...i think that might be a good way of doing things. anyway a view from the other-side. sorry for the vent...i don't have anyone to talk to.
- jdsalaro 6y agoThis might be uncalled for, but from your comment it seems like you could really use some input. IMHO it isn't qualifications you're lacking, but a method for "working smart" and proving you can adapt to the industry on top of being able to work hard; as you've surely noticed, the latter is seldom enough. You "don't get this market" probably because you haven't understood what the companies you're applying to are looking for, and you haven't understood what they're looking for likely because you need to recalibrate your understanding of value delivery and expectations in the industry as opposed to academia. You can contact me (info in bio) in case you want me to look at your CV, want to do a mock job interview or want other sort of feedback. In any case, stay strong! Also, https://www.reddit.com/r/cscareerquestions https://www.reddit.com/r/cscareerquestions and https://www.reddit.com/r/cscareerquestionsEU https://www.reddit.com/r/cscareerquestionsEU might come in handy.
- sgustard 6y agoThe point is, even if there weren't lockdowns, the psychological toll of the virus would be huge. Plenty of people would self-isolate anyway out of justified fear of the virus. In fact, being surrounded by people who recklessly disregard risk is even more damaging for those who are cautious. It is difficult to separate the cost of specific lockdowns from the overall mental toll of living through a pandemic.