10 ms·
A drone pilot was fined $182K by the FAA
- WJW 6y agoWow, just wow. Continuing to post youtube videos of your unlicensed drone flying in controlled airspace after already receiving two written warnings from the FAA is pretty stupid. Also this gem: "These clips also revealed flight in hazardous conditions including heavy rain, fog, snow, and close proximity to buildings in downtown Philadelphia. There was also posted proof of the pilot intentionally losing radio signal, and control, of his drone." That goes way beyong "innocent experimentation with your new drone" and into "deliberately endangering people and property", especially if you've been warned about it twice already. Youtube money must've been pretty good to keep going.
- rualca 6y ago> Youtube money must've been pretty good to keep going. The idiot's most viewed video has about 33k views. I'm not sure that's enough to cover $200k in fines.
- gameswithgo 6y agonot even close!
- knodi 6y agoGood
- scoot 6y agoThe videos don’t appear to be monetized, which is just as well, since that would be another violation - unlicensed commercial drone flight.
- redis_mlc 6y agoYou can likely monetize Youtube for incidental footage during your flights without a commercial drone license, but not for real estate, pipeline, etc. This is more of a concern, and likely heavily violated: "You must fly in Class G airspace. If you need to fly in Class B, C, D or E controlled airspace, you need to apply for airspace authorization." https://www.dronepilotgroundschool.com/drone-license/ https://www.dronepilotgroundschool.com/drone-license/ Most US cities would be Class B/C to the ground near a large airport, and Class D/E would be common for smaller cities.
- scoot 6y ago> You can likely monetize Youtube for incidental footage during your flights without a commercial drone license It's a grey area I agree; but if you're filming your flights with the intention of putting the videos on YouTube and monetizing them, that's arguably commercial use.
- aeternum 6y agoIt is a grey area, but if the FAA goes after drone pilots for this, then they should also go after the many student and private pilots who monetize their training and flight videos.
- danaliv 6y agoFair warning to anyone thinking of taking advantage of this gray area: the FAA is very, very strict when it comes to interpreting whether something is a commercial op. Pilots, for example, are considered to be getting compensation when they log flight hours, even if no money changes hands. (If this sounds ridiculous, you’ve never had to build 1500 hours. Every tenth is solid gold.)
- redis_mlc 6y ago> Pilots, for example, are considered to be getting compensation when they log flight hours, even if no money changes hands. The above comment is so vague that I won't even comment on it. Depending on the details, it could be either correct or not. 1) For example, if I fly an airplane, I can take real estate photos that I sell myself as a private pilot. That's how many new pilots funded further training back in the day. There are several other business activities that private pilots are allowed to do. 2) Most pilots log all hours flown, without concern for whether being paid or not. (The only required logged hours are to meet various currency requirements, but I've never seen anybody do minimal logging.) So when interpreting FAA drone rules, I would carefully read them with the understanding of how airplane and airspace rules reply, hence my original post above. If you don't know why and how the FARS were written, then you're probably wrong, as most of the posts above appear to be uninformed. The most important thing to know about FARS is that they're intended to separate traffic. So if your drone is in an airspace where other aircraft are flying, you likely have a violation. If you recall a couple years ago, drone pilots griped about 400' or 500' AGL max. Well, look at a sectional chart to see why. If you can't read a sectional chart, you shouldn't be flying drones near a city or airport.
- JKCalhoun 6y ago"There was also posted proof of the pilot intentionally losing radio signal, and control, of his drone." I wish there were an exception for this. Likely the drone had programmed waypoints and was in an autonomous mode. I remember hearing about attempts (back in the 80's?) to send a self-piloting model airplane across the Atlantic. I believe they finally succeeded? Fascinating to me. Utterly illegal I suppose. But weather balloons get pass? I know amateurs launch balloons as well — perhaps there are restrictions however (like not near an airport, etc.). Just some random thoughts. EDIT, found a successful crossing in 2003, I thought there was an earlier one — perhaps only earlier failures. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Spirit_of_Butts%27_Farm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Spirit_of_Butts%27_Farm https://www.sciencenewsforstudents.org/article/model-plane-flies-atlantic https://www.sciencenewsforstudents.org/article/model-plane-f...
- koluna 6y ago> But weather balloons get pass? Those are licensed and regulated. And I am pretty sure that if FAA sends you a notice to stop flying your weather balloon, you stop flying it. It’s not like this “pilot” didn’t know what he was doing - he received written warnings and chose to ignore those.
- ProAm 6y ago> Those are licensed and regulated. And I am pretty sure that if FAA sends you a notice to stop flying your weather balloon, you stop flying it. This is not true, as for certain weights of payloads are regulated, all these 'near-space' hobbyist balloons do not need to notify the FAA about anything. It's common courtesy to let them know you are going to send something up to 120,000' but not required.
- reaperducer 6y agoPointing out an exception does not make the previous comment false.
- danaliv 6y agoAre you sure? I looked into this extensively a few years ago, and while I don’t remember well enough to say with certainty, I recall there being strict equipment requirements (e.g. redundant payload releases) and a requirement to notify any ATC sectors your balloon will pass through.
- nathancahill 6y agoThis is the original link, the dpreview link is editorialized: https://jrupprechtlaw.com/drone-pilot-received-182000-proposed-fine/ https://jrupprechtlaw.com/drone-pilot-received-182000-propos...
- scoot 6y agoI wouldn’t say editorialised so much as summarised, and without the casual tone. I didn’t get any more information from reading the original than the one posted, despite the length of the former.
- nathancahill 6y agoHere's the pilot's YT channel¹, and one of the videos that triggered the fines: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MQx6xhSSKco https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MQx6xhSSKco ¹https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCrLRWeZSXoTrDlZ5zfkWjQA https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCrLRWeZSXoTrDlZ5zfkWjQA
- hanklazard 6y agoThe Philly accent is truly something to behold.
- Medox 6y agothere's also his response: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L_GgqTMvx-I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L_GgqTMvx-I
- loeg 6y ago@4:21 he claims to not know about any drone flight regulation rules until "a day ago" (video from November 27, 2020). That doesn't exactly square with receiving multiple FAA warnings, as early as October or November 2019.
- fblp 6y agoThanks for sharing. That video to me indicates that he has a child-like blind love for his drones. I imagine he couldn't give up that love even as he got the letters from the FAA.
- strogonoff 6y agoOn one hand, cases like this is why responsible pilots may become (and in some countries already are) unable to fly a drone without jumping through bureaucratic hoops. On the other hand, the About section of his channel is a poignant read. In my eyes, DJI application’s UI is as much (if not more) to blame here. It puts way, way too little emphasis on FAA regulation violations; a small corner alert when entering a controlled airspace is IMO inexcusable (“Fly with caution” and then it disappears). Generally speaking, the app knows everything necessary—location, country, time of day, lighting conditions—to show a big “Only proceed if you are indoors, outdoor flight is subject to $xxxxx fine” warning before flight takes place.
- djohnston 6y agoI have a friend who likes to fly his drone in a valley. I asked him about helicopters, which are in the area since there are a lot of ski resorts, and he just shrugged. There's really a crazy level of incompetency when it comes to these amateur drone pilots and I fear the gap will only be plugged with blood.
- kawsper 6y agoIt doesn't help that the drone community is full of people that do risky (not to themselves) stunts: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TJgRuMXBHHI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TJgRuMXBHHI
- mindslight 6y agoI'm not into drones myself so forgive me if I'm missing something obvious, but I'm a bit puzzled by all of these comments about safety. What exactly do you see as risky in that video? That drone is what, half a pound? It seems like the biggest risk is it hitting a pedestrian or cyclist (of which I did not see any), and could result in perhaps a single person needing to go the hospital. Meanwhile that video shows a bridge full of a hundred vehicles with one ton+ curb weights, driving at one another, piloted by what are most likely bored inattentive drivers. Due to the vehicle weights, there's extreme danger to pedestrians (over a hundred thousand causalities per year in the US, deemed acceptable). Due to the large difference between weight classes of vehicles, there's a significant risk to the passengers of those vehicles. And it's kept in line mostly by voluntary adherence to visual boundaries and an expectation that drivers will hit the breaks if the vehicles they're driving at change course.
- serf 6y ago>That drone is what, half a pound? It seems like the biggest risk is it hitting a pedestrian or cyclist (of which I did not see any), and could result in perhaps a single person needing to go the hospital. What happens when a half pound drone that's going 15+ kph hits an oncoming car windshield going many times that speed? >hundred vehicles with one ton+ curb weights, driving at one another, piloted by what are most likely bored inattentive drivers. what happens when you distract those drives with an aerial nuisance while they're trying to cross a bridge that offers no positive outcomes if the vehicle vector is changed? Things don't have to be universally safe to point out a safety flaw with a specific variable. Driving cars isn't safe, but doing something unsafe while compounded with distractions and possible bogeys is even more unsafe.
- inoffensivename 6y agoAs a pilot: good. This kind of behavior needs to be stamped out before it gets someone killed.
- sokoloff 6y agoAlso a pilot (and also annoyed by some drone operators). To me, this one didn't seem that egregious/bothersome. Virtually all of his operations in the video I watched were under 500' MSL (so below where even helos would be typically be operating and well below any fixed-wing operations). When the FAA warns you and you decide to YOLO it, I don't cry for you when you get what they promised you, but a few hundred feet over cities is nothing compared to flying beyond visual contact at altitudes where airplanes are commonly traveling.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Clubber 6y agoDoesn't the fine seem excessive? I mean I would think $500 would get the point across. Seems like they are ruining this guy financially to make an example. You know he's gonna end up in jail due to inability to pay (debtor's prison?). That seems totalitarian to me.
- mikestew 6y agoI mean I would think $500 would get the point across. You would think two letters from the FAA would get the point across. But you think it’s totalitarian not to give them just one more chance.
- hh3k0 6y agoHonestly, after ignoring these two letters he was _begging_ the FAA to make an example of him. Fine him $500 after two stern warnings? That's a good way to make sure that absolutely no one will heed any of your warnings in the future. I don't see anything totalitarian about it. I wonder, is GP by any chance a libertarian? The man is getting his just deserts, and that's all there is to it.
- Clubber 6y agoHow about a million dollar fine then? Is that excessive? Here's the text of the 8th amendment of the US Constitution, part of the Bill of Rights. "Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted."
- hh3k0 6y agoIt is not excessive, if one operates a drone recklessly with no regards for air traffic over a busy city… well, that behavior is endangering many. As far as I am concerned, he is no better than someone who tries to blind pilots with a laser pointer (and there's precedent for that): > Interfering with the operation of an aircraft is a crime punishable by a maximum of 20 years in prison and a $250,000 fine. (Source: fbi.gov) Kudos to the FAA for nipping that in the bud.
- bane 6y agoMy neighbors had a wedding in their front yard a few weeks ago. The photography of it included a dramatic drone scene where the drone took off from the couple and flew away at tree top level (about 60-80 ft). We live within 5 miles (as the crow flies) of a major international airport. Did they have an airspace authorization? I have absolutely no idea. Did they know they needed one? Probably not. Was there risk of any in-flight aircraft incidents? Not really, unless somebody was flying in the canopy of our local trees over a bunch of houses. To be honest the rules are confusing. For example, some cities have an absolute no-fly zone in and around the city. The rules then say you are free to fly (with certain restrictions) outside of that zone. But in major metros, the restricted zone is usually so large that it merges with other no-drone-fly zones (like the ones near other airports, air force bases and the like) making the entire metro practically a no-fly zone. We're talking about areas that are maybe more than a 1000 sq mi. In the pockets you can fly in, you usually need pre-authorization and have restrictions. At some point drones need to know where they can fly/can't fly (and simply report an error), automate the flight authorization and authorization envelope and just simply license pilots as well. Considering somebody with no training at all can buy a drone out of the local Best Buy, and probably can't read a pilot's navigation chart to understand what an airspace is, and probably doesn't know the regulations at all (or that there are any really), it's probably time.
- heartbreak 6y agoDJI drones (the post popular consumer drones) have software that clearly displays flight restrictions and won’t let you take off if you’re too close to an airport. You can put in your code from the FAA to unlock an area if you get your approval. The problem with flying low near an airport isn’t that you might collide with a plane flying at 50 feet AGL, it’s that you’ll have an uncontrolled flyaway incident.
- mathogre 6y agoAs a hobbyist: Good! I like flying my drone, and I do so responsibly. I don't want people like this ruining it for others, and I especially don't want people like this endangering others with their irresponsible behavior. I have a DJI Mavic Mini. If you're marginally competent, DJI makes it very clear that you are operating an aircraft and have rules to follow. In certain circumstances, you do not need to be Part 107 certified to operate this aircraft, nor do you need to register your aircraft. That said, you still must follow all related FAA regulations, like them or not. From the linked video from @nathancahill below, I see the Beyond Visual Line of Sight (BVLOS) issue, night time flying (appeared to be started before the 30 minute twilight, and I doubt he had supplemental lighting which would have brought it over the weight limit for registration), and generally reckless operation. Height is to be 400 feet AGL (above ground level) unless near structures, which allows you to operate 400 feet above that (§14CFR107.51(b)). The FAA warned him. He didn't pay attention. Maybe a $182K fine will get his attention.
- mig39 6y agoIronically, the Mavic Mini seems to have been designed to not be subject to rules, especially in other countries. Here in Canada, none of the drone rules and regulations apply to it, as it's too small to be considered a drone. I have a drone ... addiction. I generally use my Mavic 2 for most of my flights, but when I want to fly somewhere I'm not allowed to fly, I switch to the Mavic Mini. So yeah, all those rules the FAA has in the USA, we have similar rules in Canada and other countries. But they don't apply to the Mavic Mini.
- Sodman 6y agoThis is largely true in the US as well, the Mavic Mini is 249 grams intentionally because most of the FAA rules explicitly only apply to aircraft >= 250g. They know exactly what they're doing, it's literally the first question in their FAQ page - https://www.dji.com/mavic-mini/faq https://www.dji.com/mavic-mini/faq I'm generally very pro-drone but this definitely makes it hard to defend the hobby against anti-drone arguments. Most of the things people complain about we can say "Well that's already illegal, and with RemoteID it will be much easier to report them and have consequences"... But these 249g drones with 30 mins battery life and 4k cameras don't have to follow a many of these laws, even though they cause a large proportion of the problems.
- amelius 6y agoHow about the guy flying with the jetpack on his back?