4 ms·
I sincerely doubt that basic income will make us all Victorian-era gentleman scientists and patrons of the arts. I agree with the premise that culture comes fro
by nicbou 6y ago
I sincerely doubt that basic income will make us all Victorian-era gentleman scientists and patrons of the arts. I agree with the premise that culture comes from leisure, but realistically, if you give everyone a fixed amount of money, won't the cost of things just rise accordingly?
Instead of giving people free money, wouldn't it make more sense to heavily subsidise the basics? Is there any indication that UBI would work better than guaranteeing affordable food, housing and healthcare?
- tt433 6y agoNot who you are replying to that's a bit of a strawman: he never said anything about Victorian era gentlemen. The book he mentioned doesn't either, at least in the first few pages. Why do you start talking about that? Usually when other people mis-state what I say, I get pretty angry.
- glenstein 6y agoMore than a bit, it's massive strawman that wastes everyone's time, no pun intended. To the extent that people have tried to develop a Theory Of Comment Sections and why they are so frequently, unfortunately bad, most of it centers around the frequency of uncharitable bad faith engagement with things that could be interpreted more reasonably. Nobody addresses themselves to the most reasonable interpretation of the thing they respond to, and that's the primary mechanism that pushes the quality of comment sections down. And I think we've got another datapoint in support of that here.
- DougN7 6y agoI think he meant that we’ll not see a huge amount of increased art and beauty. Instead, and I think, we’ll see more consuming of entertainment (video games and youtube).
- nicbou 6y agoIt was tongue-in-cheek way to say "make art and pursue other hobbies".
- taneq 6y ago> if you give everyone a fixed amount of money, won't the cost of things just rise accordingly? I hear this argument a lot but I don't think it necessarily follows: - The supply of low end goods (the sort which you can afford with your UBI) is highly automated and will increase rapidly for any small price increase, making their pricing fairly inelastic. - The demand for these goods won't rise greatly (except for low end luxury / status items, for which UBI makes the difference between people buying and not) since anyone living above a subsistence level is already buying roughly as much as they need (they're just feeling more financial stress now by doing so). So overall I'd expect we might see a small price rise but nowhere near enough to cancel out the UBI.
- balfirevic 6y agoThat's probably true, except for one important category of goods that has a tendency to suck as much income from people as they can bear - housing. It is true that with UBI people have the option to move somewhere where housing is inexpensive, but I don't think it's desirable to have people already dependent on UBI move to places with lower economic opportunity - cementing their dependence on it. That being said, expensive housing is a problem that exists with or without UBI, even if it would interact with it in an unfortunate ways.
- amelius 6y ago> That's probably true, except for one important category of goods that have a tendency to suck as much income from people as they can bear - housing. Exactly. One important piece of evidence is how housing became more expensive when families got double incomes.
- kebman 6y agoIf you own a rental in an inexpensive part of town, or perhaps outside town, and you know a lot of people will be looking for more peripheral and inexpensive places, what would you do with that rental? I think most owners would simply increase rent as demand also increased. It might be slightly beneficial for the price of central apartments, but then most people like the convenience of being close to shops and public communications.
- throwaway2245 6y ago> if you give everyone a fixed amount of money, won't the cost of things just rise accordingly? > wouldn't it make more sense to heavily subsidise the basics? Breaking this down a little: Industries with monopolist practices can be expected to raise their prices to capture more of this new income. I agree, that seems likely. In my mind, this would likely include housing/land ownership. By proposing to subsidise housing instead, you're proposing to effectively give this money directly to landlords instead of to everyone to have their own negotiating power and make their own decision. But, won't the cost still just rise accordingly, by your theory - won't landlords just pocket that money and demand even more? It seems more effective to trust people with their own money.
- LoathsLights 6y ago> If you give everyone a fixed amount of money, won't the cost of things just rise accordingly? And what if it did? What if we gave every person the money and assets equivalent of the richest man on earth, 113 billion dollars [1]. Now Bezos would only be about twice as rich as the average person. Instead of being 1.13 million times as rich as the average household in the US [0]. Surely the prices would skyrocket, but now we're at a more even playing field. [0]: https://www.marketwatch.com/story/whats-your-net-worth-and-how-do-you-compare-to-others-2018-09-24 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/whats-your-net-worth-and-h... [1]: https://www.forbes.com/billionaires https://www.forbes.com/billionaires
- BTinfinity 6y agoSurely Bezos would adjust his prices as well, increasing his profit and leaving the playing fields very similar to what they are now
- LoathsLights 6y agoThat's why I included assets in the proposition, and not just the money. He would still have the ability to earn about twice as much as others given he also will be given the same amount of assets as the rest of the people. edit: Which kinda makes it a bad comparison to UBI I guess. Maybe what we need is more than just money for UBI, but also a distribution of assets.