9 ms·
Again I remind about the idea of exponential patents: the holder has to pay every year twice as much as last year. If the patent is protecting some business's
by nine_k 6y ago
Again I remind about the idea of exponential patents: the holder has to pay every year twice as much as last year.
If the patent is protecting some business's hockey-stick growth, it's worth the fee, so it fulfills the original purpose of patents, that is, avoiding trade secrets while protecting cash-cow inventions for a limited time.
But sitting on a patent becomes prohibitively expensive soon enough even for a large company.
- amelius 6y agoI think the major flaw in patents is that they provide a monopoly on the technology (for a limited time). Monopolies are bad. Let the USPTO determine a fair price for a technology. That way the company can decide if they keep the technology secret, and the USPTO can decide if they think the technology is too important for society and it needs to be open (and thus increase the price). Other companies can then get a license on the technology for that price. And no companies can be denied access to a technology (like the current situation).
- WalterBright 6y agoNobody, and certainly not the USPTO, is able to determine the future value of any patent.
- amelius 6y agoNobody can predict the future value of pretty much anything, yet trading happens all the time. To improve the predictive capability of the USPTO, they could host a bidding process in which other companies can participate.
- finnh 6y agoThat's kind of what the private market already does, without the PTO's involvement. If people think your patent has value, they can license or or buy rights to it.
- amelius 6y agoNo, because if the patent applicant keeps the technology secret, there is no patent. Meaning the road is open for other companies to invent the same technology.
- nine_k 6y agoThe point of patents is that the invention should be described, and patents are publicly accessible. This is what allows you to discuss infringements in a regular court.
- justinclift 6y agoJust to point out, there do seem to be certain (niche) fields where Patents can be kept "secret". eg National Security, Nuclear, (etc) type of things: https://slate.com/technology/2018/05/the-thousands-of-secret-patents-that-the-u-s-government-refuses-to-make-public.html https://slate.com/technology/2018/05/the-thousands-of-secret...
- ptero 6y agoI have pretty low faith in USPTO (or, to be fair, any other organization), making reasonable predictions on the technology value. And even if they did, I think inventors would feel low-balled: "those idiots did not understand the revolutionary benefit of my invention", etc. Rather than trying to estimate the value of the idea we could drastically reduce the time for patent protection. Shortening protection period to 2-5 years should still encourage inventions, but would discourage early carpet-bombing filings (which scare many inventors away) as well as move successful inventions into public domain while they are still relevant. My 2c.
- jbay808 6y ago5 years is plenty of time for patenting some clever software trick that took a minute to think up and a week to implement (eg. minigames in loading screens). But some inventions take years or even decades of research (eg in materials science) and, even after being invented, may take a year or more to spool up the production line, let alone the procurement process.
- Leherenn 6y agoWould it make sense to have the patent office choose the patent length between say 2 to 20 years? Estimating the value seems pretty much impossible, but estimating a length seems more reasonable. Clever software trick, quick to invent, easy to capitalise -> 2 years. Ground breaking new drug/material with slow market deployment -> 20 years. There's still some subjectivity involved (but that's already the case with the current patent system), but you could try to base it on some objective metrics.
- iguy 6y agoOr perhaps it could be a fixed duration per field, somehow, so that you know before filing what you will get. It would be easy to discriminate between 20 years for drugs vs. 5 for anything software, but I guess it's tricky to decide whether something like e-paper should count as fast-moving consumer-facing tech or hard-won physics/chemistry knowledge.
- 6y ago
- rektide 6y agoit being impossible to get 100% right doesn't mean we must be afraid to try to assess merit. perhaps a fair value assessment might include some % of revenue or profit, to self adjust?
- WalterBright 6y agoIt's not likely to be remotely correct. The only people who have a chance at it are those who are willing to risk their own money on it.
- paxys 6y agoCompulsory licensing is already a thing in many countries. It's mostly used in drug manufacturing.
- olliej 6y agoCopyright also provides a monopoly, that’s the whole point, if it didn’t then the GPL, etc would be useless.
- erhk 6y agoWhy should I invest in R&D then
- visarga 6y agoThat's right, the greedy approach would free a patent now to unlock a technology, but what do we do about not freezing creativity over the next decade?
- contingencies 6y agoIdeas are global though, and the patent system isn't. In order to turn a patent in to a literal recipe for a competing product all you have to do is step out of a registered jurisdiction. So people who actually come up with something meaningful have the financial burden of registering in numerous major jurisdictions at a minimum. However, each comes with its own quirks, costs, and processes, some of which can be slower (eg. Japan) or qualitatively different (actual novelty checks performed vs. only cursory inspection) and thus vary from verging on legally dubious (more like "option to expend lawyers on creating problems for competitors in the future" than actual patent) to total lockdown. It's a mess. Mostly it only keeps patent lawyers in business. We need to get rid of it.
- rektide 6y agoweird juxtaposition of arguments. you start by arguing that one system's rules aren't relevant when there are many jurisdictions. then you talk about each jurisdiction having very unique flavors & characters to them. the favt that the uspto governs such a vast share of products-sold carries a lot of weight. I tend to think increasing the cost of patents is a silly idea, because right now they cost nearly nothing if you file & do the reject/re-apply dance yourself (and know how to). unless we the people are going to start charging billions for good ideas being monopolized, I tend towards a fair reasonable & non-discriminatory access model for all ideas, with a depreciating over time scale. i'd rather open the closed system than try to find the right price for it. but either way, I think the uspto & Congress has a lot of power to fix this practically free hand out that ongoingly locks down this world & obstructs progress time & time again.
- contingencies 6y agoIf we begin with the unspoken assumption that the system is supposed to be useful, then it's effectively dead in the water because ideas aren't under national jurisdictions. I think this "weird juxtaposition" is the innate problem with the status quo.
- mschuster91 6y ago> In order to turn a patent in to a literal recipe for a competing product all you have to do is step out of a registered jurisdiction. When you have a registered patent in the USA and the EU, there is no real alternative market for competition except India and China - because both the US and EU will reject any import of a patent-violating product.
- dman 6y agoWhy would the USPTO not rig things in favor of US companies by underpricing the value of patents from foreign companies?
- IlliOnato 6y agoFor every complex problem there is an answer that is clear, simple, and wrong. H. L. Mencken
- giancarlostoro 6y agoIf you merely double the cost though it removes the human element for error.
- godelski 6y agoI want to nitpick. Monopolies aren't bad. Monopolies tend to be dangerous because they aren't self regulating and they can easily extort consumers. But monopolies can also be very useful to consumers if they are acting in their interests, particularly in goods that have network effects (where the number of participants directly increases the product's utility or makes it cheaper. As opposed to a S curve). Bell labs existed because the government gave Bell a monopoly over telephone networks so there wouldn't be hundreds of wires everywhere (literal network), but the lab was part of the deal.
- fredguth 6y agoI am no fan of the patent system, but what you propose is worse. Companies can get a license but by a price defined by the market. Giving this power to some burocrat seems odd.
- fossuser 6y agoI think this would just move people back to trade secrets. That said, I think patents could be given out less often when the operation of the device is clear or can easily be discovered by the public without a patent. E-Ink screens released without a patent kept under 'trade secret' wouldn't have mattered, the idea would have been implemented elsewhere. I suppose you could argue that without exclusive rights the original inventor wouldn't have bothered to create it at all - in that case there's probably a better middle ground of something less than 20yrs. 5yrs? 2yrs? First $1million in profit?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fastball 6y agoIs moving back to "trade secrets" really a bad thing? Is there any evidence that the introduction of patents actually encouraged innovation?
- fossuser 6y agoThe purpose was to both incentivize invention, but also require detailed specs of that invention to be given to the public. In exchange the inventor gets exclusive rights for a limited time. If trade secrets cause knowledge to be held from the public and then ultimately lost that would be worse. Whether that’s still relevant today I don’t know. In cases with massive research R&D like drug discovery they still seem really important. In that case a trade secret wouldn’t be enough to justify up front investment if the drug can be copied and sold as a generic for cheap along side it.
- fastball 6y agoI'm not sure I understand how a patent system would ever encourage knowledge to be made public in a way that wouldn't have already happened. Even with a patent system, if your innovation is not easily reverse-engineered then you have no reason to patent it. If you invention is easily reverse-engineered, then the knowledge becomes public effectively as soon as you release your innovation, and that is when a patent is most useful.
- forgotmysn 6y agothats still not a good enough reason to maintain a failing system.
- ekianjo 6y ago> Again I remind about the idea of exponential patents: the holder has to pay every year twice as much as last year. Would not be very effective for companies like Amazon or Apple which have billions to play with. Rather a 5 years maximum duration would be more effective across the board instead of the ridiculous 20 years we have to live with.
- enraged_camel 6y ago>> Would not be very effective for companies like Amazon or Apple which have billions to play with. On the contrary, such companies tend to have tons of patents. Apple for example has over 70,000 patents for the 2009-18 period alone. Exponential fees would quickly add up to a substantial amount of money on such a massive portfolio.
- Ekaros 6y agoHmm, maybe also have a them exponent by number of patents. So if you are small player you can handle having the core ones. If you are just throwing stuff at wall and see what sticks it gets really expensive. Could also force companies to focus on those patents that actually stand or are important for them...
- ardy42 6y ago> If the patent is protecting some business's hockey-stick growth, it's worth the fee, so it fulfills the original purpose of patents, that is, avoiding trade secrets while protecting cash-cow inventions for a limited time. Wasn't the original purpose of patents not to protect big business's hockey-stick grown, but to allow small inventors to capitalize on their inventions (and not have them shamelessly ripped off by some big business). I think the other original purpose was to make sure inventions would eventually become publicized and exploitable by all. That exponential patents idea seems like it would render patent protection prohibitively expensive for all except maybe the rich or inventors unusually well-position to quickly capitalize on their invention. The little guy who takes ten years to get his business off the ground is out of luck.
- chx 6y agoMy experience with the little guy and patents are second hand: my uncle is the literal bearded guy tinkering in his garage... until he invented a new sprinkler head which he promp tly patented. This was a massive win for everyone involved: he didn't need to raise enough capital to build a factory, on the other hand the factory who eventually bought it became one of the world leaders in the field and sold many millions of it without fronting the cost for the R&D process. So yes, sometimes the patent system works.
- NetOpWibby 6y agoWhat’s your uncle doing now? Still inventing?
- chx 6y agoHe is mostly retired, dabbling in some coding. Inbetween he rode the solar wave, had a successful solar installation company, with two more patents which of course were nowhere near as successful.
- cft 6y agoThe problem is that some areas of technology are now completely outside of the little guy's domain. Biotech and even electronics patents now require large r&d budgets, otherwise they're obvious and thus not innovative. In other words, a lone inventor in those areas without a serious R&D budget probably means a patent troll. I think in these areas (unlike mechanical engineering) patents should become exponential. As a reform, it would be more palpable to change the fee schedule depending on the area of the patent.
- andromeduck 6y agoI think having a mandatory auction + proceeds rebate system is better and then whoever holds it can write indefinite contracts/licences. For example, imagine you get 100% rebate of auction proceeds untill year 5, then it drops 1% per year: - at year 5 it's nearly impossible to do a hostile accquisition because you have a 100x advantage and only lose 1% of highest or second highest if it's a blind auctio. - by year 25 you have to pony up up to 20% FMV per year just to retain monopoly. And only have a 5x advantage vs a competing bidder. - the remaining fraction if paid back to consumers as basic income, can be thought of as a - losing an auction doesn't hurt your buisness operation if you wrote yourself a perpetual contract - auction loser is compensated less every year the contract ages and therefore has strong incentive to sublicense - government and trade groups can buy out key patents at fair prices - defensive patent pools still work, trolling is riskier
- runeks 6y agoWhy would it help to put an arbitrarily high price on a monopoly? In the case where the profit (from owning the patent) is less than the cost of the patent it will be equivalent to the absence of patents. In the case where the profit is higher than the patent cost it’s still a company bribing the government for monopoly rights. Unless the profits made by the government from patents is used to put a discount on the retail price of the product for which the patent is held. But even this is probably worse than free competition.