8 ms·
New bill upgrades unauthorized Internet streaming to a felony
- Jach 16y agoIt seems like a bunch of laws are trying to get around the "safe harbor" clause of the DMCA. This directly threatens Google, I'd think Google would be interested in either buying up the music and movie companies or, a much cheaper option, buying politicians. Perhaps that's the slippery slope to an Evil Google, but there don't seem to be many options for stopping the insanity. They may not pass the bill this time or next time but they keep bringing this stuff up, I can't help but think if they paperclip it to the right other giant-bill-everyone-is-in-favor-for it'll be bound to pass eventually.
- khermitian 16y agoPerhaps a better route for google is to put their cash into a grassroots anti-lobbyist campaign.
- danssig 16y agoThere is no "evil" or "good" Google. There is only Google; a publicly traded company.
- kevingadd 16y agoJust think of it as a job creation measure - jail lots of people for unauthorized internet streaming, that way we'll build more private prisons and hire corrections officers to staff them.
- anonymoushn 16y agoWe could just criminalize alcohol and tobacco (or start enforcing marijuana in the bay...) if we wanted to do that.
- younata 16y agos/bay/state of California/ Sadly, it's true.
- m_myers 16y agoThis is getting ridiculous. Under current U.S. law, felons cannot vote or carry guns; it isn't just a matter of a disproportionate prison sentence and fine.
- CWuestefeld 16y agoIn principle, it sounds like a good idea to prevent those bad people from voting. But now you can see that this can actually be used as a political weapon, to keep those you disagree with from having a voice.
- Terretta 16y agoOr a gun.
- eurohacker 16y agoyou americans seem to be under attack by the oligarchs, if you havent noticed yet
- anonymoushn 16y agoI'm not sure what to do about it. Voting doesn't do anything, and hoisting the red and black would only get me kidnapped or murdered.
- younata 16y ago"hoisting the red and black"? Google doesn't help (suggests maybe resorting to piracy, but that wouldn't result in you getting kidnapped/murdered), so would you explain that idiom?
- anonymoushn 16y agoThe most common anarchist flag is red and black.
- jussij 16y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anarchist_symbolism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anarchist_symbolism
- lwat 16y agoYou could move to Canada or somewhere so that you don't keep supporting the bad system with your tax dollars. That's about the only thing I can think of that might have any effect.
- cheez 16y agoAre you in Canada? Keeping up with the changes?
- anonymoushn 16y agoI could, but I would continue owing taxes to the U.S. for 10 years after giving up my citizenship. I could move to a country that doesn't have an extradition agreement with the United States and refuse to pay, but I don't really want to limit myself to those countries. I could also make my living under the table, but that would be against the law. I wouldn't want to break the law, because if I did that I might get kidnapped.
- 5l 16y agoNot that I support this in any way, but I can't quite comprehend the technical ignorance in legal circles that has lead them to distinguish between streaming and downloading in the first place.
- anigbrowl 16y agoThe definition of downloading was written into law before streaming became widespread; likely, when the former was used to prosecute someone for streaming copyrighted material, the defense pointed out the inadequacy of the existing definition. There's a distinction in law between downloading in the sense of saving something to your hard disk and just having it in RAM. Obviously, if I go to your website and see something on my screen, I have 'downloaded' in some fashion, but if just passing through memory was considered a download then running a program or opening a file would be considered equivalent to making a copy.
- bdhe 16y agoIs it just me, or has there been a flurry of internet-related legislation of late. With the PSN hack still fresh on their minds I wonder how much more legislation is yet to come. Between this, COICA and PROTECT IP, things are starting to look bleak. Are there similar precedents when other disruptive technologies started eating into traditional markets (maybe the introduction of tapes or CDs, or the telegraph and radio)?
- johngalt 16y ago"Did you really think we want those laws observed?" said Dr. Ferris. "We want them to be broken. You'd better get it straight that it's not a bunch of boy scouts you're up against... We're after power and we mean it... There's no way to rule innocent men. The only power any government has is the power to crack down on criminals. Well, when there aren't enough criminals one makes them. One declares so many things to be a crime that it becomes impossible for men to live without breaking laws. Who wants a nation of law-abiding citizens? What's there in that for anyone? But just pass the kind of laws that can neither be observed nor enforced or objectively interpreted – and you create a nation of law-breakers – and then you cash in on guilt. Now that's the system, Mr. Rearden, that's the game, and once you understand it, you'll be much easier to deal with." ('Atlas Shrugged' 1957)
- johnny22 16y agoquoting fiction doesn't help your case.
- johngalt 16y agoHow about non-fiction? http://www.amazon.com/Three-Felonies-Day-Target-Innocent/dp/1594032556 http://www.amazon.com/Three-Felonies-Day-Target-Innocent/dp/...
- anigbrowl 16y agoI'm a fan of that particular legal theorist, but I think you'll need to go a bit farther than merely mentioning the title, which refers to life in the USSR under communism. He's not saying that everyone in the US is actually committing 3 felonies a day, but rather arguing for tort reforms, better sunset provisions, and a more responsive legislative process. A great deal of law finds its way onto the books because 'it seemed like a good idea at the time,' and very often such laws are the result of populist pressure. Some are engineered by people with selfish motives, many are simply misguided.
- Bo102010 16y ago
- rorrr 16y agoGuys, it's a cheap trick. Introduce some ridiculous charges, hear the expected outrage, tune it down a bit to the levels they wanted.
- mcritz 16y agoHow does this idea serve to protect the American people?
- Construct 16y agoMaking this a felony is beyond harsh. For reference, here are a few other crimes classified as felonies: Murder, criminal sexual conduct, manslaughter, criminal vehicular homicide, assault, robbery (simple or aggravated), kidnapping, neglect or endangerment of a child, solicitation of juveniles, prostitution, arson, and burglary. And, if these senators (and their media industry supporters) are successful, unauthorized streaming of 10 or more copyrighted works in a 180-day period. You can't really argue that unauthorized streaming doesn't impact the entertainment industry negatively, but it should be obvious to everyone that the impact is not significant enough to make it a felony.
- jfoutz 16y agoWriting a bad check for more than $20 dollars, being drunk in public, or disturbing others by making loud and unreasonable noises, are all felonies. It's probably not a bad thing that this stuff would go to criminal court. I think criminal courts would be far less enthusiastic about claiming 1 song is worth thousands of dollars. Really, the amount of effort to prove something like this is off the charts. It's not like searching a car and finding a bag of weed. How many prosecutors are going to put together the logs to show this actually happend and it was worth more than 5k?
- humbledrone 16y agoIn most states you need to bounce a significantly larger check to become a felon: http://www.ckfraud.org/penalties.html http://www.ckfraud.org/penalties.html Being drunk in public is a misdemeanor: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_intoxication#State_public_intoxication_laws_today http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_intoxication#State_publi... As is disturbing the peace: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disturbing_the_peace http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disturbing_the_peace
- jfoutz 16y agoHmm. I must have been mistaken about the check fraud - or things have changed in the last 20 years. disturbing the peace and disorderly conduct have a felony versions when weapons or drugs are present. The point is, stealing $5000 is a big deal. Streaming $5000 dollars worth of unlicensed music for public performance could be a big deal too. However, i have a hard time believing a criminal court would value a streamed song at much more than a few cents each. You'd literally be streaming thousands of songs a day. This isn't (afaik) streaming your stuff to your family, it's cloning pandora and not paying license fees.
- sehugg 16y ago"What are you in for?" "Karaoke."
- Luyt 16y agoThat's what I call a draconian law. "Draconian is an adjective meaning great severity, that derives from Draco, an Athenian law scribe under whom small offences had heavy punishments."
- bfrog 16y agoAt what point do we just call the US government what it really is, an oligarchy. Republics actually represent the public at large not just the wealthy and connected.
- pstack 16y agoI'm reluctant to accept any violation of copyright as anything more than a civil issue.
- rglover 16y agoA bit sad. I can understand the desire to prohibit the streaming of copyrighted material, but taking infringement of any sort (especially streaming media) to a felony level is a bit ridiculous. This is just lobbyist nonsense. You're elected to protect the American people, so do it.
- j_baker 16y agoI'm not worried. Ars Technica digs up at least one of these scary bills going through Congress each year and nothing ever comes out of it. Our lawmakers may be in the pocket of big content, but they aren't stupid enough to pass something as draconian as this. The real things we need to worry about probably won't be as obviously draconian.
- zinkem 16y agoHave you seen the adminstration's white paper on IP enforcement? This type of legislation is a priority for Obama and Biden. http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/ip_white_paper.pdf http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/ip_white_paper...
- dexen 16y agoThe repeated requests for that kind of law modification have effect of moving the Overton window [0] in the direction of stiffer IP enforcement. Even if the bills fall flat one after another, they move the bounds of discussion towards heavy-handed IP rules. Preparing grounds for small, creeping changes. ---- [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overton_window http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overton_window
- VaedaStrike 16y agoLet's find the closest friends and relatives of these politicians who infringe any intellectual property rights in any way and then get them on record saying they'd readily see their own kindred hit with felony convictions. Things like this come from people who don't understand why intellectual property was enshrined into law in the first place.
- Timothee 16y agoThe distinction between downloading and streaming can be considered odd from a technical standpoint, however I do think that it's much much easier to stream illegal content unknowingly than it is downloading it. Basically, if you download an episode of a TV show for free, common sense would tend to say that something is fishy: you end up with a file on your drive forever. However, in the case of streaming, I feel like it's much less clear. Two scenarios: I want to watch an episode of The Office, I google "The Office season 6 episode 3" and end up watching the episode with ads on Hulu. I can also pay a subscription to watch any episode I want. I then want to watch an episode of Dexter and google "Dexter season 5 episode 3" and end up watching the episode on MegaVideo with ads (for MegaVideo, MegaUploader… mostly) and a daily limit that can be waived with a subscription. The first one is legal, the second one is not but a non-savvy user couldn't really tell the difference. I don't really have a way to know that MegaVideo doesn't pay the copyright holders with the subscriptions and ads.
- harshpotatoes 16y agoIf my understanding is correct, Megavideo is the person streaming the video and you are the person watching the video, meaning Megavideo would be the one with the felony.
- mkramlich 16y agoPerspective: leading the US into an unnecessary war in Iraq, under what most reasonable people would say were trumped up claims and distorted logic, which then directly led to 3000+ American military deaths, and a multiple of that in Iraqi deaths..... Not a felony. Streaming a video without authorization? Felony. A woman claims a man (IMF chief Strauss today) forced her into some sex acts: mere accusation causes him to be led off a plane and put into a jail cell pending a full trial. Before a fair trail, he's now in jail. Based on one person's accusation. (Which may or may not be legitimate, or may have been a honeypot setup, we don't know yet, and may never know.) Several men and women claim a man (and his administration) did (the things I claimed in my first paragraph): neither Bush or Cheney or any other top leader ever spent time in jail to this day, nor even charged in the first place. (Libby doesn't count, he was charged with something else, a formality.) What's broken here?
- tzs 16y agoFlagging, because the discussion is going nowhere, mainly because either almost no one is reading the article before commenting, or they are reading it but not understanding it. To elaborate, unauthorized copying and distributing has long (decades) been a felony if you are doing it for commercial advantage or private financial gain, and in any 180-day period this involves copies worth more than $1000. Look at the language Ars quotes. It talks about streaming a certain number of copies in any 180-day period, and puts a threshold ($2500 retail value or $5000 licenses) you have to meet in order to run afoul of the new provisions. It sounds likely, based on the similarity to the existing felony provisions, that these new provisions fit in with those, and thus are only covering people who are doing illegal streaming AS A BUSINESS (and doing a good amount of business...if the retail value of a streaming move is $5, they have to have 500 customers over six months to hit the threshold). They are not nailing people who consume the streams (just as the felony copying and distribution provisions don't nail the customer).