3 ms·
I think that something like UBI is the only humane way to run a society, especially with the increasing automation. Personally I think that if people study the
by ilaksh 6y ago
I think that something like UBI is the only humane way to run a society, especially with the increasing automation.
Personally I think that if people study the problem they will realize that there are reasons that UBI is universal and that non-universal UBI probably won't work.
I also believe that if you look at the cost of living in the US and the potential federal revenue increase from radical corporate tax reform, it will still not add up.
So I think that we need extreme cost reductions. But beyond that, I don't think the monetary systems we have now actually can support UBI indefinitely. The math just doesn't add up due to the high cost of living. Eventually the poor countries can't tolerate letting the rich countries increase their debt infinitely anymore. This is going to be a big risk for global war in the next few years.
So I believe we need a totally new type of high tech money. One that integrates more information and has more fine-grained controls. I believe the only way we are going to have global security is if this new money is built on a fair international standard.
- JKCalhoun 6y ago> I think that something like UBI is the only humane way to run a society, especially with the increasing automation. Or maybe don't automate. The assembly line has given us repetitive tasks that perhaps, for humane reasons, we should automate. But where are skilled manual labor jobs? Construction is the only thing that comes to mind and there is not enough of it. I strongly dislike UBI because it gives the economically-blessed tier a pass. "I gave at the office," they can claim while stepping over the homeless or passing the very-nearly homeless on the way to their Tesla. (Lets be clear, $1000 a month is not going to suddenly give everyone a home and 2.5 children.)
- glogla 6y agoYeah, the other problem with UBI deployment is housing. It would take some more changes so that all of UBI doesn't basically end up taken by landlords.
- megameter 6y ago$1000 a month creates an environment where the poor finance each other: if you lend $100 to your buddy, you have some confidence he can repay the amount, because he is getting something, so emergency debts can be spread out. At $0 a month there is no trust to build, no credible source of income. Nobody has anything, so nobody gets anything, so nothing happens, no opportunity to build a richer economic web is created or pursued. The poor are then in a position where staying idle seems best. What's actually in place today in the US is effectively somewhere in between $0 and $1000, in that you get something if you fill out the right forms regularly and aren't denied one day, and many parts of it are a targeted package with limited liquidity(like EBT). These packages in their current form accomplish exactly the thing you describe of UBI: They create a homeless-industrial complex that allows bleeding hearts to proclaim virtue. Barely keeping people alive doesn't get them to the next rung of the economic ladder, it enmeshes them in a one-way dependency not shared throughout the society. "Universal" is a really important component in effective socialized policies.