4 ms·
Can a Worker-Owned App Pull Drivers from Uber and Lyft?
- millzlane 6y agoI think it could. In Baltimore there is a culture surrounded by giving cheap economical rides. It's called "hacking" or "catching a hack" https://afro.com/the-anatomy-of-a-hack/ https://afro.com/the-anatomy-of-a-hack/ . I think an app that just allowed people to be their own boss and hail their own rides could easily upend uber or lyft. If the idea of the app is to empower people to be their own bosses. Let people set their own rates. Maybe charge a flat rate of $0.25 per ride. Drivers would benefit and so would passengers. Obviously hacking/hitchhiking can be dangerous so the driver/passenger identity system would still need to be addressed.
- cafard 6y agoHow? Uber loses money on every ride, doesn't it? Are you going to get VC money for a co-op?
- mattkrause 6y agoI think they mean a 25¢ fee to the platform for matchmaking; you’d pay the driver too.
- tehwebguy 6y agocafard is saying that it’s not likely possible to get users without subsidizing each ride
- valuearb 6y agoUber makes money on rides in nature markets, it’s losses are from investing in new markets and businesses.
- mikem170 6y agoSome of the ride cost is VC subsidy. Some of the ride expense is Uber corporate (thousands of programmers, pay for officers, managers, building rent, etc). Do we know which is greater? Maybe there is room for an app with low overhead to compete.
- wool_gather 6y agoI'm supportive of the co-op idea, but my bet would be that the drivers don't matter nearly as much as users. So unless it can compete on a UX level with the convenience and branding of the VC-backed options it's not going to succeed.
- Hammershaft 6y agoI agree, although the flipside is cheaper rides that can be marketed as going to local drivers.
- Kalium 6y agoWith any app, your driver is going to be local enough to be picking you up.
- Hammershaft 6y agoA larger cut is retained by a distant middleman.
- stu2b50 6y agoDepends on the market. Uber makes money on rides in established urban areas, ie look at the NY or LA numbers.
- la6471 6y agoTo compete with apps like Uber and Lyft you have to continuously add features , scale and be reliable. While producing an app similar in function to Uber is quite possible , I think the biggest hurdle comes from adoption of the app and continuous iteration at the speed of Uber.
- abdullahkhalids 6y agoWhat novel software features have Uber and Lyft added in the last two years?
- zaroth 6y agoI would imagine the vast majority of the work is in mapping metadata/annotations and functions to customize the features of a route based on that data. Airports would be the first example that comes to mind. Guiding both driver and passenger to the designated pickup location, which might be separate from the normal passenger loading/unloading areas. But throughout big cities you will have designated taxi/ride share POIs that need to be coded. I’m sure the pricing algorithm is also quite complex. It’s an easy mistake to make to look at something from the outside and assume the details are all pretty simple.
- abdullahkhalids 6y agoBoth of those are important improvements, and the first is more of a life-long process than a task. A coop ride-sharing app would benefit from a "wiki-map" like OpenStreetMaps which can be directly added edited by the drivers, whose pockets will see more money if maps were better, and riders who will spend less money if maps were better. The pricing algorithm, I can see, will require a lot of advanced mathematics, and will involve a lot of politics, which might make it hard for a democratic organization to function. The politics comes from the fact that different pricing algorithm will have different losers and winners.
- stu2b50 6y agoI think good UberPool functionality is one. The routing for that is a lot harder technologically and prepandemic I did a lot of Uber pool rides, since in many cases I wasn't in a hurry and it was quite a bit cheaper.
- cma 6y agoThe drivers should be the customer, who search out the matching company together as one big negotiating block. But the US has made it illegal unless they all work for someone other than themselves, along with making other main tools of unionization illegal, like secondary strikes.
- lyxsus 6y agoAs a non-US citizen, I have 3 questions: 1. WTF 2. Is it even enforceable? 3. Does anybody know recent examples?
- imtringued 6y agoIt could happen, but only after the cash fountain at Uber has dried up.
- foolmeonce 6y agoIf it seems to be happening why throw money away by investing in Uber? A fair trade alternative they can't buy out is not going to allow them profit until they have a scale advantage that doesn't exist in car services. I.e. they are throwing money away until they have a pure AI fleet and then a new fleet from an automaker has no such debts.
- commonturtle 6y agoApps and the associated infrastructure (driver background checks, payments processing, customer support, etc.) are much harder to build than they look. I'm willing to bet against a worker-owned app taking >= 10% of Uber and Lyft market-share in >= 10 mid-size American cities.