5 ms·
It's a little sus that CEPR titles this doc as a factual declaration when the first sentence is "The European Commission (alongside other regulators) is conduct
by shadowgovt 6y ago
It's a little sus that CEPR titles this doc as a factual declaration when the first sentence is "The European Commission (alongside other regulators) is conducting an in-depth investigation of the Google/Fitbit deal." It calls into question the objectivity of the investigation when the announcement of the investigation is a statement of a conclusion they the EC is, one assumes, actively investigating.
- ceejayoz 6y agoI don't think "Google/Fitbit will monetise health data" requires the in-depth investigation to conclude.
- variaga 6y agoThere needs to be some corollary of the "extrodinary claims require extraordinary evidence" phrase for ordinary claims. I feel like I can safely assume things like "a for-profit corporation will monetize resources available to it" without any specific evidence about the particular corporation or asset.
- fastball 6y agoDoesn't seem like a corollary. The corollary would require ordinary evidence, and you're saying you're happy to not have any.
- ceejayoz 6y agoThere's plenty of ordinary evidence that corporations monetize data.
- gowld 6y agoThere's plenty of ordinary evidence that corporations decline to monetize some data. Example: https://support.google.com/adspolicy/answer/143465 https://support.google.com/adspolicy/answer/143465 "Advertisers can’t use personal hardship categories to target ads to users or to promote advertisers’ products or services. See below for specific examples of what we don't allow." "Examples: Treatments for chronic health conditions like diabetes or arthritis, treatments for sexually transmitted diseases, counseling services for mental health issues like depression or anxiety, medical devices for sleep apnea like CPAP machines, over-the-counter medications for yeast infections, information about how to support your autistic child"
- fastball 6y agoWith the extraordinary claims, the extraordinary evidence usually needs to directly pertain to the claims. It is not "extraordinary claims require other similar extraordinary things to have happened in the past". That is not evidence for your claim.
- ceejayoz 6y agoExtraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, yes. The point is that "corporations will monetize data" isn't an extraordinary claim.
- fastball 6y agoNo, that is an ordinary claim, and one that has plenty of ordinary evidence to back it up. This company will monetize this data is also an ordinary claim (from history), but similarly needs evidence. "Companies have monetized similar in the past" is not evidence they'll do it in this case. If you're a gambler, you should absolutely use that fact to inform your betting, but it's not evidence.
- ceejayoz 6y agoI'm not a fan of "regulators must allow actual harm before intervening" here.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- variaga 6y agoNo, I have plenty of ordinary evidence in the form of my observations of the behavior of every other for-profit corporation across all of history. Like if you claimed "pine sap is sticky" I don't feel compelled to challenge you and demand to touch it myself before I believe you. I've encountered plenty of pine sap in my life, and it was all sticky. I _have_ evidence that pine sap is sticky generally, so I don't demand _extra_ evidence that a _specific_ portion of sap is sticky.
- fastball 6y agoYes, and water is wet. But water and pine sap are to the best of our knowledge fairly homogenous, while companies are definitely not that. Complex things are, well, complex, and absolutely not all the same.
- harry8 6y agoThey're not homogenous. The companies that don't make money go broke and cease to be. No sign of that from Google. They're buying the data to monetize it. If they were doing something unexpected like destroying it for the greater good they'd announce it. The extraordinary thing here is if they bought the data to /not/ monetize it. That requires the evidence. Not the overwhelmingly expected thing. They are mutually exclusive alternatives after all. Go with the overwhelmingly likely one until you've got a solid reason not to. We don't here.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- idclip 6y agoIts only needed legally so courts can act
- ehsankia 6y agoDoes Apple monetize their health data? I'm not talking selling ads against it, but monetize it in any way? Do we consider that harmful too?
- explodingman 6y agoApple can monetise user data by keeping it private and offering privacy as a feature to drive hardware sales/margins. I don't know for sure if this is their business model. I think it is, and it makes sense as a strategy.
- ehsankia 6y ago> I don't know for sure if this is their business model. That's the point, and you also don't know for sure what Google's business model with the health data will be either. The GP post I was replying said that it was obvious Google was monetizing the data, and implying that it was therefore bad. My point is that if monetizing health data is inherently bad, then so is what Apple is doing.
- Talanes 6y agoWas that the implication? I got more of a "Of course they will monetize it, that's how corporations handle assets" vibe. Because monetize is a meaningless word here. Unless Google suddenly decides to go against their fiduciary responsibility and purposefully lose money, any use of the data is going to be somehow monetizing it.
- _jal 6y agoLast I looked, Apple Health data doesn't leave the phone - there's no "cloud" aspect. They could of course change that, or sneakily exfil it. The first hasn't happened yet, and the second would destroy a vast amount of consumer trust well before all the lawsuits started. So I do rather doubt it.
- username90 6y ago
- henearkr 6y ago"Monetize" is an harmfully vague choice of words. Research teams for medical or pharmaceutical ventures "monetize" health data (to develop e.g. drugs or tools) but they do it in an ethical way, through anonymized or aggregated data, following good practice guidelines, etc. And there is no wide polemics on these methods. Why would not Google/Fitbit use the data in the same ethical ways?
- germanier 6y agoWhich is why the actual announcement of the investigation is titled "Commission opens in-depth investigation into the proposed acquisition of Fitbit by Google" [0] written a month before. The title you are commenting about is written by the CEPR, an institution independent of the EU, which supports that opinion with their own arguments. This should not be confused with the Commission's investigation. [0]: https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_20_1446 https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_20_...
- gowld 6y agoCEPR is an activist org. Their claims are their opinions, like any blogger.
- escapecharacter 6y ago> little sus Sidebar: I love that this expression has entered the majority vernacular, thanks mostly to Among Us. I don't think we had such a terse form of this expression before.
- iamacyborg 6y agoIt’s been common parlance in the UK for at least a decade
- r00fus 6y agoYou're correct, the title would more accurately say: "CEPR says Google/Fitbit will monetize health data and harm consumers".