3 ms·
As a matter of law, brokers have a duty to seek what’s called “best execution”, meaning they’re required to both shop around for better prices and pass all of t
by SpicyLemonZest 6y ago
As a matter of law, brokers have a duty to seek what’s called “best execution”, meaning they’re required to both shop around for better prices and pass all of the price improvement they can find onto their customers. Payment for order flow is still kosher in many circumstances; there's no clear duty to go to the people offering it and demand price improvement instead. But what you definitely can’t do is accept a worse deal (or stop trying to find better deals) in order to protect your payment for order flow revenue stream.
It’s fair to say that this rule cuts off some interesting business models which might better serve different market segments, but that’s largely the point. In the SEC’s judgment, the potential for abuse is too high if stock brokers start acting like retail stores.
- dmurray 6y ago> As a matter of law, brokers have a duty to seek what’s called “best execution”, meaning they’re required to both shop around for better prices and pass all of the price improvement they can find onto their customers. That's the definition of best execution as it applies to undirected orders. But you can also offer your clients direct execution on the exchange, in which case you don't have to (and must not) shop the order around. If RH had done that, they'd be in the clear. Yes, I understand that retail brokers aren't usually in the business of directed orders (because shopping round the orders is in the interest of both them and the client).
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoInteresting, I didn't know that. Is it plausible that Robinhood could rescue their business model by just saying they're doing direct execution now?
- dmurray 6y agoNo, because if they do direct execution, that means they don't send the orders to the brokers who are giving them the PFOF. If you send it direct to NYSE or Nasdaq, the exchange charges you, not pays you.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI see. That does seem pretty problematic for them.
- esoterica 6y ago> Payment for order flow is still kosher in many circumstances; there's no clear duty to go to the people offering it and demand price improvement instead. But what you definitely can’t do is accept a worse deal (or stop trying to find better deals) in order to protect your payment for order flow revenue stream. This seems like a distinction without a difference. If you accept any payment for order flow you're always implicitly rejecting a hypothetical alternate arrangement where you agree to give up all PFOF in exchange for better price improvement.