5 ms·
Wait, he went around different sites all around two countries digging this stuff up, and officials were surprised he didn’t turn it over to the state? Nobody c
by Aeolun 6y ago
Wait, he went around different sites all around two countries digging this stuff up, and officials were surprised he didn’t turn it over to the state?
Nobody could be bothered to retrieve these artifacts in the first place. I don’t see how the state has (or should have) any more inherent right to them than this guy.
The least they could do is pay him for the objects. Apparently they’re worth 700k!
- nsajko 6y agoNo. There are two issues: the artifacts are not just treasure - scientifically their context (in the ground and in time) is what matters, the context the treasure hunter removed them from. I.e., he prevented scientists from ever being able do the digs themselves. The other issue is that, AFAIK, scientists often prefer to leave parts of sites intact for future research, presumably hoping for better technology in the future.
- yostrovs 6y agoNo one else wanted to dig this stuff up. He didn't "prevent" anyone from doing anything.
- isbvhodnvemrwvn 6y agoThey denied anyone in future from digging it up (or not doing so, noninvasive archeo is a thing). I'm both surprised and not to find such selfish arguments as yours here.
- samizdis 6y agoThe UK has similar laws, requiring people who find things defined under the Treasure Act 1996 (except in Scotland) as treasure to report their find to a coroner within 14 days. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treasure_Act_1996 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treasure_Act_1996 Finders have to offer the treasure for sale to a museum/similar at a price determined by an independent panel. The UK also has broader, older rules governing "treasure trove", with slight regional variations. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treasure_trove https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treasure_trove The bottom line isn't "finders keepers", but rewards are fair and often handsome. The rules try to strike a balance between public interest/education, common good, and providing an incentive against individual greed.
- jansan 6y agoThis makes a lot of sense. These artefacts usually disappear in a museum's basement and nobody actually gives a shit, but officials act as if they have great value. If the museums actually have to shill out some money, it becomes quite clear which artefacts actually do have value and which don't.
- flagrant 6y agoThis is honestly an abhorrent way to think about archaeological finds. You do not have to ascribe a monetary value to everything you see and our history should not be bought and sold as a commodity.
- Aeolun 6y ago> our history should not be bought and sold as a commodity The thousands, maybe millions of old coins that we find from previous eras are absolutely a commodity, and it doesn’t detract from our heritage in the slightest. The largest set of coins I’ve seen was in the british museum and that was already too much. I think they have one of every variety of coin and it just makes my head spin. Once they have one of each (add another 10 for other musea across the country) the remaining thousands can remain in private hands.
- jeltz 6y agoRemoving the treasures from their context removes a lot of the scientific value of the finds. A coin tells us that the much more if you know where it was buried.
- frankfrankfrank 6y agoMit to mention that the fact that European states are so authoritarian and immoral about it incentivized theft and deception. I wouldn’t have even bothered reporting anything if I were him, and this case seems to prove the point why. They’ve likely also note through their draconian policies lost the information on where the finds were made and all associated historical knowledge, e.g., the coins of a certain type would indicate the location of possible troop movement that was not clear before.