8 ms·
An astonishing amount of this list amounts to “spend money”, so while these things may play well here I think it’s worth pointing out that a large majority of t
by eyelidlessness 6y ago
An astonishing amount of this list amounts to “spend money”, so while these things may play well here I think it’s worth pointing out that a large majority of the population is not allowed to do those things because they can’t afford to.
- imgabe 6y agoPsst - you are also allowed to make more money.
- flyGuyOnTheSly 6y agoYou're allowed to save money for a future goal.
- eyelidlessness 6y agoI have. I’m also allowed to recognize that most people don’t have that luxury.
- onecommentman 6y agoMedian household income in US is $68K (2019) https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-economy-census-idUSKBN2662EY https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-economy-census-idUSKB... Median mortgage payment is $1550/mo. 40% of US homes are free of mortgage. https://www.businessinsider.com/personal-finance/average-mortgage-payment?op=1 https://www.businessinsider.com/personal-finance/average-mor... https://www.forbes.com/sites/brendarichardson/2019/07/26/nearly-40-of-homes-in-the-us-are-free-and-clear-of-a-mortgage/?sh=77ebca0447c2 https://www.forbes.com/sites/brendarichardson/2019/07/26/nea... There are a lot of folks in the US that are just scraping by. There are a lot more folks with enough disposable income to pursue one of these strategies. Not everybody. [And this doesn’t include wealth and savings.]
- fsflover 6y agoThe parent did not say "in the US".
- staticman2 6y agoNot sure what Median Mortgage payment tells you without looking at health insurance payment, retirement savings, college saving for kids, college debt, auto payments etc. I would expect a median family with median mortgage to have little money left over if they have children.
- klipt 6y agoBut encouraging rich people to hire grad students will probably help spread the money around more!
- tartoran 6y agoYep. Rich people can hire experts to validate and spot check their ideas, even write articles and what not about it. I wonder how much money do I need to be able to do that. A few things in the list that cost money are worth it if done at the right time. Tutoring with the the right resource can be the best investment sometimes and of course rich people will afford more of that.
- ehwhyreally 6y agoNa, rich people use other peoples money to buy shit.
- tomcam 6y agoCool! I'm rich and I've never heard of that trick. Tell me how we do it, please.
- R0b0t1 6y agoYou're not rich enough.
- kylebenzle 6y agoYep, $1M is not going to attract people to do things for you just because. The $50M+ people will have people flock to do small things for you for free. I saw it with my old boss. People would always be asking if they needed help or would just offer free stuff in hopes of getting something later.
- Kim_Bruning 6y agoCorrelation may not be causation though. Do people flock to him because he's rich, or is he rich because people flock to him? (or ... something in between?)
- tsumnia 6y agoI'll tell you how, but it'll cost ya :D
- ramraj07 6y agoThis is clearly directed at people with some amount of disposable income. Also many may value their time and money differently. I used fancyhands for a bit when I was on a grad student salary and I thought it was worth my time even then. Last year I saw a C level exec in a mid size startup spend 20 min on hold with a credit card company to dispute some booking. I was wondering why they would not offload that.
- shmageggy 6y agoMore specifically, I think it's directed at people (like me and apparently the author) who grew up, and maybe even spent a while as an adult, without much or any disposable income, but now are lucky enough to have some. It is taking me years to unlearn habits that no longer make sense for my situation, simply because when you're poor, so much of your life revolves around optimizing for money that it takes many, many reminders that it's ok to place value on time as well.
- henrikschroder 6y agoI have a bunch of friends that grew up working class, and they still, consistently, value their own time at 0. Regardless of their actual adult income. Which means they often spend ridiculous amounts of time and effort to save tiny amounts of money. I grew up lower middle class instead, so I have other stupid frugal habits. Growing up, my parents never, ever, ever replaced a thing that was working. The only time you were allowed to replace a thing was when it was irredeemably broken. Took me a while to get rid of that habit.
- pram 6y agoI know what you mean, but I've come to understand that some people subconsciously enjoy that kind of 'penny wise' behavior. My wife does a lot of things I consider to be a huge waste of time when it comes to saving small amounts of money (like making specific combinations of orders because they're a deal and so on) but they perceive it differently. It's like part hobby and part pathological addiction.
- closeparen 6y agoThere is an absolutely massive marketing industry out there contending for discretionary income. It is worth pointing out options which may have high utility for the buyer, but where the sell side doesn't spend billions on pumping awareness into the culture.
- eyelidlessness 6y agoOkay? Still worth pointing out that most people don’t have anything resembling that kind of discretionary income.
- closeparen 6y agoMost people don't speak English. 89.5% of Americans live above the poverty line.
- pimlottc 6y agoDefinitely noticed that, and it is certainly a privilege to be able to trade time for money; but it is also something that many people don't stop to consider. It makes sense to be thrifty when you're younger and poorer but it can become a blind spot when things change and your time starts becoming more valuable. Especially when it gets tangled up with moral judgments or self-image: "why order something at restaurant that you can make at home?" "what kind of cyclist can't change a flat" "only a loser has to pay to get dates" etc... None of those things are absolute right or wrong, but it should be based on a honest assessment of the tradeoffs, not emotional associations or ingrained assumptions.
- SapporoChris 6y agoregarding: 'trading time and money'. My simple rule has always been, if I can hire someone to do something by the hour less than what I get paid by the hour then I should do that. This is 'trading money for time'. To offset the money spent, I should then reverse and 'trade time for money' either by increased work or training and education for an increased pay rate.
- DoofusOfDeath 6y agoIn my own experience, I've found that reasoning that way has some real downsides: - Just because my hourly rate is $X, it doesn't follow that I can always work an additional hour to make an additional $X. - After working 40+ hours/week doing paid work, working an additional hour at my day job to avoid doing something else does not make for a happy life. In fact, it makes life quite dull, and made me a very narrow person.
- klipt 6y agoAlso your after tax hourly income is substantially lower than your pre tax income (which is what most people think of).
- Kim_Bruning 6y ago
- diehunde 6y agoI don't think it's worth pointing that out. It's pretty obvious just like it's pretty obvious who the target audience is.
- Jommi 6y agoIf you see this list only as "spend money" I think it's the perfect article for you. The overarching point of the author is that most of his target audience (and those reading HN) are used to being thrifty and not spend money at all, even when they get older. They fail to realize that at some point, it's worth your time to spend the X amount either because the value of investing X down the line is so great, or because the time saved by spending X is now so much greater than before, because of something changing in your life (career has progressed, valuation of free time has changed). I definitely see this myself daily, ending up wasting few minutes each day on trivial things that add up, while it could be fixed by paying a small amount. Or for example trying to wade through a free course to learn something, but ultimately just dropping it out of no motivation. Compared to paying for a course, which makes you more responsible s you paid for it and usually also offers more effective training.
- glenstein 6y agoI agree, and the spin that I would put on it is that I find the framing of this article to be particularly helpful. The sense of "wait, you can do that?" For me, it has often been the case that b I've encountered new concepts that I've never clearly thought about in my own head before, but that once I hear stated openly, are as clear as day. For the longest time, I had not encountered a concept of "self-care" but then I started seeing that term pop up around the internet and it seemed quite obvious that it was an important thing. That might seem silly, but if your timeline for these things reaches back to the '90s, like mine does, a notion like self-care is relatively recent on the historical timeline as a familiar concept. I've also seen this in writing, with how you handle plot and character development. Or even some things that are silly but obvious like the fact that you can just go out and go on hikes if you want, and there are tons and tons of places to do that. I feel like there's all kinds of hidden mental blocks that you can go your whole life not knowing that you have, and I appreciate this idea of elevating the concept to its own genre and targeting it with articles such as the one posted here.
- Jommi 6y agoYes, definitely. Unfortunately this all is usually buried behind heaps and heaps of people trying to sell you something that won't work (either because it just doesn't work for you or because it's a scam! Or maybe both!)
- wojciii 6y agoI saw this list as one that lists many examples where I can trade money for time that I don't have to spend doing something worthwhile. This is specially important to me now that I have children and very little time for stuff that I care about besides my family.
- OJFord 6y agoTFA says up front: > I haven’t tried everything on this list, mainly due to cost. But you’d be surprised how cheap most of the things on this list are (especially the free ones).
- jpttsn 6y agoA large majority? Of what population?
- carlmr 6y agoI grew up not poor by world standards, but somewhat poor by Western standards. What really resonated with me was the point about buying a comfortable mattress. It wasn't the mattress in my case, but the bed I slept on. I bought it used 8 years ago. I fixed it twice. It was creaking again. It's not that I couldn't buy a new one, it's just that I was used to not buying furniture. After all it's only comfort. Last year I bought a new bed and it improved a lot of things for me. It's simple, but if you grow up thinking about every penny you spend you get weird habits.
- theshrike79 6y agoToo many people downplay or underestimate the quality of life that a good nights sleep brings. The average human spends (or should spend) 8h in bed every single day of their life. The next 8h is the place you work, the ergonomics should fit you. Spend money to have quality sleep. Spend money to work comfortably.
- rchaud 6y agoYes, there are certainly a few core areas where spending money can greatly improve quality of life. A solid bed and chair (if you work a desk job) are two of them.
- eyelidlessness 6y agoI relate to 100% of this. I guess I should clarify that I’m not saying it’s bad advice to people with means to say “you’re allowed to spend money to [achieve some life comfort or progress]”. And owning a nice bed is definitely one I can relate to (and when I have the disposable income again I intend to get a better mattress than the one I currently have). I guess my objection to the article, as presented, is it’s kind of tone deaf particularly at a time when many people are financially struggling to just assert that you’re “allowed” to hire people for a long list of tasks, at a cost that many people wouldn’t even dream of being able to afford or justify.
- mwcvitkovic 6y agoIt's true money can buy a lot of them, but you can barter too. E.g. make a deal with your housemate to clean the house if they'll do a few hours research for you. So you have to spend/trade something, but (for me) it's harder to think of what's worth spending/trading for. Hence the post.
- elindbe3 6y agoSo they can just ignore the advice in the article if it doesn't apply to them. What's your point? People should only write articles from the perspective of extreme poverty?