6 ms·
While obviously crystals are not alive, they satisfy more careless definitions of life that were sometimes encountered, i.e., when put in a "nutritive" solution
by adrian_b 6y ago
While obviously crystals are not alive, they satisfy more careless definitions of life that were sometimes encountered, i.e., when put in a "nutritive" solution, they are able to grow and reproduce themselves.
- beowulfey 6y agoI think even under that definition they don't truly reproduce and still aren't really life -- they don't create the same material they arise from for example (so not allowing for additional crystals to form). A non-renewing source of the material has a maximum amount of crystal that can grow, I would imagine. This is different than something like a virus, which carries the instructs to replicate itself and the ability to travel to new hosts to create more of itself (and still isn't really considered alive).
- Ericson2314 6y ago> A non-renewing source of the material has a maximum amount of crystal that can grow So any biosphere that fails to escape its looming red giant was never alive? I'm not a "all abstractions leak" type of person, so I will choose my definitions very carefully, with funny choices about clays, crystals, virus, etc. as an acceptable causality.
- dekhn 6y agoThis is just wrong (as you say, careless). The criteria is "metabolism", not growth and reproduction. Similarly, viruses are not alive although they can reproduce. Interestingly, there are some highly parasitic organisms with limited ability to metabolize, that is, they have lost their genes and instead depend on their host organism (but I think all those examples still have some level of metabolic capability).
- Ericson2314 6y agoI don't really know what "metabolism" means, abstractly. I am deader than a virus without chloroplasts existing elsewhere. Viruses need a host for the productive bit, I had food for the non-reproductive bit. Viruses don't break down fast enough compared to their abundance to cause extinction, so why fault them for optimizing? People commonly theorize that virus came from rump parasitic cells. I wouldn't be surprised if at some point a huge virus with a membrane accidentally picked up enough stuff to become a cell again. To go back to chloroplasts again, it would be like how brown algae is an ex-heterotroph.
- geomark 6y agoMetabolism has two parts: Catabolism breaks down complex molecules into smaller building block molecules - think proteins -> amino acids. Then anabolism uses those building blocks to build up larger molecules for growth and maintenance. Crystals don't do the catabolism part.
- kubanczyk 6y agoNah, this seems more like an implementation detail than an actual core of life's "functionality".
- BlueTemplar 6y agoLooks like cell's phospholipid bilayer is anabolized just like an "endothermic" crystal : no need to cross a potential barrier (and releases energy instead of consuming it)? On the other hand, other forms of anabolism require crossing an energy barrier (and consumes energy) ? While catabolysm is the inverse operation : crosses a barrier, but releases energy? The formation/destruction of "exothermic" crystals like dissolution of Sodium Hydroxide if put in contact with water is I guess similar to above two reactions ? (Or better example: explosives)
- Ericson2314 6y agoWhile I don't think it's a good definition for life, I do think it's a good definition for metabolism. That simply means "metabolism" isn't the concept to generalize further, and I'm OK with that.
- webmaven 6y ago> People commonly theorize that virus came from rump parasitic cells. I have an alternate theory, that I've never seen articulated elsewhere: Viruses might be inter-microbial biochemical warfare gone wild; Among primitive and not-particularly robust cells, one competitive strategy might be to package toxins or other disruptive molecules into capsids that cleverly get past the 'enemy' cell membrane, perhaps aimed simply at disrupting the initially brittle reproductive process. Packaging random genes in with these capsids would be the beginning of the Horizontal Gene Transfer function that viruses perform in the ecosystem. A refinement would be to add in the specific genes for producing capsids as a deliverable so a subverted 'enemy' then takes out several neighbors (but 2nd gen capsids don't have to necessarily contain the same genes in order to accomplish their 'mission', or even be entirely identical to the 1st gen, as long as they work). A further refinement would be increasing fidelity, and packaging the responsible genes into the 2nd gen capsids produced by subverted cells so the 'weapon' can spread exponentially. And voila, the 'weapon' has now escaped the originating organism and can evolve independently parasitizing the target. Each incremental step can at least hypothetically provide an evolutionary advantage so the whole thing doesn't have to spring forth fully formed. Depending on how widespread variants of the original strategy were, viruses might have independently emerged more than once. If I'm right, we ought to still be able to find cells that attack or suppress competitors with capsid-like molecules that don't particularly resemble existing virus lineages, possibly containing non-genetic payloads of various sorts. We might also find bacteriophage endoviruses that as their 2nd stage only produce capsids sans-genes or that otherwise aren't identical to the endovirus, or ones that aren't very good at packaging up the correct genes, or that are much better at disrupting cell reproduction than hijacking it, or that the subsequent copies are only low-fidelity ones that can similarly penetrate the host but not spread any further; basically any indicators that the mechanisms for penetration of the membrane, attacking the cell, and even for making poor 2nd gen copies, have been evolving longer than capabilities only needed for indefinitely repeated copying, retransmission, and reinfection. I suspect though that the oldest reconstructible endoviruses will no longer be capable of penetrating current members of their host cohort, which tells us little about the virus itself, but may offer clues about whatever ancestral cells were still prone to infection were like.
- sterlind 6y agoViruses need a host environment to replicate. Fish need water and plant life or other fish to replicate. Algae needs nutrients to replicate. Every lifeform can only exist in some host environment. Viruses simply happen to have biological host environments, right?
- dekhn 6y agothis is certainly not the mainstream way of thinking; it's certainly not specific enough.
- bufferoverflow 6y agoYou're equivocating environments and hosts. Hosts do the replication for the viruses. Environments do NOT do the replication for the fish.
- jacquesm 6y agoIn fact, for quite a few fish they do, ditto amphibians and insects too. Mammals are the exception here, there the environment for replication is an integral part of the body of the parent. But in all those other cases, including, technically, marsupials it isn't.
- kaba0 6y agoJust because it happens outside the ‘parents’ body doesn’t mean the environment does it anymore than a mother being only a filter around the womb and the environment. An egg is a complex life that can reproduce the whole organism (and actually with energy stored INSIDE, that’s why they are great nutritios value for others)
- cdogl 6y agoThe distinction between environment and organism here seems a little arbitrary. The organism’s cells have membranes, but they’re permeable and the organism can’t do its job without an interaction between itself and the environment. Even with the energy stored inside, it requires warmth and atmospheric pressure. I suspect there are any number of counter examples of life forms that challenge the simplicity of this formulation. You could just as easily argue that each cell is a life form unto itself, right?
- Igelau 6y ago> obviously crystals are not alive Very few things are obvious. Is this?