10 ms·
The recent HN article on meritocracy comes to mind. I had never considered it this way in the past, but in the 70’s, productivity started decoupling massively
by mensetmanusman 6y ago
The recent HN article on meritocracy comes to mind.
I had never considered it this way in the past, but in the 70’s, productivity started decoupling massively from productivity gains.
I.e. the best people at finance (meritocracy) figured out how to capture all the new earnings relative to the workers (who didn’t know this game was going on).
This has snowballed into a situation where the financial meritocracy is competing with itself and could now never imagine a situation where non-finance people are being paid more in proportion with their value relative to baseline productivity gains.
This article would fit that narrative as a symptom of one-upmanship gone amuck.
How do we exit this brutal cycle? It requires a generation of new blood that is actually concerned about societal stability and recognizes the connection between instability and leaving 99% of folks behind as games are fought in ‘the ivory cloud’.
Will this be dealt with sans revolution? Who knows...
- dehrmann 6y ago> productivity started decoupling massively from productivity gains. Productivity is a ceiling for wages. "Decoupling" implies that, for various reasons, there's been a surplus in the labor market since the 70's.
- medium_burrito 6y agoWhich there has been, basically. We effectively double the workforce with women entering the labor supply. H1B ramped up in the 90s, but that's not the same magnitude of change.
- dehrmann 6y agoAlso include automation and China industrializing, enabling outsourcing.
- runawaybottle 6y agoThe only chance of changing it was that our new emerging industries were supposed to be more equitable. Unfortunately not much of that happened, and the tech boss is the same as the finance boss, meet the new boss, same as the old one. I’m sorry gig workers, contractors, Amazon warehouse workers, startup workers, but there’s not much to see here. We’ll try to be better later if we get lucky enough to get a whole new industry again.
- travisoneill1 6y agoI don't buy this explanation. Very few employees are paid in any financially complex way. Wages dropping overall must have a different explanation, which I suspect is an increase in labor supply due to women entering the labor force and illegal immigration combined with a decrease in demand due to automation.
- jaypeg25 6y agoYou can't be serious. Are you insinuating it has nothing to do with executive wages ballooning (CEO compensation growing nearly 1,000% since the 1970's) and is instead because women are working? https://www.epi.org/publication/ceo-compensation-2018/ https://www.epi.org/publication/ceo-compensation-2018/
- frockington1 6y agoI think you are missing the scale and reaching for a political point where one does not need to be made. There are 500 CEOs in the SP500 and 164 million women in the US. The supply increase of 164 million women will have a far greater impact on the common persons salary than 500 CEOs getting paid more
- jayd16 6y agoIsn't that still like $7b[1] at the average 15m? Compare that to $45k[2] * for the 76k[3] women in the workforce, that's only ~$3.5b. Its US women vs the global S&P list, but it is interesting to compare, now that you mention it. [1]https://aflcio.org/paywatch https://aflcio.org/paywatch [2]https://www.catalyst.org/research/womens-earnings-the-pay-gap/#:~:text=A%20Gender%20Wage%20Gap%20Exists,time%2C%20year%2Dround%20workers.&text=This%20is%20compared%20to%2060.2%25%20in%201980.&text=Women%20earned%20a%20median%20of,2018%2C%20and%20men%20earned%20%2455%2C291 https://www.catalyst.org/research/womens-earnings-the-pay-ga.... [3]https://www.catalyst.org/research/women-in-the-workforce-united-states/#:~:text=Covid%2D19%20Is%20Disrupting%20Women's%20Labor%20Force%20Participation&text=In%202019%2C%20there%20were%2076%2C852%2C000,of%20the%20total%20labor%20force.&text=57.4%25%20of%20women%20participated%20in,compared%20to%2069.2%25%20of%20men https://www.catalyst.org/research/women-in-the-workforce-uni....
- swyx 6y agorequisite link to other potential correlations to 1970s changes https://wtfhappenedin1971.com/ https://wtfhappenedin1971.com/
- danans 6y ago> productivity started decoupling massively from productivity gains. I think you meant "wages started decoupling ...", right?
- mensetmanusman 6y agoYes, brain autocorrect. Can’t edit now that people have replied though :)
- danans 6y agoNo problem. I don't usually like to engage in pedantry, but I think that the point you were trying to make is not obvious to many, so worth clarifying.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoBlaming bankers and proposing revolution is one of those explanations that sounds satisfying but doesn’t really match the evidence. In some ways, as markets have become more efficient and transparent it becomes harder, not easier, for finance people to simply squeeze money out of the systems through financial tricks. We’re also living in a world where interest rates are at historical lows, making the cost of capital almost negligible for anyone with a good idea. The downside to taking this capital is that you’re giving away upside, but that’s not exactly a secret. The bigger factor is that per-worker productivity is amplified immensely by technology. Historically, businesses needed to scale their employee base nearly linearly with the number of customers. If you were in the business of building houses or growing produce, your economies of scale topped out early. If you want to serve more customers, you have to hire more people to do the work. In the technology era, the marginal cost of additional customers is minuscule. Netflix has to pay marginally more for bandwidth and licensing fees with each additional customer, but the number of employees necessary to support a growing customer base is minuscule. Even physical goods can have automated production as they scale up, so physical workers are less and less necessary as scale grows. For the jobs that remain, supply and demand still dominates the equation. Engineer salaries have been pushed upward because demand for engineering work exceeds supply. Factory worker salaries have been flat or gone down because demand for [domestic] manual labor is decreasing, meaning more people are willing to work for lower compensation just to take those jobs. Try as they might, the financial people can’t simply break the laws of supply and demand. If they try to keep so much of the profits that their wages fall below other companies, employees will simply leave for higher paying jobs. If the company raises wages so much that they need to charge customers more, their customers will simply leave for lower cost competitors. This behavior is more intuitive when you put yourself in the shoes of the decision makers. If you called a plumbing company to fix your drain and they quote you a price 2X that of the competitor but claim that it’s because they pay their plumbers more, are you going to gladly take it? Or would you just call any number of alternatives that will charge you market rate costs? (If you are among the few who would gladly pay more for the same service, ask yourself how the general population would behave)
- lock-free 6y agoI agree it doesn't make sense to blame bankers for exploiting the legal system that allows them to enrich the rich at the expense of the poor for a commission, other than the revolving doors between government and industry and lobbying efforts to maintain our broken society the way it is. There are numerous financial products and services available to only the wealthy that reduce tax burden and increase wealth and income that are inaccessible to anyone else, create little value, and are predicated on the concentration of wealth in the hands of a few. Just a random example, if you can afford to buy a home in cash, you shouldn't because the mortgage terms the banks will offer you are too good to pass up - you'll come out ahead just by taking on low interest debt and accounting for the rise in the home's value plus the more lucrative investments you can make with the cash. In other words, the people who get the most help are the ones who need it the least. That is the travesty of contemporary finance. When the critique of the financial system is made its not in place of supply and demand for labor but the fact it creates very little besides disparity. The god of liquidity should not be worshipped so much.
- pdonis 6y agoThe 70s wasn't the first time this had happened. The Industrial Revolution itself was a small number of people extracting most of the new earnings from productivity gains relative to the workers.
- weeksie 6y agoNo. What happened was that in the 70s energy got expensive. As renewables and battery tech get cheaper, we'll see bigger gains across the board. The "evil bankers" stuff is mostly a just so story to explain away the slowing of real growth for the last 40 years.
- pdonis 6y ago> What happened was that in the 70s energy got expensive. Only temporarily. Energy today, adjusted for inflation, is actually quite a bit cheaper now than it was even before the early 70s oil crisis.
- weeksie 6y agoNope [1] Lord grant me the confidence of a HN commentor talking about economics :/ [1] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?id=WTISPLC https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?id=WTISPLC,
- aaronblohowiak 6y agoIs this graph in nominal price or inflation-adjusted price? It is not obvious from the source.
- weeksie 6y agoJesus fucking Christ
- aaronblohowiak 6y agoI asked a question to learn more, please be nicer.
- weeksie 6y agoExtraordinary
- simonebrunozzi 6y agoOr, you get someone very influential (like YC) to start that revolution. Oh, wait: they don't have a strong incentive to do that. Even if my guess is that YC partners are well intentioned, doing something this radical would make many enemies in the VC ranks, and damage YC in the long run. I don't know... Perhaps a "revolution", like you're saying.