5 ms·
>No wonder the Sobells tried to block the follow up study with lawsuits It seems like there would be a totally reasonable concern about privacy here as well. I
by s1artibartfast 6y ago
>No wonder the Sobells tried to block the follow up study with lawsuits
It seems like there would be a totally reasonable concern about privacy here as well. If I participated in a study with finite scope, I wouldn't want my identity and medical information transferred to another group of researchers.
- placer 6y agoThe subjects were delighted (Edit: See below for actual quote from one of the Pendery team researchers) to be contacted by another research group, and some of them felt the treatment they got in the Sobell group was so shoddy, they ended up trying to sue the Sobell researchers. Reference: https://www.nytimes.com/1984/09/11/science/panel-finds-no-fraud-by-alcohol-researchers.html https://www.nytimes.com/1984/09/11/science/panel-finds-no-fr...
- s1artibartfast 6y ago>The subjects were delighted to be contacted by another research group Where did you get that they were delighted from the article you linked? Were they all uniformly delighted? It seems that either way, the original agreement/contract/TOS should govern what can be done with personal medical information.
- placer 6y agoThe reference was for the fact some of the original patients tried to sue the Sobells. The “delighted” bit comes from Alcoholism: A Review of its Characteristics, Etiology, Treatments, and Controversies by Irvine Maltzman, which goes in to the Sobell controversy in great detail. Edit: Going back to the book, here’s the most relevant quote from the late Maltzman: “the patients contacted prior to the court injunction all expressed a willingness to cooperate and to be interviewed” Maybe “delighted” was too strong of a word.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoThanks for clarifying.
- londons_explore 6y agoYet in society as a whole, the desire to prevent more people going down this "moderate drinking" path and ruining their lives seems far more important than the need to prevent 20 people getting a phone call saying "Can I ask some followup questions?". I feel like using someone's private data for the purpose of asking if they want to join a follow-up study should always be acceptable.
- overscore 6y agoI feel like using someone's personal data for any purpose other than the one for which it was collected should never be allowable. Luckily I live in the EU, where this would already be unlawful.
- bluecalm 6y agoImagine it was discovered 5 years after the initial study that the medicine given during it was harmful and there are long term health consequences. The discovery was made by another team. Wouldn't you like to know? Another example: a study for rare condition was conducted. No effective treatment was found. A few years later very promising treatment was discovered. Wouldn't you like to know, even if the original form didn't ask your permission?
- frereubu 6y agoThe easy way to remedy this is that all forms should ask for that permission explicitly, and many do. When doing an MSc in neuroscience, even though our research was about the contribution of early visual areas to reading tasks, we always asked permission to get in contact if we found anything problematic on structural MRI scans. If someone explicitly says no to that (which I can't remember happening - as you suggest, the vast majority of people would like to know) that's their choice. Edit: What no-one has said here is whether the initial study did say that, and the original researchers were going against the wishes of the participants. Given how the researchers behaved that doesn't seem entirely unlikely.
- 6y ago
- jacquesm 6y agoDo you think it was their 'reasonable concern about privacy' that drove their zeal to suppress the report or do you think it was because the was immediate proof that their study was nonsense?
- tolien 6y agoDoes it really matter? The cost of throwing out the privacy baby along with the bad actor bathwater is much higher than that of this one bad study, even if it was mitigated slightly by the good intent of the follow-up. It would have been better to run a new study and try to reproduce the results but as we’ve seen with the crisis in reproducibility throughout the sciences, that’s problematic in itself.
- placer 6y agoThat’s not what the judge looking at this very issue felt: “Judge Hauk concluded that on balance it was more important to determine how the patients were faring following treatment than any possible breach of confidentiality and invasion of privacy which were protected by their right to refuse to participate in the study” Source: Alcoholism: A Review of its Characteristics, Etiology, Treatments, and Controversies by Irvine Maltzman (Keep in mind this was the mid-to-late 1970s in California)
- tolien 6y agoSo in the same era as the Tuskegee Syphilis Study? I couldn't really care less what the judge concluded, I hope we've since established that medical ethics weren't what they should be. The better of the quotes you've dropped in this discussion is > the patients contacted prior to the court injunction all expressed a willingness to cooperate and to be interviewed That is to say, the participants' expressed their consent to follow-up action. I'd still prefer not transferring personal information to another group of researchers, though - the same thing could have been achieved with some kind of advertisement in the media ("participated in a Sobell study? Call this number").
- 6y ago