13 ms·
3D printing boats is becoming standard practice
- mbrumlow 6y agoAnybody know what would stop home printers from printing like the way they printed the bot? It really seems like a lot of prints of mine would be way stronger if it where done at a angle like that that. note I 3d print everything all the time. My house is speckled with orange printed parts (I like to point out when something was 3d printed).
- sjnu 6y agoCreality has one.
- numpad0 6y agoBlackbelt/Printrbelt/CR-30 style has patent and speed issues, they can't reliably print at speeds of Prusa i3 or something like that.
- anzuli 6y agoNothing stopping home printers printing at a 45 degree angle, in fact Creality currently has a kickstarter campaign for one called 3DPrintMill. 45 degree printing is very useful for overhangs in a single direction. This is likely why they've utilized it for printing the bow of the boat. But this makes printing overhangs in the direction of the nozzle impossible, thus not useful in all applications.
- miahi 6y agoThe easiest way to test printing at an angle is to rotate the object 45 degrees before printing; you'll need a lot more supports, but it can be done. The results depend on the forces your object will see. The tensile strength is lower perpendicular to the printing direction, as the adhesion between layers is lower than the continuous filament adhesion. So printing at an angle is better if you need more tensile strength on the Z axis (but then you can rotate it to have that axis flat), but it also reduces the strength on that angled direction.
- systemvoltage 6y agoProblem with 3D printing is how slow it really is. I do see a path for better printing quality and overtime becoming indistinguishable from injection molding, but I do not see any path for beating a 15 second cycle time. Printing a coffee mug can take whopping 8 hours, depending on specifics of quality and the machine. I feel like Injection Molding is far more amazing, interesting, intriguing and challenging process than 3D printing and yet, it gets zero media coverage. Before people respond to this - yes, I know the pros/cons of 3D printing and it certainly has place in manufacturing processes. Just pointing out the media hype around 3D printing which I thought would die down after 2015 or so... but it continues to overwhelm news sources. Edit: Goddamn it HN, why are you all responding to the pros/cons of 3D printing? My complain is about media coverage and how click baity engagement metrics propelled 3D printing into this glorified do-all-world-changing-technology. It disproportionately gets attention, was just using injection-molding as a talking point. There are so many interesting manufacturing techniques. Every MBA exec wants their engineers to explore 3D-printing without knowing its downsides, thanks to the stupid media.
- sfifs 6y agoAs with nearly all capabilities in all fields, you're trading off flexibility, quality, throughput and speed to market. You're also trading off cost on the vectors of capex vs. opex. Injection moulding gives high quality and throughput with low flexibility and relatively high capex. That makes it fit for use for some cases and not for others. In my home 3d printer for instance, i can download and print a snowflake or some small toy my child wants to hang on the Christmas tree that she is missing in about 20 mins which otherwise would entail a trip to the store or ordering online and waiting. However, if i were to print all the decorations she wants to hang, it would take an inordinate amount of time and I'm better off making the trip to the store.
- notRobot 6y agoInjection molding is established technology and nothing new, and is much harder to DIY, which is why it gets less media coverage. The beauty of 3D printing is that you need no molds. You can print all sorts of stuff with the same printer in the same config.
- helsinkiandrew 6y agoFor boat building - apart from small dinghies/run-arounds its hard to see 3d printing will beat using a mold with sheets of carbon fibre or fibreglass. 1. The sheets will make the structure stronger in more directions 2. The mold will result in a 'shiny smooth' surface. 3. Delamination of glass fibre sheets is already a worry/problem with older boats. How well will strands of 3d printed material cope with decades of exposure to salt water and UV light? (ABS has poor UV resilience) I'm sure CNC/Robotics could be used in creating molds, cutting sheets of carbon fibre, and possibly laying them in molds. See the huge molds used here: https://www.yachtsinternational.com/owners-lounge/carbon-fiber-the-new-black https://www.yachtsinternational.com/owners-lounge/carbon-fib...
- loremipsium 6y agoThere is an interesting paper on bouyancy optimization in 3d printing. You could define a waterline and orientation on any 3d shape and print it so that it stays afloat.
- jerzmacow 6y agoI wonder how water tight these are in practice. Small scale FDM prints aren't airtight, and are questionably watertight. For something like a sailboat that floats in the water it's whole life, even a small leak can be a problem.
- yarcob 6y agoI wonder if they do any post processing on the prints. Some wooden boats are coated with glass fiber & epoxy resin to protect the wood. You could do the same thing with a 3D printed part -- that would make it watertight and would also increase stiffness.
- semi-extrinsic 6y agoIf they do that, it's essentially identical to how you do a cedar strip plank boat. The 3D-print/wood is only used for its compressive strength across the ~1 cm hull thickness, which is really high, and the glass (or carbon) fibre translates bending of the hull into tension of the fibres plus compression of the separating material - loading each material in the way where it's strongest. The technical word for this is a torsion box, and you find it everywhere, from doors in your house to aircraft wings.
- chewxy 6y agoI clicked into it thinking it was about benchies. It's about actual boats.
- SftwreEngnr 6y agoWow!
- EE84M3i 6y agoFor anyone else unfamiliar: "a calibration and torture-test part for 3D printers." http://www.3dbenchy.com/ http://www.3dbenchy.com/ It is shaped like a boat.
- jbay808 6y agoSome time around 2009 I met Enrique, the author of Skeinforge, a popular and extremely feature-rich software suite for slicing 3D models into 3D printer G-code. He said his dream wanted to someday 3D print a boat. I thought that was far-fetched.
- Tepix 6y agoThe wood that is processed to be harder than steel that was mentioned the other day seems like a better fit for boats. But who knows how far this tech will carry us? Boats are great and i welcome new processes to build them.
- shimonabi 6y agoI hope they print 3DBenchy in human size some day.
- tweetle_beetle 6y ago"A string of projects" (only 4 examples in last 2 years are provided) covering a global industry sets a pretty low bar for "becoming standard practice". > ...the usual thing that is done in a particular situation. [1] [1] https://www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/english/normal-practice-standard-practice https://www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/english/normal-...
- ansible 6y agoHeh. This reminds me that there was a link to an interview about a dramatic shift in funding models for content creators. The person being interviewed was really in it for... 1.5 months. The "veterans" were in it for less than a year. Yeah... come back in another year before we can call this some kind of long-term trend.
- markdown 6y agoThousands of boats are made every year. Seven and a half 3D printed ones doesn’t make it “standard practice”. Why is this clickbait condoned on HN?
- tomcam 6y agoSpoiler alert: not standard practice at all. A few pilot projects using slow and very expensive techniques have been completed successfully.
- gitowiec 6y agoWhat about all this microplastic which gets from this "boat" into water? This should be banned, I think.
- Jipazgqmnm 6y agoI'm kind of jarred by the enthusiasm expressed here. The end-product is not environmentally friendly in any way.
- detaro 6y agoDoes this loose more microplastic than other boats?
- bigbubba 6y agoAlmost certainly; look at the rough plastic surface of it. Sea water and UV will almost certainly degrade this boat and have it shedding loads of plastic. The only upside is they didn't choose to cover it in glitter, but such coatings are certainly optional for traditional boats...
- sesuximo 6y agoMost boats are covered in protective sealants/paints so I think this is not a major concern unless the boat crashes
- theon144 6y agoDoes anybody have any read as to why FDM is only receiving this kind of attention now? It seems that the technology has been there for quite a while (and I mean decades at least). Is it just riding the hype from home 3D printers?
- lylecheatham 6y agoI'd say the real hype cycle for FDM was in 2013-2015, as evidenced by the SSYS stock price [1] (many other 3D printing companies have similar curves). I think we're now on the tail end of the hype cycle graph and people are starting to find real uses for FDM [1] https://www.google.com/search?q=ssys+stock https://www.google.com/search?q=ssys+stock (set to max time)
- yardie 6y agoA lot of 20 year patents on FDM have expired within the last 5-10 years. Technology that was only affordable to R&D labs and university have made it to the end user and experimenters. More hands in the pot means more diverse ideas. Expertise isn't cloaked in NDAs but published in wikis.
- stevehawk 6y agothis is one of the most clickbaited titles I'll see all day.
- ascales 6y agoFor scale prototypes, it's great. I have a 3D printed 1/100 scale sailboat hull on my desk right now. However, you aren't going to beat building hulls out of fiberglass. With a large CNC, foam/starboard/coosa, and a roll of fiberglass you can prototype a full scale boat in a weekend. Maybe printing a hull buck would be a good move? But you just as easily could CNC foam blocks for that too...
- hn_ltl-ftc 6y agoNot to be harsh, or dis-respectful, but there's an unfortunate amount of incorrect, or obsolete, information in the comments on this article. Let me see if I can do better... -- Full disclosure: I used to (relatively recently) work for a vendor of 3D-printing technology. It is important to consider the full 'volume' range of manufacturing, when evaluating a particular process or technology. Some will be good for making ONE part; and some for a million+ parts, and some in the middle. It's also important to consider the intended usage: for example, prototypes and military and medical parts may not be cost-sensitive, but, say toys, or consumer electronics are the opposite. Speed of manufacture is a key cost driver, especially in high labor-cost countries. Raw material wastage, and cost of energy can also be key cost drivers in manufacturing. With regards to 3D-printing (more formally known as: additive manufacturing), I have to admit that I _used to_ be a skeptic, too. I can't tell you the number of: toys, action figures, souveniers, etc. that I saw printed from low-end, plastic 3D printers--and they just struck me as 'junk'. And even a lot of the industrial parts that I saw from middle-tier, plastic 3D printers were...unimpressive. I few years ago, I even thought that I was detecting a 'backlash' against 3D printing, at least at the hobbyiest level. And it is true that there has been some consolidation of vendors of low-end/hobbiest 3D printers. But, there's also been a gradual, and now accelerating maturity in AM, and also an increasing diversity in approaches, and in uses. In particular, most people only think about 3D printing in plastic. But metal AM, and also directional-composite (e.g., oriented carbon-fiber) printing is really coming along. In particular, AM lets us create parts that have voids (of controlled size/shape) throughout the part. That may not sound like a big deal, until you think about weight-sensitive transportation usage. If you can get 20-30% of the normal weight out of a part, that's huge for cars; and game-changing for aerospace. Here's one case-study, where they're claiming a savings of 3,180 kg of fuel, per-year, PER-PLANE: https://www.autodesk.com/customer-stories/airbus https://www.autodesk.com/customer-stories/airbus I noticed that lots of commentors are discussing how much 'better' injection molding is than 3D printing in plastic. Sure, for anything above prototyping quantities, that's probably true. But, also think about the manufacture of the _molds_ for those machines. What if you could cut your mold production time by 30%, and your mold production cost by 90%? Here's a case study on that: https://www.desktopmetal.com/resources/builtrite-3d-printed-injection-molds https://www.desktopmetal.com/resources/builtrite-3d-printed-... What if 3D printing--including in METAL--wasn't a S-L-O-W process. Here's some folks that can do metal AM at very high speed: https://www.digitalalloys.com/ https://www.digitalalloys.com/ The caveat there is that the resulting part has pretty crude tolerances, so a finish pass (with conventional CNC machining) may be needed. But there's some higher-quality, and pretty high-volume, metal AM processes coming along, for example: https://www.desktopmetal.com/products/production https://www.desktopmetal.com/products/production and: https://www.exone.com/ https://www.exone.com/ Lastly, AM opens up some design space possibilities, that previously were either wickedly cost-prohibite, or were completely impossible to do. For example, the previously mentioned _molds_ for injection molding machines. Being able to carefully control the mold temperature is a key process parameter. With 3D printing, 'conformable' cooling channels can be designed-in to the mold. And these channels can basically be any geometry that is needed--looking like animal veins, for example, to give optimal cooling. It's probably going to take a new generation of designers and mechanical engineers, before the full--and I use this word deliberately: disruptive--effects of AM are 'internalized', and used to their best potential. For example, here's a (software) CAD tool that produces 'organic' designs, and ones that would only be practical to manufacture with 3D printing: https://www.desktopmetal.com/products/software/live-parts/ https://www.desktopmetal.com/products/software/live-parts/
- yters 6y agoFiberglass is really fast and cheap, and you can throw together a simple mold with wood. Hard to see 3d printing competing in the space of just making useful boats.
- yardie 6y agoFiberglass is incredibly useful for prototyping and repairs. I watched a shipwright rebuild a bow by creating a mold from sheets of melamine. Then epoxy it to the cut open hull. And this was an age old technique using little more than hand tools and common sense.
- bigbubba 6y agoA black plastic boat? I'm going to go out on a limb here and assume they chose black for a reason; many plastics degrade in sunlight; adding carbon black is an effective way to make plastic more resilient to UV. Probably this boat would degrade if left out in the sun for too long, particularly if it wasn't black. But a black boat is going to be pretty damn unpleasant to be on in sunny warm weather anyway; it would be like a solar cooker. This doesn't seem like the future of boat building to me.
- sunstone 6y agoI wonder if anyone will make boats out the steel that the cybertruck will use? It Should be at lot cheaper than aluminum, though might not be corrosion resistent enough.
- dukeofdoom 6y agoSeems like the sweet spot would be printing sub million dollar catamarans. Something that is unsinkable maybe with trapped air compartments. If you have a million to spare, the current fiber glass designs, are awesome. But the amount of trouble and maintenance required makes me question if its worth it even owning a new boat. When sailing around the world on cruise ship is so much more luxurious and cheaper. From watching youtube, the sealants around windows are a constant problem. Algae and barnacles growth on the hull, requires repainting the boat every few years. Its basically a part time job to maintain these things.
- rrauenza 6y agoAnd I thought this was going to be an article on the obsession with printing the 3d "benchy". People print them over and over and over to evaluate how "tuned" in they've gotten their printers and then they show them off on 3d printing facebook groups. The object is designed to test out various aspects like bridging, overhangs, holes, etc. https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:763622 https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:763622
- cwkoss 6y agoThe Ultimate Benchy