6 ms·
> It sure looks like Gnome 3 took the wind out of Gnome's sails. For me, GNOME made three mistakes and made them back to back: - No 3D graphics, no desktop
by bayindirh 6y ago
> It sure looks like Gnome 3 took the wind out of Gnome's sails.
For me, GNOME made three mistakes and made them back to back:
- No 3D graphics, no desktop for you (wrong timing).
- All advanced settings is embedded in a registry-like structure (too much OS X influence, sent the wrong message, made a lot of things hard).
- Extreme paradigm shift without communication (GNOME 3 became something different, almost OS X like, also Canonical's influence did this IMHO).
As a result GNOME3 didn't evolve. It went through metamorphosis. It's core qualities (low resource usage, balance between customization power & approachability, and more importantly familiarity) disappeared. Compounded with backlash (MATE mainly) took the excitement out of GNOME.
- dleslie 6y agoFor the first: and it was a pig until even recently; you still need a fairly beefy machine to run it at 60 fps! For the second: not just moved, many options were flat out removed; I dropped Gnome because of this. For the last one: and broke many apps in the process.
- hda2 6y agoI still remember how their developers requested that transmission (a popular third-party torrent app) remove support for system tray icons because Gnome removed them. They eventually decided to side-step developers and remove system tray support from GTK entirely. Edit: changed "demanded" to "requested" to be more neutral. See comment bellow.
- cycloptic 6y agoFor reference, here is the bug: https://trac.transmissionbt.com/ticket/3685 https://trac.transmissionbt.com/ticket/3685 Reading further down, it's hard for me to see a demand there, I see a heads-up about an upcoming deprecation and a suggestion of what to do about it. The reason the system tray support was deprecated and removed eventually was because nobody was keeping it up-to-date.
- anoncake 6y agoMoney quote from the bug: > I guess you have to decide if you are a GNOME app, an Ubuntu app, or an XFCE app unfortunately. I'm sorry that this is the case but it wasn't GNOME's fault that Ubuntu has started this fork. And I have no idea what XFCE is or does sorry.
- bayindirh 6y agoWhy can't Transmission-gtk be just a well written GTK app and play nice everywhere? Why the (forced) distinction?
- NullPrefix 6y agoYou're either with us or against us!
- cycloptic 6y agoYou might say this is "fragmentation." Up until two years ago Ubuntu had a different shell (Unity) with a different API for this, and up until last year XFCE was mostly still using GTK2 and its deprecated APIs. Things are getting better now (Ubuntu's tray is just an ordinary GNOME extension, XFCE supports the new API) but it's taken time to reconcile everything.
- bigbubba 6y ago> And I have no idea what XFCE is or does sorry. This is the point where I realized that person was not commenting in good faith. It simply isn't plausible that a GNOME developer was earnestly unaware of XFCE's existence.
- hkt 6y agoIt was a big step, yeah, but it was also something new in open source. There are lots of choices if you want desktops that are plainer than Gnome. There's only one choice if you want something simple and slick and sort of luxurious on your Linux machine. I wouldn't be without it, and having just received my Pinephone I'm happy and looking forward to it being with me wherever I go.
- still_grokking 6y ago> There's only one choice if you want something simple and slick and sort of luxurious on your Linux machine. I wouldn't be without it, and having just received my Pinephone I'm happy and looking forward to it being with me wherever I go. You mean KDE Plasma, right?
- hkt 6y agoHaven't actually tried plasma, but I hate KDE on the desktop with a passion. Maybe I should give plasma a look though
- dleslie 6y agoFWIW, I have a PinePhone and Plasma is just all-around superior to Phosh; faster, more responsive, and uses less battery. I don't even like KDE, but such as it is, Gnome on mobile is not great. Ten years of pushing touch UI design on us, and it's... Still five to ten years undercooked.
- badsectoracula 6y ago> There's only one choice if you want something simple and slick and sort of luxurious on your Linux machine. According to /r/unixporn... i3-gaps? :-P (honestly, people in that subreddit seem to manage to make any window manager look totally unexpected visually, e.g. see this[0] for a DWM customization - someone from Suckless must be digging their grave so they can roll in it :-P). [0] https://imgur.com/a/VaO5Evi https://imgur.com/a/VaO5Evi
- aerique 6y ago
- pantalaimon 6y ago> also Canonical's influence did this IMHO Huh? Canonical switched away from Gnome with the dreaded version 3 and created their own Unity instead.
- bayindirh 6y agoIIRC they tried to evolve GNOME to what they wanted first, then decided to create unity later. I may remember wrong though. I don't follow GNOME, Unity and Ubuntu very closely.
- curlypaul924 6y ago> It's core qualities (low resource usage, balance between customization power & approachability, and more importantly familiarity) disappeared. I think you hit the nail on the head. KDE gave you the full DE experience, but there was that pesky Qt license. GNOME was full GPL/LGPL and it felt like it was built to attract power users. Skins were at the height of their popularity (remember Winamp?), and GNOME gave users an easy way to customize everything without having to muck with some arcane config file format. Every release felt closer to some platonic ideal of a fully customizable yet easy-to-use DE. Then came the iPhone, and suddenly the world went hyper-modern and hyper-minimal. Restaurants names like "The Heavenly Chicken" are now old-fashioned; today the same restaurant is simply "chicken". GNOME was also affected by this cultural shift, and as you point out, ended up abandoning its core qualities. I believe that hyper-modernism, like other movements, is just a fad, and in a few years we will "rediscover" modding. Everything will be customizable, from the color of your keyboard to the genes that control your eye color. Who knows, we might even shake the dust off the blink tag.
- bayindirh 6y agoGNOME left in the middle of a perfect storm IMHO. I remember GTK being much faster and lighter than Qt/KDE and boasting this fact with blog posts with performance metrics. These years also were problematic for Linux on laptops. Power management, wireless and overall experience was very bad. MacBook had a considerable mind and market share among Linux developers. I remember a slide saying "Linux on desktop cannot move forward because of MacOS's advantages and features on mobile", which was very true for that day. With the rise of Ubuntu, iPhone and MacOS, GNOME wanted to be the MacOS of Linux. Straightforward, minimal and somewhat capable. However, leaning heavily on GConf, burial of features, dumbing down of UI marked their downfall. I've moved to KDE before that time and was spoiled by kio, integrated DE features and other stuff. 4.0 was rough but, I endured and KDE became something different. A class by itself. The so-called Qt Agreement and dual-licensing also saved them. I also believe that customization will return. I wish GNOME best of luck and give me some reason to try them, at least in a VM. I won't change my primary DE, but I'll play with others at least. GTK has some nice qualities but, GNOME3 is not treating its foundations and features as it should IMHO. I can still dig my .kde folder and look what are the settings and how things configured though. GNOME, while being the flagship DE of GNU movement, feels closed, bloated and devoid of any GNU/Linux spirit. Maybe that's the aim for mass market adoption. I don't know. --- Addendum: I want to add that initial GNOME3 and GTK3 documentation was horrible. They moved everything to JS based introspection stuff and generated documentation automatically with no explanation whatsoever. We've tried to develop a gigantic project with GNOME3 and the best way to develop software was via trial'n'error in their new and shiny developer console. It was like being insulted continuously while walking in the dark in a room full of Lego bricks on the floor and sharp corners at head level. To add insult to injury, their touch implementation was buggy. I dug the WM implementation for two weeks and found a comment basically saying that "We hacked this together. It's not X protocol compliant & needs to be re-implemented from ground up. Since you've found here, maybe you can do that, thanks." Grr... However, the WM code was very clean and readable. I'll give them that.