4 ms·
In the real world, there aren't many people making purchasing decision between an M1 Apple laptop or Mac Mini and an AMD 5800X desktop machine anyway. Still int
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
In the real world, there aren't many people making purchasing decision between an M1 Apple laptop or Mac Mini and an AMD 5800X desktop machine anyway. Still interesting to see the comparisons.
The leaked Geekbench results of AMD's upcoming 5800H laptop parts are about 85% of the M1's single core score and matching the M1's multi-core score. TDP is still higher than the M1, obviously, but AMD is also using a 7nm process while Apple got the jump on 5nm by buying exclusivity on TMSC's 5nm process through the end of the year.
I'm extremely impressed with the M1 and I'll be buying an Apple Silicon device as soon as they have something with 32GB or more of RAM. However, the sentiment that the M1 chip obliterates any and every desktop part on the market is getting kind of silly at this point.
- viraptor 6y agoSome are making a "desktop with cheaper terminal laptop -vs- pro laptop" choice though. And in that case the comparison may matter.
- reader_mode 6y agoThing is M1 air is cheap for the quality/performance so you could probably get both.
- viraptor 6y agoSure, but this article helps answering "do I need both".
- sudosysgen 6y agoDepends. If you go for the base model, yes. If you need more memory or a lot of fast storage or gobs of GPU horsepower or a lot of I/O, the 5800X will be definitely cheaper by a mile. That being said, at the same config, the 5800X system would indeed only barely be cheaper.
- SomeoneFromCA 6y agoI need lots of harddrives and pcie slots for my type of work. No matter how fast the M1 is, I'd rather use i3-10100 instead.
- akmarinov 6y agoLet’s not forget that the M1 is the budget (for Apple), low performance SoC. Let’s see what the M1X is like mid next year.
- echlebek 6y agoAbsolutely, the M1 is extremely impressive and the best performer in its class by a long shot.
- lazyjones 6y agoYep it's probably the first at this size and packaging that you can just hook up to a TV and replace a decent desktop computer with (like I did; goodbye late 2015 iMac 5K...).
- alwillis 6y agoHowever, the sentiment that the M1 chip obliterates any and every desktop part on the market is getting kind of silly at this point. 1. Nobody ever stated that. If anything, it was all of the Intel and AMD users who created that straw man. "See, it's slower than a 64-core Threadripper at 280 watts". No kidding. 2. The M1 is clearly not a desktop-class SoC nor was it intended to be. However, it's more than competitive with many desktop x86 processors that run faster and hotter while consuming much more power. 3. As a first attempt, the M1’s performance per watt is very impressive. Obviously the 5nm process helps but it's never one thing with Apple: it's the unified memory, the 8 instruction decoders (AMD and Intel max out at 4), and the integration of the 16-core Neural Engine, among other features.
- ComputerGuru 6y ago> the unified memory Castrated by a paltry 8GB of RAM in stock configuration!
- alwillis 6y agoCastrated by a paltry 8GB of RAM in stock configuration! Probably not. macOS has had RAM compression since 2009; by now, it's probably implemented in the M1 SoC, so it's really really fast. 8 GB on an M1 is closer to 16 GB on most other processor/operating system combinations.
- tartrate 6y agoThat's amazing. I usually read in 16 GB of image data into memory for analysis. I'm guessing that will work fine on the 8GB ram macbook then. /s
- gambiting 6y agoLook, it doesn't have to work for everyone. Of course there are workloads where it's not going to be enough. That's fine. My personal workload requires 128GB of ram but I don't go around telling people 8GB laptops are pointless.
- reader_mode 6y ago> In the real world, there aren't many people making purchasing decision between an M1 Apple laptop or Mac Mini and an AMD 5800X desktop machine anyway I have a 15 inch 2018 i9 MBP that's objectively a terrible device (throttling/keyboard). With corona and WFH I'm weighing my options - right now everything is out of stock but early next year I'd be interested in building a desktop. My problem is the M1 is so good that if they do a 8 performance cores version for 16 inch MBP in spring there would literally be no point in having a desktop - I could have a single device that outperforms the desktop machine. Frankly I don't see why they couldn't offer a 13 inch varian with more cores - thermals are not a constraint.
- oezi 6y agoHas there been any leak that a 16 inch MBP with Apple Silicon is coming anytime soon? Haven't heard any substantial info on roadmap.
- least 6y agoThere’s not been leaks, but there’s no reason to believe that it won’t be coming any time soon. Hypothetically the latest it would come out is in first half of 2022, but I’d be surprised if it took that long for the 16 inch macbook pro.
- Rapzid 6y agoDoes Apple ever announce anything before the day it happens? This is the company that drops iOS, macOS, and M1 on developers the day they do the public. I'm not sure where people are pulling all these Apple silicon timelines from, but I can guess :)