7 ms·
I don't believe that at all. Google doesn't need Skype. Microsoft bought Skype because they have large amounts of cash in Europe that they cannot repatriate wit
by fauigerzigerk 16y ago
I don't believe that at all. Google doesn't need Skype. Microsoft bought Skype because they have large amounts of cash in Europe that they cannot repatriate without taking a huge tax hit. For some strange reason, Ballmer has that obsession with hyperactively pursuing the same consumers that Google and Apple have. That's why he didn't see anything else to buy in Europe (Actually there isn't a whole lot).
But there is something: SAP. What Microsoft should do is take on Oracle and IBM instead of Apple and Google. They should make an offer to that large number of companies who want one thing more than everything else: Peace of mind based on an integrated stack. They are ready to pay up. Microsoft is the master of integration (some call it lock-in). Together with SAP, Microsoft has the most complete enterprise stack imaginable. All of a sudden even Windows Phone would have a place in this world as a BlackBerry successor.
- gfodor 16y agoI agree with this wholeheartedly -- Microsoft's fatal error was assuming they would continue to be the dominant force in both consumer and enterprise computing. They still own the enterprise. Why they aren't happy with this and focus on taking steps to ensure their dominance there for the next decade is beyond me.
- Raphael_Amiard 16y agoThey're still the ones who make the most used OS in the world. They're not the ones innovating and creating new markets and paradigms. But were they, ever ?
- erikpukinskis 16y agoI've waved the "What did Microsoft ever invent?" flag plenty in my life, so let me try and advocate for the devil: Microsoft basically invented the hardware-agnostic software platform. Before Microsoft, there were a variety of hardware platforms, each with their own libraries and languages... not unlike the situation today with phones. Developers had to choose what to target... not only Mac vs PC, but different video cards, different sound cards, different network stacks, etc. Microsoft took that fragmented market and unified it under a set of standard APIs for both hardware makers and software developers to target. I would consider that an innovation: the loose coupling that they enabled allowed much faster innovation in both hardware and third-party software. Interestingly, Netscape tried to play the same game on top of them (unifying Windows, Mac, and UNIX under one standardized API), and though Microsoft was able to destroying them, Webkit has succeeded where Netscape failed, and it is slowly making Microsoft irrelevant, just as Gates feared. Other than that, I don't think Microsoft invented much. But they did a good job copying, were ruthless with business executation, and so their one innovation ended up being a multi-trillion dollar innovation.
- lurker19 16y agoExecution is everything. For everything Microsoft copied from someone you know about, five things you know about were copied from someone you do not know about.
- rbanffy 16y ago> Microsoft basically invented the hardware-agnostic software platform Digital Research did that. You could run a CP/M program on any CP/M-capable computer. Microsoft tried that with MSX (and failed) and then with MS-DOS (and succeeded on a different hardware platform). Only then, different graphics cards and printers became relevant. > Other than that, I don't think Microsoft invented much Visual Basic is one thing that comes to mind. I don't remember anything like it before. Hypercard and Toolbook were huge and heavy in comparison. VB allowed BASIC programmers to write compact Windows programs. That more or less doomed DOS.
- abecedarius 16y agoNote that VB was an outside acquisition.
- rbanffy 16y agoOh... So was MS-DOS... Well... Not very surprising. That company has been sick for decades.
- yuhong 16y agoTo be more precise, MS-DOS (and 86-DOS before that) tried to copy CP/M on that area (the original platform for SCP 86-DOS which MS bought and renamed MS-DOS was SCP's S-100 8086 cards which existed before the IBM PC), but MS bought SCP in the first place because they needed an OS to sell to IBM for their 8088-based PC, and so of course it first shipped on the IBM PC, and what happened was that the DOS calls was too limited and slow, so apps used the BIOS and even direct hardware access. So in the US full IBM PC hardware and BIOS compatiblity ended up being needed. (In Japan it was a different story)
- encoderer 16y ago
- contextfree 16y agoThey think that what's popular with consumers will eventually make its way into enterprise. Or in other words, their consumer efforts are the steps they're taking to (try to) protect enterprise dominance in the long term.
- raganwald 16y agoYou might have something there! A few years back I wondered if enterprise software was experiencing a disruption because of the way user expectations were being set outside of the company: http://weblog.raganwald.com/2007/09/we-have-lost-control-of-apparatus.html http://weblog.raganwald.com/2007/09/we-have-lost-control-of-... Maybe Microsoft sees this they way you suggest and believes that by controlling the consumer experience, they will also control the enterprise experience. For example, if they control the dominant VOIP consumer application, their tools can dominate enterprise-VOIP integration. I don't know if they have the management moxie to pull it off, but I think you may be right about what they're trying to do.
- contextfree 16y agoYeah, this isn't my speculation, it's how Ballmer and others have been publicly justifying their decision to continue targeting both consumer and enterprise instead of splitting up into two companies or dumping the consumer side.
- maayank 16y agoNot only that, but they (MSFT) have much less of an existing/quality solution in either the small business market or the enterprise *RM markets.
- ansy 16y agoInteresting point about taxes. Can anyone confirm if this is how it works? What prevents Microsoft Europe from buying an entity in the United States and holding the new company in Europe? It's not like other European entities need to pay tax penalties on top of the purchase price when buying assets abroad, right?
- fauigerzigerk 16y agoGood question. Presumably, a corporation cannot pick and choose to act as a single entity in one regard and as multiple independent companies in another. But I'm not sure either how it really works. Would be interesting to hear from an accountant or tax lawyer. [Edit] There's an article in the WSJ by John Chambers of Cisco and Safra Catz of Oracle on the issue: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704469004575533880328930598.html http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405274870446900457553...
- ansy 16y agoHumorous how the article recommends the US can take the suggested 5% repatriating tax revenue and use it to give a tax break. So the net repatriating tax revenue to the US government would be 0%? Ah, WSJ. On the other hand dropping the tax would encourage even more overseas shenanigans, which I guess is burning Microsoft (and presumably Oracle and Cisco) for not thinking ahead, forcing them to pass on valuable domestic investments and overpay for less valuable overseas investments.
- rprasad 16y agoThe WSJ article gives a basic, but slanted description of how it works. Briefly: income earned by overseas subsidiaries is not taxable to the American corporate parent until those overseas earnings are sent back to America via a dividend. Here, rather than pay a 35% rate on their overseas profits, Microsoft chose to use it to acquire another company, essentially delaying taxation on that income until much later into the future, if ever. Edit: There is no advantage to the reverse (MSEuro buying a US company), since the US-earned income is taxed in the US at the US corporate rates, which are much higher than the European corporate rates. The money would be taxed at a lower rate when repatriated to the Euro owner, but you would have ended up paying the higher tax rate first.
- raarky 16y agoI agree with you. MS and SAP would be a pretty formidable force. Having said that, MS continue to make very good strides in the business market but they still need to play in the consumer market.
- ansy 16y agoYou guys do realize that SAP is at least one order of magnitude larger than Skype, right? It rings in at a $77 BILLION in market cap on the NYSE[1]. I'm not even sure that represents SAP's total value, either. There seems to be a separate listing valued at $55 BILLION that's traded on ETR[2]. SAP AG was the fourth largest software company in the entire world by revenue in 2010[3]. That kind of merger would be unique in Microsoft's history[4]. In fact Skype is already Microsoft's largest merger in history by a sizable margin. EDIT: The ETR listing is valued in euros, where 55 billion EUR roughly translates to 77 billion USD. Although I still don't know if that fully accounts for SAP AG's value. [1] http://www.google.com/finance?q=NYSE%3ASAP http://www.google.com/finance?q=NYSE%3ASAP [2] http://www.google.com/finance?q=ETR:SAP http://www.google.com/finance?q=ETR:SAP [3] http://www.softwaretop100.org/global-software-top-100-edition-2010 http://www.softwaretop100.org/global-software-top-100-editio... [4] https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/List_of_mergers_and_acquisitions_by_Microsoft https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/List_of_merge...
- fauigerzigerk 16y agoI'm aware of that. Usually deals of that size are done at least partly through a share swap, not all cash. Microsoft needs to do something big. Skype just won't move the needle and it still costs a whole lot of money. But there is indeed a problem caused by SAP's size. It's completely uncertain whether regulators in Europe would allow such a deal to happen. Microsoft and SAP wanted to merge many years ago (when MS was arguably more powerful) but it was called off due to regulatory issues.
- barkingcat 16y agoThat's why it would be an interesting acquisition / merger. It would be a transformative event, changing both companies in radical ways that would require a true leader with vision to take the reigns and recreate both companies. In my opinion, buying SAP would be Ballmer's worse nightmare - he wouldn't even know where to start in harnessing the energies of both companies, and that's why we'll probably never see this happen.
- rbanffy 16y agoGive Ballmer a couple years and SAP may be able to buy Microsoft. That was unfair - Microsoft's demise is not completely Ballmer's fault. The market has been changing in directions Microsoft was not able to follow at speeds they were never able to match.
- hnhg 16y agoThey have begun taking on Oracle and SAP after buying Navision and turning it into Microsoft Dynamics. From what I've seen, it's a very strong product and I'm expecting it to do well. EDIT: Link here: http://www.microsoft.com/en-us/dynamics/default.aspx http://www.microsoft.com/en-us/dynamics/default.aspx
- leandrod 16y agoI have been expecting it to do well for several years already. Not really, but I guess you make my point.
- raisenBran 16y agoI think you are missing the main point that the article is arguing. You're right about Google. They do not need Skype, but the article does not say anything about Google needing Skype at all. The article only said Microsoft needed Skype. It was a defensive measurement on Microsoft's part. I think this is the most important sentence of the article: "Were Google to buy Skype they’d convert those 663 million Skype subscriptions to Google Voice and Gmail and in a swoop make parts of Yahoo and MSN irrelevant." This is important for a number of reasons. 1. If Google were to buy Skype, the 663 million users would probably convert to Google's search engine - if they have not already - and not use Bing, which Microsoft has invested heavily in. 2. By buying Skype, Google could force the 663 million users to only register with a Gmail account. Meaning, those with an MSN email account would be forced to convert. 3. Google would also integrate Google Voice with Skype. With the two utilities working together, they would make an incredibly powerful tool, and the users might start to rely on the two combined utilities. This would mean the users would want the utility on their phones which entices them to buy an Android phone and not a Windows phone. 4. With the buy, Google was looking ahead in the future. They could integrate Skype with Google TV. (Which I know was first a failure, but they are still banking on the idea. They'll come out with it again soon enough.) They would also integrate with Chrome OS, and, if the users come to rely on it heavily with the integration of Google Voice and Android, then it would entice them to us Chrome OS and not Windows. I think Google had much more use for Skype compared to Microsoft. So, Microsoft did not buying it to go after the consumers of Google and Apple; instead, they mainly bought it to keep their users.
- patrickk 16y agoWould Microsoft be able to afford SAP? According to Google Finance, they have a market cap of $77.04bn and Microsoft would have to pay a hefty premium over this. http://www.google.com/finance?q=NYSE:SAP http://www.google.com/finance?q=NYSE:SAP Also, what would the European Commission say about this? I don't think they would look favourably on this. They're not exactly fond of Microsoft. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Union_Microsoft_competition_case http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Union_Microsoft_compet...
- netcan 16y agoGood point. SAP is an order of magnitude bigger than Skype but the point about getting into this space if they're serious about getting into a different space is a good one. Netsuite, intuit & salesforce are trading @ $2.3b, $16.75b & $17.9b. They could conceivably buy all three with just this 'overseas cash' they supposedly need to spend and still have change. Thinking about MS's available cash in terms of companies they could buy really puts some perceptive on it - huge.
- patrickk 16y agoAccording to this article, Microsoft are sitting on a $50bn (!) pile of cash, $42bn of which is located ouside the US: http://blogs.forbes.com/ericsavitz/2011/05/10/microsoft-with-skype-a-good-use-for-the-giant-overseas-cash-pile/ http://blogs.forbes.com/ericsavitz/2011/05/10/microsoft-with... They could do nearly six Skype-sized deals, just using cash (without issuing bonds or using stock!) Incredible. They could probably buy SAP, but their cash pile would be gone, plus they would have to give up a significant amount of stock as well. Doubt Ballmer would be willing to risk this. I've heard elsewhere that Apple is sitting on a ~$35bn cash pile. One wonders when the US Government will declare some sort of 'tax holiday' or window during which these companies can repatriate all this cash.
- rkudeshi 16y agoApple has $43bn right now. http://www.investorplace.com/33461/apple-inc-nasdaq-aapl-cash-on-hand-43-billion/ http://www.investorplace.com/33461/apple-inc-nasdaq-aapl-cas...