8 ms·
Why Microsoft bought Skype
- bambax 16y ago> Microsoft bought Skype to keep Google from buying Skype. Except Google wouldn't buy Skype, according to a recent story: http://edition.cnn.com/2011/TECH/web/05/11/google.skype.wired/ http://edition.cnn.com/2011/TECH/web/05/11/google.skype.wire... ...?
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- siglesias 16y agoLevy interviewed Chan et al for his book. Not speculation.
- nikcub 16y agoye, this guy is wrong there and in about a dozen other places in this article. notice that you can read all of this and not acutally learn anything. welcome to 90s era tech punditry
- brown9-2 16y agoThat "recent story" details something that happened in 2009.
- javabuddy 16y agoThis is another attempt of Microsof to compete Apple and Google after tieing up with nokia for Windows Mobile phone.
- VB6_Foreverr 16y agoHe's expressing an opinion except his style is to state his opinion as fact without providing any evidence at all. It's not worth reading. Now if he had predicted this purchase, that would be different.
- jodrellblank 16y agoIt should be the default understanding that what someone says and writes is their opinion. Not having that as the default is how we ended up with the terrible popular style "in my opinion it could be argued that for some people it is mostly better if they XYZ, where possible (consult your doctor)". NB, when I say it's a terrible style, that's my opinion, not a universal truth or peer reviewed fact cited in a published journal. See?
- dgreensp 16y agoGeneralities aside, the criticism of the post stands. It's pretty vacuous, offering no new information or insight. Some writers online actually do have knowledge of Google's or Microsoft's position with respect to Skype, so when they say "Google/Microsoft wants X," they mean something more factual than "I can speculate that Google/Microsoft wants X." In particular, I've heard from more informed sources that Google passed on Skype and has its reasons, contradicting one of the post's few concrete assertions.
- macrael 16y agoI'm not so sure. I agree that weasel words can destroy a piece of writing, but a complete lack of them can come off badly too. The main effect of killing the qualifiers in your writing is increasing the confidence in the tone of the piece. Obviously, we all have different levels of confidence in our many different opinions, and if you stop using qualifiers all together, you lose the ability to distinguish between different points on the confidence continuum. If I write with the same confidence about two opinions I have, one I am vey sure of and one I am doubtful about, then I have failed to communicate well. Furthermore, writing in a way that expresses complete confidence in your opinions can change the tone of the conversation that it sparks. When you qualify your opinions, you signal that you are more willing to discuss that point. Speaking with complete surety can shut down a comment thread or turn it more antagonistic.
- jodrellblank 16y agoI like your point that the author can assign different levels of confidence to different parts of their writing, but the reader shouldn't automatically mistake the confident sections for facts and the unconfident sections for falsehoods, that seems to be conflating two signals into one. When you qualify your opinions, you signal that you are more willing to discuss that point. Speaking with complete surety can shut down a comment thread or turn it more antagonistic. OK, I can see that happening.
- ghshephard 16y agoSkype is the google of VoIP. I recently travelled to Brazil, and needed to make free calls to our US 1-800 number (vs R$18/Minute for the phone in the Blue Tree Marumbi in São Paulo). I had used google voice as a test a few months ago, and spent the better part of 5 minutes trying to figure out how to do it again - but failed - and I'm obviously highly technical. That suggests to me that 95% of your average community of people would not be able to use Google Voice, as it stands today, to make a phone call from Brazil to the United States. Skype, on the other hand, made it numbingly obvious and about 2 minutes after typing "skype.com" I was making free international calls to US 1-800 numbers. Purchasing Skype for Telecom is like purchasing Google for Search. You basically will be purchasing the market segment at this point. Lots of good reasons. And $3.00/Month for unlimited calling to the United States - Wowza! Lots of room to grow fees there. :-)
- sek 16y agoWhy did you fail with Google Voice? You pay and then you call a number, what is the difference?
- ghshephard 16y agoHave you called The US from Brazil? They had some geolocation filtering that either made it complex or impossible to make a voice call. Not at all like using it from the united states.
- sek 16y ago"First they ignore you, then they ridicule you, then they fight you, then you win." We didn't hear much ridicule from Ballmer in the last months.....
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- coffeedrinker 16y agoMicrosoft is weak on social network, and Skype could be a first step to fixing that. Skype offers a great foundation for social because the contacts it contains are often better ones than Facebook offers. By adding to components to what already has an entrenched base, Microsoft can leap forward without trying to "break into" the established market.
- officemonkey 16y ago>the contacts it contains are often better ones than Facebook offers. Really? That's not my experience. The contacts I have on Skype are the people I call from my computer, not all my friends. For instance, I don't call my coworkers from Skype, because all their numbers are on my cell phone. I don't call my close friends, because al their numbers are on my cell phone. In fact, the only contacts I have on Skype are the out-of-town people I video call (my parents, my sister, my niece) and the places I order food for delivery.
- fauigerzigerk 16y agoI don't believe that at all. Google doesn't need Skype. Microsoft bought Skype because they have large amounts of cash in Europe that they cannot repatriate without taking a huge tax hit. For some strange reason, Ballmer has that obsession with hyperactively pursuing the same consumers that Google and Apple have. That's why he didn't see anything else to buy in Europe (Actually there isn't a whole lot). But there is something: SAP. What Microsoft should do is take on Oracle and IBM instead of Apple and Google. They should make an offer to that large number of companies who want one thing more than everything else: Peace of mind based on an integrated stack. They are ready to pay up. Microsoft is the master of integration (some call it lock-in). Together with SAP, Microsoft has the most complete enterprise stack imaginable. All of a sudden even Windows Phone would have a place in this world as a BlackBerry successor.
- gfodor 16y agoI agree with this wholeheartedly -- Microsoft's fatal error was assuming they would continue to be the dominant force in both consumer and enterprise computing. They still own the enterprise. Why they aren't happy with this and focus on taking steps to ensure their dominance there for the next decade is beyond me.
- Raphael_Amiard 16y agoThey're still the ones who make the most used OS in the world. They're not the ones innovating and creating new markets and paradigms. But were they, ever ?
- erikpukinskis 16y agoI've waved the "What did Microsoft ever invent?" flag plenty in my life, so let me try and advocate for the devil: Microsoft basically invented the hardware-agnostic software platform. Before Microsoft, there were a variety of hardware platforms, each with their own libraries and languages... not unlike the situation today with phones. Developers had to choose what to target... not only Mac vs PC, but different video cards, different sound cards, different network stacks, etc. Microsoft took that fragmented market and unified it under a set of standard APIs for both hardware makers and software developers to target. I would consider that an innovation: the loose coupling that they enabled allowed much faster innovation in both hardware and third-party software. Interestingly, Netscape tried to play the same game on top of them (unifying Windows, Mac, and UNIX under one standardized API), and though Microsoft was able to destroying them, Webkit has succeeded where Netscape failed, and it is slowly making Microsoft irrelevant, just as Gates feared. Other than that, I don't think Microsoft invented much. But they did a good job copying, were ruthless with business executation, and so their one innovation ended up being a multi-trillion dollar innovation.
- cletus 16y agoAm I the only one who has had terrible experience with Skype? I live in New York but my family is from Australia so I use video-calling them to them all the time. I've tried using Skype but basically it's terrible. Poor audio, choppy frame rates and at some point it will start giving messages about "degraded performance" and we'll lose video. My setup is a 50Mbps cable line using wireless (N) from a Macbook Pro. The other end is ADSL of varying degrees (1.5 to 10Mbps) on wireless (N) from a Windows PC or laptop. We've basically given up on using Skype. What works flawlessly and with much higher quality? Facetime. Am I really the only one who has had terrible experience with Skype? My point with this is that Skype is not the dominant video medium it once was, especially not from a technical standpoint. What's more, video calling is becoming a commodity. I think we're near or above 100M Facetime-capable devices (iPhones, iPod Touches and Macs). Google Talk is available to however many millions of GMail users are out there. Skype isn't even a strong business (IMHO). Most consumers don't pay, which leaves the business type users who use multiway calling I guess. But where p2p video calling is becoming commoditized, who's to say multiway calling won't quickly follow suit? Basically, $8.5B for Skype is nuts. It seems the one who really needed to buy Skype was Facebook who have no video calling to speak of. One wonder if Skype was "the last piece of chocolate cake" syndrome, meaning you want something you otherwise wouldn't just because it's the last piece.
- barrkel 16y agoAustralia has small and expensive pipes to the rest of the world, and it shows up as caps and high prices. I'd be surprised if Australian telcos weren't working hard to degrade VoIP generally. For my own part, I use Skype for almost every outgoing phone call. I spend perhaps 5 GBP/month on threshold auto-credit. The biggest problems with it happen with concurrent upload activity, especially torrents.
- cletus 16y agoThis was true 10 years ago but a lot has changed and it's fairly damning evidence of just how much the US has stood still on Internet access in the last decade. Consider iiNet, Australia's third largest ISP: http://www.iinet.net.au/broadband/plans.html http://www.iinet.net.au/broadband/plans.html 200GB/month ADSL2+ for $50/month (+$30/month "phone tax"). In NY I have Time Warner Cable 50Mbps but it's basically capped at 250GB and I think I pay $80/month for it. But there are three important advantages Australia has in this regard: 1. The caps are known and advertised. In the US they are far more surreptitious; 2. You get what you pay for. If you pay for 200GB, you get 200GB. There is no hiding behind "fair use" or nebulous definitions of "unlimited". This also means that a low traffic user can pay as little as $30/month for their ADSL2+ connection. Nor do you get labelled a bandwidth hogged and get transferred to some incredibly oversubscribed network if you dare to download (common practice in the UK); and 3. If you wish, you can pay for and get 1TB+/month. Where I am, my only choices are TWC and crappy ADSL1 providers. If I wanted >250GB/month I couldn't get it. And all this is the current system. Australia is in the early stages of rolling out FTTH (fibre to the home) for ~95% of the population with structural separation between providing wholesale and retail services. So I wouldn't be too quick to crow about Internet advantages in the US over Australia (or anywhere really).
- jkaljundi 16y agoToday Ballmer made a full day visit to the Skype development HQ in Tallinn, Estonia. He also met with the President of Estonia: http://www.president.ee/en/media/press-releases/6096-president-ilves-met-with-ceo-of-microsoft/index.html http://www.president.ee/en/media/press-releases/6096-preside... It's interesting that while Microsoft-related Nokia in Finland is decreasing headcount, the southern neighbor Estonia's Skype is looking to potentially grow.
- dotcoma 16y agoSkype is now worth almost 50% of Estonia's GDP.
- soofaloofa 16y ago> Apple is not the next anything because the role it aspires to transcends anything imaginable by Microsoft, ever. Really? Both are publicly traded companies whose role is to make money for shareholders. I don't see how it's possible to transcend this.
- megaman821 16y agoHe sure has a lot of confidence on how successful Google would be with Skype but that doesn't really jive with reality. Google's only successful home grown products are Search and Gmail. Android and Youtube are the most successful acquisitions. Voice, Double-Click, and Analytics are doing ok, and then there are about three dozen failures. It is ok to fail but people shouldn't pretend everything Google touches turns to gold. Skype probably has just as much chance as succeeding with Microsoft as it does with Google.
- movingahead 16y agoI think Microsoft will leverage its relationship with facebook and use skype as their alternative to apple's facetime. Though I am worried about the future of Skype's linux client.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- mcantelon 16y agoTldr: Cringely believes Google is the next Microsoft. Microsoft is worried about its future and bought Skype so Google wouldn't buy Skype. Cringely believes Apple, however, is a magical unicorn that Ballmer cannot even comprehend.
- mcantelon 16y agoAccording to Cringely "Apple has no peer". I guess that depends on how you look at it. Apple's execution is unparalleled, but the broadness and disruptive nature of Google's strategy is hard to deny. The new Android Open Accessory Development Kit strategy, for example, is something I'd never expect to come from Cupertino or Redmond.
- slowpoison 16y agoApple did announce the APIs for iPhone accessories a year or so back with iOS 3.0. Scope and traction of Google's and Apple's specifications/APIs might vary.
- stcredzero 16y agoAnd the $8.5 billion price? That was effectively set by Google, not Microsoft. Ballmer would have paid anything for Skype. $8.5 billion is just the price at which Google feels it is better for them to build rather than buy. That's not really 8.5 bil for Skype. The cost to develop that would be a lot less. That's actually 8.5 bil for 140 million active users. That's about $60 a head. Not a bad deal for a big company in the telecom/mobile hardware space.
- rndstr 16y ago> In the end Apple will probably beat both Google and Microsoft, but that’s not a story for today. Alright, I stopped reading there. Unfortunately, it was too late.
- mitultiwari 16y agoSkype+Kinect+xbox can bring video calling to living room. Also, Skype could be a great addition to Windows mobile phones. I think these two might be the main reasons for Microsoft to buy Skype. Now depends on how well Microsoft does Skype integration with their products.
- itgoon 16y agoMS v. Google? v. Apple? After reading this, and the comments, and a little thinking about it, the more this makes sense. MS has a clear weakness in its lineup. Skype brings a bunch of existing technology and know-how, not to mention all those sweet, sweet users. Multiply by some factor of Ballmer being an idiot, and 8.5 is almost reasonable. Part of what convinced me - and I realize HN comments are anectdotal - was people's impressions of Skype and Google Voice (I've done no more than played with each). From the sounds of it, Skype's biggest issue is its UI. MS has plenty of experience (and some success ;) with good UIs and backend work. Other than that, it satisfies its basic function well: it makes the calls. It sounds like Google Voice, at least internationally, isn't as straightforward. So, they get the users, and a jump on the tech. Okay, decent, but not great, business decision. Will they turn it into something successful? Ehhhh, I have my doubts. Who knows? Ballmer isn't actually an idiot; maybe he's learned something by now. *Edit - spelling
- VladRussian 16y agostrangely, to me Skype deal looks like Storagetek: 1.obsoleting technology (Skype's power is Internet (typically PC, not mobile device) to "real phones" only enabled endpoints - this power is diminishing with communication networks growing today in any other segment except the segment of "real phones"-only enabled endpoints) 2.and commoditization of the rest of their technology - i.e. speech and video over Internet, and their technology not even being better 3.and no noticeable presence in disproportionally growing and more numerous segment of devices - mobile The Skype was just becoming a niche player (in its old niche) and one among many in the rest of the telecom world.
- lurker20 16y agoHere is what Microsoft should do with Skype and it's 140Million-member social network: Beat Facebook. Turn Skype into Diaspora. (Specifically, take Skype's persistent chatrooms into the next dimension) Integrate Skype with Windows Photo Album, Movie Maker, Spaces, blah blah. Mayke Skype a local application for managing your personal content -- photos, videos, thoughts, whatever. Leverage Skype's encrypted P2P infrastructure to make truly privacy-protected social networking. Automatically send status updates and comments and stuff to a user's friends over the Skype network. Make social network truly social, and not dependent on a central server. Monetizations: * ads in the the client software * for-pay special privacy settings for business/paranoid: An Enterprise version that runs inside a private (corporate) network, with centralized IT authority. * For-pay broadcast-type features for self-promoters. * For-pay "professional" and other custom front-end for more specifically-structure communities than Facebook's free for all pseudo-"Friend" relationship. Let users import/export their data between Skype and other network and blog systems. Skype could displace Facebook, making social networking better for everyone, and rain money on MS.
- joe_the_user 16y agoWow, that's a great idea for a company that users trust. If only a company like that had bought Skype...
- stcredzero 16y agoWow, that's a great idea for a company that users trust. If only a company like that had bought Skype... The thing is, Microsoft only has to get people to trust them as much or more than Google, Facebook, Sony,...
- sshah 16y agothere are talks about skype integrating with television sets. Think its LG and more to come. Xbox sits next to that tv and is one of the successful products in it's stack. maybe msft wants to be part of your living room?
- zmmmmm 16y agoI can't agree with this. The basis of it all doesn't make sense: > Were Google to buy Skype ... they’d build a brilliant Skype client right into the DNA of Android Google has had loads of opportunity to build VOIP functions into Android and has dragged their feet all the way. They already have a a voice chat service and it has no presence in Android (edit: yes, just now they released video chat, but only for a tiny percentage of phones). The latest versions have some SIP functions but it's clearly been kept obtuse enough to prevent any mass consumer take up. Google is heavily constrained by needing not to offend the carriers. The idea that they would en masse integrate something that would destroy their business models is delusional.
- Facens 16y agoThe reason behind this acquisition is signaling to the market, and to Microsof's competitors, that MS is still strong and wants to play as a leader in the market. This acquisition is not justified by business reasons, it's a matter of game theory ;)
- Facens 16y agoThe reason behind this acquisition is signaling to the market, and to Microsof's competitors, that MS is still strong and wants to play as a leader in the market. This acquisition is not justified by business reasons, it's a matter of game theory ;)