11 ms·
Boeing 'inappropriately coached' pilots in 737 MAX testing: U.S. Senate report
- markdown 6y agoUSA really needs to do something about its regulatory capture problems. At this point the FAA has zero credibility.
- GoOnThenDoTell 6y agoIt still has plenty of credibility, just less than before
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- markdown 6y agoFair enough. It has no credibility when it comes to certifying aircraft airworthiness for Boeing.
- joe_the_user 6y agoWell, the "congressional capture" problem makes that hard. But even more, Boeing actually "should" want decent regulation because it gives them long term credibility. The problem others here have point out is that Boeing also wound-up "captured" by a finance/management regime that for twenty years has been gutting the company's long term prospects for short term profits - the ridiculous amalgam that is the 737 Max demonstrates this (it has paper manuals still, guess why?).
- topspin 6y agoThis case has Congress criticizing both Boeing and the FAA and of the two the FAA comes back with the crappiest response, trying to throw shade on the report. Congress is certainly not a collection of innocent choir boys, but here, given these responses, the FAA is the worst of the bad guys. Sorry if that fact frustrates, but that's how it is.
- joe_the_user 6y agoThat particular detail doesn't really effect my overall statement. Congress may at times contradict regulators. My point would be that congress isn't going to change the regulatory capture situation because congress itself is part of the "revolving door" of regulators, corporate bureaucrats and congressional staff. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolving_door_(politics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolving_door_(politics)
- xiphias2 6y agoOpenly criticizing may just mean that they want a lot of corrupt money in return. What happened with the Hungarian and Polish veto was terrifying for me: the governing prime ministers got away with all the money stealing despite the huge criticism. The only rational explanation is that they will continue chanelling lots of money back to Germany through car companies.
- medecau 6y ago> [...] at this point this airframe is probably the most heavily scrutinized to ever exist can we drop this take now?
- cjbprime 6y agoThe funny thing is that this (bad) take is correct as written -- it is heavily scrutinized. It's incorrect in the unsaid implication, that extreme scrutiny implies extreme safety.
- randycupertino 6y agoIt reminds me of Lance Armstrong's common refrain before he was outed as a drug cheat, "I am the most tested athlete in professional sports and I have never been found guilty of taking performance enhancing drugs!" All while he was a heavy drug user.
- allie1 6y agoIf one were to down again, it would immediately be assumed FAA is to blame for not catching yet another issue so them reapproving is putting their reputation on the line. Also boeing is on thin ice. They would not weather another incident like this. So in this case, I think it does mean extreme safety.
- pacificmint 6y ago> They would not weather another incident like this. One would think so, if normal rules applied. But it is hard to see how the US would allow Boeing to not weather this, or any other event. For defense reasons alone it seems unlikely they would ever allow Boeing to fail.
- bdavis__ 6y agoBoeing defense could be broken off and sold to others, in pieces, without impacting the defense of the US. There are not any "pure" military air vehicles being made by Boeing right now (T-X trainer). F15 and F18 used to be owned by someone else, they could be again.
- cageface 6y agoThe US is turning into on object lesson on what happens when you make wealth a religion.
- systemvoltage 6y agoI am glad the problems are surfacing and cracks are showing up so we can fix them. In some nations it is impossible to even criticize the government.
- cageface 6y agoI don’t think we’re beyond repair yet but it feels much more like gaping fissures than surfacing cracks. Our infrastructure, education and healthcare is a disaster.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThe cracks are surfacing from a very, very deep root. The basis on which American society is built is dearly lacking. I cannot understand how America went through something like the Civil War without making any radical changes. Maybe the language of religion is appropriate, after all.
- Ekaros 6y agoWasn't civil war also really about money? Either use of labour or control of land?
- thereare5lights 6y ago> without making any radical changes. You seem to have forgotten Amendments 13,14,15.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThat isn't radical change. That's outlawing slavery. The system that led to slavery being allowed wasn't changed. I'd love for you to make a list of countries that went through such a civil war yet kept the same constitutio.
- ringshall 6y agoI find this really disgraceful. A flaw in procedure that led to the initial catastrophes is at least understandable in terms of insidious errors in complex systems. A continuation after the initial error is hard to explain other than by deliberate personal moral failure.
- systemvoltage 6y agoI feel bad for the engineers and scientists that work at Boeing. I've worked with some of the brightest people in the aviation industry and I am sure they're internally facepalming at the actions of a few bad individuals.
- jjoonathan 6y ago...inside a system that very intentionally put N people in competition to cheat, thereby ensuring that cheating would happen, and in a manner that could plausibly be blamed on the person who happened to do the cheating rather than the system that knowingly ensured that the cheating would happen.
- schoolornot 6y agoHave any Boeing engineers publicly left due to this? I remember tons of people leaving well known tech firms just for having Homeland Security / ICE as customers. I couldn't continue to work for a company that exhibited such deprave indifference to human safety.
- RachelF 6y agoBoeing has been run by accountants from McDonald Douglas for the last 15 years, not engineers like it used to be. Perhaps that has some bearing on the problem?
- newacct583 6y ago> A continuation after the initial error is hard to explain other than by deliberate personal moral failure. No, just denial: Look, it's a safe plane. We know it's a safe plane. Sure, it's not exactly like the earlier model, but those rules are needlessly strict. This plane is better, we know it's better. And pilots aren't idiots. They'll figure it out. As we all learned, there's no single feature you can point to in the MAX that was a bad engineering decision in isolation. So if you don't want to see bad engineering, you don't have to.
- ohiovr 6y agoJust press AZ-5 in emergencies.
- LordDragonfang 6y agoIt's worth noting that the fact that this is an international incident speaks to how safe flying is in general. Two fatal crashes in the hundreds of thousands of flights for Boeing 737 Max alone is still a ridiculously small number for something as potentially dangerous as powered flight.
- deepspace 6y agoThe irony is that the level of safety we enjoy today is the result of processes and procedures written in the blood of thousands of accident victims from more cavalier times. Boeing's actions go against everything the aviation industry has learned about safety, which why their misconduct is so egregious.
- caconym_ 6y agoHumans are surprisingly bad at understanding that some solutions have to be maintained to keep the problem(s) they addressed from coming back. I get it in the case of organizational rot but sometimes it can be staring people in the face and they still don't get it, e.g. in the case of vaccines—who needs them, when nobody gets those diseases anymore?
- pdonis 6y ago> vaccines--who needs them, when nobody gets those diseases anymore? If a disease becomes rare enough that the probability of getting it if you're not vaccinated, is less than the probability of harmful side effects from the vaccine, then it is rational for an individual not to get vaccinated. The proper response to this at a societal level is to further reduce the risk of harmful side effects from vaccines (for example, by using refrigeration more aggressively as an alternative to preservatives which have a small, but nonzero, risk of harm), not to brand people who don't want to get vaccinated against rare diseases as crackpots. This is actually an illustration of the more general problem we have as a society: we have forgotten that there are objective criteria we can use to evaluate things, and that as conditions change, we need to re-evaluate based on those criteria instead of just assuming that things that worked in the past will continue to work. In the case of the 737 MAX, Boeing failed to realize that relaxing engineering standards was a bad idea because the company had been taken over by a different corporate culture, and a regulatory regime that had grown to trust airframe manufacturers based on past information that showed they were worthy of that trust failed to see the change in incentives that made them less worthy of trust than before.
- btmorex 6y agoI encourage everyone to never, ever fly a 737 MAX under any circumstances. Boeing has not been sufficiently punished (as in their future behavior will change). If people refuse to fly the 737 MAX, hopefully they go bankrupt and the existing management can be replaced.
- Aloha 6y agoWhy would I refuse to fly in a perfectly safe airplane? I'm not punishing Boeing, I'm punishing Southwest and American Airlines at that point - and probably myself too, as I live immensely close to DFW (I just heard an airplane land).
- eganist 6y agoSouthwest and AA would be incentivized to pursue recourse if it turns out their faith was placed in a product as a result of deception or fraud... but this is even more true if consumers punish the airlines for falling victim to such deception in the first place.
- caconym_ 6y agoThis "perfectly safe airplane" has been grounded for almost two years after two crashes killed 346 people. The root cause of these crashes is a mind-bogglingly irresponsible bit of design that can be linked directly to decision makers at Boeing deciding to prioritize corporate profits over human lives. I don't have a hard time believing that we won't see any more MCAS-related trim runaway accidents after the scrutiny of the past two years, but what evidence do we have that the dysfunctional leadership behind this particular flaw is the exception rather than the rule? When the Max was flying, it was still extremely unlikely that you'd die on one, but dying is a pretty big deal (to me, at least). For the foreseeable future, I'll be choosing alternatives to Boeing when they're available.
- throwaway201103 6y agoProblems are easy to see in retrospect. You could have made similar arguments after every air crash that was caused by a design flaw. These problems are found, fixed, lessons learned, new rules enacted, and we move on.
- deepspace 6y ago> Boeing officials encouraged test pilots to “remember, get right on that pickle switch” That just sounds like such a heartless, psychopathic thing to do. How could they not feel guilty, knowing that their actions could potentially lead to hundreds of people losing their lives?
- cherylskylar 6y agoHorrible how we can place success above morals: regard for safety is not as properly promoted as competition.
- Diesel555 6y agoI'm convinced that people would generally not place success above morals when isolated. But a corporation isn't a person and without regulation and oversight it will do this every time. Some will transition faster than others. Some will find success in morals (Apple's privacy policy) - but in the end it's a means to success over just doing the right thing.
- bootlooped 6y ago> Boeing officials encouraged test pilots to “remember, get right on that pickle switch” What does the switch do? I have scanned a few articles about this by now, and none of them describe it's purpose or function. Does it turn off MCAS?
- deepspace 6y agoNo, it disables the autopilot, but I believe that indirectly disables MCAS
- throwaway201103 6y agoNo MCAS is not active with autopilot, because it's not needed. MCAS is there in manual flight to give the human pilot a specific "feel" to the control column forces at high angles of attack. Autopilot doesn't need that.
- dTal 6y agoOne wonders in that case why they didn't put the actuator on the control column, rather than the horizontal stabilizer.
- throwaway201103 6y agoThe pickle switch is the thumb switch on the control yoke that controls the stabilizer pitch trim. Using it will pause, but not deactivate MCAS.
- WalterBright 6y agoThe pickle switch overrides the MCAS command, meaning it can be used to restore normal trim. Then, the trim system can be turned off via the console cutoff switches.
- salawat 6y agoTechnically it (used to) reset the timer until MCAS activation to 5 seconds after it is released. So you'd have to repeatedly engage to get your stabilizer to where you want it and cut the power. They removed the ability for the electric switches to actuate while the FC was isolated from the stabilizer motor controls as part of the MAX design. With NG's you could flip one cutout switch which would isolate the computer, while leaving on the yoke switches. In MAX, flipping either one apparently cuts out both the computer and the switches.
- zed88 6y agoThis is what happens when you patch-up airframe stability issues with code. We have gone to the point of no return to save one last buck and only the MBA types are to blame for this.
- alkonaut 6y agoWhat’s the status of the European review?
- TinkersW 6y agoWas this coaching after the crashes, during the new recertification?