13 ms·
This statistic from the article is mind-boggling: > Ultra-processed products now account for nearly half of the average dietary intake of some high income coun
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
This statistic from the article is mind-boggling:
> Ultra-processed products now account for nearly half of the average dietary intake of some high income countries, with consumption rising rapidly in most other countries.
Note that they aren't just referring to processed foods. They classify ultra-processed foods as a step beyond what we typically think of as processed foods:
> Ultra-processed foods and beverages can be defined as products with additives and industrially processed ingredients that have been technologically broken down and modified. They are not merely processed foods with high levels of sugar, salt, and fat but also contain ingredients and additives not commonly used in home kitchens and artisanal restaurants
I wish we put more emphasis on educating young people about basic cooking and nutrition. There's a common misconception that people reach for ultra-processed foods because they're cheaper, but in my experience most people prefer these foods because they think it's more convenient.
For many people, the idea of cooking a meal has been elevated to a special occasion event, as a treat or a date night. This is partially due to the fact that boring, everyday meal recipes just aren't as flashy as a 15-ingredient, hour long recipe that results in a stunning picture for someone's blog or instagram. Everyone should learn how to cook some boring, staple meals using basic ingredients from the store. It's amazing how many people don't know how easy and cheap it can be to prepare simple crock pot or stir-fry meals that are healthy and delicious.
- orev 6y agoFood companies have led very good marketing campaigns for many years telling people that “cooking is SO difficult and SUCH A PAIN. Just buy our prepackaged food which is so much easier.” Unfortunately when so many people buy into it, it impacts those who don’t. Lately I’ve noticed that basic bags of frozen vegetables are being replaced with “ready to steam” bags that contain half as much quantity for the same price.
- kzrdude 6y agoIt's a steady productization, which gets a higher price
- bonoboTP 6y agoMay God save us from everyday staple cooking becoming trendy on Instagram with influencers because they will make bags of broccoli become some fancy overpriced fad product with some celebrity photos on the packaging.
- dragontamer 6y agoIf half of our food is ultraprocessed, then that's a problem with the definition of ultraprocessed. Breakfast cereal is "ultraprocessed" by the definition of the article. But Grain Berry cereal is going to be grossly different from a nutritional perspective than Frosted Flakes. For both to be lumped into the same category of "ultraprocessed" is a bit ridiculous. ----------- Its not like "processing" makes something more or less poisonous. 100% all natural fully organic death cap mushrooms will kill you. Now high-fat, high-sugar, high-salt, high-preservative stuff is probably bad. Those things have clear science and nutrition issues associated with them. But the nutrition in "processed" canned corn (picked and canned at peak ripeness) is often found to be superior to "fresh" ears of corn (which loses nutrition the longer it sits in the food aisle). If you cook all-natural brown rice with fresh pork-belly all day every day, and you'll have a heart attack from all that fat you're eating. It doesn't matter if that pork-belly is ultraprocessed bacon or freshly cut from a squealing pig in your backyard: pork-belly contains a ton of fat and is just innately unhealthy.
- watwut 6y ago> If half of our food is ultraprocessed, then that's a problem with the definition of ultraprocessed. Why? Just because we consume a lot of it does not mean it is not "ultraprocessed". We should be afraid of a name just because a lot of modern food falls into the definition.
- dragontamer 6y ago* Are there bad foods that are ultraprocessed? (Ex: Frosted Flakes) * Are there good foods that are ultraprocessed? (Ex: Grain Berry) * Are there good foods that are unprocessed? (Ex: Brown Rice) * Are the bad foods that are unprocessed? (Ex: Pork Belly) If "ultraprocessed" fails to distinguish good from bad, then the word itself is worthless.
- icandoit 6y agoWhat if the processed-food percent of a persons diet predicts their health outcomes as well as questions like "do you exercise regularly?". Aren't we more interested in health outcomes associated with food rather than moralistic rules or labels? The leap from "this general rule has some exceptions" to "this is worthless" is unwarranted. You still personally expect people that eat less processed foods to be slimmer on average than those that eat more, right?
- detaro 6y ago> but also contain ingredients and additives not commonly used in home kitchens and artisanal restaurants That is incredibly broad though? Not sure what "processed foods" would be then.
- jasode 6y ago>, but in my experience most people prefer these foods because they think it's more convenient. [...] Everyone should learn how to cook some boring, staple meals using basic ingredients from the store. It's amazing how many people don't know how easy and cheap it can be to prepare simple crock pot or stir-fry meals that are healthy and delicious. I'm a strict health food eater but I have to be realistic and concede that preparing healthy meals is more work. For example, I have a green smoothie drink made from raw vegetables every day for breakfast for more than 10 years. I'm pretty efficient at it but it still takes more work (and time) than just putting an unhealthy Pop Tart in the toaster. And my dinners of lentil soup or tofu are more prep work than tossing a frozen pizza into the oven. I have a diabetic friend who often "cheats" with junk food (McDonald's burger) because cooking supposedly "simple" healthy meals is still too much of a hassle even for him. Yes, cooking healthy may be "easy" but it's still more work than junk food. Convenience junk foods are just... more convenient.
- jeromenerf 6y agoI totally agree. As I was until recently working in a food startup, producing "ready to cook" products (organic fair trade delicious mixes of grain, dried vegetables and spices), I can testify of a strong society injonction towards healthier food AND at the same time a rejection of this pressure.
- jriot 6y agoCooking in general is time consuming. You and I appear to eat vastly differently, yet we both make our own food from scratch. For breakfast I eat 10oz whole milk, 2 - 3 strips of bacon, 2 - 3 eggs, and grits with butter (at time I'll have potatoes or toast depending). Our other other meals will include roasted vegetables, potatoes and meat. Preparing each meal everyday is time consuming but I view as the best investment in my family's life. We rarely get sick, if so its a day cold when the weather changes. We sleep a solid 8 hours a day, and only go to the for our yearly health check-ups. We also highly naturally so this factors into it. Now I do live in Louisiana and Mardi Gras is right around the corner which means King Cake. Is this healthy for me? No, not at all. But it's once a year and we buy them from the local bakeries, where each bakery has their own recipe. Does this it make anymore healthy? Probably not, but they are good.
- megameter 6y agoA very common pandemic meal in our household has been "taco night" - fry some ground beef with onions, throw some tortillas and cheese in the microwave, simmer a can of pinto beans, then add salsa, cream, avocado, tomatoes, etc. It tastes good, it's simple and can scale up and down to the effort, energy and tools available.
- pkaye 6y agoSo would a beyond meat be ultra processed while ground meat is not?
- another_sock 6y agoYes because one is meat and the other is not meat.
- an_opabinia 6y agoUltraprocessed is a counter marketing term from the meat and dairy lobby. It is authored in opposition to things like Impossible Burger and Beyond Meat. Nobody uses this term organically, look in Google Trends yourself. It is an obvious and conspicuous marker of a campaign, exactly equivalent to something like “drinkability,” an Anheuser Busch marketing term. This is a market that traditionally derives most of its profits from a close relationship with the government, for subsidies (the #1 source of profit for farms, maybe for the whole agricultural sector) and health guidelines (the cheapest, and therefore highest RoI advertising). Beyond Meat enjoys none of these advantages and its equities wildly outperformed e.g. Tyson. I am not saying that marketing does not play a role in health outcomes. Just that the nutrition discourse is overwhelmingly marketing budget driven, that actual nutritionists struggle against consumers immensely, and that once you’ve heard one ad campaign you easily become jaded of all of them. Well meaning people get coopted by all of this.
- YeGoblynQueenne 6y ago>> Ultraprocessed is a counter marketing term from the meat and dairy lobby. This sentence risks framing industrially manufactured food products as equally nutritious to meat and dairy (and fruit and vegetables, beans and pulses, eggs and fish, etc. etc.).
- the-pigeon 6y agoThe point though is that this article decrying the influence on science by industry is itself influenced by industry and shows this by not using neutral terminology.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoIt's a true framing! Off the top of my head, cheese, yogurt, tofu, and flour are nutritious and industrially manufactured through chemical processes. And I don't mean this in some tricky "everything is chemicals" way - you can look up pictures of the Chobani factory online, and it's pretty indistinguishable at a glance from any other snack food production line.
- 6y ago
- bergstromm466 6y ago> For many people, the idea of cooking a meal has been elevated to a special occasion event, as a treat or a date night. This is partially due to the fact that boring, everyday meal recipes just aren't as flashy as a 15-ingredient, hour long recipe that results in a stunning picture for someone's blog or instagram. I think the root is that everyone's rents and other costs are way higher. Many folks are barely getting by. I don't think it's Instagram or vanity - I think that might reveal your personal privilege and position in society. That isn't meant in a demeaning or derogatory way, it's just that it surprises me how today people from different classes do not often 'meet' each other anymore, in their day to day lives. Propably due to rising inequity. I think a lot of working class people buy quick meals because they have so little time. > Everyone should learn how to cook some boring, staple meals using basic ingredients from the store. 100% agree. Shame we're still letting corporations brainwash the general population, not to mention kids.
- bonoboTP 6y agoBarely getting by in America means being rich for much of the world including many European countries. How is it that the economics works out so differently in, say, Eastern Europe where poor people's best choice is to buy staples in bulk and cook and can't afford packaged convenience food and eating out? It's because American people's time is priced much higher and they earn much more overall.
- Aerroon 6y agoWhen I was a kid, eating at McDonald's was considered to be like going to a restaurant. A moderately fancy one at that. The limiting factor was cost. It's not the case anymore. While McDonald's is still certainly more expensive than food people regularly eat, but the gap seems to be closing. People just aren't satisfied with eating basically potatoes and sometimes some meat. They make fancier meals, but this increases cost. At some point the cost isn't all that different from what fast food charges.
- bonoboTP 6y agoSeems like people are having more disposable income and higher standards for quality of experiences. That hardly matches the narrative that this is caused by people barely getting by and being poor.
- ApolloFortyNine 6y agoThe popularity of Chipotle really says a lot to me. The steak bowls are a little more cost effective, but for the price of one chicken bowl, you seriously could make at least 4 chicken bowls if you simply went to the grocery store instead of Chipotle. The time to cook and prepare is quite similar to Chipotle as well, especially if you go to Chipotle instead of delivery. Rice, beans, salsa, lettuce, cheese, chicken. Everything that goes into a burrito/bowl is quite cheap. You could prepare everything in half an hour and then make bowls at the same speed Chipotle does just pulling containers out of the fridge.
- nickff 6y agoI can walk into Chipotle, order a burrito, and be out in less than 5 minutes with a delicious meal and no clean-up (maybe 10 if there's a lineup). It takes me much longer to cook the chicken and rice, even if the 'prep' is done, and I still have to clean up! I have what I'd consider a healthy diet, and I've been avoiding restaurant and prepared meals throughout the pandemic, but cooking everything has been a huge time-sink.
- tartoran 6y agoCook food for a couple of days and time per meal will decrease. It takes a bit of getting used to it but once you find the gist of it it really works out
- nickff 6y agoAs mentioned above, I cook every meal I eat these days (averaging take-out once every 6-8 weeks). Chipotle is still much faster. Cooking chicken takes a minimum of ten minutes, rice is longer, even assuming no prep time and no clean-up.
- ApolloFortyNine 6y agoThe thing is, you don't have to stare at the rice as it's cooking. Unless you live on top of Chipotle it's very likely the time actually invested cooking will be less than traveling to Chipotle and coming home again. And beyond that, your simply overpaying for a meal that can be made at home. It's a waste of money, you can save it and waste it on something else you couldn't just make at home.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 6y ago>I wish we put more emphasis on educating young people about basic cooking and nutrition. More difficult than it sounds. Most people want to eat healthier but when they research it they'll get fad diets and pseudoscience. Just look at Keto, paleo, whole 30, etc.
- majormajor 6y ago> More difficult than it sounds. Most people want to eat healthier but when they research it they'll get fad diets and pseudoscience. Just look at Keto, paleo, whole 30, etc. Any of those are a big improvement over Five Guys and In N Out and other takeaway or fast food...
- bonoboTP 6y agoAsk your parents or grandparents. Or just combine some of: meat, fish, rice, potatoes, veggies and legumes. How hard can it be? Maybe it will taste bland. Get over it.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 6y agoI basically cook myself fish or chicken every day but that's not my point. My point is that it's very hard for the average american to receive good dietary information.
- bonoboTP 6y agoHow is it specific to diet? It seems very hard for them to get good history, climate, science etc info. There's a ton of lobbying and targeted marketing and political propaganda to keep the average person non-thinking. To all the above, including diet, it looks simple (just read a book, just Google this and this), but if you don't know what to trust because you're confused so much at the very foundation and you've been told so much distorted and selective truths and straight up lies, what can you do? People believe homeopathy, pyramid schemes, that it's patriotic to go invade the middle east again, that universal health care is communism and free tuition equals gulag, that workers rights are anti business and so anti American, that the Bible is literally true, that a televangelist deserves your money, that drugs are bad mkay, that sex ed is evil etc etc. The food you are fed is just one small way you are exploited.