5 ms·
It's a great book for emphasizing the importance of sleep. The author's desired outcome is to get people interested in healthy sleep habits, and he hits a home
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
It's a great book for emphasizing the importance of sleep. The author's desired outcome is to get people interested in healthy sleep habits, and he hits a home run in that regard.
However, take some of the science positions in the book with a grain of salt. The author is notorious for being directionally correct in his opinions, but exaggerating a lot of the science for dramatic effect. This doesn't matter at all if you're reading the book to convince yourself to build better sleep habits, of course.
However, it does seem to leave some people with exaggerated worries or anxiety about dying early or developing serious disease conditions if they've ever gone through periods of life with short sleep (college, raising kids, video game addiction) or if they're in a life situation that limits their sleep. In that regard, it's worth noting that the author is really stretching some of the studies and cherry-picking results to support his argument. Getting 6 hours per sleep at night will not be the death of you, despite what the book suggests.
It's also commonly known that people get less sleep than they think they do. Someone might tell you they get 8 hours of sleep each night because they try to sleep from 11PM to 7AM, but in reality they stretch their bed time to midnight more often than not and then read their phone in bed for 15-30 minutes. Sleep advocates try to compensate by exaggerating target sleep times for adults to 8 hours. In reality, 7-ish hours of sleep appears to be just fine for most adults, with some requiring less and others requiring more. That said, most people will have to target 8 hours of dedicated bed time to really get those 7 hours of sleep in practice, hence the common exaggerations.
- rubicon33 6y agoI have a weird relationship with sleep. If I sleep LESS (5, 6 hours) I feel better. More energy, lighter on my feet, less depressed. That lack of sleep always catches up with me though, and after 4-5 days of that I'll have a day where I just feel EXHAUSTED and end up sleeping like 10 hours that night.
- Guest42 6y agoFor me it seems like the earlier I start the less is required.
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago> If I sleep LESS (5, 6 hours) I feel better. More energy, lighter on my feet, less depressed. This is a well-known phenomenon, believe it or not. Acute sleep deprivation has a strong anti-depressant effect in people suffering from depression. It can even trigger hypomanic or manic episodes in people who have bipolar disorder. Scientific American wrote a nice article about it several years ago: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-sleep-deprivation-eases-depression/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-sleep-depriva... As you noticed, the effect is completely unsustainable. Chronic sleep deprivation will worsen depression, not improve it. There has been some research into using acute sleep deprivation to kick-start treatment with traditional antidepressant medication. Results are mixed, but it can help some patients cope until the antidepressants start working. There is also some [very] weak evidence that advancing your sleep phase (going to bed earlier, waking up earlier) can stabilize the acute antidepressant effects for a couple of days: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12799743/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12799743/ Long term, treating the underlying depression with traditional methods (CBT, bright light therapy, exercise, antidepressant medications) is the only sustainable solution for most people.
- James_Henry 6y agoIn studies on wake therapy I've seen, there is a percentage that have long-lasting positive improvement from just one night of sleep deprivation.
- porknubbins 6y agoI started to notice the lack of sleep mood boost once it was pointed out. Occasionally I’ll wake up 3 hours earlier than normal for no apparent reason and generally feel energetic and productive.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoLong lasting improvement compared to a control group? Depression studies are basically useless without a control group. In any given depression cohort, a number of patients will spontaneously improve even if they receive placebo or no treatment at all. For many (lucky) people, depressive episodes simply resolve after some time, so capturing them in studies without control groups can produce misleading results.
- tartoran 6y agoTo me that mark is 6 hours. The more I sleep past that the more lethargic I become. Likewise if I sleep between 5 and 6 hours I’m fine but will catch up with me
- mbesto 6y ago> and end up sleeping like 10 hours that night Paraphrased from the book - basically once you get passed the number of REM cycles needed all of the sleep after that is worthless and ends up just making you groggy. In other words the idea of "catching up on sleep" is BS.
- Darkphibre 6y agoI do find it curious that the body seems to need to sleep longer after long bouts of insomnia (or a week of 18hr work days). I think the hypothesis "You need an extra hour of sleep for every hour missed" is disproven, but the body clearly needs a single dose of extra recovery time after exhaustion.
- James_Henry 6y agoDoes the book give sources for this? And do those sources actually support this claim? It doesn't sound completely correct.
- mbesto 6y agoFor this specific notion - I can't remember honestly. But most of the book is backed up by sources / studies. As I noted in this thread - I don't think 100% of what author communicates in the book is factual or conclusive, but he does a great job of collecting multiple perspectives and studies to combine it into one thought provoking read. Like any book that has an agenda/angle, a healthy dose of skepticism is always required.
- copperx 6y agoMy biggest criticism of the book is that it didn't address oversleep. Where did you find that bit of info?
- James_Henry 6y agoWake therapy is a well known treatment for depression, but I have a theory that for some people this sort of thing is a sign of sleep apnea. The reason being sleep breathing is more likely to be disturbed during REM which is more predominant in the later hours of sleep. So skipping those last 1 or 2 REM cycles could be skipping out on, for sleep apneacs, the most stressful parts of the sleep.
- michaelcampbell 6y agoIf I may ask, how old are you? As I age I find that I can handle a little less sleep, but my ability to handle swings in amounts of sleep is way less; even if I can get by with :30 less per night than 5 years ago, 1:00 less on one night affects me WAY more than it did 5 years ago. I'm in my 50's, FWIW.
- mbesto 6y ago> However, take some of the science positions in the book with a grain of salt. The author is notorious for being directionally correct in his opinions, I've read it and I agree. Although he does admit in the beginning that there basically is not much conclusive facts about sleep, hence his motivation for writing the book. It's implied that what he is saying is fact, and its a lot more correlation than I think panacea. > It's also commonly known that people get less sleep than they think they do. A few things IIRC from the book: - The specific number is irrelevant as long as its "around 7~9" - If you're lying down / resting this still "counts" (its not as impactful, but still beneficial) If people don't want to read the book, the JRE podcast is actually pretty good at summarizing whats in the book: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pwaWilO_Pig https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pwaWilO_Pig Good high level points about what to do to get to sleep (5 things): https://youtu.be/pwaWilO_Pig?t=3011 https://youtu.be/pwaWilO_Pig?t=3011
- mike_d 6y ago> the JRE podcast is actually pretty good at summarizing whats in the book Anyone who expects to learn something from a Joe Rogan podcast should understand that it is for the most part, a podcast where people go to have their ideas go unchallenged: https://www.vice.com/en/article/9kv9qd/the-joe-rogan-experience-is-a-safe-space-to-launder-bad-ideas https://www.vice.com/en/article/9kv9qd/the-joe-rogan-experie...
- mbesto 6y agoSo let me get this straight. The entire basis for "we should understand that ideas go unchallenged" is because a Vice article told you that? An article that doesn't do anything other than cite a few instances where JR lets interviewees go unchallenged? Honestly, that article is terrible. I would expect something more conclusive to say something like "we fact checked 100 of JRE's guests and found 47 of them to be factually incorrect in what they were saying" I mean I generally agree that he doesn't necessarily challenge his interviewees but to say you don't learn something from JRE is kind of off IMO. Anyway, that's besides the point because I've both read the book and watched the podcast. Additionally I've checked some of the sources and they're consistent with what the author has communicated. In a world of sound bites, I'm simply offering that this soundbite is better than single sentence headliners but not as good as reading a whole book or even further, reading a book and every source.
- rriepe 6y agoI read it less as exaggeration and more as... art? The book is really well-written. It emphasizes things with a rhetorical tone that I thought was completely appropriate given how much our culture abuses sleep. He also specifically and thoroughly goes over the sleep window thing, unless I'm remembering another book.