5 ms·
For running Silk Road perhaps, but I never fully understood the whole "hired hits" part of this case. Did Ulbrecht actually think he was hiring hitmen to commit
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
For running Silk Road perhaps, but I never fully understood the whole "hired hits" part of this case. Did Ulbrecht actually think he was hiring hitmen to commit murder? Was it just bravado? Because I can't understand supporting Ulbrecht's clemency if he really thought he was hiring assassins to kill 5 people.
Edit: To be clear, because I've already got what feel like knee jerk downvotes, I honestly don't understand the hitman charges in the case and would like if someone has any more info. I mean, the chat logs looked pretty damning, but then all of those charges seem to have been thrown out, so I'd like to understand the reason for that. Were the chat logs forged in some way? Was it a technicality? Did the Feds just not care because they had enough in the drug charges?
- tptacek 6y agoThe evidence presented suggests that he did believe that; moreover, despite repeated claims to the contrary on message boards, his murder-for-hire scheme was brought to trial; it was a predicate on his conspiracy charge.
- nullc 6y agoHe was never charged with most of that so he didn't have an opportunity to defend against it. I personally found it hard to read as something he believed was real, ... assuming he actually had those conversations at all. One of these discussions goes something like this: Crook: Sorry dread pirate, I don't want to extort you but a big bad nasty dealer is demanding money from me. DPR: Put him on, let me see if I can work it out. Crook-wearing-nose-and-glasses: This big bad dealer. DPR: Okay why don't I pay you what the 'other guy' was demanding, and you make him go away forever. Crook-wearing-nose-and-glasses: Can do. I can't be the only person that read that as a subtext of "I know I'm just talking to you, but I want to make it clear that you're not going to get to try this stunt multiple times"-- arguably an assault. But I would just assume that getting death threats is just a cost of doing business as an extortionist. Of course, there is no allegation that anyone actually died at all. Keep in mind that much of this evidence was collected by a couple of phenomenally corrupt officers who compromised the silkroad systems and robbed it blind (some of whom have now been convicted but it appears there may have been an additional one who wasn't caught). Ulbrecht's defence was denied access to large amounts of potentially exculpatory evidence because the prosecution completely concealed the corrupt officers from the case. It is absolutely a miscarriage of justice to hold the murder for hire allegations against him when the prosecution dare not have charged any of it because doing so would have forced them to expose that the chain of custody of their evidence went through extremely corrupt LE who had a tens of millions of dollar incentive to keep all the attention on someone else while they lined their pockets. But I'm just some internet hothead. Here is what the National Lawyers Guild said: > “The sentence was based on judicial findings related to allegations of serious crimes that not only were never found by a jury but were not even among the charges leveled at trial.” Because of this I think we can never know the truth, but it a basic bedrock principle of our legal system that when the prosecution is corrupt and engages in misconduct such that we can't be sure of the truth, we'd rather let a guilty person walk than wrongfully convict or reward unethical and inequitable conduct by the state.
- tptacek 6y agoUS SDNY v. Ross William Ulbricht. COUNT ONE: Narcotics Trafficking Conspiracy _Overt Acts_ (10) (b) On or about March 29, 2013, ROSS WILLIAM ULBRICHT, a/k/a/ "Dread Pirate Roberts," a/k/a "DPR," a/k/a "Sild Road," the defendant, in connection with operating the Silk Road website, solicited a Silk Road user to execute a murder-for-hire of another Silk Road user, who was threatening to release the identities of thousands of users of the site.
- nullc 6y agoIndeed, that was the log I gave a characture of above-- you'll note that there is no mention of the supposed four other ones as they entirely rested on claims made by the now-convicted officers Carl Mark Force IV and Shaun W. Bridges. Media coverage from back then: https://www.dailydot.com/crime/silk-road-murder-charges-ross-ulbricht/ https://www.dailydot.com/crime/silk-road-murder-charges-ross... > To date, there have been precisely zero murder charges filed. Instead, the indictment has been changed without explanation, the formal charges omitted, and the broader accusations buried within a lesser drug trafficking charge. > Of the six murder indictments trumpeted by the U.S. government in the days following Ulbricht’s Oct. 2013 arrest, five have fallen off the table and the sixth sits untouched in a separate indictment (legalese for an unproven allegation) that was purposefully left out of the upcoming trial. Of course, we know now why they didn't charge-- those charges were impossibly tainted by the involvement of the corrupt officers. But the trial was no less prejudiced just because they skipped charging on the murder-for-hire parts: those corrupt officers had administrative control over the systems, they fabricated evidence to conceal their heist, and so on. Had the compromise of the investigation not been fatal to the prosecutions case they simply wouldn't have risked concealing it from the defence.
- tptacek 6y agoIf what you were trying to communicate was that Ross Ulbricht was never charged with ordering a murder, all I'm saying is, the indictment flatly refutes that. Whatever corruption you say taints the charge, it taints the entire Narcotics Trafficking Conspiracy charge as well! The murder-for-hire scheme is a predicate!
- lixtra 6y agoThe verdict did not include the hitman charges and the separate trial about them was stopped[1], so hard to tell if they were substantial. [1] https://news.bitcoin.com/ross-ulbricht-murder-for-hire-indictment-to-be-dismissed/ https://news.bitcoin.com/ross-ulbricht-murder-for-hire-indic... Edit: To quote Wikipedia (more precise than my statement): Ulbricht was not charged in his trial in New York federal court with any murder-for-hire,[28][36] but evidence was introduced at trial supporting the allegations.[28][37] The evidence that Ulbricht had commissioned murders was considered by the judge in sentencing Ulbricht to life, and was a factor in the Second Circuit's decision to affirm the life sentence.[37] A separate indictment against Ulbricht in federal court in Maryland on a single murder-for-hire charge, alleging that he contracted to kill one of his employees (a former Silk Road moderator),[38] was dismissed with prejudice by prosecutors in July 2018, after his New York conviction and sentence became final.[39][40]
- tptacek 6y agoBoth the verdict and the sentencing memoranda included the murder-for-hire scheme.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- stickfigure 6y agoAnd yet that's profoundly unsatisfying. Ulbrecht was not convicted of murder-for-hire; he was accused of it, and that accusation influenced his sentence for other crimes. Which a fairly large part of this community believe aren't actual crimes.
- tptacek 6y agoHe was convicted of the charge for which the murder-for-hire was a predicate! A finding of fact in the trial was in fact that he ordered someone's murder!
- 6y ago