6 ms·
How it works: https://www.liquidpiston.com/how-it-works https://www.liquidpiston.com/how-it-works
by verdverm 6y ago
How it works: https://www.liquidpiston.com/how-it-works https://www.liquidpiston.com/how-it-works
- tsomctl 6y agoA picture is worth a thousand words. (Well, video in this case) I still don't understand how it seals better than a Wankel. I understand how it's turned inside out, and it's very clever, but it seems like it would have the same problem with seals.
- wffurr 6y agoThey claim the seals are stationary and can be lubricated from the housing, which "solves" the durability and emissions problems with Wankels.
- prsutherland 6y agoA Wankel has seals attached to the rotor that rub against the wall of the chamber. This engine only has three points on the chamber wall that touch the rotor, so the seals can be installed on the chamber wall and it is significant easier to cool and lubricate a fixed seal rather than a rotating seal.
- dv_dt 6y agoWouldn't there also be seals on the two faces of the rotor too?
- ansible 6y ago> Wouldn't there also be seals on the two faces of the rotor too? Yes. However, the apex seals of the Wankel are the most troublesome, from what I've read about the RX-7/8.
- sitharus 6y agoAs I understand it from friends who're in to rotary engines, the biggest problem is the spark plug hole. The seal - which is being forced outwards by rotation - will fall in to the hole slightly and then wear against the edges of the hole as it rotates past. This gradually increases blow-by and reduces efficiency until it no longer seals at all. This design has a smooth surface against the seals at all times, and they can be lubricated directly.
- pengaru 6y agoThat is not the primary source of wear problems on Mazda Wankels. What you're describing is a challenge on peripheral port (race) engines where very large intake and exhaust ports must be bridged by the apex seals, and in the pursuit of performance their radius is often less than ideal making the transition onto and out of the port area more abrupt. The spark plug hole however is relatively small and circular. High-mileage Mazda Wankels typically require overhauling because the side seals become seized in a compressed state (their springs are meager segments of ~sinusoidal wire, and the motor burns oil by design causing excess carbon/coking clogging them up), resulting in excess blow-by and unintended oil burning. Once the side seals go, the combustion gases start reaching the oil control rings, baking their soft interior seals into brittle plastic and it's all downhill from there. source: former rx-7 enthusiast with multiple diy engine rebuilds in his past. Edit: BTW something that's often misunderstood about Wankels is that the rotor turns lazily at 1/3rd the engine RPM. So despite it being a "high revving" engine, there isn't actually that much centrifugal force acting on the apex seals at conventional engine speeds. The pain point in this department is the stationary gears responsible for converting that 3X eccentric shaft speed into a mix of orbital and rotational motion at the rotors.
- smokelegend 6y agoInsane power 1000+Hp Turbo 4rotor AWD [All-Wheel-Drive] https://m.youtube.com/results?search_query=4rotor+turbo+1200hours+awd https://m.youtube.com/results?search_query=4rotor+turbo+1200... There's definitely a market for rotary engines, time will tell how this new form takes shape.
- deelowe 6y agoThe same seal that contacts the rotor likely seals the face as well. That's how wankels work.
- mannykannot 6y agoThe 'seals' section in this article suggests that wankels need separate apex and side seals: http://what-when-how.com/automobile/wankel-engines-automobile/ http://what-when-how.com/automobile/wankel-engines-automobil... See also Pengaru's comment about problems with side seals, specifically: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25451923 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25451923
- tsomctl 6y agoSo what, you have oiling or cooling passages immediately behind the seal?
- Groxx 6y agoHuh. So it's basically a rotary 2-stroke engine? I'm curious what the emissions look like. And I'm not sure if the apex seals actually change how much distance they rub over (though stationary may be enough to make them easier to deal with, and probably cheaper to replace the rotor rather than the housing if it gets scratched).
- irjustin 6y agoThe thing that makes this so interesting is that it's a 2-stroke, 3-lobe engine. The traditional wankel being a 4-stroke, 1-lobe. I don't expect emissions to be any good since it's fundamentally a 2-stroke, which is perfect for non-road based applications. I don't think we'll see this on the road... ever.
- SamBam 6y agoCould you explain that last part further?
- irjustin 6y agoReally small 2 strokes (like leaf blowers) use mixed oil-fuel which is absolutely terrible for emissions. To make a 2 stroke meet emissions while maintaining its primary gain - thermal efficiency, and matching the power density a lot of complexity is needed. This quora post[0] largely sums that up, but quora is only so trustworthy. [0] https://www.quora.com/Why-arent-2-stroke-engines-used-in-cars https://www.quora.com/Why-arent-2-stroke-engines-used-in-car...
- topspin 6y ago> I don't think we'll see this on the road... ever. It's very small and lightweight, so it could serve as a range extender running a generator in an electric vehicle.
- irjustin 6y agoThe primary limiting factor is emissions for road cars and 2-strokes. 2 strokes have to go oil-sump + direct injection with supercharger to be able to match a 4 stroke when it comes to maintaining thermal efficiency, match power density while meeting emission standards. All that complexity and the 4 stroke atkinson's cycle looks really attractive again. A huge benefit in of the Atkinson's setup is it can switch back to the Otto seamlesssly and directly drive the car for additional power (i.e Hybrid vehciles) If you can parse through the noise of Quora posts, this highlights above[0]. Tesla won't use it gasoline for range extension - it's against their religion - which I subscribe to. [0] https://www.quora.com/Why-arent-2-stroke-engines-used-in-cars https://www.quora.com/Why-arent-2-stroke-engines-used-in-car...
- ksec 6y agoIs this not the same / similar design as the new Mazda Rotary ?
- donw 6y agoIt looks like the rotor design is quite different -- much more rounded and oblong, as opposed to triangular, with the combustion happening inside the rotor. That's actually quite clever -- increase the capacity, without increasing the size. The new piston design looks to have a much larger sealing area against the walls of the block, and the lack of distinct edges -- the ever-so-fragile apex seals -- should increase longevity, although IANAME, so have your salt-shaker ready for action. These look fairly simple to build as well.
- fastball 6y agoIntake/exhaust is happening through the rotor, not the combustion.