3 ms·
There's lots to criticize about other Western countries and how they've managed their own resources (and especially for any outsourcing of environmental harm to
by throwaway894345 6y ago
There's lots to criticize about other Western countries and how they've managed their own resources (and especially for any outsourcing of environmental harm to which they contribute), but we don't need to be dishonest by arguing that they've depleted their own resources. North America has some of the most abundant forests, oil fields, and coal deposits in the world, and that without accepting payment to compensate for not consuming them. Similarly, Europe has many resources of its own. And (especially in Europe) most of the consumption of natural resources in these countries predated our modern understanding of environment.
If the US demanded a check from Brazil in order to halt the creation of some oil pipeline or coal mine, they would rightly be laughed out of the room--the US shouldn't contribute to worsening environmental issues because it's every country's moral responsibility to create a sustainable future.
> especially when they buy meat and soya from Brazil.
I'm a big fan of economic solutions to economically-derived environmental problems. I want as many countries as possible to have a carbon tax, and I want those countries to have a border adjustment so China or whomever can't out-compete other countries by polluting (externalizing the cost of production to the environment). Maybe the analog here is a border adjustment for Brazil and other countries that aren't managing their environment to some accepted standard, so that other Western countries aren't contributing to Brazilian deforestation (and other environmental issues).
- rmsaksida 6y ago> North America has some of the most abundant forests, oil fields, and coal deposits in the world, and that without accepting payment to compensate for not consuming them How much economic benefit would those resources offer if consumed? In the case of forests, is the land covered by them fit for pasture or crops? Is that an apt comparison with the Amazon? Also, how much does North America need the money they'd get out of consuming those resources? > Similarly, Europe has many resources of its own Is that so? How much of Europe is covered by native forests? In Brazil it's roughly 50% of the country. And that's native rain forest, not artificial reforestation. Is Europe willing to relocate people out of territories they've occupied for generations to restore the original forests? > most of the consumption of natural resources in these countries predated our modern understanding of environment Yes, but the fact is Western countries are wealthy and the resources they consumed throughout their history surely played a part in the wealth they've accumulated. Why shouldn't Brazil have that chance? To clarify, I do not think it's reasonable to cut down the forest - but it's very easy and convenient for European countries to point fingers when they've gotten rich off their own resources and other countries' resources via colonialism. > If the US demanded a check from Brazil in order to halt the creation of some oil pipeline or coal mine, they would rightly be laughed out of the room If the US were a poor country and the oil pipeline would represent a big economic gain for them, I honestly don't think that would be unreasonable. You can't expect poor countries to sit on their hands if it's a game changing opportunity. > Maybe the analog here is a border adjustment for Brazil and other countries that aren't managing their environment to some accepted standard, so that other Western countries aren't contributing to Brazilian deforestation I would fully support that. I don't think we'll see any improvements to the situation until other countries maneuver to make deforestation an economic issue.
- throwaway894345 6y ago> Also, how much does North America need the money they'd get out of consuming those resources? How much economic benefit would those resources offer if consumed? In the case of forests, is the land covered by them fit for pasture or crops? Is that an apt comparison with the Amazon? The US alone has more untapped oil than any other country on the planet, including Saudi Arabia or Russia, and those countries are largely dependent on oil for their whole economies. So I would expect that there's enough oil to finance an entire second world economy (if not first world), especially prior to the recent decline in oil prices. And that's not counting forest or oil. As far as forests, I'm sure much of it isn't fit for crops because most of what was fit for crops was cleared hundreds of years prior to our modern understanding of environment. America should work to eliminate and reverse its own environmental damage and Brazil should do the same. To that end, America has bigger environmental opportunities than reforesting agricultural land--for example, passing a carbon tax (with border adjustments) will certainly yield more environmental benefit (at lower cost). > Is that so? How much of Europe is covered by native forests? In Brazil it's roughly 50% of the country. And that's native rain forest, not artificial reforestation. Doesn't matter. The original claim was that western countries exhausted their own resources, so any amount greater than zero suffices to disprove it (and thus the broader argument that depends on that claim). > Is Europe willing to relocate people out of territories they've occupied for generations to restore the original forests? I don't buy your underlying assumption that Brazil not knowingly deforesting the Amazon is equivalent to Europe reversing damage they did during the Iron Age. What sense does it make to fault living Europeans for decisions that Iron Age Europeans made? They're both nominally European in that they reside in Europe, but they're different populations. I grant you that extant Europeans benefit from the dearth of forests in the same way that Brazilians benefit from the forests that have already been cleared, but how do we compare these things? Why do we need both polities to have the same percentage of preserved vs cleared forests? Or does fairness demand that the economies of all polities are exactly the same (or the same per-capita)? Fairness is inherently subjective, so we oughtn't defer environmental progress to such a time as we discover some objective notion of fairness (or even one that we all agree upon); rather, each country should work to improve its own environmental trajectory and not make excuses based on other countries. > If the US were a poor country and the oil pipeline would represent a big economic gain for them, I honestly don't think that would be unreasonable. You can't expect poor countries to sit on their hands if it's a game changing opportunity. According to Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oil_reserves_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oil_reserves_in_the_United_Sta...), there's something like $20 trillion in oil (at its peak price in 2008, there was about $20 trillion in undiscovered oil reserves alone). There's no dearth of poverty in the United States.
- gdubs 6y agoThis glosses over the fact that here in the US we’ve emitted, historically, more than any other country. [1] 1: https://www.statista.com/statistics/1007454/cumulative-co2-emissions-worldwide-by-country/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1007454/cumulative-co2-e...
- devmunchies 6y agoObviously the biggest country to pioneer modernization will have the most historical emissions. You have to break a few eggs to make an omelette. More important are our current post-modernization emissions.
- gdubs 6y agoI’m not hostile to this point of view — I understand it. But ultimately there will have to be some sort of middle ground. Carbon emissions stick around a very long time, and we can basically assign our name (speaking from the USA here) on the majority of them. They’re the emissions causing challenges today, and they disproportionately affect the poor developing nations, who — while they may benefit from our innovations — are going to have a hard time accepting that they can’t take the same easy route to success that we did.
- throwaway894345 6y agoIt doesn't gloss over it at all; as previously mentioned, there's lots to criticize about the US and other countries. The US ought to do better, but its sins (especially those prior to our modern understanding of environment) don't vindicate Brazil's deforestation today. This line of argumentation--that we all need only be as good as the worst of our rivals (and by whatever standard suits us in a given moment, no less)--is just a race to the bottom and I reject it wholesale.
- badconvincer 6y agoWhat are you talking about? The US has old growth forests only in the Northeast and Europe has all but cut down all of its old growth forests except in parts of Poland and maybe Germany. You gotta take responsibility at some point. Just because a generation flips over doesn’t mean the slate has been wiped clean of the faults of your fathers.