6 ms·
We should distinguish having above average mental faculty, and above average skills. I vastly overestimated the impact of the former until university. Engineer
by nicbou 6y ago
We should distinguish having above average mental faculty, and above average skills.
I vastly overestimated the impact of the former until university. Engineering classes kicked everyone's asses. Everyone was equally smart, but some people studied harder than others.
On the other hand, I know I am well above average at certain things because I've been doing them for many years. I have an above average interest in those things, and put an above average effort into learning them.
This is also true for other people. My dad is an average dad, until you ask him about cars or motorbikes. I knew he liked cars, but I didn't get to appreciate the breadth and depth of his knowledge until I started wrenching on vehicles. He spared me the details out of politeness, because I wasn't into cars. Now, he doesn't spare me, and it turns out he's a mechanical grandwizard. It was right under my nose this whole time.
I suspect most people are like that. They are average, except at one or two things. We tend to judge others based on the one or two things we value, and fail to appreciate them for what they're good at.
- code_scrapping 6y agoI agree with all above, and I'll go on a slight tangent. I dislike the "genius" and "gifted" labels because in the long run they're excuses why you're not one. "It's ok that he got a better salary - he's a genius!". With a "nature" argument, you don't have to think about the "nurture" argument - your actual skill. Then you can give up without being ashamed. 99% of the people you'll actually meet are averages with interests and luck to manifest their skills in the right way. And on the other hand, I've attended local Mensa chapter meetings to see first-hand that "geniuses" can in 99% of cases be just ordinary people with some special interests on which they may or may not capitalize. So - always value contextual knowledge, skill and effort, and encourage yourself and other people to develop. Because otherwise you just like to play the lottery and complain how the numbers are too random to your liking.
- 411111111111111 6y agoSalary doesn't reflect skill level or worth to the company. It's at best correlated and shouldn't be part of this discussion.
- code_scrapping 6y agoIf we're discussing the capitalist society, the salary does represent in a very literal form your worth to the company, and by consequence probably your skill level too. I'll admit that it's more complicated than that. What you should not associate with your salary is your own sense of worth or success, because there you're on mentally unstable grounds. But in my original response I just gave a random example, and you're right that we should not expand the discussion in that direction.
- richardwhiuk 6y agoAssuming that the labour market is efficient, which is manifestly not true.
- Hammershaft 6y agoThe definition of "worth" in that context is also contingent on factors that have nothing to do with the quality or social value of the skill that salary supposedly represents. Can you create an exaggerated perception of your skill in others? To what degree does your skill have latent demand vs effective demand? To what degree has your skill been monopsonized? To what degree does your skill apply to solving problems that are currently externalized? Some simple examples: An amazing social worker could change the lives of dozens if not hundreds of people, however, since those people are broke & homeless, her target demographic is unable to compensate her for what she does (latent demand), and her salary is very meagre and state subsidized. An expert in environmental restoration could save a strip mining conglomerate millions of dollars while improving the health of hundreds of thousands of people in communities downriver, however because that conglomerate chooses to externalize those costs onto those communities, that environmental expert also ends up recieving a meagre state subsidized salary.
- burade 6y agoLmao no it doesn't. Your salary is simply the amount of money you have convinced a company to pay you. You could waste 3 years making 100k a year only to deliver a failed project that resulted in 0 revenue.
- msiyer 6y agoThe labels 'genius' and 'gifted' look convincing until you read about 'accidental genius' - genius acquired after a serious illness or injury. 'genius' is just a particular configuration out of millions or billions in which a brain can form. Brain's real estate is malleable like a city's. So, no reason why one cannot configure it to one's liking. Now, the procedure to do so might not be as easy. I also think that there is not much difference between an alcoholic (any addiction for that matter) and a workaholic genius. The reason is that both do not know what drives them.
- ishjoh 6y agoI would like to read more about accidental genius, are there any scientific papers or books you would recommend?
- solveit 6y agoI note that there are many sensational media stories about accidental genius, and zero accidental geniuses who leveraged their genius to become absurdly rich/famous/powerful. I am therefore very skeptical about whether accidental genius really exists. All this is tangential to your point of course.
- andi999 6y agoThe genius and gifted 'myth' is also bad for the genius and the gifted themselves. I know a guy, he is clearly gifted, but due to not adding hard work stalled in his PhD.
- Aerroon 6y agoIs being hardworking a talent or something you learn?
- Taylor_OD 6y agoMost of the exceptionally gifted people I've run into in life have either also been very hard working or have run into a wall when they get to a level where their giftedness is no longer enough for them to get through every situation without also putting in hard work.
- anonunivgrad 6y ago>run into a wall when they get to a level where their giftedness is no longer enough for them to get through every situation without also putting in hard work I have hit this wall and have sometimes wished I was less intelligent but more diligent. I would be healthier and wealthier for sure. To any intelligent but lazy young man reading this, don’t delay improving your diligence. Seek counseling and coaching if you can. Don’t let your good grades, impressed teachers and peers, and fancy college acceptances convince you otherwise. But avoid ADHD drugs. They will wreck your body, make you numb, and sap your enthusiasm for life.
- nicbou 6y agoThis trope is so common that I suspect we're not that smart. High school was just really easy.
- anonunivgrad 6y agoIt hits people at different points. Could be college, could be grad school, could be work in general, could be a promotion. But it will ultimately catch up to you.
- Taylor_OD 6y agoI ask any high schooler that is heading to college if they actually study and how difficult school is for them. Most of the "smart" one tell me their classes are really easy. I tell them to expect to actually have to study and for those easy A's or B's just for showing up to become C's and D's in college. My buddies kid actually took the advice to heart and has been getting A's and B's in college still which is good to see. I wish someone would have given me that advice and saved me an extra semester.
- svachalek 6y agoI've seen way too many people handicap themselves this way. In my experience, someone with completely average gifts in a given area will likely never win a world competition, but putting in repeated and consistent effort can probably be better at that thing than anyone they will encounter in day-to-day life. But it's so much easier to just shrug and say oh well.
- eyelidlessness 6y ago> I dislike the "genius" and "gifted" labels because in the long run they're excuses why you're not one. They’re also excuses when you are one. “Genius here, don’t need to cook or clean.” They’re a point of failure whichever side of the fence is greener.
- croon 6y ago> He spared me the details out of politeness, because I wasn't into cars. Now, he doesn't spare me, and it turns out he's a mechanical grandwizard. It was right under my nose this whole time. I only have one, but have interacted with many, but I think your dad's special there. Most dads don't spare you. It's something I've been thinking a lot about since having kids, and who I will be to them when we're peers.
- LC_ALL 6y agoThe term grandwizard is extremely dated. If you do not know what it means its better not to find out.
- sdoering 6y agoWow. I only knew the term from fantasy role plays and fantasy overall. Would not have guessed it to have a real world connotation. By your comment I learned from the Wrestler, but more importantly the Ku Klux Klan reference and meaning. Thanks for laying out a bread crumb to follow for new insights.
- nicbou 6y agoWhoops, not intended. Though my father did threaten to disown me if I ever brought a Volkswagen home.
- vsareto 6y agoAs a happy Golf GTI owner, oof
- dj_mc_merlin 6y agoLetting racists keep the term is a loss to us all. Did you know Grand Wizzard Theodore invented the disc scratch? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grand_Wizzard_Theodore https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grand_Wizzard_Theodore
- sdoering 6y agoI can relate. My late father had an incredible penchant for mechanical watches. Whether wristwatch, pocket watch, wall clock or alarm clock. Even large church clocks fascinated him immensely. It was the artistry of the mechanics that made his heart beat faster. I could not understand this for a long time. Could not understand why one spends several thousand euros on watchmaking seminars to learn the craft as a hobby. At some point I learned that as a child he wanted to become a watchmaker, but this did not work out and so he had to take another profession (which he nevertheless loved very much). Only late he has fulfilled his childhood dream. And actually, it is only today, after he has passed away and I have occupied myself with the watches he had collected in the course of his life, that I can really begin to appreciate the little bits of knowledge he gave me every now and then. Today, I wear few watches myself. They are the ones that were especially precious to him. And I appreciate them very much. Both in their external and mechanical aesthetics.
- PanMan 6y agoWhen I was a student (so I thought I was smart), I got to pick up a bunch of desks at a moving company. How hard could that be... The (older) gentleman working at the moving company saw us struggle for a few minutes, then asked us to move aside, and he was WAY more efficient at packing the truck with desks, than we were... Was a nice lesson that experience can beat a lot of "smarts".
- ZephyrBlu 6y ago> Was a nice lesson that experience can beat a lot of "smarts" It doesn't 'beat' smarts, it's just different. What most people call being 'smart' means you're a fast learner and/or are good at abstract thinking. Of course someone with experience knows how to do something better than you if you have no experience, but if you're left to figure things out for yourself you might work out a more efficient way to do things faster than the experienced person did. If you're doing a repetitive task, being smart isn't that important and so experience usually trumps being smart. If you're doing a dynamic task where you face new problems, then pure repetition doesn't help as much because each problem is different.
- kamaal 6y ago>>What most people call being 'smart' means you're a fast learner and/or are good at abstract thinking. The very definition of being good at a thing means, being able to that specific thing well. You could learn something fast, but really getting at good that will demand tons of practice before it begins to appear as sleight of hand. >>If you're doing a dynamic task where you face new problems, then pure repetition doesn't help as much because each problem is different. Each heart surgery is different, yet in many ways similar. Practice matters a lot in these cases. Your initial enthusiasm might not even matter in these cases.
- ZephyrBlu 6y agoI agree with your points, but I'm not really sure why you quoted me when your comment isn't really relevant to mine. I never discounted practice, and yes to be "really good" (Whatever your definition of that is) at something takes a lot of practice regardless of how smart you are. I also specifically said _pure_ repetition because I know that repetition is important for all skills, but for more complex skills you need to synthesize your past experience and extrapolate to future experiences (I.e abstract thinking). This is a lot more involved than pure repetition.
- LordFast 6y ago"Practice makes perfect."
- analog31 6y agoOddly enough, my music teacher told his students: "Practice makes permanent." What he meant was that if you practice it wrong, it will become a habit to do it wrong.
- coding123 6y agoI think there are a lot of people in tech that never get this insight. It's sad when I see tech people treat others like idiots, including calling them idiots. I think most people need a humbling event in their life to see it. You can have them watch one of the millions of Disney movies that showcase this attitude but they will never realize it's not really an evil queen that is doing the harmful actions, it's everyday people treating others disrespectfully.
- roastytoasty 6y agoI'm saving that last sentence. What a great quote
- kamaal 6y agoBasically the distance you've travelled with any subject is what determines really how good you are. The very definition means there's only few things you can be really good at. If you are careful there are a certain things you can chose be good at that will help you on the longer run. Stuff like personal finance, retirement planning, health etc. Good news is you can be good at nearly anything by spending some time getting a little better every day. But you have to keep that going for a few years before you notice some thing phenomenal coming out of it. Unless you are very at the precipice of death, pretty much any body has a chance of being good at anything.
- Geminidog 6y agoExperimental evidence and logic counters your point. It is wishful thinking to believe that most people are average but this is not the case. There are more people on the right and left side of a bell curve than in the center. When you account for all bins most people ARE not average though the "average" represents the biggest bin. (It also depends on how big you make your bins but in general if you make your bins a reasonable resolution more people live to the side of the average than in the center) What this means is that there are people all over the spectrum, tons of people who are bad, and tons of people who excel and are better. It is convenient to think otherwise but it does not mesh with reality. There are people who are better than you in all things just through sheer talent and there are people who are worse than you in all things also because of sheer talent. Your uni anecdotal example also is biased. It also depends on the university you attend. Universities filter off of cognitive ability through grades and testing. Students within the same university are more or less roughly equivalent in ability due to going through the same filtering to attend the same university. There is, however, a very evident difference in skill between students who go to different universities. If you ever transferred from a lower tier university to a higher one, you can feel this difference anecdotally. The difference in ability between students on average in say Stanford is markedly different then those in a community college.
- SoSoRoCoCo 6y ago> There are more people on the right and left side of a bell curve than in the center. That's almost tautology they way you worded it. Statistics has a term to describe "left and right", it is called standard deviation, and one standard deviation covers ~70% of the sample population. What is true is that half of any population is below average by whatever metric you choose to apply. (EDIT: for normal/Gaussian distributions)
- Geminidog 6y ago>What is true is that half of any population is below average by whatever metric you choose to apply. Not exactly, this is sort of true in practice but not true logically. Imagine a population of [1, 100, 100, 100] or a population of [1,1,1,1,999999]. Two examples where the population that is below average exceeds half the population and is below half the population. But this is just semantics. If the population follows a bell curve and at high resolution standard deviations, what you said is generally true.
- _carbyau_ 6y agoI agree with your last paragraph. There is a value in "seeing the good in others". But we tend not to see it unless it benefits us. I also think the effort to see it - mostly time and patience - is less forthcoming nowadays. Whether it is the rush of life. Or disposable society meaning craft/repair skills are less valued so it isn't worth the time to get to know "elderly appliance repair person". Or the polarisation of debate and views of people. But yeah, I try to hold that every stranger has some cool/good/great thing that I can't compete with. There are a zillion things in the world. The chances that MY one or two cool things overlap with theirs is minimal. But their cool thing - whatever it is - is still cool.