4 ms·
Something that I've never understood. We have markets that are based on allowing trades to happen at any agreed on price, as fast as people's minds can meet.
by btilly 16y ago
Something that I've never understood.
We have markets that are based on allowing trades to happen at any agreed on price, as fast as people's minds can meet. Which can therefore result in very high volatility.
Why hasn't anyone tried building a market that goes the opposite way? Prices drift at a fixed rate (eg min(1 cent, 0.05% of price)/minute) in a direction determined by whether there is an excess of buy or sell orders, and trades execute as soon as both a buy and a sell are available at the right price. This would give greatly reduced instant volatility in return for uncertainty about how quickly orders will complete.
The advantage of the latter strategy being that it is very resistant to attempts to compromise it via high frequency trading techniques. That 1/100th of a second time margin doesn't matter because the price changes too slowly. Therefore a long-term investor knows that they aren't getting charged "rent" via the automated algorithms.
It might be objected that lack of trading volume would make such a market initially useless. But arbitrage would keep its price close to the mainstream market. Hmmm..I guess it initially comes down to whether you're paying more in rent on arbitrage or on HFT...
- waqf 16y agoThis reminds me of my idea for a compiler that guarantees performance but not correctness, instead of the other way round.
- regehr 16y agoI have a compiler like that. It turns any code into "return 0".
- btilly 16y agoYou mean C? http://blog.llvm.org/2011/05/what-every-c-programmer-should-know.html http://blog.llvm.org/2011/05/what-every-c-programmer-should-...
- repsilat 16y ago3D rendering and media compression are almost entirely based on the idea that "close enough" is vastly cheaper than "do it right". At the code level, though... You'd have to be fairly careful about what you allowed, and you'd probably have to be able to enforce correctness to some degree to get any meaningful use out of it. I like the idea of a compiler making lossy simplifications to mathematical formulas for speed - "You told me to divide by seven. This (faster) machine code divides by 8 most of the time, and divides by 4 every now and then." Blindly trusting the branch-predictor could be fun, too, as long as it took into account the correct answer in its subsequent predictions. Were you thinking along similar lines, or did you have something completely different in mind?
- waqf 16y agoI like those ideas a lot. I hadn't thought about it in enough detail to come up with similar ones, but that's exactly what I was hoping for. The problem, of course, is that it's hard to find a metric for "close enough" that works for every program. Perhaps it's easier if you're compiling from a high-level language than from C.
- r00fus 16y agoThis would be a great idea, but will never get implemented because wall street has almost perfect regulatory capture.
- dpapathanasiou 16y agoThere's been a lot of academic research on call auctions (e.g. http://www.springer.com/business+%26+management/finance/book/978-0-7923-7256-1 http://www.springer.com/business+%26+management/finance/book...) which are somewhat similar what you describe in terms of their effects on price stability (though pricing happens differently), but they've not been successful in practice.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoWhat is the advantage of such a market? Near as I can tell, what would happen is that whenever the market believes the price should move, liquidity will drop to 0. Eventually the market will allow trades at the right price, and liquidity will return. Why is this a good thing? Also, HFTs will still exist. Suppose the "right price" is $50 - even if the market hasn't adjusted (say it's stuck at $51), HFTs will race to have their orders first in the queue at $50 for when the market does readjust.
- hristov 16y agoFor markets to work one must try to get as much trading as possible on them. Only if the majority of trading happens on markets will markets be able to effectively discover prices. If one puts such artificial limitations on markets, than there is always a danger that people will not trade there. If people trade in side deals instead of the markets, then markets would not be able to discover prices and all kinds of inefficiencies would result from the uncertain prices. For example if you put in your limitation, there will be occasions where both buyers and sellers will want to buy and sell at a certain price but the exchange will simply not let them. In this case the buyers and sellers will try to meet and do the transaction outside of the exchange and that is usually a bad thing. I think there are other ways this can be fixed. For example one may even the playing field by simply adding a clock to the market so that all trades must happen on clock "ticks". This would prevent the advantage of HFT. Or the exchanges could just stop selling offer data to the HFT people. This would not cause the market problems discussed above, because it would only remove things that actual market participants do not have anyways. Thus, these measures would not remove any actual supply or demand from the market. The solutions are not hard to figure, the problem is that exchanges do not want to implement them. Exchanges make a lot of extra money from HFT and want to keep and grow that money even if endangers uncertainty in their markets.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoFor example one may even the playing field by simply adding a clock to the market so that all trades must happen on clock "ticks". This would prevent the advantage of HFT. No it wouldn't. At 12:00:00:001, all the HFT's will race to place an order and be the first in the queue. At 12:00:01:000, the fastest HFTs will be the ones to trade. Additionally, if news occurs at 12:00:00:998, the HFTs will all race to cancel their orders as fast as possible.
- fleitz 16y agoWell it largely depends on whether you want price stability or price discovery from your markets. Please explain where the source of capital for the arbitrage comes from, it's not exactly clear to me who would be willing to take huge arbitrage losses from this market. (Maybe the fed could back it, they seem to like taking a bath on arbitrage)
- nradov 16y agoHFTs aren't charging us long-term investors any "rent". They're actually giving us better trade execution. Some HFT algorithms might temporarily distort the market price of certain securities but over the long-term those minor inefficiencies get arbitraged away.
- btilly 16y agoShort term trading is a zero sum game. Therefore the profit that HFTs make is entirely money that in their absence would have been captured by other investors. Given that HFTs consistently do make profit, that is a form of rent charged on other players in the market.
- nradov 16y agoThere's no evidence that the majority of HFTs consistently make a profit. It may just look that way due to survivorship bias. The HFTs that do make a profit are harvesting their gains from other active traders, not from long-term investors.
- vecter 16y agoThe market is a place for risk transfer. That is where the profit that HFT makes comes from. Long term investors transfer the risk of being or not being in a position to HFT market makers, who then (in expectation) make a small profit per transaction. The bigger picture that your argument misses is that trading is zero sum in wealth, but NOT zero sum in utility. That is the amazing thing about trading (and by trading, I mean trading in general). Say I have three oranges and you have two bananas. It turns out that I really really love bananas, and you have equal preferences for oranges and bananas. I would be happy to exchange two of my oranges for one of your bananas. The next result is an increase in both of our individual utilities. That is how trading work (and why people trade), and HFT is no different.
- cma 16y agoHere's a better analogy: Bananas and oranges go by nightfall after arrival in the day by ship, and there are no other sources of bananas and oranges. For every banana a person eats, they must also eat an orange. Ships arrive sporadically throughout the day, and a ship can only contain bananas or oranges, not some of each. Only a few ships arrive each day. An equal number of bananas an oranges are shipped each day from the sources, but some of the ships sink on the way, so that there may be a surplus or deficit of bananas or oranges (remember, to eat one banana you must eat one orange). Spotters see the ships coming at roughly the same time, with some randomly variation, and immediately adjust the price of existing bananas or oranges based on what the incoming ship is carrying--after all it didn't sink, and the fact that it didn't gives some information on whether or not there will be a banana/orange deficit. One day a man invents a telescope and begins seeing the arriving ships five minutes before everyone else. He provides no net-wealth to society as a whole, but with the money he makes via arbitrage he begins commanding a disproportionate share of society's wealth for his own use. *Galileo originally used his telescope invention for exactly this (in conjunction with a wealthy family)--one of the least useful things he ever did. Would you rather someone work in HFT (scope out banana boats 5 minutes earlier than the next guy) or work in something useful like scientific research/general technological improvement (Galileo's discovering of deeper secrets of the heavens/improvement of navigation and cartography enabled by the scope)?
- joshu 16y agoContinuous auctions have the advantage of being continuous at the expense of volatility. You could instead have a single auction every day and this would be more fair but less available. Your example is not unlike how specialists control the price for markets. You should probably look into how these things actually work.
- baconface 16y agoBitcoin is a market that grows at a fixed rate! The stock market is kind of a joke...