7 ms·
I think in order for the opposite thing to work, you have to approach the material with the understanding that "There are people who believe this stuff as firml
by kqr 6y ago
I think in order for the opposite thing to work, you have to approach the material with the understanding that "There are people who believe this stuff as firmly as I believe the complete opposite. If you asked them, they say, with absolute conviction, that I'm nuts. How might that happen? What if they're right? What could I have missed?"
This engages System 2, hard. And it's so easy to slip back into System 1 and continue to reject the evidence in front of you, as System 1 does so well when it doesn't like what it's seeing.
I have to constantly remind myself of the possibility that I could be wrong or have an incomplete view of things, but then that allows me to extract the valuable nuances and hidden assumptions that underlie the belief.
Even more importantly, it tends to cast a light on my unconscious biases and assumptions that underlie my beliefs.
- AntiImperialist 6y ago>There are people who believe this stuff as firmly as I believe the complete opposite. If you asked them, they say, with absolute conviction, that I'm nuts. How might that happen? What if they're right? What could I have missed? After having read books on two sides of various things, I have found that most people don't have firm beliefs at all. Their beliefs don't even have anything to do with how they live. They have everything to do with what they're told will make them look good. So, just because someone says they believe something, I'm not willing to waste any more of my time on learning how it is justified on an intellectual or logical level (which is what books tend to capture). Even the believers most likely don't have any understanding of it themselves or how or why it matters to them. It's simply not worth it.
- azeirah 6y agoI believe that it's important to understand the perspective of someone you fundamentally disagree with. Or, well, you described it more accurately, it's a bit deeper than disagreement, it's an entirely different epistemology! Like waaayy different
- AntiImperialist 6y agoThe problem is most people don't have those perspectives. Their beliefs don't come from their life experience or that of their family handed down to them. It comes from marketing material. Therefore they're highly inconsistent in their beliefs and what they believe they believe does not have anything to do with them or how they actually live their lives. So, if you want to understand what they think they're about, you can just watch the "news" or read other PR material targeted to them. That is now more difficult because it's a bit more targeted because of social media marketing but it is still possible. But if you want to know what they actually believe without even knowing that they do, you have to look at what they actually do and how they live their lives.
- bonoboTP 6y agoAnd that's also true of most high brow, abstract school stuff. Like evolution. Even in countries where creationism isn't a thing and everyone "believes in" evolution, most of them couldn't describe a logically workable mechanism of evolution, they know a cartoon version but believe it because they "know" that "evolution" is true. But would you say it makes no sense to read books on evolution just because most people who believe in evolution don't believe in it for the reasons outlined in advanced books? Why did schools end up teaching evolution? For scientific reasons? To suppress religion in some freemasonry conspiracy? You can ask the same about the race topics.
- AntiImperialist 6y ago>Why did schools end up teaching evolution? For scientific reasons? To suppress religion in some freemasonry conspiracy? I think it has nothing to do with "increasing scientific literacy" or anything like that, for sure. It would be very odd that of all the scientific things you could push to teach kids, the theory of evolution is somehow the most important one. I think it has everything to do with attacking the Christian Right at their homes by forcing their kids to learn something they don't want them to. It's a socio-economic and political tool for war. When grilled by someone, I remember Richard Dawkins, one of the "Four Horsemen" of New Atheism, said that he just wants people to understand that it happens in nature but doesn't want people to live by the idea of natural selection or something to that effect. In other words, he wants people to understand evolution but not "believe" it... i.e. in the sense that he doesn't want people to live by it (I disagree with Dawkins, but more on that later). Speaking of that, it reminds me of a comment I posted yesterday here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25412712 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25412712 I know that if one really believes in evolution, there is absolutely no reason to "conserve a species". It makes absolutely no sense. Species come and go. Whatever species remain will evolve to acquire characteristics suitable for whatever changes happen... or perish. So why does everyone believe in conservation and in evolution? Because they don't. But what if they believed in Noah's arc? It would be terrible if one of the species that Noah himself picked to be on a boat were to go extinct because humans did something, wouldn't it? That is exactly the reaction you see from all these westerners who allegedly "believe" in evolution. I mean people can make use of certain rhetoric for status, or political gains or economic gains, but to actually believe those is a different matter altogether. I think westerners believe in many dogmas of Christianity, no matter how much they deny it or pretend that they are above it. I, as a non-Christian non-westerner who grew up mostly outside of the reach of westerners, see it in many aspects of how they actually live. The things that they actually believe in comes from Christianity. The things they pretend believe in comes from corporate and political PR material that they're exposed to... and some of it they do believe, as long as it doesn't contradict with Christianity.
- kevinpet 6y agoI tried to read "The End of Policing". I got half way through chapter 1 before the author stated, as support for his argument, that The Bell Curve was "overtly racist". Now, you could argue that lots of racists like that book, that the authors might be motivated by bias, etc etc, but no credible reviewer at the time it came out would call it "overtly racist". This is retroactive moving of the goal posts, and the word "overt", to me, still has meaning. So I tried to read the tripe, but the arguments are not persuasive unless you already believe what they are trying to convince you of.
- kqr 6y agoI know very little to nothing of the works you cite, so my ideas are to be taken with a grain of salt, but... I don't think the author was born thinking those complex thoughts, so clearly they were persuaded by something that didn't rely on previous belief. What could that be? Why isn't that persuasive to you? What sort of person does it persuade and why? Are there other arguments that could persuade you of the same thing? Or of something similar? Intellectual exchange requires constructing the steel man argument of your counterpart, as impossible as it may seem at times. Underneath, we're all humans, longing for food, shelter, companionship, and stability.
- bigbubba 6y ago> I don't think the author was born thinking those complex thoughts, so clearly they were persuaded by something that didn't rely on previous belief. What could that be? Very often the answer is mundane; 'It's what my parents taught me.' Particularly in the most contentious cases, like religion and politics. It seems like 'born thinking it' vs 'was persuaded' is a false dichotomy, unless you count being steeped in a culture as a child to be a form of persuasion.
- not2b 6y agoI suspect that the author is using the term "racist" differently than you use it. The Bell Curve explicitly argues that some racial groups are inherently, biologically less intelligent than others. In the author's view, that in itself is overtly racist (because it argues that one racial group is genetically inferior to another racial group), no matter how much intellectual argument is presented or how gently it is stated. Perhaps you use the word differently, and believe that something is only racist if the author hates people on the basis of race.
- sieabahlpark 6y ago> I think in order for the opposite thing to work, you have to approach the material with the understanding that "There are people who believe this stuff as firmly as I believe the complete opposite. If you asked them, they say, with absolute conviction, that I'm nuts. How might that happen? What if they're right? What could I have missed?" Always spoken to a person as if they're wrong. How about seeing this problem from yet a different view too? One in which the answer is, "You first, show good faith before you're critical of my views" You don't go into a board room telling the CEO he's a fuckwit and that you're right without first getting how they understand something. You're never going to change any mind with this program unless it's compulsory and even then you'll only drive people to be more certain of their views. I swear HN is about as academic as reddit is, which is to say zero. There is no actual critical thinking about the hypotheticals. Immediately, without provocation, it's that one side is right and wrong and feeling strongly is ultimately equivalent to being that wrong. I'm ashamed I even bother posting on here at all, not that anyone responds of course since this is a dead account.
- Viliam1234 6y agoIt is generally good to try seeing things from the other person's perspective, but it is also possible that sometimes the other person is simply wrong. Just because an idea is wrong, that doesn't magically prevent millions of people from following it.
- chordalkeyboard 6y agothe idea here is to understand why people believe something that is (consider by you to be) wrong.
- bonoboTP 6y agoThat can have lots of reasons,like they grew up with it, were indoctrinated in school/college when they had little experience or critical thinking skills and stay due to sunk cost fallacy or tribalism, or it satisfies some deep psychological need to feel superior or virtuous etc. Plenty of reasons besides them analytically arriving at a position through a lot of thinking.
- kqr 6y agoSure, but all of those things could apply to your thinking too, maybe even just as much. Figuring out who suffers more from those kinds of biases is often harder than just saying, "yeah, it's definitely the other guy."
- chordalkeyboard 6y agoThis is all true for everyone. The point is to get a better understanding of those reasons and why those reasons led this person to these beliefs. Plenty of people grow up and change their minds and then have different opinions than their parents indoctrinated them with. Plenty of people rely on the reasons you mentioned above to dismiss other people's views without critically examining their own views, which are subject to the exact same reasoning process.