4 ms·
I agree speed camera are necessary but "time of travel" speed cameras are absolutely violating the intent of the law, which is to have people drive safely. Par
by XorNot 6y ago
I agree speed camera are necessary but "time of travel" speed cameras are absolutely violating the intent of the law, which is to have people drive safely.
Part of driving safely is that you may need to speed up to avoid a situation, or change lanes safely or what have you - a time of travel camera (in the way they get implemented which is identical to single-point speed cameras AFAIK) is essentially just a random ticket generating machine. If we're going to use these things, let's just require them to publish the license plate and time online, so our phone's can download the number and tell us if we're currently going to get ticketed going past them.
Because tickets aren't just monetary - at least in Australia, license demerit points mean you eventually lose your license, thus your ability to drive and very likely your job as a result.
- ISL 6y agoDriving slightly under the speed limit (and perhaps bumping existing speed limits slightly upward before increasing the efficiency of enforcement) should address most of those concerns.
- ceejayoz 6y agoThe speed limit is an upper bound. If you cannot safely pass someone without speeding, slowing down is generally an option too. If you're speeding to escape a homicidal maniac, challenge the ticket later.
- loeg 6y agoIn at least parts of the US, it is not an upper bound. You can exceed the posted limit to pass.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoWhere in the US?
- loeg 6y agoWashington, for example. RCW 46.61.425: > a person following a vehicle driving at less than the legal maximum speed and desiring to pass such vehicle may exceed the speed limit https://app.leg.wa.gov/rcw/default.aspx?cite=46.61.425 https://app.leg.wa.gov/rcw/default.aspx?cite=46.61.425 This random internet webpage claims that Idaho, Wyoming, and Minnesota have something similar: https://blog.directauto.com/driving-laws/going-over-speed-limit-when-passing/ https://blog.directauto.com/driving-laws/going-over-speed-li... .
- lotsofpulp 6y agoThat’s cool, I didn’t know that!
- ceejayoz 6y ago> You can exceed the posted limit to pass. If you're doing this consistently, over several kilometers, you're just speeding.
- smnrchrds 6y ago> Because tickets aren't just monetary And the only monetary aspect is not the fine, it is the also the increased insurance premiums. The latter can be much more punishing than the former.
- judge2020 6y agoI didn't know this was a thing in the US until a few months ago - apparently the local police notify insurance companies (somehow) of speeding violations and thus give the insurance reason to increase your premiums.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoIf the goal is to charge people who take actions that result in higher probability of losses, then it makes sense. Otherwise, drivers that have less probability to cause losses are subsidizing those that do. Also, in the US as far as I know, you can “fight” the ticket in court and pay the local government more to reduce the level of speeding ticket and hence points you get, so that the insurance company doesn’t see any speeding (or sees less severe speeding).
- loeg 6y ago> If the goal is to charge people who take actions that result in higher probability of losses, then it makes sense. Otherwise, drivers that have less probability to cause losses are subsidizing those that do. It's a noisy and weak signal.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoIt it was not a good signal, then a competing auto insurance company would advertise that it does not penalize speeding drivers and win more business.
- loeg 6y agoThis is a false dichotomy. It can be noisy and weak without being a competitive disadvantage for the insurance business.
- beagle3 6y agoIn most countries that don’t try to just fill coffers through speeding tickets, enforcement happens at 10% or so above legal speed limit. If the two cameras are more than 1km apart, that makes your point moot.
- gpm 6y agoTime of travel are the only ones respecting the intent of a law? Systems that measure your instantaneous speed will ding you for speeding up to avoid (or reduce the probability of) a collision. Time of travel as defined in GP only dings you if your average speed over many km exceeds the speed limit, a few temporary bursts of speed won't change your average speed significantly.
- megablast 6y agoWhat a load of rubbish. Driving fast to overtake will not make a significant difference, unless you are one of those assholewz weaving between cars constantly overtaking. It is ridiculous how blaze most roads users take speeding. And yes, most countries have a point system.
- yongjik 6y agoFor thought experiment, assume a five-mile stretch of road with 60mph limit, and "time of travel" ticket kicking in at 65mph. It takes 5 minutes to drive legally, and if you take less than 4:37 then you get the ticket. Assume you drive at 60mph and then you suddenly have to "speed up" to 80mph to avoid a situation. How long can you drive at 80mph before you're ticketed? 69 seconds. If you're driving for 69 seconds at 20mph above limit then you're not "avoiding a situation". You are speeding.
- scott_w 6y agoThere are exactly 0 situations that require you to break the speed limit to become “safe.” The UK Highway Code and driving lessons are very explicit in how you respond to emergencies and “speed up” is not on the list.
- brewdad 6y agoThere can be but only after you have already been inattentive or negligent leading up to the situation. My teen is less than a year into his license. The other night he was driving us in an unfamiliar area and missed a sign indicating that the 3 lanes were merging into 2. He found himself at the merge point completely blocking a car trying to merge. Yes, the merging vehicle is obligated to yield but speeding up for a few seconds with open road in front of him was the safer move than braking hard or maintaining speed and hoping the merging vehicle yielded appropriately before it ran out of pavement.
- scott_w 6y agoSo either he slows down to aid the overtake or it’s not possible in time and the overtaking vehicle slows down to merge behind. Appreciate these things are tough when you’re still new, nervous in an unfamiliar area, etc. but that’s the time you go back to basics on your driving to maximise safety.
- bluecalm 6y agoThere are very rare situations when speeding saves you. One example is someone going into your lane and driving into you for a head on collision. Assuming there is space to swerve you should also accelerate to escape faster. That being said it's so extremely rare there is no point debating those cases. If speeding was physically not possible it would be a better and safer world.
- scott_w 6y agoAbsolutely not. In such a situation, you don’t have time to look to your side to check it’s empty. The safest thing is to slam on your brakes and hope they do the same. If you’re suggesting someone is intent on killing you by speeding vehicle, then yes this pretty much never happens between cars.