3 ms·
> but not all that much (yes, really). Cutting 8 years(I think? have something like 2029 in the back of my head) of support from the thing a bunch of people ju
by detaro 6y ago
> but not all that much (yes, really).
Cutting 8 years(I think? have something like 2029 in the back of my head) of support from the thing a bunch of people just moved to, with no publicized plan what they'll have to move to instead in the next months(?), doesn't sound like "not all that much" for the kind of environments I've seen CentOS in. What's the plan for them?
- freedomben 6y agoThis is actually the big area where I think the criticisms are right and fair. Dropping 8 years was uncool. Moving to Stream is an option immediately (see post[1] for more information about how CentOS is NOT unstable or "the new Fedora" or whatever else everybody is saying), but there are also forthcoming announcements about new free RHEL subs for individuals and edu institutions and the like. I don't know anything about those. I personally think it was terrible to announce the CentOS changes without those to accompany, but hey if I ran things everything would be perfect :-D [1]: https://freedomben.medium.com/centos-is-not-dead-please-stop-saying-it-is-at-least-until-you-read-this-4b26b5c44877?sk=e500c2f16403d634ff8a4ea17d705252 https://freedomben.medium.com/centos-is-not-dead-please-stop...
- ikiris 6y agoDon't care. Nothing I run will ever run a red hat product again, and most of the people I've talked to feel similar.
- detaro 6y agoThanks. Luckily not my personal problem (or if it is nobody has told me yet...), but knowing how much hassle goes into any major upgrade (even if it's smooth sailing technically) in places with overly conservative processes, I hope those paths and changes get clearly communicated.
- freedomben 6y agoTotally agree. This has the potential to be a nightmare of epic proportions. I strongly wish Red Hat hadn't done that. At the same time if you take any piece of free (as in beer and speech) software and don't pay a vendor promising support, you are kind of taking a risk that whoever is doing work for you for free might decide to stop. In no way does that take Red Hat off the hook here, but it is something I consider. I've got a non trivial migration myself to handle before next December. Depending on how well Stream goes in my testing (so far it's been flawless but I'm not totally done with testing yet) and depending on what RH announces next month (or two), I may be cursing their names next fall ;-)
- cpncrunch 6y agoFor me, with a single production server, migrating to Ubuntu LTS on a new server seems a much less risky proposition to me than an in-place upgrade to either RHEL or Stream.
- freedomben 6y agoForgive me, but if you're just building out a new server, wouldn't it be easier and less risky to stick with RHEL or Stream since you already know your workload runs fine? You also already know all the packages you need and probably have config files all set up and everything. At a minimum I would think they would pretty equal as far risk and ease if you're rebuilding. My workloads are mostly containerized at this point so the host OS is pretty insignificant overall. Perhaps you're in the same boat, although I'd still think it's at worst equal, at best easier to stick with RHEL flavored.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y agoCanonical has not, to my knowledge, ever dropped 8 years of support off a release - even the non-paid ones! Redhat has. In some people's minds, that changed the risk assessment significantly; not "well it worked on this RHEL-family OS, so it should work on this other RHEL-family OS", but "I need to replace my OS - should I use one from the same vendor that just screwed me over, or should I switch to literally anything else?" Honestly, you've got people seriously suggesting Oracle Linux over anything from Redhat; do you have any idea how much trust you have to burn to get people to treat Oracle as a good option!?
- secabeen 6y ago> there are also forthcoming announcements about new free RHEL subs for individuals and edu institutions and the like. This is the surprising part. It seems like customer service 101 to have those announcements ready when this announcement was made. By not having those details ready in a timely fashion, they inherently devalue those programs.
- marmaduke 6y ago> the thing a bunch of people just moved to Yep, if this had been for 7, it would’ve been just “meh” and move on to Arch BTW or something. But I just reinstalled new servers to move to 8 and now that was a waste of time.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y ago> Cutting 8 years(I think? have something like 2029 in the back of my head) Correct: https://web.archive.org/web/20201101131417/https://wiki.centos.org/About/Product https://web.archive.org/web/20201101131417/https://wiki.cent...