3 ms·
I have one question in case Raph passes by: Isn't that a bit risky to go this deep? If I understand things correctly, you are currently trying to build a font
by littlestymaar 6y ago
I have one question in case Raph passes by:
Isn't that a bit risky to go this deep? If I understand things correctly, you are currently trying to build a font editor in Rust(runebender). Because there is no good UI library in Rust, and there's good reason to think Rust is a good fit for this, you want to build your own (Druid). So far so good. But, now you are also trying to build your own 2D renderer and not a basic one: you want to advance the state of the art in that field too.
Not that I'm not exited, because if all this lands, it will be super great for the Rust ecosystem, but sometimes because you're so deep in the rabbit hole, I'm afraid you get burned-out (or bored) and that everything would be lost because nothing would be polished enough to be usable at that point.
Is that a risk you're taking on purpose? Or is it just that you have a plan to avoid it?
Thanks in advance.
- fhars 6y agoOn the other hand, looking at Raph's previous activities, I wouldn't be too surprised if all those other things you describe are just project management kung-fu to put him in a position where he just hast to continue to do research that advances the state of 2D rendering.
- pavlov 6y agoI’m not someone of Raph’s caliber, but this reminds me of my own career rabbit hole. In 2002 I was a film student with a “new media” side job (that’s what they used to call web/Flash development). I had cleared my schedule for six months so I could work on an ambitious animation project mixing 2D and 3D. As I got started, I figured I’d need to write some scripts for a 3D application I was using (Softimage). Looking deeper, I came to the conclusion my needs were complex enough that I should write a small separate application rather than scripts. Then I realized my application would need a little compositing engine to mirror what existed in Softimage. To make that work fast enough, I needed to learn about GPU shaders (brand new at the era). Also I needed to learn about YUV pixel formats and media containers... Flash forward 18 years, I’m still at the bottom of this rabbit hole, sometimes halfheartedly looking for the door to go back up but just finding more glimpses into weirder wonderlands. I wrote another YUV compositor just a couple of months ago, but haven’t made a serious attempt at animation in probably 15 years. I wonder if other people have this kind of experience, and whether there’s some kind of law of “tech stack career gravity” in evidence here. When you become expert in something lower level, it increases the “career delta-v” to move back up.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- megameter 6y agoIt's a "forever project". [0] If you look at a lot of luminary careers, they also involve forever projects that happen to produce a digestible result. There's an element of needing a bit of direction and structure so that you don't go full "mad scientist" and lose your grounding. For me, the actual forever project, if I had to put words to it, is something to do with studies in the cybernetics of creativity, or in ELI5 terms: "why is making games hard?" It's not really approachable just by making a slightly better tool, or a great tutorial, or a magic algorithm, or by organizing a great team for a single project - and the scope is multidisciplinary, making it less legible what I'm doing or why. But if I examine all my attempts there is an orbit to it that is gradually getting tighter. With respect to examining low level issues in computing there's a huge pull to engage in forever projects because everywhere you look, the solutions being built on are rough-and-ready ideas rushed into production decades ago and then examined only occasionally afterwards. My own efforts started getting sucked into the gravity well of "perhaps I need to write a language, an operating system and a runtime environment to properly express this" - I managed to climb out again recently by focusing on formats, data portability and conceptual specifications instead of concrete ones with actively maintained production code - it's always the maintenance that is a killer and I can see that being an issue for Piet's current strategy too. Our ability to conceptualize always outstrips the daily grind, but we need to have one to stay in that grounded mode. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24917834 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24917834
- chrismorgan 6y agoOne thing that Raph is exceptionally good at is building a community around these sorts of things, and guiding it in the right direction. None of these things are being built by Raph alone, though he’s definitely still a primary worker in a lot of them.
- raphlinus 6y agoThis is a good question, and I'm well aware of the broad scope of my projects, especially spanning low to high level. A few things might help put this in context. First, Druid well predated Runebender, though Runebender is now the "hero app" (before, it was xi-editor, now on the back burner). Second, I have a lot of experience doing high performance 2D and font rendering, from libart to working on the PDF 1.4 blend modes in Ghostscript to font-rs. I've also been curious about GPU for a while, not least because that was what was actually painting the text on Android, and I worked on the Android UI team for almost 5 years. So now that GPU compute is becoming mainstream, I see an almost unique opportunity to apply my skills there. Third, I'm not doing all this by myself. I'm deliberately trying to cultivate open source community involvement and, really, building a team, though it has diffuse borders. Now is also a good time to acknowledge my long-time collaboration with Colin Rofls, who does a huge amount of the day to day work on both Runebender and Druid. Lastly, I published this in advance of a career move, which is becoming a research software engineer on the Google Fonts team. I believe this is a perfect position for me to continue pushing this research agenda forward, and I'm hoping will bring more resources and focus. There is no chance of me getting bored doing this. Burnout is something I'm watching carefully, as I have experienced it (it was the end of my time on Android), but one thing I discovered in my 2.5 years away from being a full-timer at Google is that graphics research is what I love the most, and would probably be doing even if it wasn't also a good career move.
- jancsika 6y ago> a lot of experience doing high performance 2D Is there a good ELI5 about the current state of 2D GPU acceleration?
- raphlinus 6y agoAs I posted to a similar request, this is an arcane field, and different things are meant by 2D - in games, it's largely painting sprites from sprite sheets, I think of it as involving vector graphics, and there are other contexts. I think a good blog post that motivates some of the main differences between 2D and 3D in the GPU context is this one: https://blog.mecheye.net/2019/05/why-is-2d-graphics-is-harder-than-3d-graphics/ https://blog.mecheye.net/2019/05/why-is-2d-graphics-is-harde...
- still_grokking 6y ago> that everything would be lost because nothing would be polished enough to be usable at that point. You mean like abandoning Xi in a "not good for anything" state after making big promises? Sorry for being "this guy" but I'm extremely disappointed about the outcome of the Xi project... Half way in coming to the conclusion that "building a proper text editor is just to complicated and tedious" is a complete joke. It was clear form day one that solving the over half decade old text editor issue would be a very big thing! And I'm better not saying what I'm thinking if this wasn't clear. I feel fooled. No matter how smart this person is now I'm extremely skeptical to anything coming form that direction. I have just no faith in people that give up because things start to look complicated. Especially as it was obvious upfront that things will get very very hairy. There's a reason the text editor issue isn't solved until this day and we have to deal with a bunch of 80% solutions. And now you're fee to vote me into oblivion because I've dared to criticize one of the geniuses out there. (No, I'm not creating throw-aways to voice an unpopular personal opinion as it's usual here; as I am standing to what I'm saying).
- still_grokking 6y agoCan't edit any more but got aware of a typo: s/over half decade old/over half century old