6 ms·
This really needs to go farther. As a purchaser of any product, I should not need to create an Internet account with the manufacturer, in order to use or contin
by ryandrake 6y ago
This really needs to go farther. As a purchaser of any product, I should not need to create an Internet account with the manufacturer, in order to use or continue to use a product. Once I buy it, it should be mine. I don't want to have this ongoing relationship with your company. This trend of companies making you tether yourselves to them in order to use a product you paid for has to end. I'm not a huge fan of regulating tech, but need some kind of "Right To Use" law that says once you buy something, it's yours and you don't need to connect to the manufacturer to use it, and the manufacturer can't revoke your right to use it.
- jariel 6y ago"I should not need to create an Internet account with the manufacturer, in order to use or continue to use a product. " This is a nice sentiment, but probably not possible given the reality of the interconnected nature of everything. The tech generally 'needs' the internet to work. The issues are: 1) FB requires your so-called 'real identity' which is something fundamentally different than an e-mail address. 2) Related to 1, they ban a lot, for various reasons. Those things nee to be disentangled. I wonder if the US/DE regulators are going to be smart enough to do something specific because if their redress is too wide, their going to put a zillion businesses in a very grey area. Thoughtful clarity would be nice.
- kybernetikos 6y agoBanning accounts that are the sole way a user has to access things they have 'purchased' should be made illegal. If that causes problems because it's also tied to a social media account, then that's an argument for social media companies keeping it separate. Imagine if a car I'd bought stopped working because I stuck a 'Find my lost cat' poster up somewhere it wasn't supposed to be.
- jariel 6y agoA car is not a service. It doesn't need an account. Most things these days are service-related and absolutely need 'accounts'. Like your XBox. Occulus will invariably require some kind of 'account'. 'Accounts' are not evil.
- tpxl 6y agoXBox and Occulus have no absolutely no reason to be services. Requiring accounts for no reason is anti-consumer and therefore evil. Of course online stores require accounts, but those are not required to use the hardware.
- jariel 6y agoThere is nothing anti-privacy about an 'account'. Someone having an arbitrary email address doesn't constitute a breach of privacy. Downloading games is greatly enhanced by accounts. Playing most games require accounts. Banning cheaters effectively requires accounts. It's 100% perfectly fine and there is nothing wrong with it. The hyperbole here gets really tiring after a while.
- tpxl 6y ago> Playing most games require accounts. No it does not. Most games are not multiplayer games and don't require accounts. > Downloading games is greatly enhanced by accounts. It's greatly enhanced by accounts _with the application vendor_ not the device manufacturer. I'd be quite upset if AMD required an account to be able to download Steam games. I _was_ quite upset when a(n offline only) game I bought on Steam required a Games for Windows Live account I didn't was. > There is nothing anti-privacy about an 'account'. Someone having an arbitrary email address doesn't constitute a breach of privacy. I said anti-consumer, not anti-privacy. Online only is also cancer, which is what requiring an account effectively is.
- inetknght 6y ago> Like your XBox But you absolutely should NOT need an account to use your Xbox.
- jariel 6y agoYou don't need one. But it's extremely useful in most cases, necessary for many things (playing other players, game accounts) and absolutely nothing privacy-invading about it. Giving someone a random e-mail has nothing to with identity. You're giving someone a random set of characters, so that if you chose to re-engage with that entity, you have some way of doing that.
- account42 6y ago> The tech generally 'needs' the internet to work. Most of the time, that "need" is entirely artificial - or at least not the only way to design the device.
- dessant 6y agoThere is a need to begin calling out Facebook and Google employees directly for their role in harming society, especially because they seem ready to rise up whenever one of their peers is mistreated. What would be your strategy for holding a mirror to these people and to make these jobs undesirable?
- patrickk 6y agoIs there a need for that? Why don’t we call out bank employees for all the fraud and deception leading up to the 2008 crash? Car makers and oil companies employees for polluting the earth? Farmers for allowing run off into rivers? Pharma employees for relentlessly jacking up prices and pill mills poising countless people? The reality is most employees have virtually zero impact on the direction of their company. The Zuckerbergs of this world will retreat to their private island estates in Hawaii till any backlash blows over.
- jdgoesmarching 6y agoIf only employees had some way of joining their collective voices to create an actual power structure that could bargain with executives and shareholders. Probably a bad idea though, we should just keep assuming that the founders lucky enough to reach critical mass will do the right thing for the world even when they are incentivized not to.
- Barrin92 6y ago>Why don’t we call out bank employees for all the fraud and deception leading up to the 2008 crash? Car makers and oil companies employees for polluting the earth? a lot of people complain about those all the time. In Iceland they even put them into prison. >The reality is most employees have virtually zero impact on the direction of their company I don't think that's true. Software workers, in particular at those large companies in senior positions wield quite a lot of influence. It's right that they're not owners of the firm, but they're in short supply and they command a lot of power. That said, even your average lowly developer has a very simple choice to have more than zero impact. Don't help them build these systems.
- 6y ago
- jedberg 6y agoI can't be banned by my power company or my water company. Perhaps if Facebook wants their login to be treated as an essential service for multiple products, they should be regulated like a utility... Or you know stop doing that.
- searchableguy 6y ago> they should be regulated like a utility I expect that's what they want. Oauth logins could be regulated by government in a similar fashion to mobile spectrums and it won't be easy for competitors to pop up.
- collias 6y ago"I can't be banned by my power company or my water company" Los Angeles is breaking new boundaries in this arena!
- e12e 6y agoWell, we already have Google fiber and Google phone service. So there are some utilities you can get banned from because of happy birthday playing in the background of a YouTube video or something...
- paulpan 6y agoI wonder one motivation (besides harvesting more user data) is that the Oculus devices are sold at a break-even point or even at a loss. So Facebook is essentially subsidizing the cost of an Oculus headset initially and making up the profit on ads data. Similar to the console business of selling the hardware at or below cost and making it up in the games sales.
- ahupp 6y agoThe Quest is a game console. How would you get content on it without an account? e.g, you can't buy an online PS4 game without an account.
- inetknght 6y agoThe same way you should be able to get content on any other game console or device without an account. Bring your own games. ... in the old days, things were distributed on punch paper. ... then floppy disks became an excellent medium of distribution. ... then CDs became prevalent. ... later DVDs came along and provided lots of distributable content. ... some games distributed content with DVDs. These days though... there should be nothing wrong with distributing your content via a USB or microSD card. Other than, you know, that whole "oh my gawds my copyrites waaaaaa"
- account42 6y ago> These days though... there should be nothing wrong with distributing your content via a USB or microSD card. Or just a file. No need to produce more plastic trash.
- robotnikman 6y agoAn Oculus account which is in no way tied to your facebook account unless you choose to do so
- ahupp 6y agoSure, that makes sense. I was responding to the grandparent post which argued for no accounts at all.