7 ms·
CentOS Stream, or Debian?
- doublerabbit 6y agoNeither. FreeBSD
- cyberpunk 6y agoFor infra stuff (storage, firewalls, maybe loadbalancers) maybe -- but unless it can run k8s it's not going to displace linux anytime soon..
- WillYouFinish 6y agoI'd love to use FreeBSD, but Docker still seems to not work and I depend on Docker a lot.
- whizzter 6y agoI actually like Windows as my dev machine and writing server software i would use less *nix-y dependencies to make most of my local development/debugging time and usually having mainly BSD as target but Linux working (with few dependencies coming from Windows both usually works once one is done since the diff to Windows is always bigger leading to fairly stable code). Now however with WSL2/Docker enabling easier development I'm tempted to take taco-bell style shortcuts, it'll go quicker in many ways but also reduce portability to other platforms like FreeBSD (that while a favourite overall ends up behind in total if i start taking these shortcuts).
- skizziepop 6y agotaco-bell?
- whizzter 6y agoBasically using built in tools in the classic "unix" way to do stuff rather than write code in a "lower" level language http://widgetsandshit.com/teddziuba/2010/10/taco-bell-programming.html http://widgetsandshit.com/teddziuba/2010/10/taco-bell-progra...
- tyingq 6y agoCentOS Stream defeats the entire purpose of CentOS, and is a completely different thing. So I think the title is the wrong question.
- whizzter 6y agoI think the poster is trying to make a point that it might be more pain for now to move over to a real community project like Debian, but in the long run you'd be less at the whims of IBM/RH overlords using you as beta tester (CentOS Stream) or at the mercy of them trying to handicap new "freeloading" projects (RockyLinux,etc).
- INTPenis 6y agoI agree, CentOS was mostly used as a stable distro. Now it's the dev branch of RHEL. And it won't even benefit from being the dev branch, there is no way RedHat is releasing security updates in it before RHEL gets them. So all updates and bugfixes will be pushed to CentOS Stream first, but they'll go out of their way to circumvent this for security patches. Just because of their paying customers. Makes sense but it's kinda funny. The OP is mostly about being a Debian fanboy. It doesn't even consider that Fedora uses pretty much the same level of packages that Debian has and offers stable release upgrades for 6 years now. Because Fedora has no such thing as LTS. But is that really necessary if you treat it like a rolling release? I'm of course a RHEL fanboy and I love stuff like SElinux and yum/dnf too much to go back to Debian.
- em500 6y agoThe OP is a Debian developer / Project Leader [1], maintaining quite a few packages, not some rando "Debian fanboy". [1] https://wiki.debian.org/highvoltage https://wiki.debian.org/highvoltage
- INTPenis 6y agoI didn't say random, you added that. Clearly you'd have to enjoy what you do to be project leader.
- edoceo 6y agoDebian
- candiddevmike 6y agoI think Debian is the sweet spot for release cadence--stable is supported for ~3 years, and there is a new stable released ~2 years. This cycle avoids the RHEL issue of a "rolling turd of backport fixes"/trying to figure out WTF version you're really running for packages, and the Ubuntu issue of not knowing exactly what's coming in the next release (users can easily deploy Debian Testing to validate the next version). Finally, the breadth of Debian's packages are outstanding, and Debian's backports repo gives you an easy, "blessed" way to use newer package versions without impacting your existing system.
- sm4rk0 6y agoNot advocating for Ubuntu, but there's also "devel" "release" where you can see the current state of next release. How's Debian Testing different from that? Edit: it's "devel" not "develop"
- bayindirh 6y agoDebian Testing comes in two flavors. Rolling and non-rolling. You can either always stay in the rolling state for Desktop and non-critical application or, get to the bandwagon early and end-up with stable release eventually. To keep on rolling, you can use the keywords (stable, testing, unstable) in sources or use release names to stop rolling when something releases (buster, stretch, etc.). The nice thing about using release names is the annealing effect during development. First major version bumps stop (feature freeze). Then minor version bumps stop (RC state / full freeze). Then one day you read that Debian is released. Congrats! A last apt-get and you've arrived in stable.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- CameronNemo 6y agoPersonally I will advocate for Flatcar Linux in my organization for any on-metal deploys.
- locusofself 6y agoI've always had a personal preference for debian/ubuntu, but in practice I've had to work on applications that ultimately had to run in highly regulated environments where RHEL was the only approved platform. Having the ability to have lots of testing environments running CentOS without huge licensing fees was a win. I don't know the specifics of pricing but I hope RHEL can ease the burden this may place on startups etc by offering a generous free non-production licenses if they don't already.
- bboozzoo 6y agoSo why not Ubuntu instead of Debian?
- Thaxll 6y agoDebian runs old kernels.
- hiq 6y agoThe current kernel on stable backports is 5.9.6: https://packages.debian.org/search?keywords=linux%2Dimage%2Damd64 https://packages.debian.org/search?keywords=linux%2Dimage%2D... Backports can be activated by adding one line to your sources. If I trust https://www.kernel.org/ https://www.kernel.org/, the last stable kernel version is 5.9.13, and according to https://kernelnewbies.org/LinuxChanges https://kernelnewbies.org/LinuxChanges, 5.9 has been released two months ago. There are plenty of reasons to criticize Debian, but that's not one of them.
- zozbot234 6y agoDebian provides up-to-date kernels in the stable-backports repository. You get a choice of what to run. And nowadays even the 'old' stable kernel is a LTS release so there's no support issue.
- discreditable 6y agoWith Ubuntu, anything not in the main repo (universe, etc) doesn't get security updates. From personal experience, I've broken way more ubuntu installs on a release-upgrade than I have on debian (zero).
- _-david-_ 6y agoUniverse may receive security updates. There is just no guarantee since they are not supported by Canonical.
- corndoge 6y agoSnaps
- gwd 6y agoThe missing piece here is drivers. Anyone who sells servers will make sure there are functional drivers for RHEL. Using a RHEL clone means you can always be sure to find drivers for your servers. Using a RHEL clone as the core of your product means more or less the same thing. Can the same thing be said for Debian?
- ryanlol 6y agoI don’t think this is a real problem that people encounter in 2020 unless they’re using some truly exotic hardware.
- zinekeller 6y ago> unless they’re using some truly exotic hardware. We're one of those (who uses, not who manufactures)! But in most cases it is not a question of Linux distribution and more of is it Windows (hopefully not XP) or not :(
- c0l0 6y agoThe solution to this problem is either dead simple, or impossible (depending on your specific field of work, I guess): You do not buy or deploy hardware that doesn't have mainline support at the time of your specific Debian release's kernel version (or its backports variant, if need be). $prevjobcompany lives by that unwritten rule for more than two very profitable decades by now, and I recommend anyone considering operating a Linux-based OS to adopt it.
- zinekeller 6y ago> You do not buy or deploy hardware that doesn't have mainline support at the time of your specific Debian release's kernel version (or its backports variant, if need be). There are glacial changes, but scientific instruments are often still shy on Debian or even Ubuntu :(
- bgorman 6y agoDo you have the source for these drivers? It probably isn’t too difficult to make them compile for a slightly different kernel
- type0 6y agoToo much of discussion has been focused on the system itself but aren't we forgetting the most important thing - all the packages that organizations depend on, some of them build in house with no resources to port to another system. It isn't as easy as everyone makes it to be, switch to Debian - ya right, rebuild the whole infrastructure - good luck with that.
- susam 6y agoI have been using Debian GNU/Linux since 2006 (Debian 3.1 Sarge). The primary reason for choosing Debian back then was the large number of packages Debian had in its repositories. Over these 18 years, I have used Debian for frontend servers, backend servers, personal laptops, personal virtual machines, team virtual machines, etc. What I have realized in these years is that its stable branch is extremely stable. I have never ever faced any issue with dependency management or package installation with the stable branch. Yes, the packages can be sometimes a couple of years old but the whole system is exceptionally stable. I believe it sets a benchmark for stability.
- iso1631 6y agoI used Debian on my home PC/laptop/PC from potato (2000ish), then testing, upto about 2008, but moved to Ubuntu LTS in 2008 for hardware purposes. On my desktop ran 08, then rebuilt to 12, then rebuilt to 16. Last night I tried doing an upgrade from 16 to 20 (via 18). Took about an hour to go through both. A couple of niggles so far 1) nvidea drivers broke, had to install the latest version with apt 2) Sound wasn't working from user accounts, pulseaudio complaining about unable to access the files. lsof showed timidity had snd files open too, and removing that seemed to do the job 3) clusterssh reported a perl issue - for some reason I had a ~/perl5 folder in my home directory vlc looks weird now too, but overall not too bad, and will last another 4 years. Not sure if this desktop will last beyond 2024 - it's a 2015 HP Z440 with a Quadro K2200 graphics card. Over time I've seen bad things with ubuntu -- changing networking, breaking logging by forcing systemd, etc. Ultimately though you can only delay change, but like Cnut, there's no much you can do about the incoming tide. Having breaking changes every 4 or 5 years is the price to be paid. Server wise we never upgrade, reboot, pxe boot, build the latest, then run the installation commands. Had various issues over the years with updating internal packages (apache 2.2 to 2.4 changes come to mind)
- mikece 6y agoHow much of a boost will this change by CentOS give to efforts to get Docker running on FreeBSD? I get the impression that many here are open to adopting FreeBSD but that Docker support is a non-negotiable requirement.
- mbreese 6y agoI’m a big fan of FreeBSD (in fact, I was planning to install CentOS on a new storage server, but I’ll probably go back to FreeBSD instead). But, I imagine anyone wanting to run Docker on FreeBSD would want to be able to run Linux-based containers. In which case, you’d end up with a Mac like situation — you could have command line Docker communicating with a Docker daemon running in a Linux VM. If that’s what you’d need, then why not just run a Linux distro to start with?
- joseph 6y agoFreeBSD has a "Linuxulator" so you can run Linux containers without a VM. https://wiki.freebsd.org/LinuxJails https://wiki.freebsd.org/LinuxJails
- phren0logy 6y agoIf you are looking for a Debian-based release for the desktop, take a look at Pop!_OS. If you can look past the appalling bad taste in naming, it's great. The software "shop" GUI makes it very easy to pick between .deb or flatpak (where available), but of course you can do it all from the CLI. It has sane defaults (if you are OK with Gnome) and easy installation of (non-free) nVidia drivers / CUDA / tensorflow. Steam works out of the box. It's as close as any OS (Mac/Windows) or other linux distro I've used to being ready to go from the first login, and staying that way with minimal fuss.
- internalfx 6y agoI can also vouch for POP. I run it on my laptop and my family's computers as well.
- Shared404 6y agoI suppose I'll jump on this bandwagon as well. It is a distro that feels like a full OS instead of a random conglomeration. My only negative with it is it uses Systemd in general, and Systemd boot in particular. If you are fine with that, it is just about the perfect distro. (I prefer open-rc as an init system/service manager, I recognize that Systemd makes sense for Pop.)
- zozbot234 6y agoSteam is included in the Debian non-free repos, so it ought to work in Debian as well. In general, Debian (Stable or Testing) makes a fine desktop distro, aside from the well-known issues wrt. proprietary drivers.
- pabs3 6y agoI'm fairly sure that Pop!_OS is Ubuntu based rather than Debian based.
- lupinglade 6y agoDefinitely FreeBSD.
- krupan 6y agoHaving lived through the transition from “using expensive commercial tools that run on expensive commercial UNIX” to “using expensive commercial tools that run on RHEL” I think I can tell you exactly why Debian was not chosen as the successor to expensive commercial UNIX. First of all, the general transition to Linux was started by engineers, customers of UNIX, who were tinkering with Linux. We weren’t software engineers and not super interested in how Linux worked, just what we could do with it. Debian was a chore to install, in the way of getting things done. Red Hat, on the other hand, was easy to install. Red Hat was the distro of choice for experimenting with Linux. The other side of it, the business side, is that RHEL met the need of, “see boss, this is fully supported, just like UNIX.” That had to be a thing before these types of businesses would transition from UNIX to Linux. Only after that transition would front-line engineers be brave enough to sneak a RHEL clone like Centos into the mix. Sadly, Debian just didn’t stand a chance in this situation. Fast forward to today and now you see front-line engineers hacking Ubuntu LTS distros to look enough like RHEL for the commercial tools to run on it. You still have to keep a RHEL box around to reproduce issues before going to support with issues in the commercial tools, but that’s much cheaper than a whole fleet of RHEL boxes.
- zozbot234 6y ago> Debian was a chore to install, in the way of getting things done. Red Hat, on the other hand, was easy to install. Debian was a relative chore to install in the pre debian-installer days. But d-i has been a feature of Debian since Sarge (v3.1, released in 2005) and it brings Debian to parity with other distros.
- rmrfrmrf 6y agoBeing fully-invested in one distro in the first place seems like an old-school approach to me, and I'd assume that, with distros like Alpine and BusyBox (maybe even throw macOS in there), it's more common for most people to deal with multiple distros than they're giving credit for. I've more or less gotten used to the cycle of figuring out which launch system and package manager I'm dealing with for any given system and having Google/StackOverflow open for the things I forget.
- Thaxll 6y agoI would argue Ubuntu is better suitted nowdays for servers vs Debian, mostly because it has support from a corporate and also because Debian once again is running older packages, notably libc / kernel.
- rurban 6y agoDepends on what. For your Desktop Debian is not good, but bearable because of the variety of packages. Fedora still the best, or Arch if you want to break your machine every few months. Some even like Ubuntu or Mint, but those should be ignored nowadays. But if you need a stable and secure server Debian or Ubuntu are a joke. There are no engineers with Debian, only lawyers and community managers. There your can use RHEL, Oracle Linux (with dTrace and ZFS), or SLES. Those do have the experts. For an unstable server CentOS Stream is fine.
- lcall 6y agoAs noted in other HN discussions, I have found Debian (a user since 1997) to have the highest quality of the distros I have tried (except maybe Devuan which is a close Debian derivative). Specific things worked reliably which seemed like they were inconsistent, broken and/or untried by their developers, elsewhere. And the Debian Policy makes packages and the system as a whole work well, more consistently, IMO. (Though I mostly use OpenBSD now -- when I have to use a linux, it is debian or devuan.) Edit: also, Debian is very easy to install, has extensive documentation, and (IIRC) commercial support is available. There are reasons that there are more eventual Debian derivatives than of any other distro.