6 ms·
You need so little water for drinking that it's essentially free or close to free. Properly trading water is more important for industry and agriculture. And
by eru 6y ago
You need so little water for drinking that it's essentially free or close to free.
Properly trading water is more important for industry and agriculture. And I'd be very happy, if some very 'thirsty' crops like almonds or industrial applications would stop because they might not be profitable once you take the full cost of water into account.
The alternative is what you see eg in California, where residential users of water often face severe restrictions, but many agricultural users have grandfathered water rights that they have to squander to keep.
- yodelshady 6y ago> You need so little water for drinking that it's essentially free or close to free. Yeah, that's developed-world life talking. Markets absolutely work at dissuading growing almonds in the desert. Until there's too much wealth disparity, and Peter is willing to pay more than Paul has in total for desert-grown almonds. Either Paul steals the water or he dies, and thieves aren't popular. Of course there's another form of currency - votes. I can't really say they're universally distributed, because FPTP screws up the purchasing power of a vote. But I'd give good odds on a very strong correlation between a functioning democracy and cheap water.
- eru 6y agoDo you have an example of a place that has both a reasonably free trade in water and where poor people can't afford water to drink? > Markets absolutely work at dissuading growing almonds in the desert. Until there's too much wealth disparity, and Peter is willing to pay more than Paul has in total for desert-grown almonds. Either Paul steals the water or he dies, and thieves aren't popular. Eh, unlikely. Peter will just get his almonds from the cheapest supplier, who is unlikely to be growing in a desert. There's nothing special about water in the scenario you are describing. Plenty of other commodities are traded on markets, and more developed markets have meant better and more secure supply for everyone, especially poor people. > Of course there's another form of currency - votes. I can't really say they're universally distributed, because FPTP screws up the purchasing power of a vote. But I'd give good odds on a very strong correlation between a functioning democracy and cheap water. Only some countries use FPTP. In any case, there's a strong correlation between any attributes generally seen as desirable. Figuring out causation is harder. Btw, you know what poor people lack even more than money: influence and connections. I wouldn't look to politics to improving their lot.
- yodelshady 6y agoI don't really care if you think it's unlikely. People dying of thirst where water-intensive, non-essential industries operate is empirically happening, now. It has happened in the past and will do so in future. Btw, poor people lacking influence is not consistent with how quite a lot of European nobles died or the vast array of modern working practices that are suboptimal from a capitalist's point of view. I'll leave the debate there since I've no interest in arguing a fictional universe.
- dnautics 6y ago> Btw, poor people lacking influence is not consistent with how quite a lot of European nobles died I believe people dying (noble or otherwise) is the recurring historical singularity we're trying to avoid; so we can both acknowledge that the poor can violently and quite temporarily gain political advantage while recognizing that during non-singular time periods (which is most of time) the converse is generally true.
- eru 6y agoWhich European nobles do you have in mind? Europeans generally didn't kill off their nobles much. (Mostly the French Revolution and the Russian October Revolution come to mind.)
- Dylan16807 6y ago> Yeah, that's developed-world life talking. Sure, but this is water in California. > Until there's too much wealth disparity, and Peter is willing to pay more than Paul has in total for desert-grown almonds. You're not going to have so much demand for thousand dollar almonds that it makes a significant impact.
- __s 6y agoWhy call out almond farming when dairy uses even more? https://www.truthordrought.com/almond-milk-myths https://www.truthordrought.com/almond-milk-myths For almonds you have to frame it about where that water is coming from, ie dairy from outside California may be less impactful. So the question should be whether futures will help sourcing water better in some sense Side thought: on things using way too much water, it's always amusing that more water goes into producing bottles as opposed to the water content in a bottled water
- s1artibartfast 6y agoNever got the almond issue. Why not go after beef, or fruit, or wine, or any number of other foods.
- dnautics 6y agoHave you ever seen an almond in the wild? It's basically the the thing inside of the pit of a fruit like nectarine or plum. The fleshy part of the fruit, which is quite moist and watery, gets thrown out.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoThe flesh is called the husk. What conclusion do you draw from that? If a almond takes the same amount of water per calorie as a strawberry, does it matter that it has a husk?
- dnautics 6y ago> If a almond takes the same amount of water per calorie as a strawberry, does it matter that it has a husk? No. But it sounded like you were surprised that almonds were so consumptive it the first place. I don't know off the top of my head that they are consumptive relative to any given metric, but it shouldn't be surprising that they are, considering how almonds "work" and how much they are produced in CA. Especially since you compared against wine. Wine can be extremely drought tolerant; there are wine fields in california that are only watered for the first season of growth and the remaining productive years are sustained by waters from the local aquifers (rainfall).
- tzs 6y agoI've seen the numbers that say to grow 1 pound of almonds you need almost 16000 pounds of water. But the actual almonds are only something like 6% water by weight, so when that pound of almonds leaves the farm for some far off destination it is only taking about an ounce of that 16000 pounds of water with it. What happens to the other almost 16000 pounds that does not end up in the almonds?
- jagraff 6y agoIt evaporates out of the leaves of the almond trees.
- maverwa 6y agoWhile the war about details is fought in other comments, I just want to say thanks for your point, it really extended my point of view. I was aware that growing some things over others (be that cattle, almonds, rice or whatever) consumes a lot more water, but I did not have that in mind when thinking about pricing water. I am still worried by the idea of water becoming a luxury good, but my view is less one-sided now. Thank you!