14 ms·
Honestly, while I have my doubts about this succeeding, it nevertheless feels like the big tech suit most likely to succeed. Amazon promoting its own brands is
by crazygringo 6y ago
Honestly, while I have my doubts about this succeeding, it nevertheless feels like the big tech suit most likely to succeed.
Amazon promoting its own brands isn't much different from a supermarket offering its own brand items. Apple isn't a monopoly in phones because of Android. And Google's search is so inherently tied to selling ads as a business model that separating them is a difficult argument -- plus search competitors are just a click away, as evidenced by how much Google pays Apple to be the default.
But FB, IG and WhatsApp are clearly separate products, all very much monopolies in their markets, easy to split up without huge adverse effects, and FB purchasing them was clearly done to neuter potential competitive threats.
So if any suit is going to succeed, this feels like it would be the one.
- pwillia7 6y agoAs I learned at my first company when we were sued for (bogus) anti trust reasons -- You do not need to actually be a monopoly to run afoul of anti trust laws. You only need the speak and act with the intent to do so. Using your market share to harm your competitors without a clear benefit to customers is enough to get you even if there are other large companies in the space.
- madeofpalk 6y ago> Amazon promoting its own brands isn't much different from a supermarket offering its own brand items. The huge difference here is that when you go into Walmart you don't announce to the company what you want to buy.
- a_crc 6y agoIs it really that big of a difference? You still have to go to the one section of walmart where they stock the cheese or car batteries or whatever. Walmart can set up their own shelves to emphasize their own brands if they want. If you pay with a credit card at walmart they can collect the same data about your purchase history as amazon would as well.
- gamblor956 6y agoWalmart paid for the products on their shelves. Amazon does not pay for most of the products you can buy on Amazon. The difference, in case it's not clear: Walmart is the manufacturers' primary customer, so it's irrelevant from their point of view what products Walmart chooses to sell in its stores. The third-party sellers are the manufacturer's customers. The manufacturers still get paid either way. But we're not concerned about the manufacturers; the antitrust issue is with the third party sellers. Since Amazon uses their data to come up with competing products that are sold in the same marketplace, it matters a great deal that Amazon competes with them, and how.
- colejohnson66 6y ago> Amazon does not pay for most of the products you can buy on Amazon. “Sold and shipped by Amazon.com” means that Amazon actually bought that product and is storing it at their warehouse.
- gamblor956 6y agoMore than half of the products sold on Amazon are not sold by Amazon.com. ( https://www.marketplacepulse.com/articles/amazons-retail-business-is-now-just-50-of-the-companys-revenue https://www.marketplacepulse.com/articles/amazons-retail-bus...) And a portion of the products that can be purchased from "Amazon.com" (the seller) are JIT orders that Amazon places with the supplier. This is why some products on Amazon are perpetually never "in stock" until a future date on the store listing page; Amazon has made the decision based on sales data to only order those products on demand. In such cases, the supplier will usually ship to Amazon for transshipment to the customer, but depending on the cost of logistics, Amazon may have them ship directly to the customer.
- mthoms 6y agoThe parent said "most of the products" and that is 100% correct.
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoWalmart pays for some products on their shelves. Companies pay for product placement: Sometimes, it is a mix - deeply reduced prices for a holiday display, for example. Soft drinks are often serviced by the local distributor, and they pay only for what is sold: If wal-mart is anything like the pharmacy I worked at, magazines and greeting cards are similar (only pay for what is sold, credited for the rest, and a rep probably takes care of stocking things). Walmart uses their data to figure out which Walmart brand products they are going to sell. Instead of using search terms, they use product placement, making sure to place their brand near the product it is imitating. Dandruff shampoo next to name brand dandruff shampoo: Mac 'n' cheese next to mac 'n' cheese. In fact, it is quite amazing how much brick-and-mortar stores can figure out about people simply by analyzing receipts - in some cases, figuring out folks were pregnant before they knew. [1] [1]https://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2012/02/16/how-target-figured-out-a-teen-girl-was-pregnant-before-her-father-did/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2012/02/16/how-targ...
- kevan 6y agoThe difference might not be as large as you think: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/06/14/opinion/bluetooth-wireless-tracking-privacy.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/06/14/opinion/bluet...
- majani 6y agoUnfortunately there's literally thousands of social networking sites, chat apps and photo sharing apps out there, and many of them have millions of downloads which keeps Facebook on their toes. Facebook can easily win this based off of that technicality.
- mrkurt 6y agoThat's only a technicality in internet discussions. Actual antitrust law in the US does not have a binary definition of "monopoly" that lets large companies off the hook.
- dybber 6y agoAmazon can be split on other dimensions, e.g. AWS as a separate company, delivery as a separate company.
- dodobirdlord 6y agoHow does cleaving companies apart into their separate unrelated businesses address monopoly practices or anti-trust issues? If Amazon has a monopoly on delivery, the parted-out delivery company will still have a monopoly on delivery. If AWS has a monopoly on cloud computing, making AWS independent changes nothing. AWS is not going to begin competing with Amazon's last-mile delivery business if the two are split off into separate companies.
- pferde 6y agoIf nothing else, it could prevent Amazon abusing its monopoly, by leveraging its monopoly in one area to slap competition around in other areas.
- GreenWatermelon 6y agoAmazon uses its cloud revenue to significantly undercut competitor prices, then raise prices again after they go out of business. Splitting these two will cause Amazon Products to be actually profitable. The platform also uses its position to push their products, products they made after gathering data of items sold on their platform. At the very least, Amazon shouldn't compete with their own customers (i.e. Sellers)
- s3r3nity 6y agoI have my doubts, simply because the markets would be significantly disrupted if the government can retroactively “unapprove” a merger over a decade (or longer) after the fact - AFTER the government previously approved it. You’re better off trying to right the wrongs through litigation that sets a better market environment.
- mrkurt 6y agoIt's not any different than splitting a company up into parts. Historically, that hasn't disrupted the markets as much as it's made sharedholders more money ... because the multiple, smaller entities are more valuable than the whole.
- dr_zoidberg 6y agoThe situation reminds me of when Google bought Motorola[0], and then the Android phone manufacturers pushed for them to sell it again. Which eventually happened. Main difference here would be that it's the government pushing now, instead of (indirect?) competitors (which also happen to be customers). [0] Good old times, I still have a Moto G3 from back then that works like a charm, except it can't "speak" to the 4G technology that got deployed in the country where I live.
- s3r3nity 6y agoMaybe, but I wonder if the difference in hardware vs. software makes the FB situation a tad more complicated. Leadership made the push a few years back when Chris Cox left to merge the code bases as much as possible. Do you trust the government to know enough to dictate how that should be undone? You can't, like, just run a "git rebase" to undo years of merging by 10000's of engineers. Then again, maybe that is just crazy enough to work???
- Analemma_ 6y agoIt's not like we haven't broken up companies in the past. It did not cause capitalism to collapse.
- biggermike 6y ago> Amazon promoting its own brands isn't much different from a supermarket offering its own brand items. Apple isn't a monopoly in phones because of Android. And Google's search is so inherently tied to selling ads as a business model that separating them is a difficult argument -- plus search competitors are just a click away, as evidenced by how much Google pays Apple to be the default. But these aren't the complaints being bade, at least not the ones in the lawsuits we know of so far. The Google lawsuit, for example, targets its practice of paying companies to make it the default search engine in order to maintain it's monopoly on search. It isn't seeking Google divest from its ad business. That being said, there's no reason search can't be separated from the ad business.
- aardvarkr 6y ago> That being said, there's no reason search can't be separated from the ad business. I’m not aware of a business model that would keep a search company in business if they didn’t offer ads to go with it. On top of that, offering the ability to companies to target their ads to highly relevant consumers is incredibly valuable to our economy.
- biggermike 6y agoThey can still sell their inventory e.g. impressions and clicks, but they wouldn't run the DSP/SSP (just like other ad supported publishers).
- dhnajsjdnd 6y agoIn other words, it would mandate the existence of a layer of middlemen between the search engine and ad buyers.
- gamblor956 6y agoAmazon promoting its own brands isn't much different from a supermarket offering its own brand items. Amazon promoting its own brands is completely different from a supermarket offering its own brand items. You're confusing a bazaar with a retail store; the two are nothing alike legally or economically. The supermarket pays for everything on its store shelves (except, rarely, for certain new products on a consignment basis in which case it only sales for units actually sold). Thus, it is irrelevant to the manufacturer whether the supermarket promotes their store-brand product or the name brand product; they've already been paid by their primary customer. Moreover, in essentially all cases, the name brand also made the store brand. In contrast, Amazon not only sells alongside its third-party sellers, it uses its access to their sales data to come up with its own competing products. Notably, and very importantly: Amazon does not pay for the third-party sellers products available on its website, the third-party sellers have to pay that. The manufacturers get paid either way (by the retailer, third-party seller, or Amazon if Amazon.com is the seller). But in the case of Amazon, the third-party sellers on Amazon's website get screwed, and that is where the antitrust concern lies.
- tracer4201 6y agoNot taking a stance on the main topic, but this isn’t entirely accurate. I worked at gas stations and managed a grocery store during my early days. It depended on the product. With Frito Lay and Pepsi products, they’d often times put stuff on shelves and we’d only pay for what we sold. Similarly, for certain breads and packaged pastries and other items, anything that didn’t sell by the date on the package would get credited to the store. If the item didn’t sell, it’s not that we always just absorbed the cost.
- gamblor956 6y agoNone of what you said conflicts with how the transactions are actually characterized for legal, tax, and financial purposes. Suppliers often credit stores for unsold inventory if they want to maintain a relationship with the store. As most B2B transactions are paid via invoices on a net-terms basis, this may mean discounts on future orders or credits against outstanding invoices. But you're store already acquired those products.
- poisonborz 6y agoBecause internet search engine, video sharing platform, streaming entertainment content division, or a self driving car division of other competitors are clearly products belonging together.
- wvenable 6y ago> But FB, IG and WhatsApp are clearly separate products, all very much monopolies in their markets What is the "market"? Things people do on their phones? What are they precisely monopolizing?
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoThat really doesn't seem like that hard of a thing to answer. E.g. just look at Facebook: name the #2 broadly "generic" social network. Is there really any other alternative here, at all? It really was a winner take all effect here, evidenced by the fact that all their former competitors are basically dead. Same thing with Instagram - anyone remember Hipstamatic?
- javagram 6y agoTwitter and Snapchat are the obvious answers here about “competitor”. And WhatsApp, of course, the competitors are iMessage, GChat, and MMS/RCS that’s already built right into every phone.
- wvenable 6y agoWhat is a social network? What makes Facebook different from Twitter, Reddit, HackerNews, or Linkedin? Basically if you define social network as something exactly like Facebook then, of course, that's what it is and everything else is excluded.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- SoSoRoCoCo 6y agoIf it doesn't succeed, expect more of the same from FAANG. Until we have FANG, then FAN, then FA, then just F.
- julienb_sea 6y agoA high profile acquisition or merger within FAANG is extremely unlikely. These companies are already treading a careful line with antitrust and a merger would be unbelievably risky. There is also basically no point on either side; these companies are doing just fine. If anything the competition is probably good for them. Netflix is probably the highest risk of being acquired by someone like Apple, or more likely traditional media owner like Disney or Comcast.
- efwfwef 6y ago> But FB, IG and WhatsApp are clearly separate products, all very much monopolies in their markets A lot of companies are like that, one could think that it's "easy" to split up Google Maps from Gmail and Google Calendar, or Office 360 from Azure and Windows, or Salesforce and Slack and ...
- andromeduck 6y agoFB IG and Whatsap are not complementary orthogonal or products in the same way Maps/Search or 360 and azure are.
- solidsnack9000 6y agoYeah, but I worry about the impact of this for rule of law generally, because those acquisitions were approved by the FTC. If something material changed or was omitted, I guess you could make the case for taking Facebook to court but if the issue is just the magnitude of the acquisition or the nature of the companies' business it seems like asking for a do-over.
- ashtonkem 6y agoI think another ripe target would be separating Google from content hosting, especially YouTube.
- zelly 6y agono one else can afford to host that much useless content except maybe the US government. the alternative would be that YT dies and nothing replaces it. sometimes there is no alternative to centralization.
- GreenWatermelon 6y agoEspecially since YouTube is, according to what I usually read in the internet, is barely (or might not even be) profitable. Google probably keeps it around because it's a source of precious data.
- julianozen 6y agoI agree with the above. I’ll also add that apple and Amazon are two of the most loved American brands. I think Amazon has a higher trust from Americans compared to almost every institution except the US military Doesn’t seem like a good political move to go after those companies in my opinion. By comparison, Facebook is loathed by both parties for different reasons. Disclaimer, I used to work at Amazon.