7 ms·
Good to see some progress in this area. As usual, it's important to emphasize that this research is about therapy, with MDMA as an additional modulator on top
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
Good to see some progress in this area.
As usual, it's important to emphasize that this research is about therapy, with MDMA as an additional modulator on top of the therapy. In this case, 15 therapy sessions over a period of 7 weeks. MDMA was only involved in 2 of the 15 sessions. If I'm reading the paper correctly, patients received 3 therapy sessions before MDMA was introduced and the bulk of reported improvements happened prior to MDMA being added. Looking at the graphs, there aren't any obvious score increases around the MDMA sessions. In fact, I couldn't tell when the MDMA was introduced without reading the methodology section.
The study was also limited to 6 couples, with no control group. Note that the control group in this case doesn't have to be a placebo group, because it's too obvious if someone has taken a powerful drug. Instead, the control group would simply receive therapy without MDMA and results would be compared. The difference would begin to show the benefit of therapy+MDMA over therapy alone, which is critically important in these trials. You can't just give people 15 therapy sessions and then attribute the benefits to 2 doses of MDMA.
People tend to see these headlines and assume that the drug is doing all the work, or that they can simply replicate the results by taking the drug and seeing what happens. This is usually backed up by a couple of random positive anecdotes in the comment section while anyone with negative experiences is downvoted or dismissed.
Please don't assume you can replicate these results with ad-hoc experimentation with street drugs. If you browse Reddit, it's not hard to find anecdotes from people who have mistaken the short-term effects of these drugs for long-term healing, which usually results in them reaching out for more drugs the next time they have problems. Once people convince themselves that the drug is the easy solution to their problems, they're on their way to low-level addiction.
- sneak 6y ago> which usually results in them reaching out for more drugs the next time they have problems "I hate to advocate drugs, alcohol, violence, or insanity to anyone, but they've always worked for me." — Hunter S. Thompson
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoI know this comment was meant to be facetious, but this is actually how many people spiral into addiction. Recreational drugs feel like they're "working" when they make the person's problems temporarily disappear, but in reality the person hasn't solved anything. When the problems inevitably return, the temptation is to reach for more drugs. Tolerance is real, though, so people tend to reach for escalating doses over time. The cumulative effects of drug abuse and avoidance behavior begin to add up, compounding the original problems and digging the person into an even deeper hole. That's why these successful programs are always therapy-first, rather than drug-first. The focus is first on identifying and fixing problems, using drugs to potentially amplify the therapy rather than avoid the problems. Sadly, most of these studies lack any control groups (e.g. therapy-only) to compare against. If you look at the graphs in the study, patients were already reporting massive improvements after the first 3 therapy sessions, before taking any MDMA at all. Unfortunately, I don't think we can draw any conclusions about the MDMA in this study other than it didn't appear to make things worse when it was introduced.
- girvo 6y agoThe other more difficult issue (and was my personal one) is when you lean on drugs (opiates in my case) to try and solve unsolvable issues. That’s a recipe for addiction, more so than anything else.
- RangerScience 6y agoIMO the difference between a drug, a medicine, and a psychedelic is behavioral more than substantive, although different substances do have more or less tendency for abuse. Morphine is a medicine until you take like a drug. MDMA is a psychedelic at a rave and a medicine on a therapist's couch. By all reports, there's no possible way to abuse ayahuasca. You will have more mileage with someone experienced, and more still with a professional, just like you would with other therapy practices that you can teach yourself, like meditation and yoga. AFAIK addiction is mostly about a person's life, and not the things they ingest. That's why rehab clinic success is so heavily dependent on the support network (or lack thereof) the person returns to. You have to have something to avoid in the first place to turn to substances to avoid them.
- mseidl 6y agoI remember reading an article or something that was something like "Soldiers with PTSD try MDMA, give rave reviews"
- uoaei 6y agoStraight from the source: https://maps.org/research/mdma https://maps.org/research/mdma MAPS does pretty much all of the coordination with the FDA and other regulatory bodies for making these studies possible.
- pmoriarty 6y ago"Note that the control group in this case doesn't have to be a placebo group, because it's too obvious if someone has taken a powerful drug." It's not, actually. I've heard interviews with researchers in other MDMA studies saying that there were subjects who were absolutely convinced they got MDMA, and acted like they were on it, but when the double-blind study was over it was revealed that they didn't. Never underestimate the power of placebos or of the human mind.
- crazygringo 6y agoWow, that is bizarre. At first I'd say it seems unbelievable, but then when you think of people in churches speaking in tongues, etc. -- I guess I could see it. But if you've ever done MDMA you'd certainly know it was a placebo, so it feels like these are people who never had, but imagined what they thought it ought to be like. I'd actually be incredibly curious to hear their description of it? Especially since everyone knows what people act like when drunk or on cocaine... but I'm not quite sure people have as definite an idea of MDMA?
- sushisource 6y agoIndeed. It's something I rarely hear mentioned, but I have found valuable about recreational drugs - they teach you a lot about how your body works and what certain things feel like. A lot like tasting a spice in isolation allows you to pick it out in a complete dish.
- tenaciousDaniel 6y agoI'd bet that that was one of the controls in the study - targeting participants who had never used MDMA before. Otherwise it would affect the integrity of the placebo group.
- twic 6y ago> But if you've ever done MDMA you'd certainly know it was a placebo What's the dose used in the experiment? Similar to a recreational dose, or much smaller? If it was much smaller, i could imagine people not really being able to tell. EDIT: The paper [1] says there are two MDMA 'sessions', about three weeks apart, and: > Each partner was given 75 mg MDMA in the first MDMA session, and 100 mg in the second MDMA session, with an optional supplemental half-dose 1.5 hours later in both sessions (participants were informed that the supplemental half-doses could prolong the therapeutic window of MDMA effects). I am told that a typical recreational dose of MDMA is 100 mg. More concretely, an Orange Tesla is ~250 mg, so make of that what you will. [1] https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/20008198.2020.1840123 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/20008198.2020.1...
- pvarangot 6y agoIt's normal to get the glowy MDMA feeling in a good "breakthrough" therapy session or deep conversation with a friend. So yeah if you just take a pill and look at the wall you'll know, but in a very warm social context or a good therapy session you may get the serotonin rush out of a placebo.
- ketamine__ 6y ago> Once people convince themselves that the drug is the easy solution to their problems, they're on their way to low-level addiction. What's the difference between this and being prescribed an antidepressant? I'd argue there is no difference except that self-medicating is much less likely to work.
- jskajakzkjx 6y agoMDMA induces tolerance and requires dose escalation for redosing after the acute effects wear off. It’s like benzos, heroin, or speed in that respect. At least it will stop working eventually so few people would compulsively redose every day, but I’ve seen people who did it every weekend and eventually had a very bad time. Antidepressants, on the other hand, are designed for daily use (and generally require sustained use to be effective). The dynamic where you want more so you keep increasing your dose to fight tolerance until you end up worse than you started is less of a risk. I don’t mean to attack MDMA. I think it’s great, and a lot of people could benefit from it. But I think this is a real issue if it’s easily available outside of a therapeutic context.
- loceng 6y agoNAC (N-acetyl cysteine) supplement anecdotally reduces the tolerance that builds. Time passing also reduces the tolerance - I initially was told to not do MDMA more than every 4 months maximum.
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago
- therealx 6y agoI actually had long term healing from MDMA, and had no problems putting it down at any time. Of course people with addictive personalities can get addicted, but thats true of almost anything.
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago> Of course people with addictive personalities can get addicted, but thats true of almost anything. reply This false equivalency is a common trap for people who end up with chemical dependencies. Just because people can get addicted to less addictive substances doesn't mean that we can ignore the fact that some substances are more addictive than others.
- spoonjim 6y agoA common trap for people in general. "My grammy smoked for 67 years and died at age 102!"
- loceng 6y ago"Once people convince themselves that the drug is the easy solution to their problems, they're on their way to low-level addiction." This happens with any substance if a person isn't actually working through the issues that lead to them wanting to "escape" temporarily. However MDMA does have the function of actually giving people access to suppressed-repressed trauma/stress, and once having access makes it easier to process/heal - this is why it's powerful to eliminate PTSD.