8 ms·
It's a private company. If you don't like their slant, use another private company. I swear, it's like people have never had to cancel a newspaper subscription
by shadowgovt 6y ago
It's a private company. If you don't like their slant, use another private company.
I swear, it's like people have never had to cancel a newspaper subscription before.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- SideburnsOfDoom 6y ago> If you don't like it, use another private company. Who are YouTube's comparable competitors?
- shadowgovt 6y agoI hear BitChute is flourishing.
- SideburnsOfDoom 6y agoWho?
- akira2501 6y agoNewspapers typically did not enjoy monopoly positions in the markets they served, and even for those that did, rarely did those translate into worldwide monopolies. Also, because newspapers have an editor, they are liable for what they print. Google enjoys protections from these liabilities, even though they're clearly willing and capable of editing their users content. The two situations are entirely different.
- shadowgovt 6y ago> Newspapers typically did not enjoy monopoly positions in the markets they served On average, newspapers definitely did. Most major cities have at most two primary newspapers. The difference between them and YouTube was geographic reach. ... even still, YT's size doesn't obligate them to provide hosting for high-bandwidth data. It definitely doesn't obligate them to put any specific videos in people's field-of-view. People with alternative viewpoints can buy cloud storage if they desperately need a place to host videos. The "Is YouTube an editor" question is a good one, but I have a hard time reconciling the notion that they're taking on new editorial behavior with the fact that they've always had both community standards and full control of their curation algorithm. Haven't they always been an editor in that sense, and the new concern is some people don't like how they're using that power?
- dylan604 6y agoMaybe prior to the 2000s that might be true, but there are plenty of major metro areas that are served by a single print newspaper.
- sangnoir 6y ago"We want freedom - except for companies": people who don't realize free speech cuts both ways, without irony.
- toxik 6y agoWhat do you think is hypocritical about not believing the rights of the individual should automatically translate to businesses? It seems obvious that they should not.
- hsod 6y agoBusinesses are made up of people, who have rights
- sangnoir 6y agoBecause in my opinion, freedoms should extend to every person: natural or legal, especially when promoting a absolutist view point. If you are going to measured/weigh rights against the rights of other persons, then those limitations ought to be extended to natural persons too.
- toxik 6y agoSo, since we do not have laws over atoms, neither should we over molecules, etc until we reach humans -- clearly I'm taking your argument to absurd levels, but it does illustrate my point. Something something seeing the forest for the trees.
- sangnoir 6y agoI don't quite get your point regarding atoms. What I was trying to say is humans are not the only "person" before the law - corporates, trust, clubs and other bodies are also persons, and should have similar rights (including free speech). If you can get congress/a court to designate an atom as a "person", then sure, the rights would extend to atoms too.
- neogodless 6y ago
- pupdogg 6y agoI thought Google LLC, it's parent, was a public company?
- ashtonkem 6y agoPublicly traded, but still a private company. "Public" in this context is referring to something being, or acting like, the government.
- noitsnot 6y agoThe monopoly that is Google and its products? There are no other viable options, I promise.
- xxpor 6y agoYou're free to go to $VPS_PROVIDER and host a video.
- mahkoh 6y agoAny attempt at making a youtube competitor for these reasons will get you banned by paypal and patreon. Any attempt at replacing paypal and patreon them will get you banned by visa and mastercard. Basically you have to start from first principles and create a new global banking system first.
- shadowgovt 6y agoWhy would you get banned from PayPal, Patreon, VISA, and Mastercard?
- speeder 6y agoThis is a subject I've been following for a while. Basically any content that is controversial for any reason, be it porn, government criticism in china or unpopular opinions, makes VISA and Mastercard wary that it will be bad PR for them, so there is some evidence that the pair is basically threaning to cut service to any of their downstream partners, for example if you google a bit there is some (sadly murky) evidence that they been threatening Patreon if they allow certain kinds of content (for example incest porn). So people noticed many particularly sensitive political videos, can only be hosted safely on outright porn hosting sites, even self-hosting is not safe unless you also own everything else needed, because the CC providers have firepower to threaten almost any company they wish to, including ISP, DNS providers, etc...
- monokh 6y agoWe've seen wikileaks deplatformed and there are many more instances that don't come with a legal power. Not hard to imagine the same happening to "a platform promoting dangerous misinformation" as is the justification from YouTube.
- shadowgovt 6y agoAh, now I follow. But that's actually predictable. Banking is built on trust. Trust is a societal construct. "It's hard to open my porn shop because the banks won't give me a loan and the town won't zone for it" is an issue older than the Internet.
- hnracer 6y agoYou're comparing a nearly perfectly competitive marketplace (newspapers) with an oligopoly due to network effects (social media). The customer has free choice in the former but very little in the latter.
- shadowgovt 6y ago> You're comparing a nearly perfectly competitive marketplace (newspapers) Ever tried to start a new one? The network effects are real in print media too.
- d_e_solomon 6y agoI'm not sure that newspapers have ever been perfectly competitive. Even in my midwest, midsized city, there has really only been one or two newspapers that achieve enough circulation. Similarly, major television media has always locked out socialist and communist points of view in the United States. This idea that only Google suddenly has a point of view in their editing what they allow on the platform seems really strange to me.
- hnracer 6y agoI agree they're not perfectly competitive but they come close (which was my claim). I view them similarly to the soft drinks market, you have moats due to brand such as Coca Cola, but vigorous competition with a heterogeneity of choices for the consumer. If I'm a socialist I can read Jacobin and if I'm very right wing I can read OANN, no matter my perspective I can find print media to suit. TV networks aren't a good comparison to newspapers/print media since they have very high fixed costs and as a result will only cater to markets that represent a sizeable proportion of the populace.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- andrewzah 6y agoThis argument doesn't really hold when you're discussing a monopoly/social network. Referring to youtube as "just a private company" or "just a video hosting service" is almost to the point of being disingenuous. There are no alternatives that come even close to what youtube offers. You can't just replicate a social network, and even if you could, who has the hardware and resources to do what youtube does? Vimeo is niche/specialized, it's not for general video uploads. Selfhosting via e.g. Peertube only really works in smallish communities, due to hardware limitations and word of mouth discovery. No other service has the social aspect that youtube does. The reality is that this is a much more complicated discussion than "oh, merely switch to another private company". > I swear, it's like people have never had to cancel a newspaper subscription before This is such a blithe comment that I'm not sure if you actually use youtube to any degree. It is -the- place to put videos and content. Nowhere else has the sheer amount of educational content, etc, all in one place. There's an extreme wealth of content that is not replicated anywhere else on the internet, much less spread across random websites. Youtube not only allows for discovery via topics/related youtubers, but it also incentivizes people to make content due to income both internally on youtube and externally as they build a brand. I'm not trying to be a shill here, but without youtube I wouldn't have been able to learn about topics like woodworking, chess, bass guitar, music theory, cooking, programming, etc, to the degree that I have , and discover great content makers as well. Not to mention discovering music that isn't necessarily on spotify/etc. So it's not so easy as to say "just use a different site/company/etc". What site...?
- shadowgovt 6y agoSo under what philosophical model do we justify forcing YouTube to host content that they find objectionable just so that content is more easily discovered using their algorithm?
- andrewzah 6y agoI'm certainly not arguing that. What I'm saying is it's complicated, and we (the people & our governments) need to have a discussion around youtube/facebook/twitter and private companies that are basically used like public utilities. It's not their fault, but the fact is there is no real alternative to yt/fb/twitter unless one wishes to avoid a large part of the human population. Of course youtube can remove whatever it wants, it's a private company. This doesn't mean that people can't find this objectionable, and it doesn't mean the only argument has to be "well, just use another company/site/provider". I think people here are -reasonably- concerned about YT censoring particular information and the precedent it sets. In this case you and I might agree with YT's stance. Will we agree the next time YT decides to take a stance and censors a topic?
- dextralt 6y agoI wholeheartedly agree. Private companies should be free of regulation and be free to do whatever they want, like refusing service to whoever they want - nazis, flat-earthers, homosexuals, anti-vaxxers, conspiracy theorists, blacks, etc.
- shadowgovt 6y agoThe reason we have specific protected-class carve-outs is because the default, outside of the need for protected classes, is exactly that. Private companies are free to discriminate except in cases where society has determined that discrimination is harmful to society. Now, if one wants to have a conversation about the societal benefits of QAnon, or broadcasting information that is re-enforcing the President's overt attempt to thwart the American election for his own benefit, we can go through the front door and have that conversation. But if one wants to fall back on general principles of "Businesses should be required to associate with everyone, all the time, forever!" we quickly find society has never actually agreed with that line. No shirt, no shoes, no service.