4 ms·
No, Democrats said Russia hacked the election results. For example Neera Tanden, Biden's OMB appointee, the President of a major liberal think-tank: https://twi
by rayiner 6y ago
No, Democrats said Russia hacked the election results. For example Neera Tanden, Biden's OMB appointee, the President of a major liberal think-tank: https://twitter.com/neeratanden/status/817744398939197442 https://twitter.com/neeratanden/status/817744398939197442
Trump claimed that "Voting machines were not touched" by Russians in the 2016 election. Tanden said that was a "lie." The media massively amplified claims of Russian election hacking that never panned out: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/01/us/politics/russia-election-hacking.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/01/us/politics/russia-electi.... They played fast-and-loose with terminology, saying that "Russia hacked the 2016 election" when they meant that Russia hacked and leaked DNC emails. (Part of the problem here is that the media has taken to regurgitating Democratic talking points. Saying "Russia hacked the 2016 election" is a clever way for an Democratic activist to describe what happened, but its misleading when that same "hacking" terminology is used by the media.)
Nalder said that, without impeachment, Trump would "rig" the 2020 election: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-12-08/nadler-says-without-impeachment-trump-may-try-to-rig-election https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-12-08/nadler-sa...
And people believed them. Even as of 2018, 66% of Democrats believed that "Russia tampered with vote tallies in order to get Donald Trump elected President": https://today.yougov.com/topics/politics/articles-reports/2018/03/09/russias-impact-election-seen-through-partisan-eyes https://today.yougov.com/topics/politics/articles-reports/20...
- tptacek 6y agoThe comment to which you're replying said "the government" didn't claim Russia tampered with the results. You can't rebut that with a cite of Neera Tanden, who was not in the government.
- Supermancho 6y agoThe 2 parties govern the US, for better or worse. The good faith interpretation allows for more than the official press releases (eg Trump talking points), which are presented to be in dispute.
- rayiner 6y agoFair point, I read "Democrats" rather than "Government."
- tptacek 6y agoI'm going to gently push harder, because I don't think you can reasonably compare what angry Democrats said and did in 2016 to what's happening in 2020. Nobody attempted to overturn any state's electors. The sitting Democratic president didn't directly lobby state governors and state house speakers to decertify results. For that matter: Democrats didn't deliberately fuck up tabulation processes to sow chaos to exploit later in the month.
- zaroth 6y agoThere were many calls by Democrats for faithless electors to flip to Clinton. See, for example, #UniteForAmerica video plea https://youtu.be/0z0iuWh3sek https://youtu.be/0z0iuWh3sek They then spent the next few years making up conspiracy theories and trying to delegitimize his election. I’d gently suggest that there are no clean hands here, and what Dems did 2016-2019 was sufficiently reprehensible.
- tptacek 6y agoYou've met my example of the outgoing administration lobbying state legislatures to overturn their own votes with a hashtag.
- zaroth 6y agoYou said, “Nobody attempted to overturn any state's electors.” I thought you might like to know that is not true. I posted a video which calls for exactly that in 2016. It’s a pretty amusing piece of history actually. To her credit, “Clinton’s team and the Democratic National Committee have steadfastly refused to endorse the efforts spearheaded by a group of electors in Colorado and Washington state.” NY Mag wrote a piece on the eve of the electoral vote documenting the extent of the harassment campaign, including hundreds of thousands of emails, hate mail, and death threats. Of course it also mentions Russia. https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2016/12/final-push-to-sway-electoral-college-voters-intensifies.html https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2016/12/final-push-to-sway-e...
- jjeaff 6y agoI follow politics pretty closely and this is literally the first time I've heard that anyone was alleging Russia actually hacked voting machines or switched votes. I had only heard about social media disinformation and social media disinformation campaigns. I also never really heard many assertions that any of this was significant enough to have likely swayed the election.
- cwkoss 6y agoRussian "collusion" was the primary topic on twitter for most neoliberal pundits and party consultants in 2017
- joshuamorton 6y agoAs someone who followed things fairly closely at the time, that's not true. There was talk of meddling with voter rolls, but changing of votes was basically not discussed and was quickly dismissed.
- jjeaff 6y agoWell, that was found to be absolutely true. Just look at the emails released by Don Jr. himself. They planned to meet with someone who they believed to be working for the Kremlin in order to get dirt on their opponent.
- Gunax 6y agoSo I think you're right in the literal sense, but rainer is accurate in the sentiment. The media used the word 'interference' in an exaggerated and nefarious context, and they didn't seem very interested in clearing it up. Election interference--without context--is usually taken to mean vote interference. Like many things, it isn't an outright lie. But I do think it was misleading. And while you might not have been mislead, enough people were--as evidenced by that poll.
- akavi 6y agoMy reading of Tanden's tweet is that she's rebutting Trump's first sentence, not the second. Ie, Asserting that Russian hacking (in the form of releasing sensitive emails) was plainly sufficient to flip 70 kVotes (Donald Trumps cumulative margin in the states over the tipping point) and ignoring the question of whether "voting machines [were] touched".
- rayiner 6y agoTrump's second sentence clarifies and elaborates that the first sentence is referring to voting machines.
- joshuamorton 6y agoSo what? I ask this very specifically because you're applying precisely the same rhetorical device that Tanden is.
- rhino369 6y agoEven if they meant Russian hacking influenced people enough to flips 70k votes, that's still unsupported conjecture worded in way that strongly implies actual hacking of votes. Calling it 70k votes makes it sound small, but its more like 1% of voters. 1% of voters making their mind up based on TRUE stories about inside baseball at the DNC? Unrealistic. I bet 99% of voters couldn't even tell you what the emails were about. And that's without considering the negative affects of the Democrats attacking Trump for being in bed with Russia, which probably cost him votes too.
- ilikehurdles 6y agoNeera was clearly saying that she believes that Russia’s actions affected the election results. Trump made two distinct and unrelated claims in that tweet. One claim was a lie, one was true. You dishonestly pretend there is only one claim. Neera was not addressing the true claim about voting machines being touched. Trump has a habit of mixing in things he’s not accused of and running on them to acquit him of the things he is accused of. He consistently did it by attacking nonexistent and unprovable accusations of “collusion” (an imprecise term that is not a crime one can be charged for) when the actual investigations, hearings, and findings centered on Russian interference and any of the campaign’s coordination of it. This includes direct communication with Assange as well as the Trump Tower meeting over Magnitsky Act sanctions. Your NYT article, in opposition to your stated conclusion, addresses infiltration attempts related to voting and voter registry systems, not the DNC hack. Nadler’s claim is only unbelievable if you memory-hole Trump’s attempt two months ago to start another misinformation and character-smear campaign against Hunter Biden. The impeachment hearings specifically addressed and exposed the early stages of this campaign. 66% of democrats in that poll are wrong, so we agree there.