13 ms·
UK warns people with serious allergies to avoid Pfizer vaccine
- klmadfejno 6y agoIt makes complete sense to exclude people with severe allergies from the trials if you believe severe allergies are likely to affect the health and safety of the vaccine. This is fairly common for vaccines. It's not cutting corners either. If you expect severe allergies to adversely affect outcomes, you don't gain anything from having them in your general trial population, because unless you make sure your data gather and trial protocols are designed to test for the difference, you're unlikely to be able to form a robust opinion on the safety of the drug for allergy sensitive people, but are highly likely to taint your understanding of how it affects "normal" people. (that is, you could probably observe risk fairly easily, but you wouldn't be sure to confirm its safe for them if nothing showed up) There might be something about being conservative to avoid what happened to these people without notice, but in the scheme of things its a pretty small pain point.
- choeger 6y agoPeople with problematic immune systems should not artificially activate an untested and unnecessary immune response. More news at eleven?
- null_object 6y agoNot sure what you mean by "an untested and unnecessary immune response" (are you suggesting that covid is 'fake news' or not serious enough to be vaccinated against, or have I simply misunderstood that part of your post?), but I certainly agree that there's nothing especially unexpected or alarming that a tiny minority of people with a history of serious allergies should have a reaction to this vaccine.
- Bootvis 6y agoA more charitable interpretation of that comment is that vaccines work by tricking the immune system into reacting to something that is not dangerous. The reaction is necessary to train the immune system when the threat does arrive but the initial reaction doesn’t have any benefit on it’s own.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- choeger 6y agoThis is exactly what I meant.
- Pfhreak 6y agoThe messaging thus far has been, "it's perfectly safe and highly effective." So it's quite important to share this info now. Also, what do you mean by 'untested and unnecessary'?
- artvark11 6y ago>it's perfectly safe and highly effective Does anyone actually believe that though? The us government and corporations have a long history of lying to the public.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>Also, what do you mean by 'untested and unnecessary'? The vaccine was intentionally not trailed on these people because of the risks. If low risk people get vaccinated then it is not necessary that this tiny minority get vaccinated because of how herd immunity works.
- _up 6y agoYou are wrong. "The notion that COVID-19-vaccine-induced population immunity will allow a return to pre-COVID-19 “normalcy” might be based on illusory assumptions." https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(20)31976-0/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6...
- choeger 6y agoUntested on people with serious allergies and unnecessary, because it's not a virus encounter at that point.
- odiroot 6y agoWe are, collectively, doing a big mistake, by starting with the elder population. The population most likely to suffer from side effects due to their weakened bodies. They're also the easiest to isolate, usually being out of the labour market. We should have started with the most mobile people from the working-age population. They're the super-spreaders and least likely to suffer from the side effects. Old people (and children) could possibly avoid the vaccination at all, when the rest develops herd immunity.
- _up 6y agoYou are infected with Media misinformation there is no expected herd immunity. This focus seems to be to reduce the severity for now. https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(20)31976-0/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6...
- annirun 6y agoI'm not sure the authors of that article would still support it on new information. The argument they're making is "assume a vaccine is 50% effective at an immunity response, and that before an immunity response kicks in there is still a brief period of time where you are contagious with a small viral load. (50% * infectiousness of immune person) + (50% * infectiousness of an unprotected person) = a lot of infectiousness" sub out that 50% for 95% (information that has come out more recently than the published date for that article) and the math looks very different. Still not "CORONA EXTINCT BY APRIL"... but much better than what you're implying
- f311a 6y agoThat's weird they didn't notice this when doing trials.
- OscarCunningham 6y ago> Pfizer has said people with a history of severe adverse allergic reactions to vaccines or the candidate’s ingredients were excluded from their late stage trials, which is reflected in the MHRA’s emergency approval protocol.
- swalsh 6y agoCould we get to herd immunity by not immunizing those people who are part of groups excluded from the trials?
- pjc50 6y agoQuite likely - I would expect "severe" allergies to be less than 1% of the population.
- belltaco 6y agoI think most vaccines right now have not been proven to have sterilizing immunity, so ppl who have gotten the vaccine can still transmit it to others who haven't been vaccinated. That's in the 1 or 2 week widow after getting infected themselves.
- OscarCunningham 6y agoEven if it doesn't produce sterilizing immunity it will reduce the spread by stopping the virus from causing coughing and sneezing. So it's possible that it will allow reaching herd immunity anyway.
- davidw 6y agoThat's how normal vaccines for things like measles work. Not everyone can take them, or they have other issues, so they depend on the rest of us to do our part for herd immunity.
- JoeAltmaier 6y ago...or any other similar vaccine?
- m-i-l 6y agoNot in this article, but in the BBC article[0]: "Both NHS workers have a history of serious allergies and carry adrenaline pens around with them." [0] https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-55244122 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-55244122
- rsynnott 6y agoIt's in this article, too: > As is common with new vaccines the MHRA (regulator) have advised on a precautionary basis that people with a significant history of allergic reactions do not receive this vaccination, after two people with a history of significant allergic reactions responded adversely yesterday, It's kind of understated, tho
- tinus_hn 6y agoGot to get them clicks though
- rubatuga 6y agoWeird that they say adrenaline and not epinephrine
- fred_is_fred 6y agoAllergies to what?
- _fizz_buzz_ 6y agoit's in the article: "Any person with a history of a significant allergic reaction to a vaccine, medicine or food (such as previous history of anaphylactoid reaction or those who have been advised to carry an adrenaline autoinjector) should not receive the Pfizer BioNtech vaccine"
- neals 6y agoWell... that's one way to find out if I have a vaccine allergy, I guess. If the first shot goes bad I'm definitely not getting the second.
- scraft 6y ago1 in 1,000 people in the UK have died after contracting COVID (this number is rising). 2 people out of thousands vaccinated yesterday had an allergic reaction that they recovered from (both people carry EpiPens and have a history of allergic reactions). Monitoring systems mean we know about this, so bottom line is everything is going well so far. We will obviously want to continue to monitor.
- ben_w 6y ago1 in 1000 deaths is of the entire U.K. population, not just of those who have contracted the virus. The death rate is roughly 1 in 28 for those who caught it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Template:COVID-19_pandemic_data https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Template:COVID-19_pandemic_dat... Which uses as a reference: * https://coronavirus.data.gov.uk/details/cases https://coronavirus.data.gov.uk/details/cases * https://coronavirus.data.gov.uk/details/deaths https://coronavirus.data.gov.uk/details/deaths
- burnthrow 6y agoYes, because one day is enough time to conclude about outcomes.
- bb123 6y agoI'm very interested to see how this sort of situation will align with the increasing number of countries/airlines/music venues/hotels/theme parks that are stating they will only admit people who have been vaccinated. It will probably take careful legislation to prevent those who can't be vaccinated from being relegated to second class citizens alongside those who won't get vaccinated. At the end of the day both groups still pose an infection risk.
- vmception 6y agothere are like 5 vaccines so just use another
- CydeWeys 6y agoPeople with serious allergies often have severe reactions to vaccines period, existing ones and all these new ones too. I wouldn't bet on any of the others doing much better.
- bb123 6y agoMy understanding is that with the exception of the Oxford vaccine, all the front runners use the same technology. This limitation could well apply to all of them.
- bt1a 6y agoHow will they verify that individuals have been vaccinated if the government doesn't supply that information? Also, you raise an interesting dichotomy between those who can't VS those who won't that I hadn't considered.
- bb123 6y agoThe NHS is providing a certificate to show vaccination has taken place. I imagine other countries will follow suit. I could even see it ending up as an official stamp in your passport or similar.
- 6y ago
- mittermayr 6y agoI really wonder if and how badly this will affect the already on-edge population on "just how soon they'll ring up to get in line" for testing, once they see this plastered all over the news this evening. And, I mean, even worse: pure gold for the antivaxxers, which is going to be a problem, too. I just hope people will understand this is part of the process and not let go of their motivation to get vaccinated.
- mindcrime 6y agoI really wonder if and how badly this will affect the already on-edge population on "just how soon they'll ring up to get in line" for testing, once they see this plastered all over the news this evening. n=1 anecdote follows: I'm somewhat in the camp of "Of course I'll take the vaccine, but I don't necessarily want to be at the front of the line" and this - to me - is irrelevant. So far it's two people out of thousands, and those two had a known history of severe allergic reactions. So this doesn't make me any more reluctant to take the vaccine. And, I mean, pure gold for the antivaxxers, which is going to be a problem, too. Yeah, I am worried about that as well. The last thing we need is anything to encourage the anti-vaxxer crowd and fuel their ridiculous conspiracy theories. sigh
- alacombe 6y ago> The last thing we need is anything to encourage the anti-vaxxer crowd and fuel their ridiculous conspiracy theories. sigh A good start would be to stop proving them right... again, and again, and again...
- joekrill 6y agoIt's really hard to tell from the wording of all of this what exactly this applies to. It talks about medicine and food allergies, but also says those who carry an an adrenaline autoinjector. Does that mean those that carry the adrenaline autoinjector for medicine and food allergies? Or anyone who carries one AT ALL? For example, someone who has one for bee stings - should they avoid the vaccine?
- gpm 6y agoMoreover my sister reacted badly to one specific vaccine... Should she skip this based on that or assume it's fine based on the lack of reaction to most vaccines. The guidance here is really lacking.
- hedora 6y agoThe guidance is intentionally lacking. She should talk to her doctor.
- gpm 6y agoAnd the doctor is going to have better information about this vaccine than is available to the general public? That seems highly unlikely - there is not some secret doctor only channel for information on drugs. Hence why the guidance is lacking (I would not be complaining if instead the guidance was "overly technical" or something).
- qw3rty01 6y agoNo, a doctor is going to have better information about the specifics for her situation and whether or not the risk of a reaction is worth the benefit of the vaccine.
- monoideism 6y agoHer doctor is likely not going to know any better than she does. The manufacturer, and the scientists involved, are in the best position to answer this question.
- hammock 6y agoThe Pfizer vaccine - and the Moderna one - both use a polyethylene glycol (PEG) copolymer in them as a nanocarrier. PEG in injections is a known allergen, and these very serious effects are known. Whether or not it showed up in the trials is irrelevant, it didn't have to.
- hutzlibu 6y agoHow hard would it be to mass test people if they are allergic? Because current polls show you probably won't reach heard immunity with voluntarily vaccination. But can you do mandatory vaccination, when you know some people may face serious problems? Those two people seem to recover, but who knows with other people?
- ComputerGuru 6y agoI think a lot of the vaccination plan relies on voluntary vaccination in the form of “business xyz voluntarily declares that all its employees must vaccinate unless they have medical reason not to.” Hospitals are already informing doctors, nurses, and staff that they will be required to vaccinate as soon as a vaccine becomes available and airlines have already gone on the record saying they will require proof of vaccination to allow travel. It’s not as voluntary as you think for a great segment of the population, it’s just that no one will go to jail for refusing.
- lm28469 6y ago> business xyz voluntarily declares that all its employees must vaccinate unless they have medical reason not to Isn't this illegal in pretty much any first word country? I know it is in Germany and France
- ComputerGuru 6y agoNot in the USA, no. Except if it clashes with religious freedoms.
- mabbo 6y agoThis is why it's so critical that multiple vaccines were and are being developed. So that whatever subset of people can't get vaccine X, well they can get vaccine Y and Z. And hopefully, this means everyone has at least one vaccine they can take. It also highlights the need for everyone to get vaccinated as quickly as possible. Don't procrastinate when the opportunity arises, because there are people around you who can't be vaccinated or can't be vaccinated with vaccines available to them. You being vaccinated cuts off one more path the virus can take to them.
- _up 6y agoNo thanks, the pre alpha test can do other people. On top of it you still have to wear the mask it doesn't stop you spreading the virus. It just reduces the severity for the people vaccinated.
- silicon2401 6y agoI second this sentiment. I'd wager a few bucks that all the people pressuring others to hurry and get the vaccine will conveniently be in no rush to follow up and check whether the vaccine had any health consequences or offer to help.
- strictnein 6y agoI'd take it today with zero qualms. Don't worry though, what is likely the "average" HN reader (30, male), is pretty much last on the list, so by the time we get it there will be tens or hundreds of millions of people who have received all of the various types of vaccines.
- spuz 6y agoWhat? Why? You are say "those who want others to become healthy won't want to ensure they stay healthy". That sounds illogical.
- _up 6y agoHave you never heard about the word "Virtue Signaling"?
- bawolff 6y agoIsn't this kind of normal for a vaccine? Any time i have gotten the flu shot they ask all sorts of questions about allegeries, and even though i answer no to all of them, they still make me sit there for 15 minutes after "just in case".
- Exmoor 6y agoYes, it's non news dressed up as news because it feeds into fear. Ideally people would read the story, come to the same logical conclusion you did, and disregard if they aren't in the small group of people who know they have this issue. Expect similar scary headlines when news outlets realize that they're not recommending it for pregnant or nursing mothers or children (because they haven't had chance to study the effects and effectiveness).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mchusma 6y agoThis is dangerous guidance because it ignores the risk of COVID. Both of these people turned out fine, so if anything this seems like an endorsement of this vaccine for people with severe allergies. There is no guarantee any of the vaccines won't have issues. Its much better to say: "If you commonly get allergic reactions to medicines, you might get one here. Use your judgement or speak to your doctor about the risks of remaining unvaccinated versus taking this particular vaccine." Let people make their own risk decisions. Banning the vaccine is how we got into this mess to begin with.
- mcintyre1994 6y ago> They are understood to have had an anaphylactoid reaction, which tends to involve a skin rash, breathlessness and sometimes a drop in blood pressure. This is not the same as anaphylaxis which can be fatal. From the BBC article: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-55244122 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-55244122 As someone who carries an epi-pen after experiencing anaphylaxis that distinction makes a big difference to what we're talking about here.
- TillE 6y agoGood bet that it's treatable with just antihistamines, going by my experience with systemic (non-anaphylactic) food allergy reactions, which display similar symptoms.
- Panoramix 6y agoAnaphylactoid reactions can kill you just as well as anaphylaxis. "Anaphylactoid reactions are defined as those reactions that produce the same clinical picture with anaphylaxis but are not IgE mediated, occur through a direct nonimmune-mediated release of mediators from mast cells and/or basophils or result from direct complement activation" https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3209676/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3209676/
- morpheuskafka 6y agoThis is interesting, I have never heard of this. I thought all food/drug allergies (as opposed to environmental allergies) were IgE-mediated.
- yummybear 6y agoHow many people were vaccinated, and how many would have this kind of reaction to any other vaccine (like flu)?
- mxuribe 6y ago> We know from the very extensive clinical trials that this wasn't a feature... Not a feature, no kidding!?! The latter portion of that read like something for devs to understand...I had never heard of language like that in the medical/pharma world...then again, I've been removed from that industry for almost 14 years now. My dark sense of humor wants to really laugh at this, if it didn't deal with such somber subject matter.
- drummer 6y agoBeware https://blog.kareldonk.com/vaccination-is-ineffective-and-dangerous/ https://blog.kareldonk.com/vaccination-is-ineffective-and-da...
- rawgabbit 6y agoMy son is severely allergic to peanuts. Wonder how this will play out.