4 ms·
> tight hips and a bad back To the contrary, that's from sitting. Remember we already lie down for 8 hours a day while sleeping. It's restorative, not harmful
by crazygringo 6y ago
> tight hips and a bad back
To the contrary, that's from sitting.
Remember we already lie down for 8 hours a day while sleeping. It's restorative, not harmful.
What you do need to be careful of is generally weakened bones and muscles. But provided that you're getting up every hour to walk around for five minutes (and stretch, ideally), or at least every two hours, and you go to the gym moderately, then there's absolutely zero problem.
- chordalkeyboard 6y ago> Remember we already lie down for 8 hours a day while sleeping. It's restorative, not harmful. Every morning when I wake up my back and hips are extremely tight and it takes me about 2 hours to loosen them up. However if I spend those two hours laying down waiting for my body to loosen on its own, I get up 2 hours later with the same problems. I agree with you that sitting also causes the hips and back to get stiff and tight.
- marcyb5st 6y agoYou should try a stiffer mattress / topper. I had the same problem because I was sinking, ending up with a weird hip angle. I discovered this once I went wild camping with some friends. Sleeping on a thin air mattress made me realize that.
- chordalkeyboard 6y agoThanks and I will.
- crazygringo 6y agoThat's definitely not normal. Have you seen a doctor or physical therapist about that? There are lots of possible causes, with possible fixes including a different mattress, changing your sleeping position/posture, specific stretches, and massaging specific muscles.
- chordalkeyboard 6y agoyeah but I got the runaround. You're right and I should see someone else. Thanks for the encouragement.
- mb7733 6y agoI have a similar issue with being stiff in the morning but I have ankylosing spondylitis... Maybe talk to a doctor.
- chordalkeyboard 6y agoThank you for the pointer and I will.
- inimino 6y agoI'm pretty sure future generations that look back on the health foibles of our modern era will not conclude that the solution to the health problems caused by sitting and working on a computer all day was lying down and working on a computer all day. Sleep is restorative. Lying down all day is not. Just ask literally any nurse.
- crazygringo 6y agoBut the question is whether lying down all day is better than sitting down all day, if you already have no choice but to work all day. As long as you're taking breaks to be active, it's not harming you the way that sitting can do great harm to your back and shoulders and neck. That's the point.
- inimino 6y agoWe have lots of data on sitting all day because we have a large percentage of otherwise healthy adults who sit all day. We don't have the same data for lying down all day, because that's not a thing that healthy people generally do. "It's probably fine" isn't a wise conclusion to draw from this state of affairs.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Aeolun 6y agoI’m not sure about that. When my body gets tired of sitting all day my natural inclination is to go lie down for a bit somewhere. I’m inclined to think that a few million years of evolution gave us the right inclinations.
- mulmen 6y agoSure we lay down for 8 hours but what is the marginal utility of another hour? Or 8 more hours? Is 16 hours restorative?
- crazygringo 6y agoI'm not saying you need even more restoration. Just that it's not harmful. If lying down were harmful then we'd wake up in the morning with big problems. Granted some people do wake up with problems but that's not normal, and often has to do with specific sleep posture problems (mattress too soft, stomach sleeping, sleeping too curled up, etc.).
- mulmen 6y agoThat isn't the question though. 8 hours may not be harmful but does that mean 16 hours is also not harmful? What about 24 hours? Where is the line? Is there one?
- rini17 6y agoBut nobody is suggesting that lying 16 or 24 hours without pauses is going to be a-ok. Just that it's better than sitting the same amount of time.