4 ms·
And something "too big to fail" like GM or the big banks aren't...? As soon as the state decides to prop a failing business up, it's no longer capitalism and t
by londons_explore 6y ago
And something "too big to fail" like GM or the big banks aren't...?
As soon as the state decides to prop a failing business up, it's no longer capitalism and the state gets control of the companies decision making process.
- Darmody 6y agoNo, they aren't. I'm not a big fan of governments paying up to rescue big companies that made billions and in the end went bankrupt because in a free market is unfair. But that's far, very far from not being capitalism. The action itself may not be the most "capitalistic" but after that the government doesn't take control, it's not an expropriation.
- SaltyBackendGuy 6y ago> in the end went bankrupt because in a free market is unfair Not exactly a 'free market' then if they're not free to fail.
- Darmody 6y agoThat's my point and that's why I think it's unfair. If my company goes bankrupt the government won't give me millions to stay afloat.
- vorpalhex 6y agoIf the US were pure Libertarian-esque capitalist, you'd be right. But we're also a country with medicare and food stamps and we recognize pure capitalism isn't flawless. Had a company like GM been allowed to fail suddenly then entire major cities would have seen unemployment go up 3x or 4x, and that's a lot of people who don't have jobs in a city that just lost it's primary industry. Most of those people are not white collar professionals who can hop over to SV - there are very limited jobs building cars. As a country where we do sometimes engage in non-capitalist behavior (FDIC insurance, jobs programs, so on) it's sometimes more efficient to prop up a bad business and let it fail slowly then to entirely take a hands off approach.
- 1123581321 6y agoYou will find many Americans critical of “too big to fail” policy.