7 ms·
This is ridiculous. The Bay Area, specifically Stanford and Berkeley, contributed to the WWII tech research initiative and then afterwards, Terman made Stanfor
by dekhn 6y ago
This is ridiculous. The Bay Area, specifically Stanford and Berkeley, contributed to the WWII tech research initiative and then afterwards, Terman made Stanford Research Park which led to Silicon Valley.
- bgorman 6y agoWithout William Shockley moving to the west coast, the "Silicon" part of Silicon Valley would likely be elsewhere in the world.
- dekhn 6y agohe played an important role, but all the work by military tech companies and stanford during the war did as well.
- obmelvin 6y agoAs you point out he could've chosen elsewhere to move. Seems likely the aforementioned developments helped him pick where he did.
- jgon 6y agoHe chose to move where he did because he was raised there and moved back to take care of his ailing mother.
- CalChris 6y agoThat's a counterfactual. Yeah, maybe Shockley's project happened elsewhere it Silicon Elsewhere could have happened somewhere else. But it didn't happen elsewhere. But you are assuming that it would have catalyzed elsewhere. For example, it could have catalyzed in Murray Hill, New Jersey after the transistor but it didn't. Anyways, people are always leaving the Bay Area. If you came here five years ago, first you were new here and second, you've known people who have left. So Keith Rabois left for Miami. Great for him. The question is whether the next Keith Rabois will spring forth from Miami. Unlikely.
- Apocryphon 6y agoMagic Leap is based in Plantation, part of the Miami metro. So- you're still right.
- auston 6y agoI believe they will, given the current Keith Rabois as a mentor.
- bgorman 6y agoIt is interesting how you can gloss over the signifcance of the inventor of the transistor moving to the bay area, and then use the example how his former laboratory in New Jersey failed to commercialize the transistor as an example of how Silicon Valley is uniquely situated to allow innovation to happen. A much more reasonable interpretation is that Shockley was going succeed no matter where he went, not that Silicon Valley is uniquely situated, especially with the dominance of east coast companies in defense contracting.
- CalChris 6y agoWhen Shockley moved west in 1956, Stanford Research Park was already 3 years old. Its defense roots predate even that. Shockley wasn't moving to a technological wasteland. https://steveblank.com/secret-history/ https://steveblank.com/secret-history/ Ames Research Center dates to 1939. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ames_Research_Center https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ames_Research_Center
- jarjoura 6y agoWilliam Shockley graduated from CalTech, and his connections from CalTech, more specifically Arnold Beckman, funded his new venture in silicon transistors. It's true that Shockley picked Palo Alto because of his mother, but it would be unfair to not also credit Stanford who had an outsized role in helping solidify the Bay Area as the hub for "Silicon Valley". Many many many companies tried to move the industry away from California since the 50s, and every time, those companies star players ended up relocating to the bay area. California's free-wheeling culture permeates at all levels, from investors all the way down to the individual contributors. It just wasn't an accident that Silicon Valley happened the way it did.
- maxwell 6y agoOkay, so if California's "free-wheeling culture" caused SV to be where it is, what factored into CA's cultural development? Why the lack of free-wheeling culture elsewhere?
- ghaff 6y agoWhile I don't fully agree with the parent, there was a long tradition of "Go west young man" for people who wanted to make their fortunates far from eastern bankers and other conservative industries. Very broad brush, but also not wholly inaccurate.
- qqqwerty 6y agoAre you serious? SF's Castro is the gay capital of the world. Summer of Love. The Emerald triangle. The Hells Angels. I could go on.
- nph5667 6y agoThe point was the local govts did not contribute to the the rise of Silicon Valley, not that no one in the Bay area was involved
- dekhn 6y agolocal govts did a few things to enable this. They created a welcoming business environment that allowed for rapid expansion. For example, Stanford Research Park was a joint venture of Stanford, and Palo Alto. I am not sure there is any good writeup on the contribution of local governments to silicon valley.
- claydavisss 6y agoThe did little more than let tech companies buy orchards. Hardly intense business incubation.
- hogFeast 6y agoDo you know how many local govts tried to do similar things and it failed? Local govt is not the essential component here.
- nph5667 6y agoIf you say so. As an outsider (although I used to work close, in Sacramento, for 5 years), I only can say that I did not hear anything about substantial govt participation, similar to post-war infrastructure projects, or recent push for green energy. But, of course, I will be glad to find out that the Valley is the coproduct of some govt program, not only a lucky star alignment.
- xapata 6y agoI think there's some truth in the synthesis of this dialectic.
- Cd00d 6y agoYeah, I thought it was somewhat due to Stanford's handling of IP. The argument I heard was that if you're researching at Stanford and make a productizable discovery you can spin off a company no strings. I was at Cornell when I heard this, where any company built off on-campus research had to sign over 20% of the company up front. Makes those initial pitches to VC that much harder.
- dekhn 6y agoit was a lot more. they built an incubator called Stanford Research Park as a joint venture with Palo Alto. It gave access to students (key to any tech company, getting fresh students with new ideas and up to date knowledge), access to VC, and nice facilities for tech startups. I don't know the exact terms of universities when it comes to founding companies but I don't see how the university can prevent you from founding a company, or demand a percentage.
- cjhveal 6y agoI don't think that's the case. I've anecdotally heard that Stanford does take some (possibly small) amount of equity. From the first paragraph of Stanford's patent policy[0]: > All potentially patentable inventions conceived or first reduced to practice in whole or in part by members of the faculty or staff (including student employees) of the University in the course of their University responsibilities or with more than incidental use of University resources, shall be disclosed on a timely basis to the University. Title to such inventions shall be assigned to the University, regardless of the source of funding, if any. For an example of an institution with the kind of IP policy you're describing, the University of Waterloo in Canada has a policy[1] that by default assigns IP to creators rather than the institution: > Except as stipulated below, it is University policy that ownership of rights in IP created in the course of teaching and research activities belong to the creator(s). [0]: https://doresearch.stanford.edu/policies/research-policy-handbook/intellectual-property/inventions-patents-and-licensing https://doresearch.stanford.edu/policies/research-policy-han... [1]: https://uwaterloo.ca/secretariat/policies-procedures-guidelines/policies/policy-73-intellectual-property-rights https://uwaterloo.ca/secretariat/policies-procedures-guideli...
- 6y ago
- LeifCarrotson 6y agoNo one disputes that those events you cite happened. However, those events were essentially random, not caused by local efforts to stimulate industry. Because of them, the area was blessed/cursed with an excess of productivity that it didn't know how to cause. Now it's just coasting downhill, unable to maintain the altitude that it once had because it never knew how to (was never possible to?) build that altitude without a big dose of random luck.
- dekhn 6y agoStanford Research Park was a joint venture between Stanford and the city of palo alto. It was highly non-random.
- maxwell 6y agoLots of failed research parks, oil wells, railroads, gold mining operations. The thing with oil wells, railroads, and gold mining, is that geography/geology matters more than path dependence. Silicon Valley and Hollywood, and to a lesser extent NYC and London, are more about path dependence. Their dominance in their sectors seem more resulting from, if anything specific to point to, legal factors, than geography or any particular natural resource/phenomenon. Why make movies and software in California, one in the south and the other a bit more north? The founding of Hollywood was just as random as the events that "caused" the rise of the Valley. What if Griffith had gone elsewhere? What if Edison hadn't enforced his patents, causing the exodus across the country to make movies out of his purview? Similar climate/environs/affordability elsewhere, why not AZ, NM, TX, GA, FL? This is a lot different than, say, the reasons for North Carolina to eventually beat New England in textile production, or why the Rust Belt is where it is, or why rail and shipbuilding was big in the Northeast but not so much space and auto manufacturing. It's more like why the appliances that are made in the U.S. are mostly made in the south.
- Bluestein 6y agoI honestly do not understand the downvotes. These are perfectly valid points, well argued ... Edit: Was grayed out when first seen.-
- lock-free 6y agoLots of places contributed to WWII research initiatives. Why not Chicago, where the first nuclear reactor was built? Or Boston, with MIT whose research labs churned out fire control systems and computers? Or Los Angeles, with its defense powerhouses and UCLA/Cal-Tech? Or Detroit? Or anywhere else in the US with given the wartime mobilization? Because Shockley moved here. Fairchild was founded here, and the Fairchildren built Silicon Valley and its venture capitalism.
- dekhn 6y agoMIT had a similar revolution centered around Route 128.
- ylhert 6y agoWhat about other municipalities/areas who have great universities and contributed to WW2? There are many examples of areas with similar initiatives and prestigious universities but have not reaped the same outsized rewards over the past 60-80 years as SFBA. So I would posit that it is more luck than execution, and thus qualifies as a resource curse
- lotsofpulp 6y agoThe lack of non compete bans anywhere else in the country is not luck though, and other worker protections that prevent legal liability for stuff you work on outside of work.
- JDulin 6y agoYes, but as he correctly points out, none of those things were done by the local govts.
- abhinavsharma 6y agoThis lecture by Steve Blank at the Computer History Museum is a great summary of the growth of Silicon Valley https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ZTC_RxWN_xo https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ZTC_RxWN_xo
- ed_balls 6y agoCould you make a similar statement in 1970 about Detroit?
- techelite 6y ago"Detroit" moved to the suburbs. Check out the statistics for Oakland county (and possibly macomb county for the blue collar workers). Toyota, GM, Ford, Chrysler, Nissan, VW, and all their parts suppliers(and the supplier parts suppliers) have at minimum a white collar office in south east Michigan. The event that caused the Exodus from Detroit was the Race Riots. You can Google that because I'm not touching that topic.(and it doesn't help Detroit has a 1% tax)
- ed_balls 6y ago>"Detroit" moved to the suburbs Similar thing can happen to SV. People moving to "suburbs" -> other parts of CA.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoMost people I know would choose to live in a temperate climate with low humidity if they had the option. Detroit might have been economically useful due to certain modes of travel and location of population at the time, but that may not be relevant anymore.
- 8ytecoder 6y agoIt's also the strong anti-non-compete of CA that allowed the flourishing and spread of technology and know-how.