6 ms·
WW1 trench fever identified in former homeless man in Canada
- scottisbrave84 6y agoCheck all homeless everywhere for this. Team please assist!
- CryptoPunk 6y agoCanada has these problems not due to lack of social welfare spending, but due to institutional barriers to taking drug addicts off the street and into long-term care homes. Vancouver used to have a mental institution where the patients worked a farm. When it closed, its DTES district swelled with drug addicts whose condition rapidly deteriorated from drug use. Involuntary commitment and forced labor are not exactly amenable to liberal democracy, so it's understandable why there was such pressure to close the institutions and repeal vagrancy laws, but now the pro-leniency movement has gone too far, and all across liberal cities it's become a free-for-all that is absolutely devasting all parties involved: the ordinary citizens who become victims of rampant property crime, the vulnerable who are predated upon by drug dealers and who themselves commit vast amounts of crime to feed their habits, and the taxpayer whose hard-earned resources are thrown into a money pit with worse than neutral effects.
- devwastaken 6y agoCurrently this is compounded by the outrageous cost of living in any city and the heavy discrimination towards the homeless. Further away but still canada Ontario is $1200 cad for a 2 bedroom and $900 for single, that's at it's cheapest point. However If you're paying for it by welfare be it disability or Ontarios version of unemployment - you'll be denied. Doesn't matter if you have the money upfront and guaranteed, landlords don't want people who are homeless. Government housing is a 2-5 year waiting list. There's people right now on disability whom can have rent covered in its entirety, apartment complex landlords refuse. Yet some wonder how homelessness continues.
- thrower123 6y agoQuite frankly it is not worth the pain and expense of leasing housing to people who are on section 8 or similar welfare programs, if you are an independent landlord. Margins are not great to begin with, and a tenant that trashes the place or refuses to pay, quickly wipes out any profits. It's not a very good risk to take in the current market.
- badconvincer 6y agoIf I remember correctly the government pays you to house the tenants. But yes, they trash the premises and speaking to someone that does this, the only way the margins work is if you do all the fixes yourself.
- CryptoPunk 6y ago>>the heavy discrimination towards the homeless There was heavier discrimination towards the homeless in the past, with vagrancy laws for instance. The situation has gotten much worse as society has become more tolerant of homelessness/drug-use while providing far more services to those in that lifestyle. Housing costs are indeed a problem however. The largest cities in Canada, as in the US, have seen rental rates increase as a share of average income. One study looking at the US blames this on rising restrictions on land-use since the 1960s, which has prevented housing supply from expanding to the meet the growth in housing demand: https://web.archive.org/web/20201117212350/https://eml.berkeley.edu/~moretti/growth.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20201117212350/https://eml.berke...
- Chris2048 6y ago> Doesn't matter if you have the money upfront and guaranteed What kind of guarantee is provided?
- treeman79 6y agoHad an in law that abused and assaulted many people in Ontario area. Including kidnapping and elderly person. Entire extended family was begging police To arrest him. They absolutely would not do anything. I personally spent thousands on efforts to assist him. Some people are just scum. Oh and he always had some sweet girlfriend that he abused like crazy. Each one would take a couple of years to wake up that he was just using them.
- hutzlibu 6y ago"Some people are just scum." Sadly yes. There are usually thousands of reason, why they became scum in the first place and it is important to ask those questions and find ways of improvement - but those are not helpful for the present situation at hand, when others have to deal with actual fear.
- treeman79 6y agoHe had a mother that gave him everything he wanted, and made excuses for him at every stage. His sister was raised by a strict dad. She has her own problems from it, but can function in society.
- hutzlibu 6y ago"He had a mother that gave him everything he wanted, and made excuses for him at every stage." Yeah well, that sounds like the reason. Pretty much Eric Cartman stereotype (from south park).
- OJFord 6y agoWhy is this so downvoted? I'm unfamiliar (and not Canadian) but it seems informative, apolitical, and not rebuked in replies (so far anyway).
- DFHippie 6y agoWhy it does not sound apolitical to some: * not exactly amenable to liberal democracy * the pro-leniency movement * has gone too far, * all across liberal cities * it's become a free-for-all * absolutely devastating all parties involved * the ordinary citizens who become victims * rampant property crime * the vulnerable who are predated upon by drug dealers * who themselves commit vast amounts of crime * feed their habits * the taxpayer * hard-earned resources * thrown * a money pit * worse than neutral effects This reads as a list of right-wing scare phrases used in any political campaign to motivate conservative voting. This doesn't read as apolitical to people who actually live in the places these phrases are applied to and it seems to be characterizing the people in these places, "liberal cities", as either fools or sub-human villains. Also, if you are one of the people demonized you don't recognize yourself in the description.
- CryptoPunk 6y ago>>not exactly amenable to liberal democracy I'm a big fan of liberal democracy, so this was an argument against involuntary commitment and forced labor, not an argument against liberal democracy. The 'liberal democracy' reference is not using 'liberal' in the same context as the 'liberal cities' I referred to later. >>the vulnerable who are predated upon by drug dealers I wouldn't characterize that as a talking point associated with the right at all. The left is known for displacing blame for the misbehavior of drug addicts onto external forces, and this particular point does the same. Though it does sound critical of drug dealers, which is a right-ish argument. Anyway, it's impossible to not sound political, when the problem is political. And it's impossible to not be critical of the left, when it is mostly the left that is to blame. Left-wing run cities are much worse off than right-wing ones with respect to homelessness, violent crime, drug-abuse, etc, by any metric you look at, and they got that way, from a starting state of much greater social order and more functional civic life, under decades of left-wing policies that gradually became more extreme.
- bregma 6y agoStalin had a much better idea: ship the mental defectives off to gulags in Siberia. It's important to consider the criteria used when we select individuals for internment. One should also well consider the quantity of dog-whistles one embeds in a neutral-appearing comment. Using 'liberal' as an epithet, using the term 'ordinary citizens' to distinguish from those who need to be deprived of rights, bringing the idea of those who pay taxes as being especially worthy of government protection... these are all talk radio jingo. A governing institution that interns individuals based on being different, or not morially aligned, of not thinking the correct thoughts has been tried often in the past and indeed there are many regimes around the world who still do so today. If society feels the need to institutionalize people for their thoughts it should at least formalize the crime in law and open the process to justice instead of relying on the fiat of those who hold the reigns of power.
- Chris2048 6y agoAlternatively, maybe a neutral-appearing comment is indeed neutral, and doesn't contain "dog-whistles" just because you disagree with it. By saying it contains such things you are assigning a sinister motive to the comment without requiring evidence, because it's a "dog-whistle", so we have to trust you that 'liberal' is being used as an epithet, or that using 'ordinary citizens' to distinguish the homeless is something sinister. > governing institution that interns individuals based on being different, or not morially aligned, of not thinking the correct thoughts You are talking about what? apartheid? communist regimes? Homeless people aren't being treated differently for "not thinking the correct thoughts", or "not being morally aligned". They are treated differently from ordinary people, but if any ordinary person did the same they would be treated that way too. Being treated differently based on behaviour is not necessarily wrong.
- bregma 6y ago> Homeless people aren't being treated differently for "not thinking the correct thoughts", or "not being morally aligned". Homeless people who hear voices or are delusional are treated differently precisely because they are not thinking the correct thoughts. Homeless people who indulge in self-mediation with alcohol or other drugs are treated differently precisely because those behaviours are not considered morally aligned. > They are treated differently from ordinary people, but if any ordinary person did the same they would be treated that way too. Plenty of people with homes are addicts. Plenty of people with homes suffer from depression or other conditions. I don't read a lot about how they should be rounded up by the authorities and reformed or institutionalized. > Being treated differently based on behaviour is not necessarily wrong. In the 1930s Soviet Union under Josef Stalin, political opposition was considered a mental illness just like schizophrenia and hysteria. You were considered crazy of you did not support the regime. Thousands of these crazies were rounded up, often in the middle of the night, and institutionalized in an attempt to cure them. The fresh air and honest labour of camps in Siberia were considered just the thing to help. Sure, it's not necessarily wrong to treat someone differently based on behaviour. We consider it reasonable to isolate an individual who demonstrably poses a danger to others. The line is poorly drawn when it comes to differentiating between danger and inconvenience. Is seeing someone in a park smelling like urine and talking to someone you can't see enough of a threat to be isolated and force-fed mind-altering drugs? Does making unproven accusations demonstrate enough possibility of danger that we should "lock her up"? Where does the line get drawn, and who has the privilege of drawing it?
- DoreenMichele 6y agoHepatitis A seems to have resurged in San Diego, California a bit over three years ago. It traveled north from there and reached Washington state I think like over a year ago. In the meantime, I've seen articles about "the return of Medieval diseases" to California on the front page of HN. The reason this stuff should concern you is not simply compassion for the poorest of the poor but because disease can be caught by anyone. If you create conditions that serve as a breeding ground for serious illness in some people, you create conditions that put everyone at risk. This is also why more developed countries need to be concerned with what goes on in less developed countries: We are breeding antibiotic resistant infections in some places due to a lack of adequate hygiene and then sometimes those people get medevaced elsewhere for treatment. The issue here is not "Wow, we treat homeless people like crap!" Yeah, we do. The issue is "And even if you don't care how we treat homeless people, you should care that we are breeding diseases that we see as in the past and this puts everyone at risk." Social justice issues are public health issues a la "The life you save may be your own."
- swiley 6y agoAnd our new president says that state should be used as a model for housing.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- eganist 6y ago> And our new president says that state should be used as a model for housing. Hey, do you have a specific source so that I can read further? I tried googling but to no avail.
- swiley 6y agoYes, sorry I couldn't send it this morning. He talks about it on his campaign website: https://joebiden.com/housing/ https://joebiden.com/housing/
- 6y ago
- georgecmu 6y agoAs the article states, this is somewhat common in homeless populations. It should have clarified that it's spread by body lice [1], not head lice, which cause millions of infestations in the US elementary schools, but otherwise are relatively harmless [2]. PS. This is confusing in light of [3]. [1] https://emedicine.medscape.com/article/230294-overview https://emedicine.medscape.com/article/230294-overview (https://archive.vn/NSqa8 https://archive.vn/NSqa8) Trench fever is a clinical syndrome caused by infection with Bartonella quintana; the condition was first described during World War I. Contemporary B quintana disease, commonly referred to as urban trench fever, is typically found in homeless, alcoholic, and poor populations. The human body louse Pediculus humanus var corporis is the major vector involved in trench fever transmission. [2] https://www.cdc.gov/parasites/lice/head/epi.html https://www.cdc.gov/parasites/lice/head/epi.html In the United States, infestation with head lice (Pediculus humanus capitis) is most common among preschool- and elementary school-age children and their household members and caretakers. Head lice are not known to transmit disease; however, secondary bacterial infection of the skin resulting from scratching can occur with any lice infestation. [3] https://jbiol.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/jbiol114 https://jbiol.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/jbiol114 Head and body lice used to be designated Pediculus capitis and P. corporis but they are now known to belong to the same species, P. humanus x[16, 17]. Fifty years ago Levene and Dobzhansky [18] showed that head lice could be trained or adapted to become the rather larger body lice by attaching them to the body in small pill boxes. [...] Body lice, and occasionally head and pubic lice, transmit bacterial diseases: typhus (Rickettsia prowazekii) [29], trench fever (Bartonella quintana) and relapsing fever (Borellia recurrentis). The lice themselves succumb to typhus infection but pass the Rickettsia in their feces, which the human then scratches into the skin. Typhus is known as 'war fever' and 'jail fever' because it appears in conditions where lice thrive. At the end of Rats, Lice and History Zinsser [1] wrote "Typhus is not dead. It will live on for centuries and will break into the open whenever human stupidity and brutality give it a chance." Sadly, Zinsser's words were prophetic. Within a few years, typhus became the major slayer in the Nazi concentration camps; typhus broke out among Rwandan refugees in Burundi in 1994, in Bosnia in 1995 and most recently in Goma.
- macspoofing 6y agoAnyone surprised? We're seeing occurrences of 'the plague' and TB in skid row. This is what happens when we allow people to living in squalor. At some point we as a society need to make a statement that living outside, even seemingly by choice, especially in context of mental illness or drug addiction is not something that should be respected or tolerated. We're at the point where cities (spurred on by activists) have exempted homeless population from all municipal regulations and decided that allowing people with drug addiction and mental illness to live in squalor, and filth is a basic human right that trumps forceful institutionalization. I really don't understand why forced institutionalization into highly regulated institutions, staffed by clinical professionals is so evil. Worse, a social worker friend of mine in the homeless space, highlighted one issue that I wasn't even aware of. She says she sees young people who are 'homeless' as a lifestyle choice, using (and draining) resources earmarked for the chronic homeless (typically those suffering from mental illness). She is convinced that this group is at least partially responsible for the large part of the waste in this space.
- x86_64Ubuntu 6y agoIn the US we used to have such institutionalization. That disappeared when the country elected Reagan. https://sites.psu.edu/psy533wheeler/2017/02/08/u01-ronald-reagan-and-the-federal-deinstitutionalization-of-mentally-ill-patients/comment-page-1/ https://sites.psu.edu/psy533wheeler/2017/02/08/u01-ronald-re...
- CryptoPunk 6y agoThat started to disappear long before Reagan. The deinstitutionalization movement was a left-wing one that started in the 60s. It was also not entirely without merit. The abuse that still happens in these types of institutions is obscene. Even elderly care homes, where the patients are not confined to the facility against their will, are rife with abuse. The alternative to that abuse we now see is much worse, with thousands upon thousands of the drug-using homeless dead from overdoses. But I think we can do better than abusive institutions, and the current activist-spawned free-for-all, where the mentally ill have no boundaries imposed on them.
- YeGoblynQueenne 6y ago>> “We all deserve the opportunity to build a healthy life for ourselves, so it is only right we make sure this is a reality for people facing homelessness too.” We all deserve the opportunity to not be homeless, first and foremost. We'd nip the problem of homeless people catching ancient diseases in the bud if we made sure they're housed and have access to clean water and two proper meals a day, like. That's not to say that the homeless should be left to rot in sickness, quite the contrary. But we already let them rot in homelessness and I'm saying that this should also be taken care of.