4 ms·
> Which is another way of saying "I believe Apple should either not operate in certain countries, or should try to operate in those countries in defiance of the
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
> Which is another way of saying "I believe Apple should either not operate in certain countries, or should try to operate in those countries in defiance of the laws of those countries."
That's true, but it doesn't mean your beef is only with the governments, in exactly the same way that IBM's collusion during WWII can't be pinned solely on the German government. They can choose not to do business in that country, or to be as subversive as they can until they get kicked out. Not doing so is a choice.
And that choice has implications for the company in other countries, when they become dependent on the countries they do business in, which then start making demands of the company's behavior globally.
- threeseed 6y agoIn this case it is largely an issue for governments. Because what Apple is doing is not immoral or unethical but completely standard business practice. Every company who runs a marketplace sets its terms and distorts competition to benefit them. In this case the author et al are arguing that Apple should be regulated differently and forced to operate a "level playing field" marketplace.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> Because what Apple is doing is not immoral or unethical Prohibiting anti-censorship apps and content-based censorship of apps at the behest of undemocratic governments is not immoral or unethical? > Every company who runs a marketplace sets its terms and distorts competition to benefit them. Not every company monopolizes the distribution of a third party product to an identifiable discrete set of customers. > In this case the author et al are arguing that Apple should be regulated differently and forced to operate a "level playing field" marketplace. That would be a valid way to remove the moral issue by taking the ability to impose censorship out of the corporation's hands.
- soperj 6y ago>That's true, but it doesn't mean your beef is only with the governments, in exactly the same way that IBM's collusion during WWII can't be pinned solely on the German government. They can choose not to do business in that country, or to be as subversive as they can until they get kicked out. Not doing so is a choice. Same with South Africa and IBM during apartheid.
- enriquto 6y ago> Same with South Africa and IBM during apartheid. And same thing with the U.S.A. today! How do you think that this war-mongering country will be seen a few decades from now? My guess is that it will be seen in the same light as the British Empire of a century ago. True, they had very nice things "inside", but they were totally callous on the countries that they controlled for economical interests (e.g., India, South Africa).
- viraptor 6y agoI wonder if one day we'll be regularly adding GitHub+ICE to this list.
- unishark 6y agoI think the point is when it comes to censorship, taking the high road of refusing to collude with the government and ceasing to operate in the country (whether willingly or by non-compliance leading to being banned yourself) has ultimately the same effect as following the law. The communication which the govt wants to censor gets censored.
- n4r9 6y agoTaking that argument to its extreme, if someone hands you a gun and says "shoot this person for $100 or I'll do it myself", whether you do the shooting has "ultimately the same effect" of that person dying. Still, most people wouldn't.
- CaptArmchair 6y ago> The communication which the govt wants to censor gets censored Only if social dynamics evaluate as a zero sum game. Which is the exception, not the rule. Law making is really a modelling exercise. The proof of the validity of a model is measured via the success of it's implementation. The extent of that success is a function of the ability of an authority to enforce those rules. At surface level, centralizing mass media into a handful of channels - whether it's public broadcasting or market dominance through a single private actor - seems like a boon for authoritarians when it comes to censorship. But what censorship really accomplishes is just stripping away the convenience with which undesirable information is spread. It doesn't necessarily strip the wholesale spread of information. History is rife with examples. In the 20th century there were clandestine newspapers (French newspaper La Libération for example) and pamphlets, or listening in on the BBC via longwave. In modern times, there's sneakernets, streetnets (Cuba, even North Korea), datacasting,... (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship_circumvention https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship_circumvent...) When a big corporation doesn't play ball and seizes operating in a country, it only moves the needle in one direction, but never quite entirely to the end.
- harry8 6y ago"Someone else will do it if I don't so I might as well get paid for assisting evil." It's a common enough point of view. I disagree with it myself. There's plenty to discuss about just how evil it has to be before you can't live with it anymore. Those are interesting discussion. Binary discussions based on purity are usually pretty dull.