6 ms·
I am honestly disappointed to see this kind of response at the top of comments here. Every time we have some sort of social issue come up people here come in to
by saagarjha 6y ago
I am honestly disappointed to see this kind of response at the top of comments here. Every time we have some sort of social issue come up people here come in to pick apart the person involved, and I think it’s one of the bigger reasons why some maintain a generally negative view of Hacker News. Can you imagine being Timnit and stopping by this thread, where the top comment, in colorful language, reduces you to a social activist fraud? A comment coming from someone who hasn’t even read the full paper? One that ignores the job you were hiring to do (which seems precisely to draw out the social issues of AI) and lambasts it?
At you the commenter yourself: you seem to be exceptionally harsh on her based on the most minimal information that you’ve purposes to fit your claim of this being “useless things that we shouldn’t care about”. Do you know how much energy goes into training a model? I certain didn’t. Do you think that showing that AI is picking up discriminatory language is something worth looking into? I certainly think having someone look into it would be useful, yes. And Google apparently thought so too. Claiming that these things are idiotic and attacking the author of this paper for bad faith and censure is…very extreme.
- mustuhfa 6y agoHave you seen or read her toxic behavior online?
- lsiebert 6y agoIf her behavior is "toxic", who has it harmed?
- mustuhfa 6y agoHave you read her exchange with Lecun and the impact it had? Edit - Also, if her behavior online is like that, imagine what its like inside Google? Have you thought about that? Clearly her email to the brain group was an issue here, i wonder how it compared to her exchange with lecun? One final edit, even her co-authors were not ready for publishing the paper (per article), so why is the reason of censorship, supression etc even being discussed. This whole thing has been blown out of proportion and Google likely did the right thing, purely based on her behavior
- lsiebert 6y agoThey were continuing to work on the paper for publication, which, if you've never written an academic paper, is a lengthy process. There's a heck of a difference between not being done and not wanting a rough draft circulating vs being asked to withdraw the paper entirely.
- tmotwu 6y agoGiven that she seems relatively popular within Brain - more importantly her collaborators and direct manager, why should we assume she fostered a toxic work environment with those around her? More like, it appears the people who wanted her out were leadership and a set of anonymous PR/IP reviewers she does not know.
- mustuhfa 6y agoHer behavior is clear evidence of how she interacts with people. You can be a brilliant jerk and still get along with some people. In a team environment however, there is no place for this. Her exchange with Lecun, her threatening words and many of the way she puts forward her arguments. Even if she was in the right here, she can easily deal with it without doing what she did here. So yes, there is more evidence for her toxic behavior than there is for her ability deal with disagreements professionally and work in a team environment. TBH, I think this whole review things is just a reason for google letting her go. They were probably looking for a reason and she using her threatening (aka toxic) nature was just what google needed.
- tmotwu 6y agoAgain, I repeat, if her team had issues with her, her direct report would know and her team wouldn't be harping constant praise towards her. The people who removed her are executives several skips above her. That is unusual. You keep bringing up LeCun, but LeCun did not get harmed as you imagine - he only conceded to her point because she was frankly the expert in the topic of discussion and he finally acknowledged that.
- 6y ago
- Macha 6y agoBased on previous discussions, she bullied facebook's AI chief, Yann LeCun, who is apparently a respected expert in the field, off of twitter in an attempted cancellation.
- lsiebert 6y agoLecun's last post on twitter was telling people not to attack her, so I'm not sure that characterization holds.
- mustuhfa 6y agoLecun is way more an adult and professional than she is. I dont expect anything other response from Lecun. Now, lets turn the tables, have you ever seen a response like that from the person in question here?
- saagarjha 6y agoIf you’re referring to her spat on Twitter with Yann LeCun, I am aware of it although not particularly well versed in its details. Certainly not well enough that I could claim it was “toxic”, although maybe that would be an accurate classification of her behavior. Regardless, her toxic behavior elsewhere is not an excuse for toxic behavior here.
- bzb6 6y ago> I think it’s one of the bigger reasons why some maintain a generally negative view of Hacker News. Twitter already exists, we don’t need another place online to spend all day spreading false positivity.
- dash2 6y agoThe issue isn’t false positivity. It’s clear argument, politeness, precision and a willingness to assume the best of your interlocutor.
- jeromenerf 6y agoIt was my impression that Twitter was mostly about spreading false negativity. Anyway, I would prefer we discuss the content of the paper and what it implies for large models.
- saagarjha 6y agoI’m not asking you to spread false positivity, I’m asking you to not read quotes of a rereading of a paper by an author who is not the person we’re discussing and then using it to complain that a researcher is useless and that her entire field is useless. A comment that started off with “it seems like Timnit Gebru mat have overestimated the impact…” is not false positivity.
- easytiger 6y ago> Can you imagine being Timnit and stopping by this thread, where the top comment, in colorful language, reduces you to a social activist fraud? If it is accurate what does it matter?
- fortran77 6y agoThink of the blowback if the paper was published!