5 ms·
> Accept a buyout offer to exit from the brand or spend roughly $200,000 on dealership upgrades > The buyout offers ranged from around $300,000 to more than $1
by Scoundreller 6y ago
> Accept a buyout offer to exit from the brand or spend roughly $200,000 on dealership upgrades
> The buyout offers ranged from around $300,000 to more than $1 million
Seems like slow-moving Cadillac dealerships held out and got a good opportunity to leave.
Possibly Cadillac won too by forcing down a lower buyout price on members that they didn’t want to keep either?
- toomuchtodo 6y ago“Declining brand dealerships accept generous buyout offer” Edit: Auto dealership businesses are traditionally lucrative (service revenue, mostly, based on my conversations with franchise owners), and if $200k in capex wasn’t worth it (based on forecasted future revenue and profit), I think that says volumes about the future of the Cadillac brand.
- syshum 6y agoYou have exposed the problem with electric cars and dealership though. Electric cars do not need as much service, ALOT LESS infact. Thus the dealership will have to get more revenue from the initial sale instead of reoccurring service revenue. If the brand/dealership is already struggling switching to electrics is likely going to be a negative revenue hit for any dealership that survives on service revenue
- toomuchtodo 6y agoAgreed! All dealerships are dead long term (with possible exits/buyouts offered by manufacturers for service center/gallery conversions to match what Tesla has). Just like layoffs come in waves in struggling enterprises, this is just the first salvo.
- syshum 6y agoWell regulations will ensure dealerships are around for a long long time to come. In most states it is illegal for the major companies (Ford, GM, Toyota, Honda, etc) to sell direct to the public, once they start a dealer network that is how it has to be for all time. Tesla got around that because they were a new company with no dealer network, even then in some states laws were "updated" to prohibit direct sales.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- RobRivera 6y agoI see zero reason for such laws to be in the interest of the general welfare. Break up market dynamics to introduce mandated middlepeople? So dumb.
- fiddlerwoaroof 6y agoI wonder if the thinking was that dealers have more buying power since they’re purchasing multiple cars from the manufacturer at once, so they are on more equal footing when it comes to negotiating with GM and Ford. Then, since there are multiple dealerships selling the same cars, they can compete with each other on price. Thus, in theory, allowing customers to purchase cars at a price closer to the “wholesale” price. Of course, once the systems exist, the dealers will lobby for their continued existence.
- wongarsu 6y agoIf dealers really have that negotiation edge they should be able to stay relevant with market dynamics alone, instead of lobbying to prevent direct sales.
- thirtyseven 6y agoUnless the manufacturers undercut the dealers until they're out of business, then raise prices.
- ngcc_hk 6y agoApple still has dealer network with direct sell. But there are so many can’t imagine just manufactures.
- syshum 6y agoThe history of why dealership came to be is an interesting one, and why the laws was originally passed was in some way valid However today dealerships collectively enjoy HUGE state level political power, as in most states the bulk of sales tax revenue is directly tied to the resale of cars, thus the dealers of said cars have out-sized pull in state governments
- beamatronic 6y agoDealerships should remake themselves as premium service centers. Taking a Lexus in for service is a pleasure. You can sit in the business center while chomping on "free" donuts and coffee.
- alricb 6y agoCadillac did try that, they called it the "Pinnacle Project", but the dealers (mostly the smaller ones) didn't want to do it.
- artificialLimbs 6y agoI have no idea why you're being downvoted. My dad used to run service departments for a dealer chain, about 15 dealerships. This is one of the things he did. He was also very process oriented and was able to 'money motivate' employees. He took every dealership he worked with from negative or low yearly income to substantially higher yearly income and everything he touched grew customer base.
- dawnerd 6y agoThe VW dealer I bought my e-golf from has been harassing me to do my yearly oil change. And each time I have to tell them that no, my car doesn't need an oil change. They still insist on a yearly "service". I'm sure these dealerships will invent things that need to be serviced yearly.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- krrrh 6y agoHaving done a a lot of consulting for car dealerships, I’d wager that it’s more likely that their appointment reminder system is held together by duct tape and baling twine, and getting it to schedule smarter based on the data in the dealer management system is so complicated that it’s probably using default values from when it was first set up 8 years ago.
- cybwraith 6y agoOof, so true. Dealer software is stuck in the 90s.
- yourapostasy 6y ago> ...I’d wager that it’s more likely that their appointment reminder system is held together by duct tape and baling twine... The conventional car industry has coming up on two decades of observing what Tesla did right with their software and customer service experience, and what they screwed up. Tesla is still very vulnerable (QC, capacity, and infrastructure), and that window is closing fast. If conventional car dealerships become economic roadkill in the future, they only have themselves to blame.
- ashtonkem 6y agoThe big issue with the traditional car industry is how fragmented it is. OEMs, third party websites, and individual dealerships are not only on different tech stacks, they’re financially independent companies that by and large can’t be forced to work together. It’s not uncommon for OEMs to pay dealerships for data through third party websites, since they lack the ability to share certain types of data directly. One of Tesla’s advantages is unquestionably their more centralized structure. They can make changes that other OEMs can’t.
- pkaye 6y agoOr maybe we need smaller or fewer dealerships.
- maxerickson 6y agoWhat does it say? Isn't the lower service cost a feather in Tesla's cap when they come up? Who loses those dollars when GM sells an electric Cadillac?
- toomuchtodo 6y agoDealerships are left out in the cold without service dollars.
- maxerickson 6y agoYou said it said something about the brand. Dealers aren't the brand.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoDealers accepting the buyout are them bailing on the brand due to perceived lower long term value of said brand (versus the investment being asked of them). My apologies I wasn’t more clear upfront. The thesis isn’t just less service required electric vehicles, but Cadillac brand loyalty dying off with older customers (Cadillac has the oldest customer base in the auto industry). Similar situation with Harley Davidson [1]. [1] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-harley-davidson-electricbike-focus-idUSKBN1WM10N https://www.reuters.com/article/us-harley-davidson-electricb... (Harley struggles to fire up new generation of riders with electric bike debut)
- maxerickson 6y agoIt's a small transaction, and GM is on the other side of it, spending money to push the brand towards electric instead of letting it stagnate. Are 150 (likely small volume) dealers a great bellwether?
- toomuchtodo 6y agoYou could be right. Time will tell as more jurisdictions enact combustion vehicle sales bans and brands transition to electric or die. Single data points aren’t as helpful as momentum signal.
- BrianOnHN 6y agoSometimes the local population can only see into the local future. Unfortunately, those decisions impact the local grandchildren, who will live in the long-distance future. It's refreshing to see a singular board room decision lead to a better long-distance future.
- willio58 6y agoYeah I wouldn’t read too much into this. It’s good for the brand to cull the heard of non-believers.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoFirst, it's a "herd". Second, 17% is a lot of dealerships. I mean, I presume that these are the dealerships that aren't selling all that many cars, but... what total sales volume did they account for. 5%? 10%? Does Cadillac want to lose that much of their total sales? Do they want to pay money to lose that much of their total sales? And, really, pay $300,000 for a dealership to go away, because the dealership wouldn't pay $200,000 for a charging station. Why not, you know, put up the $200,000, and keep the dealership?
- krrrh 6y agoCadillac is a sub brand of GM, and most of these dealers probably did small volume on Cadillacs while their bread and butter was GM. For instance I consulted a group of Ford dealerships, only one of which had a Lincoln franchise. To keep the Lincoln brand they needed to do stuff like have a separate branded entrance and minumum floorspace for the Lincoln side of things, etc. At some point it’s not worth it if 95% of your revenue comes from selling the mainline brand.
- Scoundreller 6y agoI wonder if, at some point, a brand will subsidize those costs just to keep a foot in a market (if they fail to take the bait and cover the cost themselves).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- unreal37 6y agoThey'd have to pay $200,000 to all dealerships, not just the ones who wanted to leave. Plus I am sure that equipment takes up land/space, and reduces the number of service bays. And requires trained staff. $176 million is different than $20 million. And that's not the only cost the dealers are incurring including reduced revenue from land that could be used to sell cars.