3 ms·
> I think of web scraping as nothing less than automation of human work. I agree that scraping should be allowed. We wouldn't have Google otherwise. However,
by Wowfunhappy 6y ago
> I think of web scraping as nothing less than automation of human work.
I agree that scraping should be allowed. We wouldn't have Google otherwise.
However, there's something to be said for the fact that some activities are okay at a small scale but become problematic at a large scale—particularly the scale which becomes possible when a task is automated.
For instance, I recently bought an expensive camera and have been having fun walking around the city and taking interesting photos. Many of the photos have people in them. I don't think there's any harm in this.
I store my photos in Aperture, which automatically performs facial recognition on everything in my library. Perhaps some day, if I take enough pictures, Aperture will notice that the same stranger is present in two completely different images. That might be kind of cool—I can see myself fancifully trying to imagine this person's life story. I don't think there would be any harm in that, either.
However, if I aggregated millions of photos from different sources, and used them to track people's movements across the city, that would clearly be a huge problem! Sure, it would be merely automating the work a human could do, but the scale just changes everything!
- bobobob420 6y agoCan the case be made that recording in public is a right (as if always should be) but trying to track where everyone is at every point of time is stalking at a mass scale which should be illegal as stalking on a one to one scale is illegal? For reference this is what one site (findlaw) has given as what constitutes the crime of stalking: The crime of stalking can be simply described as the unwanted pursuit of another person. Examples of this type of behavior includes following a person, appearing at a person's home or place of business, making harassing phone calls, leaving written messages or objects, or vandalizing a person's property.
- travisporter 6y agoThis sentiment exactly. Sure the information is free. But to find my property records, phone number, and "aggregate them" like Spokeo, fastpeoplefinder and similar sites, is akin to digital stalking IMO
- filoleg 6y agoMaybe I am wrong and my take is too simplistic/naive (as I admit, I haven't thought too much about this topic), but imo aggregating publicly available data shouldn't count as stalking. Acting on that data in a way that could be constituted as "stalking" definitely is real stalking though and should count as a crime. For example, if someone's ex (who was explicitly warned that he was unwelcome) continues showing up at the doorsteps because they remembered your address from a long time ago, then it is stalking. Them knowing the address isn't. In light of this, I don't see how it matters whether they remembered the address from past experiences or just found it through a website that aggregates publicly available info. As long as the data was obtained legally and without breaking any other harassment clauses, why would just the knowledge of something be a crime? I see it just like firearms. Having a firearm (in a lot of US jurisdictions) is not a crime, as long as it was obtained legally. Doing harmful actions with it (such as threatening people or shooting someone who didn't pose a threat to your life) is a crime. Having a firearm feels like just having data, in this scenario. As long as you don't use that data for criminal actions, why would just the potential of you being able to do something criminal with that data is a crime?
- amelius 6y ago> The crime of stalking can be simply described as the unwanted pursuit of another person. Examples of this type of behavior includes following a person, appearing at a person's home or place of business, making harassing phone calls, leaving written messages or objects, or vandalizing a person's property. Except for the last point, that sounds like ads :)
- josephorjoe 6y agoads vandalize property by causing unwanted images to appear on and unwanted sounds to emit from personal property
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoVandalism usually means permanent damage. You can call the police on your neighbor for playing loud music at 3 am, but I don't think it would be correct to accuse them of vandalizing your property.
- colejohnson66 6y agoIs a highway billboard vandalism when the owner of that billboard is allowing the ad? Or are you referencing computers with ads in them (websites, etc.)? By that definition, anything disproving a conspiracy theorist is vandalism to them. That’s not how that works.
- dehrmann 6y agoThe case I thought of is how public records are great, but the way Spokeo and friends scrape them, post them, and sell them isn't.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoRight! Ensuring a process has the right amount of friction can actually be super important, to ensure it's available but isn't used wantonly.
- vsl 6y agoThis is a great way to phrase it. Friction really is essential for so many things where we're gradually loosing it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]