5 ms·
We also should not forget that The Lord of the Rings is an account written from the victors perspective. Maybe Sauron was simply an entrepreneur who favours me
by mrtksn 6y ago
We also should not forget that The Lord of the Rings is an account written from the victors perspective.
Maybe Sauron was simply an entrepreneur who favours meritocracy instead of races and societal hierarchy, thus becoming the boogeyman of the ruling class.
Please take a moment to consider an alternative account of what actually happened: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Last_Ringbearer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Last_Ringbearer
- Apocryphon 6y agoThough I've not yet read either series, I've been told that this is another alternate account: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sundering_(series) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sundering_(series)
- enriquto 6y agoThe first chapter of the last ringbearer is extremely funny! It relates the wars described in LOTR from the point of view of Sauron's soldiers (they are regular humans, the "orc" descriptions are a ridiculous libel). Unfortunately, the rest of the book describes the continuation after the wars and it is much less engaging, since you cannot draw parallels with the original story.
- ben0x539 6y agoI tend to agree (I still enjoyed the rest, and the epilogue was fun as well), but I love the weirdly extended espionage subplot just because it has a oneliner that is such an amazing, amazingly heavy-handed dunk on Tolkien: > “Because you are an Enemy. You fight on the side of Darkness, so your every word is a lie, and your every deed is evil by definition.” > > “You’re mistaken, lad,” Tangorn sighed wearily. “I’m on neither the Dark nor the Light side. If you need a label, I’m on the side of many colors.”
- eriktrautman 6y agoI love the idea of that but do wish it didn’t require altering so many of the basic facts. The most compelling alternate histories use the same set of facts but show how the victors were misguided and misled by their assumptions, because it is more tragic that way.
- Apocryphon 6y agoThen you'll probably love some of these, particularly the early War of the Ring set in 2450 and featuring a fellowship that includes both Saruman and Smeagol. http://www.oocities.org/davidbofinger/ame.htm http://www.oocities.org/davidbofinger/ame.htm
- jeanjogr 6y agoi think there are a lot of plot points in Tolkien's legendarium where you do not need to change the fact to change the perspective: - the Elves are a puppet of the Valar, doing their bid in exchange for land and favours in the Undying land. Numenor is even more so a client state - sided with us? you're rewarded with longer life and your own territory. - while the Valar do not encourage the colonization of the land of the "lesser" races (note: there are "lesser" races) in Middle Earth by their clients - Elves following Fëanor and the Numenorians colonies -, they really do not do much to prevent it. When things go south for their clients, they of course help them survive in Middle Earth through open warfare and pardon almost all of the rebels (so much for not supporting the colonization!). It is not so much different from the US being ostensibly against colonialism but bankrolling France in Indochina. - they keep their "no direct support, but no condemnation" policy on colonial powers for a while. They do not want to harm their clients when their second-rate clients want to renegotiate their terms (aka the Numenorians wanting immortality) so they call on big boss Eru. In line with their history of not wanting to dirty their hands, but still pursuing their policy objectives. - when their colonial clients are on the verge of disappearing (Gondor before the War of the Ring), they send CIA political operatives to engineer resistance, coups, and remake Middle Earth in their fashion. My bad, they are "Istari". Those agents have no qualms scarifying the lesser people and getting involved in their politics. I have no doubt that the sole purpose of reinstalling the Numenorian dynasty is to help the war effort (it is well known that internal strife bolsters the war effort), not to replace the current leadership - now quite distant from the Valar - by a man who owes everything to the Valar and their subordinates. He was even raised in a pro-Valar Elven colony! The Dunedain program exists only to have a convenient leader to choose if you want to topple current Gondorian leadership. I mean if, say, the US had hosted the descendants of the Capetian - Bourbon kings of France since the French Revolution and tried to push for France to become a kingdom again under their brand new American-raised kingdom after WWII instead of that pesky de Gaulle, would anyone think it is solely for French interests? - speaking of which, it is good that Aragorn becomes the King because he was born to become king. Right-of-birth is not a very compelling point. Cheap tricks ("the hands of a king are the hands of a healer!") are used to prop up the new Numenorian regime. - industrial technology is terrible, because it is direct competition to the nature/magic based technology of the Valar and their surrogate. - Saruman is beyond help because he chose to get power for himself rather than prop up the Valar client states' power. I guess you can make a point that betraying your bosses is wrong, but is a Numenorian disctatorship (whose leader is put into power by one of the Istari) that much better than direct dictatorship by one of the Istari? And that's just on the top of my head.
- jonsolo 6y agoI love this. I always preferred a “Wicked”-like retelling of LOTR, where Sauron’s side is one of technology and progress. We’re supposed to dislike orcs because they live in dense cities and are black? Because they chop down trees and fight against eco-terrorists?
- ben_w 6y agoI forget where I read this, but I have read that Tolkein was inspired by industrialisation and the destruction of nature when characterising Sauron, the orcs, post-fall Saruman, and the scouring of the Shire.
- jonsolo 6y agoThat makes sense, though I’ve never been able to find evidence on that (and I’ve looked). The allegory is too spot on to be accidental.
- gostsamo 6y agoLast chapters of LOTR, after the victory. The heroes come back at home and it is destroyed, no nature, no trees, and a big factory in the middle. Takes magic to restore the natural ecosystem.
- jacobush 6y agoTHAT is reality. It would take magic to restore many ecosystems by this point.
- NateEag 6y agoUh, no, it does not. It takes Samwise Gamgee, a devoted and skilled gardener, spending a year of his life planting new trees to replace the ones that were lost. Yes, he uses a magical resource he was given as part of his reforestation campaign, but it just speeds up the growth. The real factor is still Sam's tireless labor.
- yesbabyyes 6y agoFor a humorous take on this perspective, I recommend this spoof commentary on the trilogy by Noam Chomsky and Howard Zinn: https://www.mcsweeneys.net/articles/unused-audio-commentary-by-howard-zinn-and-noam-chomsky-recorded-summer-2002-for-the-fellowship-of-the-ring-platinum-series-extended-edition-dvd-part-one https://www.mcsweeneys.net/articles/unused-audio-commentary-... CHOMSKY: But without the pipe-weed, Middle Earth would fall apart. Saruman is trying to break up Gandalf’s pipe-weed ring. He’s trying to divert it. ZINN: Well, you know, it would be manifestly difficult to believe in magic rings unless everyone was high on pipe-weed. So it is in Gandalf’s interest to keep Middle Earth hooked.
- morsch 6y agoThis could be funny but they completely fail to emulate Chomsky's way of talking. I don't know about Zinn.
- badconvincer 6y agoI’ve always found this much more inspiring than the “everyone in their place” ideology that LOTR has going on.
- Razengan 6y ago> Please take a moment to consider an alternative account of what actually happened: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Last_Ringbearer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Last_Ringbearer The plot summary is hilarious.