3 ms·
A couple of easy fixes -- one, don't make H1B dependent on the employer. Once you've worked for say, one year, convert it to a general work visa. Two, automat
by jedberg 6y ago
A couple of easy fixes -- one, don't make H1B dependent on the employer. Once you've worked for say, one year, convert it to a general work visa.
Two, automatic green-card for anyone who completes a four year degree at an accredited US institution.
- nrmitchi 6y ago1. Definitely agree with that. Even if you keep the same H1-B term (7 years), you now have an EAD (Employment Authorization Document) for those 7 years. 2. I strongly disagree with this one. The end result will be accredited US institutions effectively selling green cards. If you thought tuition was high before this, think about what will happen after these schools can effectively sell permanent residency to the highest bidders (for prices under the EB-5 investment visa cut-offs of course)
- jedberg 6y agoIs number two really that bad though? Right now, rich people can find ways to "buy" citizenship already. Now at least some of the money and gatekeeping would flow through colleges. Especially public colleges, who love foreign students, because they pay full tuition.
- nrmitchi 6y agoYes, selling green cards is bad. The EB-5 program is the "government sponsored" way of doing it. I also think that is bad, and abused, but I digress. If your argument for it being good is "the money goes to public colleges, which is basically the government!" then the government should just be transparently selling permanent residency without the smoke-and-mirror charade of a "school". Are you then going to exclude private schools? I would guess that a degree from Harvard is more worthy of a green card, but then why should Harvard get a bunch of "free money" for selling a green card? US Colleges will still only have a certain amount of capacity. If all of a sudden it comes with a free green card, either 1) less US students can afford to go there, because tuition has risen so much due to "supply and demand", or 2) US students still go there, and end up with even more debt than they currently have. > Now at least some of the money and gatekeeping would flow through colleges. Especially public colleges, who love foreign students, because they pay full tuition. With the EB-5 programs (the way to "buy" a green card), you have to invest within Qualified Opportunity Zones which are (in theory) designed to assist lower-income areas, or create a certain number of new jobs (I'm sure there are other investments that qualify too; I'm not an expert on this program). Having funds go towards these endeavors is arguably "better" than going into the pockets of an already administratively-overloaded university system.
- fakedang 6y agoYou won't get the brightest students, but rather the richest.
- bluecalm 6y agoI think degrees already have too much weight. You don't want gatekeepers to control even more areas of life. Just make it: "if you worked for at least n years and paid at least n in taxes you get a green card".
- jedberg 6y agoThat's also not a bad idea.