30 ms·
My Phone Was Spying on Me, So I Tracked Down the Surveillants
- forgotmypw17 6y agohttps://nitter.net/martingund/status/1334465877153095680 https://nitter.net/martingund/status/1334465877153095680
- asicsp 6y agoThe thread also mentions https://nrkbeta.no/2020/12/03/my-phone-was-spying-on-me-so-i-tracked-down-the-surveillants/ https://nrkbeta.no/2020/12/03/my-phone-was-spying-on-me-so-i... which would be a better link than twitter.
- nbzso 6y agoThanks, I don't like Twitter for long form content. It's not designed for this.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- SamuelAdams 6y agoI agree with you, but a hacky workaround is @mythreadreader
- nbzso 6y agoThanks.
- SkyMarshal 6y agoYeah, hacky and annoying af when fifty people use it on the same thread, as is usually the case. Makes Twitter’s long-form readability and usability even worse.
- olvy0 6y agoThere's also nitter, it's slightly better than the twitter interface https://nitter.net/martingund https://nitter.net/martingund
- nbzso 6y agoThanks.
- lode 6y agoMuch more readable in Thread reader form: https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1334465877153095680.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1334465877153095680.html
- baxtr 6y agoSo we have a very successful short messages app, that now resulted in another service to be successful, which combines the short messages into a long format. Innovation and evolution aren't always straightforward I guess!
- PeterStuer 6y agoOr you can just read the article on the website https://nrkbeta.no/2020/12/03/my-phone-was-spying-on-me-so-i-tracked-down-the-surveillants/ https://nrkbeta.no/2020/12/03/my-phone-was-spying-on-me-so-i...
- mmgu 6y agoI hacked the tweet thread together in 15 min so I think the article might be a better (although longer) read.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jnsie 6y agoThat is a fantastic but very unsettling article. It's a somewhat dystopian present we live in
- throwaway_pdp09 6y agoThere are way to fight back. If you choose to. Convenience usually comes first it seems.
- strwbarie 6y agoHow? What are the best ways to fight back?
- throwaway_pdp09 6y agoI don't have a smartphone. That alone will prevent browsing habits being picked up by parasitic apps etc on a phone. What I browse at home I have more control over with blocklists etc and disabling js. I rarely carry my dumphone around, if someone needs me they can leave a message. That takes care of tracking by cell station. There are times I'd like to have a dumphone on me, eg. when meeting people, so at some point I'll get dumphone #2 not linked to me. If possible, pay cash rather than a credit card. I have done this before but in the uk this was getting more difficult and may not be possible, I don't know. There are always ways around that with grey areas. At higher levels pressure your government or use the local regulations to push back when a company seems to be behaving unethically. I'm sure there's more. But convenience triumphs and all you can see is "I need smartphone". You won't do any of this. People who ask how will never do, or they wouldn't be asking the question to which the answer(s) are obvious.
- ApolloRising 6y agoGPS chip in the car? License plate readers all around you? Face recognition cameras? Chip in the credit card that you are not using? Friends with a iphone that have your number? ID cards that swipe you into places?
- rossng 6y agoThis is a great illustration of why the GDPR - and enforcement of it - is so important. The average user has absolutely no chance of navigating the digital advertising sewer without all of their data eventually being sold to the US military.
- surround 6y ago> For the sum of 35,000 NOK (3,300 EUR / 4,000 USD), we got access to location data showing where tens of thousands of Norwegians had travelled in 2019. > One of them was 31-year-old Karl Bjarne Bernhardsen from Stavanger. The information made it easy for us to identify him in the data that – according to the data provider – had been anonymised. Here’s that article: https://translate.googleusercontent.com/translate_c?tl=en&u=https://www.nrk.no/norge/xl/avslort-av-mobilen-1.14911685 https://translate.googleusercontent.com/translate_c?tl=en&u=... And the HN thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23136612 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23136612
- Moru 6y agoWhat causes me the most irritation (to put it mildly) is that I bought the Sygic navigator that seems to be the source of this data. And still they sell my data? Just last week they forced me to agree to some new rules to be able to use the app but I already bought it 7 years ago. I will be requesting my money back as stated by that agreement, and request a GDPR data dump for moving my data to another provider.
- Moru 6y agoLink for anyone else wanting their money back: https://www.sygic.com/company/eula-gps-navigation-google-play https://www.sygic.com/company/eula-gps-navigation-google-pla...
- krono 6y agoUnsurprisingly, they're refusing my request. So, essentially, I'm now locked into this agreement with Sygic for the duration of my "lifetime" license. This is one of those situations where I'd wish I had some "fuck you" money to throw at an expensive law firm.
- Lio 6y agoSygic don't even have a Privacy Policy link on their homepage, you have to dig for it a buried legal documents page. Your privacy is not something they care about except as something to sell to others.
- tremon 6y agoThe United States Customs and Border Protection (CBP) states that they they have limited access to commercially available data, and that they are used in line with relevant rules and regulations Well sure, relevant being the operative word here. For the US CBP the only relevance is US law, since the USA has no concept of data subject ownership -- in the US, all data is owned by whoever holds it, not who it is about.
- black_puppydog 6y agoNot sure why you're being downvoted. This seems like an accurate description of what's the status quo (and what is the problem with it, IMO)
- edkennedy 6y agoThis is essential work, using the GDPR as a tool for data privacy journalism. Unfortunately, GDPR is only the beginning and lots of work like this needs to be done to uncover the breadth of the damage that is being done daily. Also, as the article states this shows that stronger laws need to be in place all over the globe.
- mmgu 6y ago(Journalist behind article.) Thank you! I can say that it is not easy to use subject access requests to get information. Without the help of Michael Veale’s template and a lot of grit, I don’t think I would have made it. Transparency is just a first step, but it is a powerful tool.
- eternalban 6y agoYou wrote: "It is uncanny to follow my own steps, even though they do not divulge any romantic affair, secret meetings, or embarrassing health issues." Contact tracing addresses that shortcoming of the current surveillance tech. Today, finding out that 2 cell phones have been in proximity requires computationally expensive analytics on the server side. With the apparently mandated requirement for contact tracing, edge devices ("your" phone) will simply detect proximate "ids" and send that to the servers and that trivializes the task of determining your "romantic affair, secret meetings, or embarrassing health issues".
- tobr 6y agoI think OP is saying he didn’t have any affairs or other secrets to divulge.
- pjc50 6y ago> Today, finding out that 2 cell phones have been in proximity requires computationally expensive analytics on the server side. No, you just have to use the right data structures. Quadtree is the obvious one if you have lat/long, or if you have cell history you can observe that e.g. the UK only has ~25,000 base stations, so you can just use them as buckets. It's probably too expensive to run on every ad load, but for targeted surveillance it's easy. Contact tracing will go away middle of next year with the end of the pandemic. Although I wouldn't rule out its reactivation next time there's a SARS or bird flu breakout.
- greenkey 6y agoRelated big data landscape 2020: https://mattturck.com/data2020/ https://mattturck.com/data2020/
- branon 6y agoTwitter thread links to https://www.vice.com/en/article/epdpdm/ice-dhs-fbi-location-data-venntel-apps https://www.vice.com/en/article/epdpdm/ice-dhs-fbi-location-...
- 18af219e 6y agoBut isn't the user international? Seems within provider's rights?
- eivarv 6y agoIf you're targeting European users, you need to comply with the GDPR.
- sunstone 6y agoIn this case the user is in Norway which is not a member of the EU.
- robin_reala 6y agoNorway integrated GDPR into its own legal system: https://lovdata.no/dokument/NL/lov/2018-06-15-38 https://lovdata.no/dokument/NL/lov/2018-06-15-38
- lagadu 6y agoGDPR was implemented in the EU and in the EEA, of which Norway is a member of.
- tobr 6y agoThe comment you’re replying to doesn’t mention EU, so this nitpick doesn’t make much sense.
- eivarv 6y agoDidn't mention EU, but to be specific: members of the EU or the EEA.
- baxtr 6y agoA good advice: disable background app refreshes if you use an iPhone.
- tclancy 6y agoCan you explain why? I'm not clear on the implications but am definitely interested.
- baxtr 6y agoBattery life, but mostly the topic of the article: apps use it to track you [1]. I always ask myself: why does this app need to communicate with a server if I didn't open the app? For the majority of apps there is no need to do anything while they're asleep. [1] https://www.macobserver.com/news/background-app-refresh-data/ https://www.macobserver.com/news/background-app-refresh-data...
- Chris2048 6y agoDo iPhones do this if I enable location with "when I use the app" as opposed to "always"?
- baxtr 6y agotbh, I don't think it's related to the location settings. I believe apps don't even need to ask for permission to do this. That's why you need to turn it off manually.
- akie 6y agoThank you! I had no idea. After I disabled background app refresh I installed a firewall (https://www.lifewire.com/why-you-need-a-firewall-app-for-your-iphone-5080119 https://www.lifewire.com/why-you-need-a-firewall-app-for-you...) - in my case the open source, security audited, on-device-only firewall "Lockdown" see https://lockdownprivacy.com/ https://lockdownprivacy.com/
- swiley 6y agoOne downside to the security model in popular mobile OSes is that once someone does gain superuser access there's really nothing the user can do short of rebuilding the device since they often don't have it themselves.
- tF73d78kq8t3R6n 6y agoLet’s not beat around the bush here: this is a uniquely Android problem. Sure, there are some iOS jailbreaks out in the wild, but these are very few and far between. There was one for then-recent iOS versions earlier this year, but it came many years after the previous jailbreak of that kind. Superuser access to my iOS device isn’t something I need to worry about. But if I ran Android? It would be a real threat.
- raxxorrax 6y agoHe consented to the collection and Apple would have exactly the same issues. Also Android is marginally more useful than an iOS device. I know that it is fancy as a music player and social media apps, but it isn't really what it could be.
- tome 6y ago> He consented to the collection and Apple would have exactly the same issues. Would it? In iOS you can selectively forbid applications from using locations services.
- raxxorrax 6y agoMy grandma uses an iPhone and it leaks far more data than her PC. Yes, the handling is the issue and here iOS is as bad as Android. That is the metric I use to determine that the app store security model is bad.
- saiya-jin 6y agoso can you in Android... well guess what, it doesn't add any feeling of security on my chinese phone (and for any non-US person, chinese or american are the same - foreign powers gathering all data possible, which may or may not be used against you in the future).
- bjarneh 6y ago> “I agree,” I pressed. We had now made a binding agreement, the app and I. I hate this whole premise. We have to agree to an incomprehensible text wall of vague legal nonsense, that very often violate our own laws (as in this case), in order to install an app. These illegal contracts are completely void of any meaning, and it should not matter that you "agreed" to be screwed over like that. Being screwed over like this is illegal, so those who do this, should not stay safe just because you clicked "I agree".
- MaxBarraclough 6y ago> Being screwed over like this is illegal More precisely, these agreements generally aren't legally binding in Europe, but generally are legally binding in the US.
- bjarneh 6y agoTrue; although who knows what would hold up in court if anyone was to file a lawsuit based on some of these "digital contracts" we agree to every time we click "I agree".
- mgamache 6y agoI have a feeling that a judge would want to find them invalid, but what happens if he/she rules that they are non-binding? The chaos it would cause for US B2C businesses would be large. This alone may sway the courts to make them binding.
- bjarneh 6y ago> This alone may sway the courts to make them binding. I'm afraid you are correct, but hasn't the whole system collapsed if: - Is this good for our businesses? is is part of your consideration when you are trying to find out if something is illegal or not?
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 6y agoCustomers should have the legal footing to negotiate every line in every contract with someone holding the status to negotiate on behalf of the company. If I can't negotiate my cell phone contact I'm placed in an impossible scenario where I either agree under duress or endure the impossible life of someone that refuses to sign contracts. Essentially, there are 4-6 contracts I'm capable of negotiating in my life out of tens of thousands I've agreed to under duress. Those 4-6 are: apartment lease (keep the Wi-Fi take off $50), groundskeeping (days, times, work to be done, breachs), trash (when, where). These negotiations are only possible because these companies have sole proprietors who will get on the phone to keep a customer. Let's move every company closer to this model by requiring every contract to be negotiable or, if online, optout no guarantees, no warranty, no liability, no tracking except for carefully and explicitly outlined exceptions.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- miguendes 6y agoInteresting article. Is there any way to mitigate the amount of data collected? If I turn GPS off can they still track my steps? One thing that I notice frequently is discussing some topic with my wife and then finding an AD related to the topic on Instagram, LinkedIn, and whatnot. Could be a coincidence but I not sure any more.
- robin_reala 6y agoOn iOS at least you can allow an app access to location data only while the app is in use (or not at all). Not sure what the situation is on Android.
- lagadu 6y agoIt's the same since at least Android 10, also you can allow one-off permissions as well.
- curiousgal 6y agoSame on Android 11. There's also an "Only this time" option.
- quenix 6y agoThat’s different. That would just ask you to confirm again if the app prompts. The iOS counterpart blocks location requests quietly when the app is in the background and allows them when the app is in the foreground.
- 1f60c 6y agoAnd, in iOS 14, you can also grant an app access to “imprecise” location data, which reduces its accuracy from about 20 feet to 2 miles.
- diarrhea 6y agoThe tracking is extremly intrusive. With GPS turned off, accuracy is diminished, but locating the device is still possible via WiFi SSIDs and cell towers the phone is logged into. Maybe Bluetooth also plays a role. In the background, the phone uses its gyro sensors so it can tell what you are doing: walking, running, getting into a car/sitting down, getting out/up, ... The unsettling part is that location logging continues to work with the phone off (saw an admittedtly obscure YouTube video on that which I can't seem to dig up again). Like the Kindle, airplane mode also doesn't stop data from being transmitted to the overlords. It merely delays it from somewhat real-time to whenever you go online again.
- gzer0 6y agoThe problem we are beginning to see is the unwillingness, chaos, and confusion on how exactly to enforce GDPR. This is concerning; no repercussions will eventually lead to where we were before.
- CivBase 6y ago> Kacanova claims that my consent had been lawfully obtained according to GDPR, and that their partners were contractually obliged to only use my data for marketing purposes. Does anyone actually believe these companies are segregating their data based on what they are legally allowed to do with it? And that those permissions somehow get propagated along with the data to third parties, who then also diligently segregate their data based on legal permissions? It's difficult to hold these companies accountable and even if you could prove they were misusing the data as an individual, it's difficult to take legal action against them. And even if you do manage to beat them in court, the compensation will almost certainly be a pittance - especially if you're not covered under the GDPR. Of course they're not doing managing users' personal data responsibly! Even with the GDPR, it's still more lucrative to just not bother.
- mbirth 6y agoEven if you can sue them into oblivion, there will be a different company under a different name doing the same. It's just too lucrative.
- hnarn 6y agoIt seems like this issue can be largely circumvented by the fact that at least on iOS, giving location data now requires much more interaction from the user? Every time a new app asks for your location, you can select whether you want to give it that information all the time, or only while using the app. Another thing that I've started using recently is NextDNS[1], and it's amazing the amount of tracker garbage that's leaking out, and being blocked on a DNS level, out of almost any mobile application. [1]: https://nextdns.io/ https://nextdns.io/
- Terretta 6y agoI'm sure someone has a database of frameworks that iOS apps turn to for user linking / monetization? I didn't readily find a list last time I looked, so I'm not sure how single person dev shops are getting hooked up with these privacy bypassing hydras. From DNS logs in Nov 2019, I had found some of the more common on iOS a year ago included: iOS “User Linking” Trackers [business].app.link [business].onelink.me [hash].ulink.adjust.com [business].bttn.io bnc.lt branch.io Some of these you can see who uses them, thanks to subdomains: https://securitytrails.com/list/apex_domain/app.link https://securitytrails.com/list/apex_domain/app.link (2962) https://securitytrails.com/list/apex_domain/onelink.me https://securitytrails.com/list/apex_domain/onelink.me (998) https://securitytrails.com/list/apex_domain/bttn.io https://securitytrails.com/list/apex_domain/bttn.io (60) These are different from iOS Measurement Trackers such as: events.appsflyer.com reports.crashlytics.com api.mixpanel.com app-measurement.com But it's gotten enough worse I almost want Apple to implement Little Snitch style blocking at the network layer, and offer a measurement anonymizing API that devs can use and is whitelisted by default. Ensure legit usage/debugging info is anonymously available, while use of other trackers would then suggest other motivations at play.
- ac29 6y ago> Every time a new app asks for your location, you can select whether you want to give it that information all the time, or only while using the app. This is exactly how it works on Android as well (since version 10, IIRC).
- mistermann 6y ago> Venntel told me in a subject access request that my data was shared, but they did not provide to whom. When contacted later - they told me in a short statement that the data was not shared with ICE or CBP. I think this is an extremely clever technique for generating mainstream interest in a topic that would probably otherwise be considered boring for the typical person: associate it with something that people have very strong emotional feelings about. 10/10
- bartvk 6y agoThe writer doesn't mention which apps he installed, nor which phone. I'd be interested in the details, does anyone know this underlying data?
- mmgu 6y agoWriter: Samsung Galaxy S7. I guess over 70 apps in navigation, weather, games, prayer apps, or relevant due to listing location companies in privacy policy. I have not named apps / companies I that were not relevant to this feature. I found other things, but I had to focus on a clear story.
- bartvk 6y agoThank you.
- dfgdghdf 6y agoWhy is "track and trace" a challenge when this exists?
- alisonkisk 6y agousing the tech still takes effort, which is preferred to be spent on incarceration than public health.
- wizzwizz4 6y agoBecause there would (rightly) be an uproar if this were made more public, and “track and trace” is one of the most public things you can do with the data. Instead, we've got an almost completely private Bluetooth-based protocol… with implementations that go ahead and phone home anyway, without even using that phoned-home data for the track & trace system.
- csbartus 6y agoI stopped to use smartphones in 2018. Since then I have a Nokia 3310 new model, with Facebook installed. However the wi-fi is turned on around 10 minutes per month, in best case. What I've immediately observed after switching to the new phone that I'm receiving more precisely targeted ads. Before, on smartphone no adds were relevant, after the smartphone new adds were all relevant. My guess was the phone / the cellular service company is listening me all the time, not just when talking on the phone. To test it we've started playing games. Sitting with friends, we've used a predefined brand name very often in a conversation. Next day I've got the ads on the social media, on my laptop, I have no other internet device. What I'm doing now? Not using the phone at all. Which means 1-2 daily quick conversation to set up places to meet. For long conversations I use email or messengers. How do I feel? It doesn't bother me at all. I'm not paranoid. I know we are all sold since the blogging era begun. Right now what I can do is to make the lives who exploit data harder in this particular case. Edit: My phone is Nokia 8110 4G, with KaiOs.
- superkuh 6y agoEven if your use a dumb phone with no real operating system or applications if you carry an operating cell phone your location is tracked and stored. In the US this data is stored for 2-5 years minimum depending on which Telco you use. It is used and sold just like in this article. Tracking is how cell phones and cell basestations work. You cannot have one without the other. The better the clocks in the base stations the better the multilateration accuracy. It's already well under <100m. That you turn off GPS positioning does not matter in the slightest. As for listening to you to provide context for what ads to show, I find that supremely unlikely. Probably other aspects of your digital life are also monitored to inform this kind of thing.
- csbartus 6y agoThe test was repeated many times, screenshots with the next day social media ads were registered. My carrier is Orange in Romania. Just in case somebody wants to reproduce the experiment.
- zug_zug 6y ago
- SoSoRoCoCo 6y agoFYI, Sen. Ron Wyden is pretty much the only US congressperson actually -doing- anything about this. He is relentless in his attacks on the industry and understands the technology. I saw him at DefCon and yes, he sounds like a politician, but he's fighting the good fight. FTA: In a statement, Senator Ron Wyden said “Venntel has stonewalled Congress for months and refused to identify the sources of the data it is selling to Customs and Border Protection and other government agencies. The U.S. needs far stronger laws to protect Americans’ privacy, and ensure transparency about where our data is going."
- chungus_khan 6y agoAnd most of the rest of congress aren't just not doing anything about it, they consistently support the American surveillance state and voted on its expansion. It's incredibly rare for privacy to even be on the ticket.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoIt finally appears that we built the wrong monetization strategy for the Internet. Ideally users would have the option of having some sort of digital bank associated with their web browsing. Micro transactions could pay to support the websites instead of advertisements.
- sebastien_b 6y agoThere’s a reason they get called “privacy rapists”.
- Abishek_Muthian 6y agoI would highly recommend NetGuard to block individual app's network access and to enable them only as and when needed. [1]https://f-droid.org/en/packages/eu.faircode.netguard/ https://f-droid.org/en/packages/eu.faircode.netguard/
- asjkaehauisa 6y agoIf you have a newer version of android (9+), you can do it without 3d app. https://www.digitalcitizen.life/how-block-internet-access-specific-apps-android/ https://www.digitalcitizen.life/how-block-internet-access-sp...
- Abishek_Muthian 6y agoTrue, but Netguard provides many more features such as alert on new app, access logs, whitelist/blacklist capabilities etc.
- bitL 6y agoIs there a list of safe phones and safe apps? Or are we supposed to use Pine/Librem/Jolla phones only to have anything resembling privacy?
- amai 6y agoI thought the GDPR is only valid in the EU. But the author is from Norway, which is not member of the EU. So how does the GDPR apply for him?
- Glawen 6y agoGDPR applies to the EEA, which Norway is part of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Data_Protection_Regulation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Data_Protection_Regula...